4.5 Review

Operational research applied to decisions in home health care: A systematic literature review

Journal

JOURNAL OF THE OPERATIONAL RESEARCH SOCIETY
Volume 72, Issue 9, Pages 1960-1991

Publisher

TAYLOR & FRANCIS LTD
DOI: 10.1080/01605682.2020.1750311

Keywords

OR in health services; home health care; systematic literature review

Funding

  1. Health Foundation [79808]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Efficient deployment of resources in home-based care is crucial for sustainable health and social care systems globally. This study aimed to identify operational research approaches to support decision-making in home health care, highlighting a lack of guidance and coherence in the literature for effective decisions. Insights from other areas of application may provide direction for future research to address this shortfall.
The efficient deployment of resources in home-based care is considered crucial for the sustainability of health and social care systems worldwide. The aim of this study was to identify and review operational research approaches to support decision-making in home health care. We identified a set of linked decisions at different planning levels (strategic, tactical, operational) and conducted a systematic review of operational research approaches used to address these decisions. We also sampled OR literature applied to analogous decisions in other settings. The 77 papers selected focused predominantly on solutions for staff-to-patient allocation, visit scheduling and staff routing, few of which were adopted by organisations. Few studies dealt with tactical decisions of team size and composition or strategic decisions of districting, and we found no studies on contract design for commissioning home health care, on staff role definitions or on reassessment of patient need. Integrative work is scarce and the aspects of system performance considered are variable and diverse. For these reasons the literature does not provide guidance for home health care services aspiring to effective and coherent decisions across planning levels. OR approaches from other areas of application provide some insights for future research aimed at addressing this shortfall.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Management

Praxis in healthcare OR: An empirical behavioural OR study

Sonya Crowe, Martin Utley

Summary: Operational researchers in healthcare face challenges related to flexibility, team maturity, organizational motivations, intuition, altruism, and creative risk-taking, all of which can impact the success of their work. Understanding these behavioral factors is crucial for achieving effective operational research outcomes in the field of healthcare.

JOURNAL OF THE OPERATIONAL RESEARCH SOCIETY (2022)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

The road to hell is paved with good intentions: the experience of applying for national data for linkage and suggestions for improvement

Julie A. Taylor, Sonya Crowe, Ferran Espuny Pujol, Rodney C. Franklin, Richard G. Feltbower, Lee J. Norman, James Doidge, Doug William Gould, Christina Pagel

Summary: Linking data sets from clinical and national audits, national registries, and other NHS encounter data can improve healthcare services, but the process of obtaining linked national data sets is challenging. The study for LAUNCHES QI faced challenges such as large amounts of information required, lack of clarity on processes, and resource constraints, leading to an extended timeframe of 2.5 years for data acquisition. Streamlining the application process for accessing data and providing clarity to data controllers could facilitate governance and accelerate scientific studies and healthcare improvements.

BMJ OPEN (2021)

Article Cardiac & Cardiovascular Systems

Cohort study of intervened functionally univentricular heart in England and Wales (2000-2018)

Elena Hadjicosta, Rodney Franklin, Anna Seale, Oliver Stumper, Victor Tsang, David R. Anderson, Christina Pagel, Sonya Crowe, Ferran Espuny Pujol, Deborah Ridout, Kate L. Brown

Summary: The study found that treatment pathways and survival rates for patients with functionally univentricular hearts are complex and variable, but nearly 80% of children survived to 10 years. Longer-term analyses based on diagnosis can provide information for parents, patients, and clinicians, driving practice improvements for complex CHD.

HEART (2022)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

Linkage of National Congenital Heart Disease Audit data to hospital, critical care and mortality national data sets to enable research focused on quality improvement

Ferran Espuny Pujol, Christina Pagel, Katherine L. Brown, James C. Doidge, Richard G. Feltbower, Rodney C. Franklin, Arturo Gonzalez-Izquierdo, Doug W. Gould, Lee J. Norman, John Stickley, Julie A. Taylor, Sonya Crowe

Summary: This study linked five national data sets to create longitudinal healthcare trajectories for patients with congenital heart disease (CHD), enabling a more comprehensive analysis of patient journeys and outcomes. The results showed successful linkage of four national data sets, providing valuable insights for future research.

BMJ OPEN (2022)

Article Cardiac & Cardiovascular Systems

Transfer of congenital heart patients from paediatric to adult services in England

Ferran Espuny Pujol, Rodney C. Franklin, Sonya Crowe, Kate L. Brown, Lorna Swan, Christina Pagel, Kate M. English

Summary: This study assessed the transfer of patients from paediatric cardiac to adult congenital heart disease (ACHD) services in England and found that majority of patients with moderate or severe CHD transfer to adult services. Patients who do not transfer undergo fewer elective CHD procedures over the following decade.

HEART (2022)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Machine learning for real-time aggregated prediction of hospital admission for emergency patients

Zella King, Joseph Farrington, Martin Utley, Enoch Kung, Samer Elkhodair, Steve Harris, Richard Sekula, Jonathan Gillham, Kezhi Li, Sonya Crowe

Summary: Machine learning for hospital operations is not well studied. In this study, a prediction pipeline using live electronic health records from a UK teaching hospital's emergency department was developed to generate short-term probabilistic forecasts of emergency admissions. The models achieved good predictive performance depending on the elapsed visit time at the point of prediction.

NPJ DIGITAL MEDICINE (2022)

Article Management

Here's something we prepared earlier: Development, use and reuse of a configurable, inter-disciplinary approach for tackling overcrowding in NHS hospitals

Sonya Crowe, Luca Grieco, Tom Monks, Brad Keogh, Marion Penn, Mike Clancy, Samer Elkhodair, Cecilia Vindrola-Padros, Naomi J. Fulop, Martin Utley

Summary: Hospital emergency department overcrowding is a global issue. Most previous studies focus on bespoke models for improvement but ignore the organizational context and have limited impact. This study introduces a configurable approach that combines quantitative modeling, qualitative analysis, and assessment of the implementation context, which successfully informed strategy in one hospital and had mixed results in three other hospitals.

JOURNAL OF THE OPERATIONAL RESEARCH SOCIETY (2023)

Article Health Policy & Services

Using stochastic simulation modelling to study occupancy levels of decentralised admission avoidance units in Norway

Meetali Kakad, Martin Utley, Fredrik A. A. Dahl

Summary: Finding alternatives to acute hospital admission is a priority, and Norway's decentralised municipal acute units (MAUs) were established to divert low-acuity patients away from hospitals. However, MAUs have faced criticism for low occupancy and not relieving pressures on hospitals. Through a simulation model, we found that merging MAUs alone may not substantially increase mean occupancy, but it offers potential for bed capacity reduction without affecting service provision. Our work has relevance for other admissions avoidance units and provides a method for estimating unconstrained demand for beds in absence of historical data.

HEALTH SYSTEMS (2023)

Article Health Policy & Services

What's the evidence?-Towards more empirical evaluations of the impact of OR interventions in healthcare

Guillaume Lame, Sonya Crowe, Matthew Barclay

Summary: This paper reviews evaluation standards in healthcare improvement research, highlights the lack of robust evaluation of healthcare operational research, and proposes possible ways for building better empirical evaluations.

HEALTH SYSTEMS (2022)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

What was the impact of the first wave of COVID-19 on the delivery of care to children and adults with congenital heart disease? A qualitative study using online forums

Jo Wray, Christina Pagel, Adrian H. Chester, Fiona Kennedy, Sonya Crowe

Summary: The global healthcare system has been significantly impacted by the COVID-19 pandemic, leading to major changes in care delivery. This study focused on the perspectives of patients with CHD and their parents/carers, highlighting disruptions to care delivery, inconsistent advice and messaging, and varying communication from healthcare professionals.

BMJ OPEN (2021)

No Data Available