4.3 Article

A Comparison of Tick Collection Materials and Methods in Southeastern Virginia

Journal

JOURNAL OF MEDICAL ENTOMOLOGY
Volume 58, Issue 2, Pages 692-698

Publisher

OXFORD UNIV PRESS INC
DOI: 10.1093/jme/tjaa207

Keywords

tick dragging; tick flagging; tick surveillance

Funding

  1. National Institutes of Health as part of the joint National Institutes of Health-National Science Foundation-United States Department of Agriculture Ecology and Evolution of Infectious Diseases program [1 R01 AI 136035-01]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

In this study comparing flagging and dragging in southeastern Virginia, it was found that flagging was more efficient in collecting some tick species adults than dragging.
In field studies of tick ecology, observed patterns may be biased by sampling methods. Results can vary by species, life stage, and habitat, and understanding these biases will improve comparisons of data across studies as well as assessment of human disease risk. A direct comparison of flagging versus dragging was conducted in southeastern Virginia. Transects were surveyed over a 6-wk period to identify differences in species and life stage collected, as well as differences between corduroy and denim material and inspection method for drags. Flagging collected more Ixodes affinis Neumann (Acari: Ixodidae) adults and Amblyomma americanum L. (Acari: Ixodidae) adults than dragging. Ground inspection was more efficient than tree inspection for collection of I. affinis adults, with no significant difference in inspection method for any other species or life stage. Corduroy was found to be more effective than denim in collecting nymphal A. americanum, although this may be an artifact of three large samples for corduroy collection of these ticks. There was no significant difference in Ixodes scapularis Say (Acari: Ixodidae) collection in any comparison. Dragging, tree inspection, and denim were not found to be more efficient in any scenario. This is the first comparison of flagging and dragging conducted in the southeastern United States. The community composition of ticks in this region greatly differs from regions where studies of these commonly used sampling techniques have been conducted. As the distributions of ticks continue to change over time, it will be important to evaluate best practices annually.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.3
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Infectious Diseases

Assessing the underwater survival of two tick species, Amblyomma americanum and Amblyomma maculatum

Lindsey A. Bidder, Kristine M. Asmussen, Sean E. Campbell, Katerina A. Goffigan, Holly D. Gaff

TICKS AND TICK-BORNE DISEASES (2019)

Article Infectious Diseases

First report of Candidatus Rickettsia mendelii in Ixodes brunneus from the United States

Alexandra N. Cumbie, Eric L. Walters, Holly D. Gaff, Wayne L. Hynes

TICKS AND TICK-BORNE DISEASES (2020)

Article Entomology

LYMESIM 2.0: An Updated Simulation of Blacklegged Tick (Acari: Ixodidae) Population Dynamics and Enzootic Transmission of Borrelia burgdorferi (Spirochaetales: Spirochaetaceae)

Holly Gaff, Rebecca J. Eisen, Lars Eisen, Robyn Nadolny, Jenna Bjork, Andrew J. Monaghan

JOURNAL OF MEDICAL ENTOMOLOGY (2020)

Article Entomology

Exploring the Niche of Rickettsia montanensis (Rickettsiales: Rickettsiaceae) Infection of the American Dog Tick (Acari: Ixodidae), Using Multiple Species Distribution Model Approaches

Catherine A. Lippi, Holly D. Gaff, Alexis L. White, Heidi K. St John, Allen L. Richards, Sadie J. Ryan

Summary: This study updated the modeled distribution of American dog tick and R. montanensis using maximum entropy model, finding that adding soil layers improved model accuracy, and the predicted "infected niche" was smaller than the overall predicted niche. Different models predicted different sizes of suitable niche, and the random forest model had the best validity and fit among them.

JOURNAL OF MEDICAL ENTOMOLOGY (2021)

Review Multidisciplinary Sciences

Scoping review of distribution models for selected Amblyomma ticks and rickettsial group pathogens

Catherine A. Lippi, Holly D. Gaff, Alexis L. White, Sadie J. Ryan

Summary: The increasing prevalence of tick-borne diseases in humans in recent decades has highlighted the need for more information on geographic risk for public health planning. A systematic scoping review of species distribution models (SDMs) literature for rickettsial pathogens and tick vectors in the genus Amblyomma found that most studies estimated only tick distributions using vector presence as a proxy for pathogen exposure. The reliance on existing data sources and the lack of original data collection may indicate a lag in new data acquisition and a full understanding of the tick-pathogen ecology.

PEERJ (2021)

Article Entomology

Focus Stacking Images of Morphological Character States for Differentiating the Adults of Ixodes affinis and Ixodes scapularis (Acari: Ixodidae) in Areas of Sympatry

Robyn M. Nadolny, Marcee Toliver, Holly D. Gaff, John G. Snodgrass, Richard G. Robbins

Summary: This study illustrates adult females and males of Ixodes affinis and Ixodes scapularis through focus stacking image photography and describes morphological character states that reliably differentiate the two species. These characteristics, along with other environmental cues, allow for rapid identification of adults of either sex in the southern Coastal Plain of the United States where these species coexist.

JOURNAL OF MEDICAL ENTOMOLOGY (2021)

Review Entomology

Trends and Opportunities in Tick-Borne Disease Geography

Catherine A. Lippi, Sadie J. Ryan, Alexis L. White, Holly D. Gaff, Colin J. Carlson

Summary: Tick-borne diseases are a growing problem worldwide, and the surveillance and control measures involve various fields such as medical entomology, agricultural health, veterinary medicine, and biosecurity. Spatial approaches can help stakeholders understand the current and future distribution of risk, with major gaps in data utilization and mapping efforts in enzootic cycles of tick-borne pathogens, particularly in Africa and Asia. Future work can focus on applying available methods to track the distributions of tick-borne diseases in these regions following a One Health approach combining medical and veterinary surveillance.

JOURNAL OF MEDICAL ENTOMOLOGY (2021)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Spatio-temporal modelling of tick life-stage count data with spatially varying coefficients

Thabo Lephoto, Henry Mwambi, Oliver Bodhlyera, Holly Gaff

Summary: This study utilized data collected by researchers at the Department of Biological Sciences at Old Dominion University in Virginia, USA, to model tick life-stage counts and abundance variability. Spatio-temporal negative binomial models outperformed Poisson models in analyzing the data, suggesting that this model is more suitable for the analysis. Results indicated that covariates varied spatially across counties, with a decreasing time effect over the study period and increasing space-time interaction effects in York County.

GEOSPATIAL HEALTH (2021)

Article Entomology

Tick Species Composition, Collection Rates, and Phenology Provide Insights into Tick-Borne Disease Ecology in Virginia

Ciera N. Morris, Holly D. Gaff, Roy D. Berghaus, C. Morgan Wilson, Elizabeth R. Gleim

Summary: A comparative phenological study was conducted in Virginia to understand tick ecology and the increasing incidence of Lyme disease. The study found that Ixodes scapularis from the northeastern United States may be migrating into western Virginia, contributing to the higher incidence of Lyme disease in the region.

JOURNAL OF MEDICAL ENTOMOLOGY (2022)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Newer Surveillance Data Extends our Understanding of the Niche of Rickettsia montanensis (Rickettsiales: Rickettsiaceae) Infection of the American Dog Tick (Acari: Ixodidae) in the United States

Catherine A. A. Lippi, Holly D. D. Gaff, Robyn M. M. Nadolny, Sadie J. J. Ryan

Summary: This study updates the distribution models of D. variabilis and R. montanensis-infected D. variabilis in the United States, using newer surveillance and testing data. The results show consistency in the predicted habitat suitability for D. variabilis, indicating its generalist habitat requirements. However, there is a slight shift in the updated niche distribution, including more southern areas, highlighting the need for continued monitoring and surveillance.

VECTOR-BORNE AND ZOONOTIC DISEASES (2023)

Article Ecology

Estimating the distribution of Oryzomys palustris, a potential key host in expanding rickettsial tick-borne disease risk

Catherine A. Lippi, Samuel Canfield, Christina Espada, Holly D. Gaff, Sadie J. Ryan

Summary: Geographic approaches are increasingly used to assess the risk of tick-borne diseases and inform public health decision-making. This study explored the potential geographic range of a marsh rice rat species and found considerable overlap with the distribution of a tick species in the southeastern United States, highlighting the need for extended surveillance efforts and attention to the role of hosts in transmission cycles.

ECOSPHERE (2023)

Article Entomology

Survival of adult Amblyomma americanum, Amblyomma maculatum, and Dermacentor variabilis (Acari: Ixodidae) in four habitats in southeastern Virginia

Lindsey Bidder, Holly Gaff

Summary: Adult unfed Amblyomma americanum, Amblyomma maculatum, and Dermacentor variabilis ticks were placed in environmental containers in southeastern Virginia from May to August 2015. Analysis showed significant differences in survival rates among the three species across all field sites. A. maculatum had a higher risk of mortality compared to A. americanum and D. variabilis, and D. variabilis had a higher risk of mortality compared to A. americanum. There was also higher mortality in flooding-prone habitats compared to drier upland habitats. The study concluded that A. americanum was not negatively affected by increased flooding, while A. maculatum was more susceptible to mortality in both dry and flood-prone environments.

JOURNAL OF MEDICAL ENTOMOLOGY (2023)

Article Entomology

A Simple, Inexpensive Method for Mark-Recapture of Ixodid Ticks

Alexis White, Robin Minch, Lindsey Bidder, Holly Gaff

JOURNAL OF INSECT SCIENCE (2020)

No Data Available