Patient Selection Strategies to Maximize Therapeutic Index of Antibody-Drug Conjugates: Prior Approaches and Future Directions

Antibody-drug conjugates (ADC) are targeted agents that have shown promise in treating cancer. A central challenge in development of ADCs is the relatively narrow therapeutic index observed in clinical studies. Patient selection strategies based on expression of the target in tumors have the potential to maximize benefit and provide the best chance of clinical success; however, implementation of biomarker-driven trials can be difficult both practically and scientifically. We conducted a survey of recent clinical experience from early-phase ADC trials completed between 2000 and 2019 to evaluate the different approaches to patient selection currently being used and assess whether there is evidence that target expression is associated with clinical activity. Our analysis of patient selection strategies indicates that optimal trial design for early-stage trials should be based on multiple factors, including prevalence and heterogeneity of target expression among intent-to-treat patients, as well as biological factors influencing expression of cell surface and soluble target. To ensure a high probability of success, early implementation of patient selection strategies centered around target expression are pivotal to development of ADCs. In this review, we propose a strategic approach that can be applied for optimization of trial design.