4.8 Review

Bugs scaring bugs: enemy-risk effects in biological control systems

Journal

ECOLOGY LETTERS
Volume 23, Issue 11, Pages 1693-1714

Publisher

WILEY
DOI: 10.1111/ele.13601

Keywords

Agricultural ecology; behavioural ecology; biological control; enemy-risk effects; natural enemies; non-consumptive effects; pest management; predation risk; predator-prey ecology; trophic cascades

Categories

Funding

  1. USDA NIFA Predoctoral Fellowship [2019-67011-29710]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Enemy-risk effects, often referred to as non-consumptive effects (NCEs), are an important feature of predator-prey ecology, but their significance has had little impact on the conceptual underpinning or practice of biological control. We provide an overview of enemy-risk effects in predator-prey interactions, discuss ways in which risk effects may impact biocontrol programs and suggest avenues for further integration of natural enemy ecology and integrated pest management. Enemy-risk effects can have important influences on different stages of biological control programs, including natural enemy selection, efficacy testing and quantification of non-target impacts. Enemy-risk effects can also shape the interactions of biological control with other pest management practices. Biocontrol systems also provide community ecologists with some of the richest examples of behaviourally mediated trophic cascades and demonstrations of how enemy-risk effects play out among species with no shared evolutionary history, important topics for invasion biology and conservation. We conclude that the longstanding use of ecological theory by biocontrol practitioners should be expanded to incorporate enemy-risk effects, and that community ecologists will find many opportunities to study enemy-risk effects in biocontrol settings.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.8
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Parasitology

Host traits, identity, and ecological conditions predict consistent flea abundance and prevalence on free-living California ground squirrels

Jennifer E. Smith, Imani B. Smith, Cecelia L. Working, Imani D. Russell, Shelby A. Krout, Kajol S. Singh, Andrew Sih

Summary: Understanding individual differences in parasite loads among hosts is crucial in understanding disease spread, and different flea species occupy distinct ecological niches. Host heterogeneity within populations can play a significant role in structuring the emergence of zoonotic diseases.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL FOR PARASITOLOGY (2021)

Letter Ecology

A Broader View on Mate Choice and Assortative Mating by Behavioral Type: A Reply to Dingemanse et al.

Amelia A. Munson, Cameron Jones, Hannes Schraft, Andrew Sih

TRENDS IN ECOLOGY & EVOLUTION (2021)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Consistent after all: behavioural repeatability in a long-lived lizard across a 6-year field study

E. Payne, D. L. Sinn, O. Spiegel, S. T. Leu, M. G. Gardner, S. S. Godfrey, C. Wohlfeil, A. Sih

Summary: The study on animal personalities in wild sleepy lizards found that males were marginally more aggressive and bolder than females, with no significant effect of mass on behavior but a positive relationship between tick loads and aggression and boldness. Both aggression and boldness showed repeatability over different timescales and there was no significant difference in repeatability between sexes. Despite a weak positive correlation, no syndrome was found between aggression and boldness.

ANIMAL BEHAVIOUR (2021)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Stable social groups foster conformity and among-group differences

A. Munson, M. Michelangeli, A. Sih

Summary: The social niche hypothesis suggests that social interactions play a key role in generating consistent individual differences in behavior, while the social conformity hypothesis points out that frequent interactions within a group may mask or suppress these differences. Research findings show that group-housed sticklebacks exhibited increased among-group differences in shoaling tendencies, while individually housed fish showed decreased individual shoaling variation and repeatability.

ANIMAL BEHAVIOUR (2021)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Early life experience influences dispersal in coyotes (Canis latrans)

Emily Zepeda, Eric Payne, Ashley Wurth, Andrew Sih, Stanley Gehrt

Summary: Natal dispersal plays a key role in connecting individual behavior with ecological processes, especially in urban environments. The study found that coyotes with more developed habitat in their natal home range were more likely to disperse and travel farther. However, the relationship between natal habitat and habitat selection during settlement produced mixed results, while early life experience with urbanization did not seem to influence survival to adulthood or vehicular mortality.

BEHAVIORAL ECOLOGY (2021)

Article Ecology

Estimating encounter location distributions from animal tracking data

Michael J. Noonan, Ricardo Martinez-Garcia, Grace H. Davis, Margaret C. Crofoot, Roland Kays, Ben T. Hirsch, Damien Caillaud, Eric Payne, Andrew Sih, David L. Sinn, Orr Spiegel, William F. Fagan, Christen H. Fleming, Justin M. Calabrese

Summary: This study introduces a method for describing the long-term encounter location probabilities for movement within home ranges, termed the conditional distribution of encounters (CDE), and demonstrates its broad ecological relevance. The CDE can be used to estimate territorial borders, identify key resources, quantify potential for competitive or predatory interactions, and understand behavior changes resulting from location-specific encounter probabilities. It provides researchers with a better understanding of population dynamics and does not require specialized data collection protocols. This method is now openly available via the ctmm R package.

METHODS IN ECOLOGY AND EVOLUTION (2021)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Population differences in the effect of context on personality in an invasive lizard

Jack A. Brand, Annalise C. Naimo, Marcus Michelangeli, Jake M. Martin, Andrew Sih, Bob B. M. Wong, David G. Chapple

Summary: This study examined the variation in personality traits of delicate skinks across different ecological contexts, finding that environmental background significantly influenced the structure of lizard personality, with activity rates being repeatable when food resources were present but not when they were absent. This suggests the important role of environmental context in mediating the structure of animal personality traits.

BEHAVIORAL ECOLOGY (2021)

Editorial Material Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

Andrew Sih

Andrew Sih

CURRENT BIOLOGY (2021)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Behavioural correlations across multiple stages of the antipredator response: do animals that escape sooner hide longer?

Chelsea A. Ortiz-Jimenez, Marcus Michelangeli, Erika Pendleton, Andrew Sih, Jennifer E. Smith

Summary: This study found that behaviors of California ground squirrels in response to predators are repeatable and positively correlated, providing an underlying mechanism for a trade-off involving fearfulness expression across stages. Additionally, human activity was found to influence some but not all stages of the anti-predator response.

ANIMAL BEHAVIOUR (2022)

Article Ecology

Personality, spatiotemporal ecological variation and resident/explorer movement syndromes in the sleepy lizard

Marcus Michelangeli, Eric Payne, Orr Spiegel, David L. Sinn, Stephan T. Leu, Michael G. Gardner, Andrew Sih

Summary: Individual variation in movement patterns is important for understanding the dynamics of populations and communities. This study on sleepy lizards found consistent differences in movement traits among individuals, which were influenced by internal traits, environmental factors, and habitat type. These differences reflect variation in life-history tactics and have implications for ecological and evolutionary processes.

JOURNAL OF ANIMAL ECOLOGY (2022)

Article Ecology

Beyond spatial overlap: harnessing new technologies to resolve the complexities of predator-prey interactions

Justin P. Suraci, Justine A. Smith, Simon Chamaille-Jammes, Kaitlyn M. Gaynor, Menna Jones, Barney Luttbeg, Euan G. Ritchie, Michael J. Sheriff, Andrew Sih

Summary: Predation risk, influenced by animal behavior and environmental conditions, is crucial in theoretical and applied ecology. Research often overlooks ecological complexities and relies on proxies for actual risk, such as predator-prey spatial overlap. Emerging technologies and statistical methods are aiding in a more detailed understanding of predator-prey interactions, leading to improved targeting and effectiveness of conservation interventions.

OIKOS (2022)

Article Biology

Mast seeding promotes evolution of scatter-hoarding

Rafal Zwolak, Dale Clement, Andrew Sih, Sebastian J. Schreiber

Summary: The phenomenon of masting plays a crucial role in the evolution of scatter-hoarding, as it reduces seed pilferage and lowers the reproductive cost of caching, promoting the evolution of scatter-hoarding behavior.

PHILOSOPHICAL TRANSACTIONS OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY B-BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES (2021)

Article Biology

Frontiers in quantifying wildlife behavioural responses to chemical pollution

Michael G. Bertram, Jake M. Martin, Erin S. McCallum, Lesley A. Alton, Jack A. Brand, Bryan W. Brooks, Daniel Cerveny, Jerker Fick, Alex T. Ford, Gustav Hellstrom, Marcus Michelangeli, Shinichi Nakagawa, Giovanni Polverino, Minna Saaristo, Andrew Sih, Hung Tan, Charles R. Tyler, Bob B. M. Wong, Tomas Brodin

Summary: Animal behavior is highly sensitive to chemical pollution, but current research methods often fail to address the complexity of natural environments. This review aims to guide the development of behavioral ecotoxicology towards increased environmental realism and understanding.

BIOLOGICAL REVIEWS (2022)

Review Ecology

Enhancing the ecological realism of evolutionary mismatch theory

Lea Pollack, Amelia Munson, Matthew S. Savoca, Pete C. Trimmer, Sean M. Ehlman, Michael A. Gil, Andrew Sih

Summary: This article presents an expanded cue-response framework using signal detection theory to predict variation in animals' behavioral responses to novel situations. By considering three behavioral options, the study provides a more holistic perspective and distinguishes between severe and moderate traps, guiding management strategies in a changing world.

TRENDS IN ECOLOGY & EVOLUTION (2022)

Review Behavioral Sciences

Task syndromes: linking personality and task allocation in social animal groups

J. C. Loftus, A. A. Perez, A. Sih

Summary: This study explores how individual differences in behavior can guide task specialization in animal groups, introducing the concept of task syndrome to explain the correlation between behavioral tendencies and task participation. By integrating concepts from task allocation research in eusocial organisms with findings from animal personality research, the study identifies future areas for research at the intersection of social behavior and animal personality.

BEHAVIORAL ECOLOGY (2021)

No Data Available