4.5 Article

Two-dimensional numerical modelling of strategies to avoid thermal stress induced flow channeling in fractured geothermal reservoirs

Journal

GEOTHERMICS
Volume 90, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

PERGAMON-ELSEVIER SCIENCE LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.geothermics.2020.101978

Keywords

Geothermal; Enhanced geothermal systems; Flow channelling; THM model; MDEM; Thermal breakthrough

Funding

  1. KPN project Controlled Fracturing for Increased Recovery
  2. Research Council of Norway [244506/E30]
  3. Lundin

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The study shows that flow channeling induced by thermal drawdown in fractured geothermal reservoirs is not inevitable, but depends on factors such as fracture aperture and injection rate. Interventions such as variable injection rates and sequential injection can improve the chances for even flow and better production efficiency. Advanced numerical models capable of THM modeling are needed for accurate geothermal production analysis in low permeability fracture networks due to significant effects of stress and pressure changes on flow patterns and production values.
Thermal drawdown induced flow channeling in fractured geothermal reservoirs has been found to be inevitable in previous work. This hypothesis is questioned and found not to be true for all scenarios. We investigate flow in a simple two-fracture network to investigate the basic behavior of thermal drawdown induced flow pattern changes, using a Thermo-Hydro-Mechanical (THM) numerical model. In addition, we propose two operational interventions to mitigate the negative effects of uneven flow on geothermal production. We found that uneven flow is not inevitable, but dependent on several factors, including initial fracture aperture, the actual value of the aperture, and the total injection rate. A small difference in aperture, a higher aperture value and a larger total injection rate are all factors improving the chances for even flow. The operation interventions include variable injection rates, and sequential injection in the fractures before normal production. Both are shown to improve the chances for even flow and better production. Overall, changes in stress and pressure as a result of cooling, are found to have significant effects on flow pattern and production values, underlining the need for advanced numerical models capable of THM modeling for accurate geothermal production analysis in low permeability fracture networks.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Microseismicity Cloud Can Be Substantially Larger Than the Associated Stimulated Fracture Volume: The Case of the Paralana Enhanced Geothermal System

Jeremy Riffault, David Dempsey, Satish Karra, Rosalind Archer

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-SOLID EARTH (2018)

Article Environmental Sciences

Response of Induced Seismicity to Injection Rate Reduction: Models of Delay, Decay, Quiescence, Recovery, and Oklahoma

David Dempsey, Jeremy Riffault

WATER RESOURCES RESEARCH (2019)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Automatic precursor recognition and real-time forecasting of sudden explosive volcanic eruptions at Whakaari, New Zealand

D. E. Dempsey, S. J. Cronin, S. Mei, A. W. Kempa-Liehr

NATURE COMMUNICATIONS (2020)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Bayesian magnetotelluric inversion using methylene blue structural priors for imaging shallow conductors in geothermal fields

Alberto Ardid, David Dempsey, Edward Bertrand, Fabian Sepulveda, Pascal Tarits, Flora Solon, Rosalind Archer

Summary: This study introduces a new Bayesian inversion method that integrates MT and borehole MeB data to improve the accuracy of inferring shallow conductor boundaries in geothermal exploration, reducing nonuniqueness and uncertainty.

GEOPHYSICS (2021)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Heat Transfer Through the Wairakei-Tauhara Geothermal System Quantified by Multi-Channel Data Modeling

Alberto Ardid, Rosalind Archer, Edward Bertrand, Fabian Sepulveda, Pascal Tarits, David Dempsey

Summary: This study focuses on quantifying first-order components of a rift-hosted geothermal field by integrating electromagnetic, lithological, and temperature data through 1D models and a stochastic framework. By jointly modeling a multichannel dataset, key heat flows within a complex magmatic-volcanic-hydrothermal province can be accurately quantified. This approach could be beneficial for decision makers in the geothermal industry to optimize sustainable electricity generation and well drilling locations.

GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2021)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Hydrothermal Cooling as a Requirement for Short Storage of Silicic Magmas

Liam J. Kelly, Guilherme A. R. Gualda, Darren M. Gravley, David E. Dempsey

Summary: The study highlights the evidence of crystallization and storage of large magma bodies in the Taupo Volcanic Zone in New Zealand decades to centuries before eruptions. It suggests that convective hydrothermal systems are necessary for short-term heat extraction from large magma bodies, rather than purely conductive models, presenting potential future directions for monitoring unstable calderas in environments with abundant hydrothermal activity like the TVZ.

GEOCHEMISTRY GEOPHYSICS GEOSYSTEMS (2021)

Article Engineering, Geological

A three-dimensional coupled thermo-hydro-mechanical numerical model with partially bridging multi-stage contact fractures in horizontal-well enhanced geothermal system

Pengliang Yu, David Dempsey, Rosalind Archer

Summary: Enhanced Geothermal Systems (EGS) have significant untapped renewable energy potential but face technical and financial challenges before widespread deployment. A new horizontal EGS well design with partially bridging multi-stage hydraulic fractures is proposed to improve heat extraction from hot dry rock (HDR), showing promising results for practical implementation.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ROCK MECHANICS AND MINING SCIENCES (2021)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Seismic precursors to the Whakaari 2019 phreatic eruption are transferable to other eruptions and volcanoes

Alberto Ardid, David Dempsey, Corentin Caudron, Shane Cronin

Summary: This study identifies a general seismic precursor signal for gas-driven eruptions through correlation analysis of 18 eruptions in New Zealand, Alaska, and Kamchatka. The precursor is manifested in the displacement seismic amplitude ratio between medium and high frequency tremor bands, exhibiting a characteristic rise in the days prior to eruptions. Real-time monitoring of this precursor may improve short-term eruption warning systems at certain volcanoes.

NATURE COMMUNICATIONS (2022)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Physics-Based Forecasting of Induced Seismicity at Groningen Gas Field, The Netherlands: Post Hoc Evaluation and Forecast Update

David E. Dempsey, Jenny Suckale

Summary: Induced seismicity from gas extraction in the Groningen reservoir in the Netherlands has been occurring since the 1990s. The accuracy and relevance of previous earthquake magnitude forecasts for different extraction scenarios are unknown. This study evaluated a prior forecast and proposed a revised model, which suggested a 1% likelihood of the largest event exceeding M 3.8 (tapered model) or M 5.4 (unbounded model) in the period 2021-2030.

SEISMOLOGICAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2023)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Association Between Injection and Microseismicity in Geothermal Fields With Multiple Wells: Data-Driven Modeling of Rotokawa, New Zealand, and Husmuli, Iceland

Pengliang Yu, David Dempsey, Antonio Pio Rinaldi, Aimee Calibugan, Vanille A. Ritz, Rosalind Archer

Summary: Data-driven models were used to study the correlation between fluid injection and microseismicity in the geothermal fields of Rotokawa (New Zealand) and Hellisheioi (Iceland). The models helped determine the wells with the strongest correlation and explain this association in a reservoir context. However, no link was found between rapid changes in injection rate and seismicity spikes, as suggested by some theoretical models.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-SOLID EARTH (2023)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Identification of Seismo-Volcanic Regimes at Whakaari/White Island (New Zealand) Via Systematic Tuning of an Unsupervised Classifier

B. Steinke, A. D. Jolly, R. Carniel, D. E. Dempsey, S. J. Cronin

Summary: This study presents an algorithm based on Self-Organizing Maps (SOM) and k-means clustering to recognize patterns in tremor time series recorded at Whakaari/White Island volcano in New Zealand. The algorithm can be applied to different volcanic settings by adjusting the classifier. Hyperparameters are evaluated statistically to determine the ideal SOM parameters. The study categorizes the seismic time series into regimes representing different volcanic states during recent unrest episodes, and the classification results show a clear separation between background regimes and those representing elevated levels of unrest.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-SOLID EARTH (2023)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Using Template Matching to Detect Hidden Fluid Release Episodes Beneath Crater Lakes in Ruapehu, Copahue, and Kawah Ijen Volcanoes

A. Ardid, D. Dempsey, C. Caudron, S. J. Cronin, C. A. Miller, I. Melchor, D. Syahbana, B. Kennedy

Summary: Volcano crater lakes, while picturesque, may hide small eruptions or hydrothermal fluid release events. This study presents a new method to identify these hidden events using seismic data, and it successfully identifies multiple potential events in different volcanoes.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-SOLID EARTH (2023)

Article Geology

Ground motion simulation of hypothetical earthquakes in the upper North Island of New Zealand

David Dempsey, Jennifer D. Eccles, Jonney Huang, Seokho Jeong, Elia Nicolin, Andrew Stolte, Liam Wotherspoon, Brendon A. Bradley

Summary: The study shows that the upper North Island of New Zealand is vulnerable to earthquakes on the Kerepehi and Wairoa North faults, with potential severe shaking near the source and liquefaction. Cities such as Auckland, Hamilton, and Tauranga could experience moderate to very strong shaking.

NEW ZEALAND JOURNAL OF GEOLOGY AND GEOPHYSICS (2021)

Proceedings Paper Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Effect of Permeability Heterogeneity on Area of Review

Rajesh Pawar, David Dempsey, George Guthrie

13TH INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON GREENHOUSE GAS CONTROL TECHNOLOGIES, GHGT-13 (2017)

Article Energy & Fuels

Comprehensive assessment of four volcano-hosted geothermal fields with relation to tectonics and faults in El Salvador

Luis Salala, Jonathan Argueta, Noel Lopez, Osmany Aparicio, Diana Martinez, Pedro Santos, Arturo Quezada, Oziel Garcia, Jose Erazo, Hiroyuki Yamagishi, Noriyoshi Tsuchiya

Summary: Geothermal systems have significant potential to replace reliance on fossil fuels. El Salvador, being tectonically active, already supplies a significant portion of its electricity demand using volcanic geothermal fields. The study compares different geothermal areas in El Salvador and highlights the controlling factors in the characteristics of geothermal reservoirs.

GEOTHERMICS (2024)

Article Energy & Fuels

A modified methodology to substitute U-shape well using a single well with fracture network: Design and performance

Lin Jia, Kewen Li, Yun Han, Chi Zhang, Lipeng Zhao

Summary: This study proposes a new approach of retrofitting abandoned oil wells into geothermal wells, and investigates the effects of different parameters on the performance using a numerical model. The results show that the enhanced fracture system significantly improves the efficiency of geothermal energy extraction, and optimal design should control the flow rate and use proppant.

GEOTHERMICS (2024)

Article Energy & Fuels

Inclusion of advection in fractures in the line source equation for analysis of thermal response tests

K. H. Kvalsvik, H. Holmberg, R. K. Ramstad, K. Midttomme

Summary: This study proposes a new analytical equation that takes into account the advective heat in fractured rock, improving the accuracy of measuring thermal properties in borehole heat exchangers. The equation is applicable to all thermal response tests and provides a cost-effective alternative to numerical modelling.

GEOTHERMICS (2024)

Article Energy & Fuels

Extraction turbines and feed-heating in geothermal binary plants: A thermodynamic performance assessment

Ronald Dipippo

Summary: This paper presents a technique of further preheating the working fluid in geothermal binary plants using extraction turbines, and evaluates the performance at various geofluid temperatures through working equations. The results indicate that this approach can be equally effective in geothermal binary plants as it is in conventional nuclear power plants.

GEOTHERMICS (2024)

Article Energy & Fuels

Technique and results of determination of vertical variations in rock thermal properties, temperature gradient and heat flow

Y. A. Popov, E. M. Chekhonin, E. G. Savelev, D. A. Ostrizhniy, A. B. Shakirov, R. A. Romushkevich, E. A. Babich, B. E. Andreyev, M. Y. Spasennykh, I. A. Sannikova

Summary: This paper describes the results of experimental geothermal studies on the formation surrounding the Savitskaya-300 well in the Volga-Ural oil and gas basin. The study found high thermal heterogeneity and anisotropy in the formation. The paper provides important data on thermal properties and heat flow variations in the well.

GEOTHERMICS (2024)

Article Energy & Fuels

Stability study of aqueous foams under high-temperature and high-pressure conditions relevant to Enhanced Geothermal Systems (EGS)

Viren Thakore, Hong Wang, Jy-An Wang, Yarom Polsky, Fei Ren

Summary: This paper focuses on the stability of foam-based fracturing fluid under high temperature and high pressure conditions. It is of significant importance for the development of foam fracturing fluid as an alternative to conventional water-based fracturing fluid in Enhanced Geothermal System (EGS). Experimental results show that with the appropriate selection of surfactants and stabilizing agents, stable foams can be obtained. Analytical models are developed to predict the foam stability for different foam compositions, considering the effects of temperature and pressure.

GEOTHERMICS (2024)

Article Energy & Fuels

Analysis of the effect of multiple thermal-cold cycles on the bearing performance of phase change energy piles

Hong Chang, Sheng Jiang, Haozhi Jiang, Yunjie Li, Zhengheng Gan, Songying Zhao

Summary: This study compared the bearing performance between phase change energy piles (GPEP) and traditional energy piles (TEP) using indoor modeling tests and theoretical formulas. The results showed that GPEP increased the ultimate bearing capacity of a single pile by about 13% compared to TEP. Additionally, the phase change materials effectively restricted the temperature-drag response of energy piles.

GEOTHERMICS (2024)

Article Energy & Fuels

Contrasting influence of salt structures and faults on the geothermal potential of regional structural highs: The Cleaver Bank High, Southern North Sea

Qiang Zhang, Tiago Alves

Summary: This study investigates the influence of salt structures and faults on the geothermal potential in the Cleaver Bank High, Southern North Sea, using high-quality 3D seismic reflection data and bottom-hole temperature data. The results show that salt structures and faults play a significant role in the geothermal gradient, with higher gradients found on the footwalls of faults. Three potential geothermal exploration targets are identified based on the findings.

GEOTHERMICS (2024)

Article Energy & Fuels

Geothermal heat pumps to reduce diesel consumption in an off-grid subarctic community: Comparison of solar assisted systems with optional underground energy storage

Hubert Langevin, Nicolo Giordano, Jasmin Raymond, Louis Gosselin, Martin Bourbonnais

Summary: This study evaluates the efficiency and cost of solar-assisted geothermal systems in a subarctic climate, and offers recommendations for optimizing ground heat exchanger configurations.

GEOTHERMICS (2024)

Article Energy & Fuels

A study on the geothermal circulation system of granite: An example from the Lancang area, Yunnan

Lei Chen, Jinchuan Zhang, Longfei Xu, Shijing Chen, Qianchao Li, Yuhang Sun, Jie Li, Xingxu Zhao

Summary: This study assesses the geothermal water circulation process of a granite geothermal system in the Lancang area, Yunnan using water chemistry and isotope analysis techniques. The results show that the geothermal water originates from atmospheric precipitation and the granite pluton serves as the main heat source. Additionally, the fault system plays an important role in the discharge and mixing of hot and cold water.

GEOTHERMICS (2024)

Review Energy & Fuels

Effect of temperature on the mechanical properties of fine-grained soils- A review

Md Azhar, Somenath Mondal, Anh Minh Tang, Akhileshwar K. Singh

Summary: Contemporary geotechnical engineering practice involves the design and construction of structures that encounter thermal cycles. Understanding the effect of temperature on soil mechanical properties is challenging, but there have been significant contributions from numerous studies. However, to date, there is no comprehensive review that provides a holistic development of the subject and its connection to field applications.

GEOTHERMICS (2024)

Article Energy & Fuels

Numerical investigation of closed-loop geothermal systems in deep geothermal reservoirs

Mark White, Yaroslav Vasyliv, Koenraad Beckers, Mario Martinez, Paolo Balestra, Carlo Parisi, Chad Augustine, Gabriela Bran-Anleu, Roland Horne, Laura Pauley, Giorgia Bettin, Theron Marshall, Anastasia Bernat

Summary: The study presents a comprehensive numerical modeling of closed-loop geothermal systems (CLGSs) and develops a publicly accessible web application for feasibility studies. The results suggest that competitive levelized cost of heat (LCOH) can be achieved, but significant reductions in drilling costs are required to achieve competitive levelized cost of electricity (LCOE). A site-based case study for multi-lateral systems and the analysis of permeable wet rock are also provided, indicating the potential for improved power production with higher reservoir permeability and temperature.

GEOTHERMICS (2024)

Article Energy & Fuels

An advanced inverse modeling framework for efficient and flexible adjoint-based history matching of geothermal fields

Xiaoming Tian, Oleg Volkov, Denis Voskov

Summary: In this study, an efficient and flexible adjoint-based framework is proposed for history matching and forecasting geothermal energy extraction. The framework reduces the parameter space using Principal Component Analysis and speeds up the iteration process using the adjoint method. Operator-based linearization is used for efficient calculation and matrix assembly. The framework is demonstrated to be highly efficient for a heterogeneous reservoir with multiple realizations, generating reliable history-matching results.

GEOTHERMICS (2024)

Article Energy & Fuels

Fracture characterisation using 3-D seismic reflection data for advanced deep geothermal exploration in the NE German Basin

Asrillah Asrillah, Agus Abdullah, Klaus Bauer, Ben Norden, Charlotte M. Krawczyk

Summary: At the Gross Scho center dot nebeck geothermal research platform in the NE German Basin, the degree and direction of azimuthal velocity anisotropy caused by sub-vertical fracturing were determined through analysis of 3-D seismic reflection data. The observed anisotropy above the Zechstein salt roughly correlates to fault structures formed by an upwelling salt pillow, while below the salt, the less pronounced anisotropy and interpreted fracturing follow the trend of the regional stress field.

GEOTHERMICS (2024)

Article Energy & Fuels

Machine learning automatic picker for geothermal microseismicity analysis for practical procedure to reveal fine reservoir structures

Kyosuke Okamoto, Yusuke Mukuhira, Dian Darisma, Hiroshi Asanuma, Hirokazu Moriya

Summary: Microseismic monitoring is crucial in geothermal development, and manual phase picking for seismic data is time-consuming. Existing deep learning phase pickers may face challenges in geothermal fields due to their unique features. This study focuses on developing a specialized deep learning model for local seismic networks in geothermal fields, allowing automatic hypocenter determinations and revealing subsurface fine structures.

GEOTHERMICS (2024)