4.7 Review

High pH stress corrosion cracking initiation and crack evolution in buried steel pipelines: A review

Journal

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS
Volume 120, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

PERGAMON-ELSEVIER SCIENCE LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.engfailanal.2020.105013

Keywords

High pH stress corrosion cracking; Buried steel pipelines; Cathodic protection; Intergranular cracks; Pipeline integrity

Funding

  1. TransCanada Pipelines Limited
  2. Enbridge Inc.
  3. Pipeline Research Council International
  4. Natural Science and Engineering Research Council of Canada

Ask authors/readers for more resources

HpHSCC, a significant threat to buried pipelines, can lead to fast rupture or leakage. The vulnerable pipes undergo five sequential stages during HpHSCC, with mechanisms discussed from environmental, metallurgical, and mechanical loading points of views.
High pH Stress Corrosion Cracking (HpHSCC) was identified in the 1960 s for the first time and is considered to be a significant threat for buried pipelines. When certain specific conditions arise in the pipeline's environment and loading it leads to intergranular cracking on the axial-radial plane. These cracks can grow under continued adverse loading and eventually result in fast rupture or leakage. Large numbers of field investigations, exper imental studies, and simulations have been conducted to delineate and understand the circumstances that lead to HpHSCC. This paper will provide a review of the circumstances, conditions, and events that pipelines experiencing HpHSCC may undergo during the course of this phenomenon. HpHSCC cracks failure happens over an extended time period, and the life cycle of the vulnerable pipe involves five sequential stages viz. incubation stage, crack initiation and early stage of crack growth, preparation stage for mechanically derived crack growth, sustainable crack growth caused by mechanical driving force, and rapid crack propagation to failure. This paper discusses the mechanisms at each stage of HpHSCC from the environmental, metallurgical, and mechanical loading points of views. The interactions and sometimes synergistic effects of different parameters are discussed during the entire life cycle of the pipes. The central focus of this review is to correlate the events at each stage of crack propagation to loading conditions and their variability, which play a crucial role in estimating the remaining life of the susceptible linepipe to HpHSCC. The discussion will include how the cyclic-loading conditions can alter the steel properties and assist in intergranular crack initiation. The changes in the geometry of subcritical cracks and subsequent alteration in mechanical driving force for crack propagation are detailed. The contributing mechanisms that cause sustainable crack growth are expanded. The modeling of HpHSCC crack growth is discussed and outlined. The gaps in knowledge about HpHSCC are highlighted at the end along with necessary future research to improve the modeling of HpHSCC.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Low Concentration Sulfolane-Based Electrolyte for High Voltage Lithium Metal Batteries

Pengcheng Li, Hao Zhang, Jun Lu, Ge Li

Summary: Electrolyte engineering is crucial for the commercialization of lithium metal batteries. In this study, lithium metal is stabilized in a highly reactive sulfolane-based electrolyte under low concentration. The use of inorganic-polymer hybrid solid electrolyte interphase enables dense lithium deposition and high plating/stripping efficiency. The low concentration electrolyte also offers excellent cycling stability and cost-effectiveness.

ANGEWANDTE CHEMIE-INTERNATIONAL EDITION (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Dendrite-free zinc anode enabled by Buffer-like additive via strong cationic specific absorption

Ziwei Zhao, Pengcheng Li, Zhiqing Zhang, Hao Zhang, Ge Li

Summary: In this study, a novel electrolyte additive (histidine) was introduced into the conventional ZnSO4 electrolyte to address the issues of dendrite growth, hydrogen evolution reaction, and by-product generation with metallic zinc-based anodes. The additive molecule exhibited strong cationic specific absorption with the zinc anode, effectively regulating Zn2+ deposition and inhibiting hydrogen evolution. The unique buffer-like functional groups of histidine further stabilized the electrolyte interphase pH value, reducing by-product generation. With this electrolyte additive, a Zn||Zn symmetric cell showed excellent stability, running for more than 3000 hours under a current density of 2 mA cm-2.

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2023)

Article Nanoscience & Nanotechnology

A pH and Temperature Dual-Responsive Microgel-Embedded, Adhesive, and Tough Hydrogel for Drug Delivery and Wound Healing

Xuwen Peng, Qian Peng, Meng Wu, Wenda Wang, Yongfeng Gao, Xiong Liu, Yongxiang Sun, Diling Yang, Qiongyao Peng, Tao Wang, Xing-Zhen Chen, Jifang Liu, Hao Zhang, Hongbo Zeng

Summary: A pH and temperature dual-responsive microgel-embedded hydrogel with excellent mechanical properties and antimicrobial properties has been fabricated for potential applications as smart wound dressing materials.

ACS APPLIED MATERIALS & INTERFACES (2023)

Article Chemistry, Physical

Probing interaction forces associated with calcite scaling in aqueous solutions by atomic force microscopy

An Li, Jing Chang, Tao Shui, Qingxia Liu, Hao Zhang, Hongbo Zeng

Summary: The prevention of calcite aggregation and scaling is a challenging problem in aqueous systems and environmental science. This study investigated the nanoscale topographic features of calcite in aggregation and found that intermolecular and surface forces significantly influence the process. Factors such as solution pH, inhibitor concentration, and salinity were found to affect the forces involved, leading to either repulsion or adhesion, which could affect calcite aggregation and surface deposition.

JOURNAL OF COLLOID AND INTERFACE SCIENCE (2023)

Article Chemistry, Physical

Dual-function electrolyte additive enabling simultaneous electrode interface and coordination environment regulation for zinc-ion batteries

Yimei Chen, Facheng Gong, Wenjing Deng, Hao Zhang, Xiaolei Wang

Summary: A low-cost and biocompatible electrolyte additive with dual-function is designed to optimize the electrode interface and Zn2+ coordination environment. The phytic acid additive can absorb on the electrode surface, cover the active sites for proton attack, and guide the uniform deposition of zinc. It also helps in the de-hydration of Zn [(H2O)6]2+ and reduces water molecules in the first hydration layer of Zn2+ through hydrogen bonding interactions.

ENERGY STORAGE MATERIALS (2023)

Article Chemistry, Physical

Fast capture and stabilization of Li-ions via physicochemical dual effects for an ultra-stable self-supporting Li metal anode

Xuzi Zhang, Yue Li, Hao Zhang, Ge Li

Summary: Researchers designed a three-dimensional material with N-doped carbon nanofibers as the base and uniformly distributed NiCo2S4 nanosheets on the surface to address the issues of dendritic growth and volume fluctuation in lithium metal batteries. The unique structure of the material can guide lithium diffusion and prevent dendritic growth, ensuring long-term stable performance. When paired with a LiFePO4 cathode, the material shows enhanced performance compared to a bare Li anode.

CARBON ENERGY (2023)

Article Chemistry, Physical

Influence of impurity metal doping on calcite growth: A first-principles study

Yue Li, Hongbo Zeng, Hao Zhang

Summary: In this study, the effect of impurity metal doping on the initial stage of calcite growth was investigated using first-principles methods. The adsorption of the CaCO3 molecule on anhydrous and hydrated calcite surfaces doped with Mg, Cu, Zn, Sr, and Ba was analyzed, as well as the interactions between water molecules and the different dopants. The results suggest that the adsorption ability of anhydrous calcite surfaces towards the CaCO3 molecule is determined by the size of the dopant, while the adsorption behavior for water molecules is dominated by chemical bonding. The study provides new insights into the inhibiting mechanism of Mg, Cu, and Zn impurities on calcite growth and highlights the feasibility of using Sr and Ba dopants to facilitate calcite growth and mineralize toxic Sr and Ba from contaminated environments.

APPLIED SURFACE SCIENCE (2023)

Article Chemistry, Physical

Approach to hyperuniformity in a metallic glass-forming material exhibiting a fragile to strong glass transition

Hao Zhang, Xinyi Wang, Jiarui Zhang, Hai-Bin Yu, Jack F. Douglas

Summary: In this study, we investigated the glass-forming behavior of a metallic glass material (Al90Sm10), which exhibits a fragile-strong glass formation pattern. We focused on the anomalous static scattering and calculated the hyperuniformity index H and the mean-square particle displacement < u(2)> of the liquid. Comparative analysis with crystalline Cu suggests that the critical value of H on the order of 10(-3) is analogous to the Lindemann criterion for melting and softening processes. We further proposed that the emergence of fragile-strong glass formation and liquid-liquid phase separation in this class of liquids is due to a cooperative self-assembly process in the glass-forming liquid.

EUROPEAN PHYSICAL JOURNAL E (2023)

Article Chemistry, Physical

Surface interaction mechanisms of air bubbles, asphaltenes and oil drops in aqueous solutions with implications for interfacial engineering processes

Diling Yang, Ziqian Zhao, Lu Gong, Yongxiang Sun, Xuwen Peng, Qiongyao Peng, Tao Wang, Qi Liu, Hao Zhang, Hongbo Zeng

Summary: Research shows that the surface interactions between bubbles, oil, and interface-active species like asphaltenes have a significant impact on various engineering processes. Experimental studies have quantified the surface forces in different aqueous solutions and examined the effects of variables such as asphaltenes concentration, pH, salinity, Ca2+ ions, and surfactants.

JOURNAL OF COLLOID AND INTERFACE SCIENCE (2023)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

A Highly Active and Durable Hierarchical Electrocatalyst for Large-Current-Density Water Splitting

Yan Dong, Zhiping Deng, Hao Zhang, Guangyi Liu, Xiaolei Wang

Summary: In this work, heterojunction nanowire arrays consisting of manganese oxide and cobalt phosphide were designed to meet industrial demand. The optimized electrode exhibited remarkable bifunctional electrocatalytic performance, superior durability, and low voltage, highlighting their potential for practical industrial applications.

NANO LETTERS (2023)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Tailored pH-triggered surfactant for stepwise separation of a three-component mineral system

Qing Sun, Jingsi Chen, Ziqian Zhao, Diling Yang, Yaoyu Xiao, Hao Zhang, Xin Ma, Hong Zhong, Hongbo Zeng

Summary: In this study, a pH-responsive surfactant was developed, which selectively interacted with different target substances through two pH-switchable functional groups, enabling stepwise and efficient separation of a three-component mineral system.

SEPARATION AND PURIFICATION TECHNOLOGY (2023)

Correction Engineering, Multidisciplinary

Probing the Interfacial Forces and Surface Interaction Mechanisms in Petroleum Production Processes (vol 18 pg 49, 2022)

Diling Yang, Xuwen Peng, Qiongyao Peng, Tao Wang, Chenyu Qiao, Ziqian Zhao, Lu Gong, Yueliang Liu, Hao Zhang, Hongbo Zeng

ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Chemistry, Physical

Role of -O functional groups at the Ti3C2O2(MXene)/Al interface in enhancing the mechanical properties of aluminum matrix composites: A first-principles study

Guocai Lv, Wenjuan Qian, Hao Zhang, Ye Su, Ping Qian

Summary: This work systematically investigates the properties of Ti3C2(O2)/Al composites using first-principles calculations. The study shows that the -O functional group enhances the tensile properties of the composites. The Al-O-Ti interlocking structure improves the load transfer capability of AlMCs and thus enhances their mechanical properties.

APPLIED SURFACE SCIENCE (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Effect of solution pH and polyethylene oxide concentration on surface/ interface properties, flocculation and rheology of concentrated monodisperse ultrafine synthetic tailings slurry

Liyi Zhu, Wensheng Lyu, Xiaohui Mao, Ziqian Zhao, Diling Yang, Hao Zhang, Kun Wang, Peng Yang, Hongbo Zeng

Summary: The effects of polyethylene oxide (PEO) dosage and solution pH on the flocculation, rheological and surface/interfacial properties of the slurry were investigated. The study found that the settling rate of the tailings was lowest in strongly acidic solutions and reached its peak in strongly alkaline solutions. PEO dosage had a modest impact on the yield stress in strong acid solutions, but a notable influence in neutral and strongly alkaline solutions. The adsorption of PEO chains on silica surfaces was enhanced in strong alkaline solutions and partially inhibited in strongly acidic solutions. Surface force measurements showed that PEO chains can bridge the tailings particles, increasing the suspension's yield stress.

POWDER TECHNOLOGY (2023)

Article Materials Science, Multidisciplinary

Article Reversible zinc powder anode via crystal facet engineering

Zhixiao Xu, Yue Li, Ge Li, Hao Zhang, Xiaolei Wang

Summary: A reversible Zn powder electrode, fabricated by controlling the growth of zinc crystals in different solvents, shows improved performance and longer lifespan in batteries due to its high orientation of Zn (002) plane.

MATTER (2023)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Fatigue behaviour of additive manufactured Nb-48Ti alloy parts from powders produced by Plasma Atomization (PA) and Hydride-Dehydride (HDH) process

Willy Ank de Morais, Railson Bolsoni Falcao, Mario Boccalini Jr, Fernando Jose Gomes Landgraf

Summary: This study compares the fatigue behavior of bcc Nb-48 wt%Ti (Ti-36at%Nb) alloy parts processed by Laser Powder Bed Fusion (L-PBF) using two different types of powders (spherical powder produced by Plasma Atomization and irregularly shaped powder produced by Hydride-Dehydride). The results show that the fatigue behavior is similar for both powders, but the specimens produced from the Hydride-Dehydride powder have higher dispersed results. Fracture primarily occurs in the porosities near the machined sample surface, and the fatigue cracks propagate in a zigzag mode parallel to the L-PBF building direction.

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Prediction of thermomechanical fatigue life in RuT450 compacted graphite cast iron cylinder heads using the Neu/Sehitoglu model

Guoxi Jing, Shuai Sun, Teng Ma, Shubo Li, Tian Ma, Junchao Wei, Jianchao Pang

Summary: This study proposes a parameter identification method for predicting the TMF life of CGI materials used in cylinder heads. The study evaluates the TMF behavior of RuT450 material and successfully predicts its TMF life using multi-objective optimization. The results highlight the influence of plastic strain amplitude, temperature, and strain rate on the damage mechanism and life prediction.

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Experimental investigation of the failure of conical picks under thermal and abrasive effects

Xin Zhang, Xu Li, Weipeng Xu, Kuidong Gao, Kao Jiang, Xinyu Wang, Hongxin Wei

Summary: Conical picks are commonly used in tunnel excavation and often experience high temperatures during the cutting process. This study investigated the influence of temperature on the wear of conical picks and proposed a method for measuring rock abrasiveness that takes into account the thermal effect. The experimental results showed that cooling liquid reduced the maximum temperature and the mean mass loss of the conical pick. Additionally, the study examined the characteristics of oxygen and found evidence of peeling, cracking, and oxidation on the grinding rod used for rock abrasiveness measurement.

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Root cause analysis of flywheel gear failure in a marine diesel engine

Vivek Srivastava, Deependra Singh, A. G. Rao, V. P. Deshmukh

Summary: Engine gear failures are a significant concern in various industries. Investigating each gear failure and determining the root cause is important for preventing future failures. This study used experimental and numerical analysis techniques to investigate the premature failure of a flywheel gear in a marine diesel engine. The findings revealed that the gear failed due to overload stresses caused by overload torque generated from sudden inertial thrust in the internal combustionengine.

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Crack cause analysis of a third stage stator vane of the low-pressure compressor in an aeroengine

Jun Zhang, Weidong Liu, Feilong Liu, Zhiqiang Yang, Jinfang Peng, Minhao Zhu

Summary: During a major overhaul of an aeroengine, a cracked stator vane of the low-pressure compressor was discovered, with the crack originating from a corrosion pit located on the arc transition between the leading edge and the upper edge plate. The fracture surface exhibited signs of fatigue cracks, indicating a pit-related fatigue crack. Metallographic examination revealed that most corrosion pits were distributed beneath the bulging or peeling paint layer on the leading edge and the concave side. Identification of the corrosion products showed the presence of sulfate and alumina, suggesting atmospheric corrosion as a likely cause for the cracked stator vane.

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Failure analysis of a train coach underframe

Juan Jose Jimenez de Cisneros Fonfria, Ester Olmeda, Susana Sanz, Maria Garrosa, Vicente Diaz

Summary: Energy absorbing devices in vehicles can partially transform impact energy and protect passengers. In this paper, the failure analysis of the underframe crumple zone in a train car was conducted through finite element simulations, showing that the component acted properly after the impact.

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Experimental and numerical analysis study on the low and medium speed bird strike

Fengqi Zhang, Gang Luo, Haiyang Zhang, Peihong Cong, Lulu Liu, Wei Chen

Summary: In this study, a predictive model for bird strike trajectory was developed based on the quasi-linear viscoelastic model. By combining simulation analysis under multiple conditions, the model reproduced the trajectory change law in low and medium speed bird impact experiments.

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Emergency Shutdown Valve damage classification by machine learning using synthetic data

S. M. de Gouveia, L. de Abreu Correa, D. B. Teles, M. Oliveira, T. G. R. Clarke

Summary: Emergency Shutdown Valves (EDSVs) are used in industrial applications to interrupt fluid flow during hazardous events. The damage to the valve seats can be detected by analyzing the pressure and torque data. This study compared three processing options and found that evaluating the complete signature with a Gradient Boosting Classifier algorithm is the most effective strategy.

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Root cause analysis of an abnormal groove-clogging failure on sink rolls in continuous hot-dip galvanizing line

Xinyan Jin, Kai Wang, Hongwei Qian

Summary: This study investigated the root cause of an abnormal premature groove-clogging failure on a sink roll in a hot-dip galvanizing line. It was found that the failure was caused by the buildup of a large amount of Fe2Al5Znx dross in the grooves, and the key factor was the control of Tstrip.

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Study on the mechanism of mechanical properties deterioration of brake disc materials of high-speed train

Zhiqiang Li, Jie Li, Cen Li, Xiaodong Xie, Zhiyong Yang

Summary: In this study, the microstructure evolution of the material in the hot spot area of the high-speed train brake disc was observed and the mechanism of mechanical property degradation was obtained through tensile tests. The research results provide guidance for crack damage identification of the brake disc and condition-based maintenance.

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Tube-to-tube impact wear damage mechanism and nonlinear ultrasonic detection method of alloy 690 tubes

Lijia Luo, Yincheng Wang, Wei Chen, Zuming Zhao, Wenfei Chen, Shiyi Bao

Summary: Tube-to-tube impact wear is a significant factor in the failure of alloy 690 tubes in nuclear steam generators. This paper investigates the wear damage mechanism and detection method of alloy 690 tubes under tube-to-tube impact loads. The results reveal the wear damage mechanism through analysis of macro and micro morphologies as well as metallographic structures. A nonlinear ultrasonic wave mixing method is proposed for damage detection and a detection device is developed to implement this method. Experimental results indicate that the damage mode of tube-to-tube impact wear varies with impact load and cycle number, and the nonlinear modulation index is effective in assessing the damage degree of alloy 690 tubes.

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Collapse-resistant mechanism of RC beam-slab substructures using kinked steel plates under two-adjacent-edge-columns removal scenario

Xing-Ju Yang, Feng Lin, Xu Du, Lu Qiu

Summary: This paper proposes a novel method of improving the progressive collapse resistance of RC frame structures by adding locally debonded kinked steel plates (KPs). Experimental tests and finite element analysis reveal that the addition of KPs significantly enhances the ultimate resistance and deformability of the beam-slab substructures. The mechanism of resistance improvement is explained, and an analytical model is developed for predicting the ultimate resistance of the structures.

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

A dynamic installation method to improve the morphological characteristics of the bolt-hole contact interface in CFRP interference bolted structures

Xiaohe Wang, Zengqiang Cao

Summary: This paper presents a dynamic installation (DI) method based on electromagnetic force to reduce damage to composite laminates and improve joint performance. The study shows that DI can effectively decrease installation resistance, reduce severe damage to laminates, and improve stress distribution in the joint.

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Failure probability analysis of hydrogen doped pipelines based on the Bayesian network

Jitong Cui, Yingying Kong, Cuiwei Liu, Baoping Cai, Faisal Khan, Yuxing Li

Summary: This paper presents a method for quantifying the failure probability of hydrogen doped pipelines and utilizes Bayesian network for quantitative calculation. The results show that this method can more accurately assess the failure probability of hydrogen doped pipelines and provide a decision basis for preventing failure accidents.

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Investigation on the mechanism and measures of derailment of empty freight train passing a turnout in the diverging route

Yiping Jiang, Maoru Chi, Jungang Yang, Liangcheng Dai, Yuchen Xie, Zhaotuan Guo

Summary: This article investigates and simulates the derailment of empty freight trains at the switch section of a turnout in the diverging route, and proposes preventive measures. The results show that the derailment is caused by the combined effect of various factors, and reducing the longitudinal coupler force and the wheel rail friction coefficient can decrease the possibility of derailment. Additionally, installing a guard rail in front of the turnout can effectively prevent derailment.

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2024)