4.8 Article

Megathrust shear force controls mountain height at convergent plate margins

Journal

NATURE
Volume 582, Issue 7811, Pages 225-+

Publisher

NATURE PORTFOLIO
DOI: 10.1038/s41586-020-2340-7

Keywords

-

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The shear force along convergent plate boundary faults (megathrusts) determines the height of mountain ranges that can be mechanically sustained(1-4). However, whether the true height of mountain ranges corresponds to this tectonically supported elevation is debated(4-7). In particular, climate-dependent erosional processes are often assumed to exert a first-order control on mountain height(5-12), although this assumption has remained difficult to validate(12). Here we constrain the shear force along active megathrusts using their rheological properties and then determine the tectonically supported elevation using a force balance model. We show that the height of mountain ranges around the globe matches this elevation, irrespective of climatic conditions and the rate of erosion. This finding indicates that mountain ranges are close to force equilibrium and that their height is primarily controlled by the megathrust shear force. We conclude that temporal variations in mountain height reflect long-term changes in the force balance but are not indicative of a direct climate control on mountain elevation. Simulations using a force balance model match mountain heights observed around the globe, suggesting that mountain elevation is almost completely controlled by tectonic forces rather than erosion.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.8
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Seismic images of the Northern Chilean subduction zone at 19°40′S, prior to the 2014 Iquique earthquake

Ina Storch, Stefan Buske, Pia Victor, Onno Oncken

Summary: The study conducted in the Northern Chilean subduction zone involved detailed geological investigations and data analysis, revealing pre-earthquake geological features, proposing views on plate interface reflectivity variations, and observing complex seismic activities between plates. The research results also revealed the existence of two distinct geological units beneath the continental slope, with seismic activities used to infer interactions between plates.

GEOPHYSICAL JOURNAL INTERNATIONAL (2021)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

The 2014 Juan Fernandez microplate earthquake doublet: Evidence for large thrust faulting driven by microplate rotation

Simone Cesca, Carla Valenzuela Malebran, Jose Angel Lopez-Comino, Timothy Davis, Carlos Tassara, Onno Oncken, Torsten Dahm

Summary: The seismic doublet that occurred near the Juan Fernandez microplate on October 9, 2014, is the largest earthquake recorded in the region, with a complex sequence of thrust and strike-slip earthquakes along different structures. The seismic activity, including large thrust earthquakes, appears to be partially accommodated aseismically in the northern part of the microplate and its boundary, but still poses a significant hazard with tsunamigenic potential for islands in the South Pacific region.

TECTONOPHYSICS (2021)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Postglacial slip distribution along the Teton normal fault (Wyoming, USA), derived from tectonically offset geomorphological features

Andrea Hampel, Ralf Hetzel, Maria-Sophie Erdmann

Summary: Using high-resolution digital elevation models derived from lidar data, this study investigated the asymmetrical postglacial slip distribution along the strike of the Teton fault, revealing vertical displacement differences across tectonically offset geomorphological features along the entire front of the Teton Range. The results indicate that the maximum vertical displacements are located in specific areas north of Jenny Lake and along the southwestern shore of Jackson Lake.

GEOSPHERE (2021)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

New constraints on the exhumation history of the western Tauern Window (European Alps) from thermochronology, thermokinematic modeling, and topographic analysis

Reinhard Wolff, Ralf Hetzel, Istvan Dunkl, Aneta A. Anczkiewicz

Summary: The study utilizes various methods to constrain the exhumation history of the Tauern Window in the footwall of the Brenner fault, revealing a fault-slip rate of approximately 3.9 km/Myr, and exhumation rates of around 1.1-1.3 km/Myr. Additionally, the thermokinematic model effectively predicts the heat transfer processes related to this extensional fault system.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF EARTH SCIENCES (2021)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Tracing wedge-internal deformation by means of strontium isotope systematics of vein carbonates

Armin Dielforder, Igor M. Villa, Alfons Berger, Marco Herwegh

Summary: This study presents the strontium isotope ratios of vein carbonates from the Central European Alps, which helps to understand the tectonic evolution of fold-and-thrust belts. The vein carbonates can trace the evolution of pore fluids and provide insights into the deformation events.

GEOLOGICAL MAGAZINE (2022)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Slow slip in subduction zones: Reconciling deformation fabrics with instrumental observations and laboratory results

O. Oncken, S. Angiboust, G. Dresen

Summary: The study explores the microstructures of cataclasites in subduction zones and deformation rates associated with slow earthquakes, indicating that cataclastic flow is the dominant physical mechanism governing transient creep episodes. The results suggest that seismic slip events may reduce fluid pressures, promoting pressure-solution creep.

GEOSPHERE (2022)

Article Geography, Physical

LGM ice extent and deglaciation history in the Gurktal and Lavantal Alps (eastern European Alps): first constraints from 10Be surface exposure dating of glacially polished quartz veins

Andreas Woelfler, Andrea Hampel, Armin Dielforder, Ralf Hetzel, Christoph Glotzbach

Summary: This study presents the first Be-10 surface exposure ages from the eastern Alps east of the Tauern Window, providing insights into the Last Glacial Maximum ice extent and deglaciation history. Results indicate that the Gurktal Alps deglaciated between 16 and 14 ka, in line with ice-sheet model predictions, while the Lavantal Alps may have been ice free or partially covered by ice before the Last Glacial Maximum. These findings suggest potential overestimation of ice extent by ice-sheet models in the easternmost Alps.

JOURNAL OF QUATERNARY SCIENCE (2022)

Article Geology

Uplift and fault slip during the 2016 Kaikoura Earthquake and Late Quaternary, Kaikoura Peninsula, New Zealand

Andrew Nicol, John Begg, Vasso Saltogianni, Vasiliki Mouslopoulou, Onno Oncken, Andrew Howell

Summary: The Kaikoura Earthquake uplifted Kaikoura Peninsula by approximately 1 m, mainly resulting from slip on multiple faults. The variable co-seismic uplift in 2016 can be reproduced by slip on different faults. The tilting of Late Quaternary marine terraces is primarily influenced by slip rates on the OSTF and ABF.

NEW ZEALAND JOURNAL OF GEOLOGY AND GEOPHYSICS (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Existence of a continental-scale river system in eastern Tibet during the late Cretaceous-early Palaeogene

Xudong Zhao, Huiping Zhang, Ralf Hetzel, Eric Kirby, Alison R. Duvall, Kelin X. Whipple, Jianguo Xiong, Yifei Li, Jianzhang Pang, Ying Wang, Ping Wang, Kang Liu, Pengfei Ma, Bo Zhang, Xuemei Li, Jiawei Zhang, Peizhen Zhang

Summary: This study provides evidence for the existence of a continental-scale river system in eastern Tibet before the India-Asia collision, which developed an extensive low-relief landscape that was uplifted and dissected during the late Cenozoic. The results challenge existing models of drainage networks and reveal the importance of Late Cretaceous paleotopography.

NATURE COMMUNICATIONS (2021)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Spatially focused erosion in the High Himalaya and the geometry of the Main Himalayan Thrust in Central Nepal (85°E) from thermo-kinematic modeling of thermochronological data in the Gyirong region (southern China)

Reinhard Wolff, Kyra Hoelzer, Ralf Hetzel, Qiang Xu, Istvan Dunkl, Aneta A. Anczkiewicz, Zhenyu Li

Summary: The subsurface structure of the Himalaya is dominated by the seismically active Main Himalayan Thrust fault. The geometry of the Main Himalayan Thrust in central Nepal has a flat-ramp-flat shape, while the geometry in the northern High Himalaya is still uncertain. Through new data from the Gyimng region in China, it has been determined that the ramp has a greater width and reaches a greater depth below the northern High Himalaya than previously thought. The fault is presumed to develop as a gently-dipping ductile shear zone farther north.

TECTONOPHYSICS (2022)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Global Constraints on Intermediate-Depth Intraslab Stresses From Slab Geometries and Mechanisms of Double Seismic Zone Earthquakes

C. Sippl, A. Dielforder, T. John, S. M. Schmalholz

Summary: The study reveals that the intraslab stress field in double seismic zones is more variable than previously thought, with a classical pattern of compressive over extensive events observed in only about half of the global double seismic zone locations. The occurrence of DSZ seismicity is not limited to regions of slab bending, and there is no clear global prevalence of slab unbending at intermediate depths. Focal mechanism observations are often inconsistent with bending estimates from slab geometries, suggesting that other stress types may also play an important role.

GEOCHEMISTRY GEOPHYSICS GEOSYSTEMS (2022)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Megathrust Stress Drop as Trigger of Aftershock Seismicity: Insights From the 2011 Tohoku Earthquake, Japan

A. Dielforder, G. M. Bocchini, K. Kemna, A. Hampel, R. M. Harrington, O. Oncken

Summary: Numerous normal-faulting aftershocks commonly occur in subduction forearcs after large megathrust earthquakes. The occurrence of postseismic normal faulting is due to stress changes induced by the stress drop along the megathrust. However, the details of forearc stress changes and aftershock triggering mechanisms are still not well understood. In this study, numerical force-balance models combined with Coulomb failure analysis are used to show that the stress drop along the megathrust can support normal faulting, and forearc-wide aftershock triggering is feasible within a narrow range of megathrust stress drop values and preseismic stress states.

GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Evolution of a low convergence collisional orogen: a review of Pyrenean orogenesis

Mary Ford, Emmanuel Masini, Jaume Verges, Raphael Pik, Sebastien Ternois, Julien Leger, Armin Dielforder, Gianluca Frasca, Arjan Grool, Constance Vinciguerra, Thomas Bernard, Paul Angrand, Antoine Cremades, Gianreto Manatschal, Sebastien Chevrot, Laurent Jolivet, Frederic Mouthereau, Isabelle Thinon, Sylvain Calassou

Summary: This paper provides an overview of the formation and evolution of the Pyrenees, focusing on the early convergence stage. It highlights the contributions of the OROGEN project and the integration of its results with other collaborative projects. The paper also discusses the role of salt tectonics in the region.

BSGF-EARTH SCIENCES BULLETIN (2022)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

The rise and demise of deep accretionary wedges: A long-term field and numerical modeling perspective

Samuel Angiboust, Armel Menant, Taras Gerya, Onno Oncken

Summary: The article reviews several decades of research on the tectonic transport processes in accretionary wedges, focusing on underplating and tectonic erosion. Through geochronological characteristics and zircon detrital ages, ancient active margins can be deciphered. Two-dimensional thermo-mechanical experiments help understand mass-flow pathways and the distribution of stresses in subduction zones, revealing the dynamical instability of fluid-bearing accretionary systems.

GEOSPHERE (2021)

No Data Available