4.7 Article

How Urban Forest Managers Evaluate Management and Governance Challenges in Their Decision-Making

Journal

FORESTS
Volume 11, Issue 9, Pages -

Publisher

MDPI
DOI: 10.3390/f11090963

Keywords

municipal government; urban planning; urban forest governance; nature-based solutions; ecosystem management; Q-method

Categories

Funding

  1. Australian Research Council (ARC) Linkage Partnership grant [LP160100780]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Decisions about urban forests are critical to urban liveability and resilience. This study aimed to evaluate the range of positions held by urban forest managers from local governments in the state of Victoria, Australia, regarding the management and governance challenges that affect their decision-making. This study was based on a Q-method approach, a procedure that allows researchers to evaluate the range of positions that exist about a topic in a structured manner based on the experiences of a wide group of people. We created statements on a wide range of urban forest management and governance challenges and asked urban forest managers to rate their level of agreement with these statements via an online survey. Managers generally agreed about the challenges posed by urban development and climate change for implementing local government policies on urban forest protection and expansion. However, there were divergent views about how effective solutions based on increasing operational capacities, such as increasing budgets and personnel, could address these challenges. For some managers, it was more effective to improve critical governance challenges, such as inter-departmental and inter-municipal coordination, community engagement, and addressing the culture of risk aversion in local governments. Urban forest regional strategies aimed at coordinating management and governance issues across cities should build on existing consensus on development and environmental threats and address critical management and governance issues not solely related to local government operational capacity.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Ecology

FlywayNet: A hidden semi-Markov model for inferring the structure of migratory bird networks from count data

Sam Nicol, Marie-Josee Cros, Nathalie Peyrard, Regis Sabbadin, Ronan Trepos, Richard A. Fuller, Bradley K. Woodworth

Summary: This article introduces the concept of FlywayNet, a discrete network model based on observed count data, to determine the structure of migratory networks in birds. By modeling noisy observations and flexible stopover durations using interacting hidden semi-Markov models, this approach advances previous studies and provides a flexible framework for studying migratory networks in birds and other organisms.

METHODS IN ECOLOGY AND EVOLUTION (2023)

Article Ecology

Prospects for monitoring bird migration along the East Asian-Australasian Flyway using weather radar

Xu Shi, Cheng Hu, Joshua Soderholm, Jason Chapman, Huafeng Mao, Kai Cui, Zhijun Ma, Dongli Wu, Richard A. Fuller

Summary: Interpretation of weather radar signals has been used to monitor bird migration patterns in Europe and America, but not yet in the East Asian-Australasian Flyway (EAAF). This study discusses the feasibility and challenges of using weather radar to complement on-ground bird migration surveys in the EAAF. The authors conclude that the weather radar network could be a powerful resource for monitoring bird movements in the EAAF, especially in remote regions.

REMOTE SENSING IN ECOLOGY AND CONSERVATION (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Retaining natural vegetation to safeguard biodiversity and humanity

Jeremy S. Simmonds, Andres Felipe Suarez-Castro, April E. Reside, James E. M. Watson, James R. Allan, Scott C. Atkinson, Pasquale Borrelli, Nigel Dudley, Stephen Edwards, Richard A. Fuller, Edward T. Game, Simon Linke, Sean L. Maxwell, Panos Panagos, Philippe Puydarrieux, Fabien Quetier, Rebecca K. Runting, Talitha Santini, Laura J. Sonter, Martine Maron

Summary: Global efforts to achieve internationally agreed goals such as reducing carbon emissions and halting biodiversity loss lack integration. To unify these goals, we have derived specific area-based targets for retaining natural and seminatural terrestrial vegetation worldwide. At least 50% of Earth's terrestrial surface needs to be preserved in order to contribute to biodiversity, climate, soil, and freshwater conservation objectives under 4 United Nations' resolutions.

CONSERVATION BIOLOGY (2023)

Article Entomology

An invasive human commensal and a native marsupial maintain tick populations at the urban fringe

Casey L. L. Taylor, Siobhon L. L. Egan, Alexander W. W. Gofton, Peter J. J. Irwin, Charlotte L. L. Oskam, Dieter F. F. Hochuli, Peter B. B. Banks

Summary: Little is known about which native and introduced small mammals maintain tick populations in urban landscapes of Australia, preventing host-targeted tick management and leading to human-wildlife conflict. This study found that introduced black rats and long-nosed bandicoots are the main hosts for urban tick populations and medically significant tick species.

MEDICAL AND VETERINARY ENTOMOLOGY (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Habitat selection and population status of breeding Wood Snipe Gallinago nemoricola in an alpine meadow in Sichuan, China

Xiaotong Ren, Shen Zhang, Ke Huang, He-Bo Peng, Changlin Li, Ding Zhao, Dehong Pang, Yong Wu, Peng Liu, Peng Chen, Rong Hou, Richard A. Fuller, Fangyuan Hua, Pinjia Que

Summary: This study provides the first assessment of the breeding season habitat use of the Wood Snipe. The results indicate that Wood Snipes prefer alpine meadow habitats with lower elevation and moderate soil moisture. The actual distribution range of the Wood Snipe during the breeding season may be smaller than expected. Further research is needed to better understand the ecology of this rare species.

BIRD CONSERVATION INTERNATIONAL (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Effectiveness of acoustic indices as indicators of vertebrate biodiversity

Slade Allen-Ankins, Donald T. McKnight, Eric J. Nordberg, Sebastian Hoefer, Paul Roe, David M. Watson, Paul G. McDonald, Richard A. Fuller, Lin Schwarzkopf

Summary: Effective monitoring tools are crucial for tracking biodiversity loss and informing management strategies. Passive acoustic monitoring has the potential to be a cheap and effective method for monitoring biodiversity, but extracting useful information from long audio recordings is still difficult.

ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS (2023)

Article Ecology

Keys to better planning and integrating urban tree planting initiatives

Rita Sousa-Silva, Marion Duflos, Camilo Ordnez Barona, Alain Paquette

Summary: Urban tree planting initiatives have been flourishing worldwide to combat climate change and promote healthy living environments. However, many of these initiatives lack clear objectives, hindering their success in achieving desired benefits. To improve their effectiveness, we propose seven principles, including planting the right types of trees where they are most needed and will have the greatest impact.

LANDSCAPE AND URBAN PLANNING (2023)

Article Plant Sciences

Eight recommendations to improve the reporting of qualitative social research in urban nature studies

Camilo Ordonez Barona

Summary: Researchers studying urban nature should use qualitative social methods (QSM) to understand how people think and behave in cities. QSM involves collaborating with participants to generate knowledge and includes descriptive, exploratory, and explanatory research procedures. It provides insights into the influence of urban nature on humans and vice versa.

URBAN FORESTRY & URBAN GREENING (2023)

Article Forestry

The Use of Compost Tea in a Containerized Urban Tree Nursery Shows No Evident Benefits to Tree Growth or Mycorrhizal Colonization

Dan Du, Stephen J. Livesley, Stefan K. Arndt, Camille Truong, Rebecca E. Miller

Summary: A study found that the use of compost tea did not have a positive effect on the growth and root mycorrhizal colonization of container-grown trees. This suggests that compost tea may not be beneficial for tree growth in a nursery setting, and further research is needed to investigate its potential benefits in urban landscapes.

FORESTS (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Associations between wildlife observations, human-tick encounters and landscape features in a peri-urban tick hotspot

Casey L. Taylor, Henry W. Lydecker, Dieter F. Hochuli, Peter B. Banks

Summary: Zoonotic disease vectors, their wildlife hosts, and the surrounding landscape interact in complex ways that vary spatially, temporally and with anthropogenic change. A study in peri-urban areas of Australia investigated the drivers of human-tick encounters at both the local and landscape scales. The results showed that sightings of potential hosts and broader landscape traits were important predictors of reported tick encounters. These findings provide a critical foundation for further research and tick management strategies in urban environments.

URBAN ECOSYSTEMS (2023)

Article Environmental Studies

Views of government and non-government actors on urban forest management and governance in ten Latin-American capital cities

Camilo Ordonez Barona, Ana Alice Eleuterio, Alexis Vasquez, Tahia Devisscher, Mariana Dias Baptista, Cynnamon Dobbs, Luis Orozco-Aguilar, Elvia Melendez-Ackrman

Summary: Addressing urban forest management and governance challenges is crucial for implementing urban forest policies. This research focused on urban forest actors in Latin American and the Caribbean cities and examined their participation in collective decision-making, the current state of urban forest management and governance, and interactor contact. The study found that increased contact among actors led to greater participation in collective decision-making and more positive views on the state of urban forest management and governance. Additionally, optimistic views about management and governance resulted in higher trust in local governments, with government actors displaying higher levels of trust than non-government actors. The findings highlight the importance of not only having sufficient resources, but also engaging in collective decision-making and building trust in institutions responsible for implementing urban forest policies.

LAND USE POLICY (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Drone-induced flight initiation distances for shorebirds in mixed-species flocks

Joshua P. P. Wilson, Tatsuya Amano, Richard A. A. Fuller

Summary: The increase in drone use has led to a need for regulations on flights near vulnerable wildlife, but a lack of data on drone-induced wildlife disturbance has hindered these efforts. This study characterizes the disturbance caused by drones among mixed-species shorebird flocks to provide guidance for drone management near shorebirds. The researchers conducted drone approaches on roosting non-breeding shorebirds in Moreton Bay, Australia and found that the flight initiation distance varies depending on the species and certain factors such as drone noise, approach velocity, and distance. The researchers recommend careful regulation of drone use, evaluation of disturbance risk in drone surveys, and seeking alternatives in the absence of disturbance data.

JOURNAL OF APPLIED ECOLOGY (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Quantifying the importance of urban trees to people and nature through tree removal experiments

Camilo Ordonez, Caragh G. Threlfall, Dave Kendal, Jess Baumann, Cherese Sonkkila, Dieter F. Hochuli, Rodney van der Ree, Richard A. Fuller, Melanie Davern, Kelly Herzog, Alex English, Stephen J. Livesley

Summary: This study experimentally quantifies the benefits of urban trees on humans and wildlife by taking advantage of scheduled tree removals. The results demonstrate that the removal of trees in urban parks led to a decrease in bird and possum abundance, an increase in invertebrate predation, and a decrease in people's perception of the importance of trees.

PEOPLE AND NATURE (2023)

No Data Available