4.6 Review

Classrooms' indoor environmental conditions affecting the academic achievement of students and teachers in higher education: A systematic literature review

Journal

INDOOR AIR
Volume 31, Issue 2, Pages 405-425

Publisher

WILEY
DOI: 10.1111/ina.12745

Keywords

academic performance; facility management; indoor environmental quality; quality of teaching and learning; school design

Funding

  1. Executive Board, the Facility Management Department
  2. School of Facility Management of Hanze University of Applied Sciences
  3. Eindhoven University of Technology

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This study highlights the positive impact of indoor environmental quality on the quality of teaching and learning as well as students' academic performance in higher education schools, particularly in the short term. However, the influence of different IEQ conditions on students' performance and the long-term academic outcomes is still inconclusive, indicating the need for further research in this area.
This study reports the outcomes of a systematic literature review, which aims to determine the influence of four indoor environmental parameters - indoor air, thermal, acoustic, and lighting conditions -on the quality of teaching and learning and on students' academic achievement in schools for higher education, defined as education at a college or university. By applying the Cochrane Collaboration Method, relevant scientific evidence was identified by systematically searching in multiple databases. After the screening process, 21 publications of high relevance and quality were included. The collected evidence showed that the indoor environmental quality (IEQ) can contribute positively to the quality of learning and short-term academic performance of students. However, the influence of all parameters on the quality of teaching and the long-term academic performance could not be determined yet. Students perform at their best in different IEQ conditions, and these conditions are task-dependent, suggesting that classrooms which provide multiple IEQ classroom conditions facilitate different learning tasks optimally. In addition, the presented evidence illuminates how to examine the influence of the IEQ on users. Finally, this information supports decision-makers in facility management and building systems engineering to improve the IEQ, and by doing so, allow teachers and students to perform optimally.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.6
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Obstetrics & Gynecology

A cross-sectional study of lactation room quality and Dutch working mothers' satisfaction, perceived ease of, and perceived support for breast milk expression at work

Sjoukje A. van Dellen, Barbara Wisse, Mark P. Mobach, Casper J. Albers, Arie Dijkstra

Summary: The availability of high-quality lactation rooms in the workplace can significantly impact working mothers' satisfaction and perceptions related to expressing breast milk at work. Research shows that higher-quality lactation rooms are associated with increased satisfaction, ease of milk expression, and support from supervisors and co-workers.

INTERNATIONAL BREASTFEEDING JOURNAL (2021)

Review Education, Special

How does architecture contribute to reducing behaviours that challenge? A scoping review

Berit Ann Roos, Mark Mobach, Ann Heylighen

Summary: This scoping review explores the impact of architecture on the quality of life of individuals engaging in challenging behaviors. The study finds that there is a lack of research on the relationship between architecture, quality of life, intellectual impairment, and challenging behaviors. Future research should focus on understanding the contribution of architecture to the quality of life of these individuals and compare their needs with those of individuals with autism.

RESEARCH IN DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES (2022)

Article Construction & Building Technology

A systematic approach to quantify the influence of indoor environmental parameters on students' perceptions, responses, and short-term academic performance

Henk W. Brink, Marcel G. L. C. Loomans, Mark P. Mobach, Helianthe S. M. Kort

Summary: Several studies have found that the indoor environmental quality of classrooms can have a positive influence on in-class activities. In order to create an optimal indoor environmental quality, it is important to understand and quantify the combined effect of indoor air quality, thermal comfort, acoustic conditions, and lighting conditions on individuals. A systematic approach was developed to study the simultaneous effect of these parameters. The approach was tested in a pilot study during a regular academic course, which showed significant associations between natural variations in indoor environmental quality and students' perceptions and cognitive responses, as well as a correlation between perceived cognitive responses and short-term academic performance.

INDOOR AIR (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Workplace impact on employees: A Lifelines Corona Research Initiative on the return to work

Mark P. Mobach

Summary: A large proportion of the global workforce migrated home during the COVID-19 pandemic and subsequent lockdowns, but there were differences between home workers and non-home workers. Study findings suggest that home workers had less favorable perceptions of on-site buildings and workplaces, but better work quality and health compared to non-home workers. However, building, workplace, and related facilities may have the capacity to positively influence employees' affective responses and work quality, but not always their health.

PLOS ONE (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

The 5-Minute Campus

Sascha Naomi Jansz, Mark Mobach, Terry van Dijk

Summary: This study aims to identify why some locations are successful in fostering unplanned meetings while others are not. The findings suggest that there are three natural moments for unplanned meetings: during short breaks, lunch breaks, and events. The study also highlights the importance of the campus environment in facilitating these meetings.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH AND PUBLIC HEALTH (2023)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Effectiveness of personalized ventilation in reducing airborne infection risk for long-term care facilities

Marloes M. A. de Haas, Marcel G. L. C. Loomans, Marije te Kulve, Atze C. Boerstra, Helianthe S. M. Kort

Summary: Throughout history, outbreaks of infectious diseases have had a significant impact on the human population. The emergence of the previously unknown SARS-CoV-2 virus in December 2019 caused a global pandemic. Long-term care facility residents were found to be highly vulnerable to infection due to their frailty. An important transmission route for respiratory infectious diseases like COVID-19 is through airborne transmission, which occurs in shared indoor environments. To reduce the risk of airborne transmission, it is necessary to consider ventilation and other building services system measures, including personalized ventilation (PV). A laboratory experiment was conducted to investigate the effectiveness of PV in reducing the risk of infection. The experiment simulated a person close to a PV system that provided filtered recirculated air, while a particle source maintained a constant particle concentration in the room. The outcomes showed that in this laboratory setting, the PV system can reduce the infection risk by up to 50%. The performance of the system is influenced by various design parameters and factors such as distance to the breathing zone, angle of the supply head, airflows in the room, and location of the particle source. Further optimization is needed to apply the system in long-term care facilities, including considerations of mobility, breathing patterns, and factors affecting comfort and use.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF VENTILATION (2023)

Article Management

Understanding how indoor environmental classroom conditions influence academic performance in higher education

Henk W. Brink, Stefan C. M. Lechner, Marcel G. L. C. Loomans, Mark P. Mobach, Helianthe S. M. Kort

Summary: This study qualitatively examined the relationship between indoor environmental quality (IEQ), lecturers' and students' perceived internal responses, and academic performance. The findings showed that poor IEQ conditions, including thermal, lighting, acoustic, and indoor air quality (IAQ), can negatively impact teaching and learning. Maintaining acceptable thermal and IAQ conditions can improve the quality of teaching and learning by reducing distractions and discomfort.

FACILITIES (2023)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Challenging Behavior in Context: A Case Study on How People, Space, and Activities Interact

Berit Ann Roos, Mark Mobach, Ann Heylighen

Summary: The aim of this study is to explore the interaction between challenging behavior in intellectually impaired individuals and space, and to investigate the use of routinely collected data for this purpose. The findings suggest that the interaction between individuals and space can be both direct and indirect, and that space has a strong impact on individuals' senses and perceived stress. People also have a significant influence, with caregivers having both positive and negative effects, and co-residents triggering challenging behavior. Providing living environments that offer choice in caregiver proximity, distance from high-tension co-residents, lower transition thresholds, and predictability would be beneficial for intellectually impaired individuals showing challenging behavior.

HERD-HEALTH ENVIRONMENTS RESEARCH & DESIGN JOURNAL (2023)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Bedroom ventilation performance in daycare centers under three typical ventilation strategies

Hailin Zheng, Zhijian Wang, Marcel Loomans, Shalika Walker, Wim Zeiler

Summary: With the increasing reliance on daycare centers for early childhood development, ensuring healthy environments in semi-enclosed baby beds is crucial. This study investigates the performance of different ventilation strategies in enhancing air quality in daycare center bedrooms. The findings reveal that personalized ventilation has the best performance, followed by displacement ventilation and mixing ventilation. Sleep positions and ventilation rates significantly influenced the performance of certain ventilation modes.

BUILDING AND ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Bed-level ventilation conditions in daycare centers

Hailin Zheng, Zhijian Wang, Marcel Loomans, Shalika Walker, Wim Zeiler

Summary: In Dutch daycare centers, concerns have been raised about the air quality inside semi-enclosed beds due to insufficient room-level ventilation. A field survey in 17 daycare centers collected data on bedroom ventilation conditions. Based on this, a full-scale bedroom was constructed to study bed-level ventilation conditions. The results showed that there was a high concentration of exhaled CO2 inside the bed, indicating the need to improve air quality in the baby bed.

BUILDING AND ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Environmental Studies

Perceived Fit and User Behavior in Activity-Based Work Environments

Jan Gerard Hoendervanger, Nico W. Van Yperen, Mark P. Mobach, Casper J. Albers

Summary: Research suggests that in activity-based work environments, workers feel a higher sense of fit when using closed work settings for individual high-concentration work, and more frequent setting-switching is related to higher perceived fit, especially among workers who do not frequently switch activities. Therefore, it is important to facilitate and stimulate the use of closed work settings for individual high-concentration work to optimize workers' perceived fit in such environments.

ENVIRONMENT AND BEHAVIOR (2022)

Article Management

Facilitating campus interactions - critical success factors according to university facility directors

Sascha Naomi Jansz, Terry van Dijk, Mark P. Mobach

Summary: This study investigates the critical success factors influencing interaction on Dutch university campuses and compares them with existing literature. It identifies key categories like constraints, motivators, designing spaces, designing services, building community, and creating coherence. By viewing the campus as an open system, practical applicability of these factors in campus design policies is highlighted for fostering knowledge sharing interactions.

FACILITIES (2021)

Article Management

The experience of patients in an outpatient infusion facility: a qualitative study

Emma Zijlstra, Mariet Hagedoorn, Stefan C. M. Lechner, Cees P. van der Schans, Mark P. Mobach

Summary: The study looked into patients' preferences for social contact in outpatient infusion centers, finding a correlation between physical aspects like enclosure and social environment. Patients preferred different physical aspects based on their communication preferences. Facility managers can use these findings to improve patient experiences and make informed decisions.

FACILITIES (2021)

No Data Available