4.7 Review

Pesticides used in Europe and autism spectrum disorder risk: can novel exposure hypotheses be formulated beyond organophosphates, organochlorines, pyrethroids and carbamates? - A systematic review

Journal

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH
Volume 187, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

ACADEMIC PRESS INC ELSEVIER SCIENCE
DOI: 10.1016/j.envres.2020.109646

Keywords

Pesticides; Environmental exposure; Neurobehavior; Autism spectrum disorder; Europe

Funding

  1. OpenHealth institute

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Background: A growing body of evidences suggests an association between early exposure to organophosphates (OPs), organochlorines (OCs), pyrethroids or carbamates and autism spectrum disorder (ASD). However, there are limited data about the other pesticide groups, especially in Europe. Objectives: Based on a systematic review, we aimed to assess the influence of neuro- and thyrotoxic agricultural and domestic pesticides (other than OPs, OCs, pyrethroids and carbamates) authorized in Europe on risk of ASD in children or ASD behavioral phenotypes in rodents. Methods: Pesticides were initially identified in the Hazardous Substances Data Bank. 20 currently used (10 pesticide groups) were retained based on the higher exposure potential. Epidemiological (children) and in vivo (rodents) studies were identified through PubMed, Web of Science and TOXLINE, without restriction of publication date or country (last update: November 2019). The risk of bias and level of evidence were also assessed. This systematic review is registered at the International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews (PROSPERO, registration number CRD42019145384). Results: In total, two epidemiological and 15 in vivo studies were retained, focusing on the azole, neonicotinoid, phenylpyrazole and phosphonoglycine pesticide groups. No study was conducted in Europe. Glyphosate, imidacloprid, clothianidin, myclobutanil, acetamiprid, tebuconazole, thiabendazole and fipronil, globally reported an association with an increased risk of ASD in children and/or ASD behavioral phenotypes in rodents. In children, glyphosate and myclobutanil showed a moderate level of evidence in their association with ASD, whereas imidacloprid showed an inadequate level of evidence. In rodents, clothianidin, imidacloprid and glyphosate showed a high level of evidence in their association with altered behavioral, learning and memory skills. Conclusion: In the framework of environmental risk factors of ASD, novel hypotheses can be formulated about early exposure to eight pesticides. Glyphosate presented the most salient level of evidence. Given their neuro-and thyrotoxic properties, additional studies are needed for the 12 other pesticides not yet studied as potential ASD risk factors according to our inclusion criteria.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Review Psychology, Developmental

Group-based educational interventions in adolescents and young adults with ASD without ID: a systematic review focusing on the transition to adulthood

Raphael Chancel, Stephanie Miot, Florine Dellapiazza, Amaria Baghdadli

Summary: There is a growing number of young people with autism-spectrum disorder (ASD) transitioning to adulthood. Among them, individuals without intellectual disability (ID) have significant adaptive deficits and need individualized care and support services. Group-based interventions, such as patient education, social-skills training, and cognitive-behavioral therapy, are effective in improving the daily life and prospects of these young individuals.

EUROPEAN CHILD & ADOLESCENT PSYCHIATRY (2022)

Article Psychology, Developmental

A longitudinal exploratory study of changes in sensory processing in children with ASD from the ELENA cohort

Florine Dellapiazza, Cecile Michelon, Marie-Christine Picot, Amaria Baghdadli

Summary: This exploratory longitudinal study found that there are different trajectories of sensory processing in children with ASD, with three subgroups based on the course of SP (improvement, stable, and worsening). Additionally, children's adaptive skills and maladaptive behaviors were related to the course of SP.

EUROPEAN CHILD & ADOLESCENT PSYCHIATRY (2022)

Review Psychology, Developmental

Predictors of an earlier diagnosis of Autism Spectrum Disorder in children and adolescents: a systematic review (1987-2017)

Julie Loubersac, Cecile Michelon, Laetitia Ferrando, Marie-Christine Picot, Amaria Baghdadli

Summary: This systematic review aims to identify factors associated with the age at which ASD is diagnosed. The results suggest that early diagnosis is associated with delayed social communication or intellectual disability, while there is limited evidence regarding the associations with sex, race, parental education, socioeconomic status, and accessibility to health care. Further studies using large and well-characterized data sets are needed to explore the clinical and socio-environmental factors involved in early diagnosis.

EUROPEAN CHILD & ADOLESCENT PSYCHIATRY (2023)

Article Nursing

Burnout among direct support workers of adults with autism spectrum disorder and intellectual disability

Sylvie Couderc, Florence Cousson-Gelie, Eric Pernon, Bertrand Porro, Stephanie Miot, Amaria Baghdadli

Summary: This study describes the burnout of DSWs who support adults with ASD-ID and identifies personal variables (experience and specialised training for ASD) and transactional variables (perceived stress and coping strategies) that could predict and mediate burnout.

SCANDINAVIAN JOURNAL OF CARING SCIENCES (2023)

Article Psychiatry

Anxiety and depression in parents of children with autism spectrum disorder during the first COVID-19 lockdown: Report from the ELENA cohort

Ela Miniarikova, Christelle Vernhet, Marianne Peries, Julie Loubersac, Marie-Christine Picot, Kerim Munir, Amaria Baghdadli

Summary: This study investigated the impact of the first lockdown in France on the anxiety and depression levels of parents of children with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD). The results showed that the parents' anxiety and depression levels were lower during the lockdown compared to the last visit, which coincided with the child's ASD diagnosis. Mothers had higher levels of anxiety and depression, and these were significantly associated with the child's challenging behaviors, parents' teleworking, and perceived knowledge about COVID-19.

JOURNAL OF PSYCHIATRIC RESEARCH (2022)

Article Psychiatry

Association between residential proximity to agricultural crops and adaptive behaviors in children with autism spectrum disorder from the French ELENA cohort

Jeanne Sandrine Ongono, Cecile Michelon, Remi Beranger, Emmanuelle Cadot, Valentin Simoncic, Julie Loubersac, Marion Mortamais, Amaria Baghdadli

Summary: This study aimed to analyze the associations between early residential proximity to agricultural crops, a proxy of pesticide exposure, and adaptive behaviors in children with ASD. The results showed that an increase in crop acreage was significantly associated with a decrease in communication scores in children without intellectual disability, during both pregnancy and the first two years of life. No association was found in children with intellectual disabilities, providing insights for future research on understanding ASD phenotypes.

JOURNAL OF PSYCHIATRIC RESEARCH (2022)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Perceptions of parents of the impact of autism spectrum disorder on their quality of life and correlates: comparison between mothers and fathers

Christelle Vernhet, Cecile Michelon, Florine Dellapiazza, Cecile Rattaz, Marie-Maude Geoffray, Herbert Roeyers, Marie-Christine Picot, Amaria Baghdadli

Summary: The study found that mothers perceived a greater impact of ASD on their quality of life compared to fathers, and there was a strong correlation between the child's clinical characteristics and parents' perception of the impact of ASD on quality of life. Certain parental factors were also associated with the impact on quality of life.

QUALITY OF LIFE RESEARCH (2022)

Article Psychology, Developmental

Dyadic Effect of Coping on the Perceived Impact of ASD of Children on Parental Quality of Life: Report from the ELENA Cohort

Leila Brillet, Marianne Peries, Christelle Vernhet, Cecile Rattaz, Cecile Michelon, Amaria Baghdadli

Summary: Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) has a significant impact on the quality of life (QoL) of families. This study found that the coping strategies of parents with ASD children have a dyadic effect on their perception of the impact of ASD on their QoL. Mothers' emotion-focused coping plays a crucial role in fathers' perception of QoL. Therefore, couple-focused interventions would benefit both parents of children with ASD.

JOURNAL OF AUTISM AND DEVELOPMENTAL DISORDERS (2023)

Article Psychology, Developmental

Determinants of Inclusion in Mainstream School for Children with Autism Spectrum Disorders from the EpiTED Study: A 10-Year Follow-up Cohort

Charlotte Lafont, Henri Panjo, Cecile Michelon, Bruno Falissard, Mario Speranza, Marie-Christine Picot, Amaria Baghdadli, Alexandra Rouquette

Summary: Inclusion of students with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) in mainstream schools has a positive impact on their social and daily living behaviors. Variables such as greater autonomy, lesser symptom severity, and fewer siblings are significantly linked to inclusion in mainstream school. However, the probability of being included in mainstream school decreases with age.

JOURNAL OF AUTISM AND DEVELOPMENTAL DISORDERS (2023)

Review Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

A scoping review of education and training interventions in Autism Spectrum Disorder

Maxime Morsa, Vincent De Andrade, Geline Alcaraz, Xavier de la Tribonniere, Cecile Rattaz, Amaria Baghdadli

Summary: This article discusses education interventions for individuals with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) and their parents. The study found that the main interventions include support groups, parental training, psychoeducation, and therapeutic patient education. However, most publications focus on the needs of parents, neglecting the educational needs of individuals with ASD.

PATIENT EDUCATION AND COUNSELING (2022)

Article Psychology, Developmental

Self-reported needs of caregivers of people with Autism Spectrum Disorder

Claire Colombet, Celine Alcaraz, Xavier de la Tribonniere, Maxime Morsa, Cecile Rattaz, Amaria Baghdadli

Summary: This study describes caregivers' perceptions of their knowledge about autism spectrum disorder (ASD) and their needs for education and training. While most caregivers feel they have sufficient knowledge, they still express a high level of needs for acquiring more knowledge and finding support.

JOURNAL OF AUTISM AND DEVELOPMENTAL DISORDERS (2023)

Article Psychology, Developmental

Factors associated with age of diagnosis in children with autism spectrum disorders: Report from a French cohort

Cecile Rattaz, Julie Loubersac, Cecile Michelon, Marie-Maude Geoffray, Marie-Christine Picot, Kerim Munir, Amaria Baghdadli

Summary: Early diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder is crucial for early intervention. This study found that the age of diagnosis is influenced by the child's clinical characteristics, family history, and socio-economic factors. Children from low socio-economic status families tend to have an earlier diagnosis, but they also have more severe intellectual impairment.

AUTISM (2022)

Article Psychology, Developmental

Multimorbidity patterns and subgroups among autistic adults with intellectual disability: Results from the EFAAR study

Stephanie Miot, Raphael Chancel, Marianne Peries, Sophie Crepiat, Sylvie Couderc, Eric Pernon, Marie-Christine Picot, Veronique Gonnier, Claude Jeandel, Hubert Blain, Amaria Baghdadli

Summary: This study examines multimorbidity patterns and subgroups in adults with autism spectrum disorder + intellectual disability. The findings suggest a high prevalence and early onset of multimorbidity in this population. A dominant pattern combining immune dysfunction, gastrointestinal disorders, neurological, and joint diseases was observed. Additionally, four distinct subgroups were identified based on multimorbidity, autonomy, and polypharmacy. The study highlights the role of the gut-brain axis in the pathophysiology of autism spectrum disorder + intellectual disability multimorbidity, and emphasizes the importance of a holistic approach for personalized care.

AUTISM (2023)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

Multistage screening process for neurodevelopmental disorders in siblings of children with autism: the FRATSA protocol study

Amaria Baghdadli, Lee Audras-Torrent, Cecile Rattaz, Veronique Gonnier, Laetitia Ferrando, Cecile Michelon, Roxane Odoyer, Thierry Maffre, Marie-Christine Picot

Summary: The aim of this study is to assess the feasibility and acceptability of a standardized screening process for neurodevelopmental disorders among siblings of children with autism spectrum disorder (ASD). The screening process includes parental questionnaires and clinical interviews, with referrals for diagnosis and treatment as necessary. The findings will be disseminated through peer-reviewed manuscripts, scientific meetings, and conferences.

BMJ OPEN (2023)

Article Nursing

Protective resources against stress among student nurses: Influences of self-efficacy, emotional intelligence and conflict management styles

Estelle Michinov, Gael Robin, Brivael Hemon, Remi Beranger, Marielle Boissart

Summary: This study investigated the stress levels among French student nurses and the impact of personal resources on their well-being. The results showed that self-efficacy played a major role in determining stress and well-being, and these effects were partially mediated by emotional awareness.

NURSE EDUCATION IN PRACTICE (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Metals recovery from polymetallic sulfide tailings by bioleaching functional bacteria isolated with the improved 9K agar: Comparison between one-step and two-step processes

Muqiu Hu, Xin Zhao, Jinghan Gu, Lulu Qian, Zhiqing Wang, Yuanyuan Nie, Xiaoyu Han, Long An, Haiqiang Jiang

Summary: Due to its simple process, environmental friendliness, and low operating costs, biometallurgy has become a popular technology for metals recovering from low-grade ores and tailings. An optimized agar was used to isolate and grow functional bacteria, resulting in the successful isolation of six functional stains. These strains were further tested for their ability to leach metals from polymetallic sulfide tailings, with significant improvements observed when the strains were mixed together. The selection of leaching process should be based on tailings composition and target metals.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH (2024)

Review Environmental Sciences

Endocrine disruptors: Unravelling the link between chemical exposure and Women's reproductive health

Saqib Hassan, Aswin Thacharodi, Anshu Priya, R. Meenatchi, Thanushree A. Hegde, R. Thangamani, Ht Nguyen, Arivalagan Pugazhendhi

Summary: An Endocrine Disrupting Chemical (EDC) is a compound that disrupts the function of the endocrine system and is found in the environment. EDCs, such as Bisphenol A and pesticides, have been shown to have negative effects on the female reproductive system. Understanding the relationship between EDCs and women's health is crucial for developing strategies to protect reproductive health and informing public policy decisions.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Long-term effects of thiosulfate on the competition between sulfur-mediated bacteria and glycogen accumulating organisms in sulfate-rich carbon-deficient wastewater

Lichang Zhou, Zhaoling Li, Boyi Cheng, Jinqi Jiang, Xinqi Bi, Zongping Wang, Guanghao Chen, Gang Guo

Summary: Thiosulfate can promote sulfur-mediated bacterial activity, inhibit glycogen accumulating organisms, and enhance denitrification efficiency. After the carbon source is reduced, the competitive ability of glycogen accumulating organisms increases, resulting in reduced sulfate reduction.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Air pollution and age-dependent changes in emotional behavior across early adolescence in the US

Claire E. Campbell, Devyn L. Cotter, Katherine L. Bottenhorn, Elisabeth Burnor, Hedyeh Ahmadi, W. James Gauderman, Carlos Cardenas-Iniguez, Daniel Hackman, Rob McConnell, Kiros Berhane, Joel Schwartz, Jiu-Chiuan Chen, Megan M. Herting

Summary: Recent studies have found a connection between air pollution and increased risk for behavioral problems during development. However, more longitudinal studies are needed to investigate how exposure during the transition to adolescence may affect emotional behaviors.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Urban green, blue spaces and their joint effect are associated with lower risk of emotional and behavior problem in children and adolescents, a large population-based study in Guangzhou, China

Jing-hong Liang, Ru-yu Yang, Mei-ling Liu, Ying-qi Pu, Wen-wen Bao, Yu Zhao, Li-xin Hu, Yu-shan Zhang, Shan Huang, Nan Jiang, Xue-ya Pu, Shao-yi Huang, Guang-hui Dong, Ya-jun Chen

Summary: This study examines the association between urban Green and blue spaces (GBS) exposure and Emotion and behavior problems (EBP) in youth populations. The findings suggest that higher exposure to GBS, particularly green spaces (GS) and blue spaces (BS), is associated with a decrease in the risk of developing total difficulties in young individuals. The joint effect of GS and BS may also contribute to the decrease in EBPs.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Neurodevelopmental consequences of gestational exposure to particulate matter 10: Ultrasonic vocalizations and gene expression analysis using a bayesian approach

Diego Ruiz-Sobremazas, Mario Ruiz Coca, Miguel Morales-Navas, Rocio Rodulfo-Cardenas, Caridad Lopez-Granero, Maria Teresa Colomina, Cristian Perez-Fernandez, Fernando Sanchez-Santed

Summary: Air pollution is associated with a range of health issues and gestational exposure to environmental pollutants may be linked to neurodevelopmental disorders. This study investigated the effects of oral gestational exposure to particulate matter (PM) on ultrasonic vocalizations (USV). The findings suggest that this exposure may lead to social deficits and abnormal gene expression related to neurotransmitter systems. Further research is needed to better understand the effects of air pollution on neurodevelopmental disorders and the neurotransmission systems involved.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Enhancement of methane production by electrohydrolysis pretreatment for anaerobic digestion of OFMSW

Yagmur Kabakci, Sadiye Kosar, Ozgur Dogan, Fehmi Gorkem Uctug, Osman Atilla Arikan

Summary: This study investigated the effect of electrohydrolysis pretreatment on municipal solid waste. The results showed that applying electrohydrolysis pretreatment increased methane production and reduced the time required for hydrolysis, suggesting it is a promising method to improve anaerobic digestion efficiency.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Quantifying the contribution of industrial zones to urban heat islands: Relevance and direct impact

Chuanwu Zhao, Yaozhong Pan, Hanyi Wu, Yu Zhu

Summary: This study analyzed the impact of industrial zones on urban heat islands using remote sensing images and a novel spectral index. The research found that the contraction or expansion of industrial zones has a significant effect on land surface temperature. The results are valuable for environmental assessment and fine management of industrial cities.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

New insights into syntrophic ethanol oxidation: Effects of operational modes and solids retention times

Bang Du, Zhongzhong Wang, Piet N. L. Lens, Xinmin Zhan, Guangxue Wu

Summary: This study investigated the performance, syntrophic relationships, microbial communities, and metabolic pathways of ethanol-fed reactors with different operational modes and solids retention times. The results showed that different microorganisms were enriched under different SRT conditions, and syntrophic bacteria related to methane production could be enriched under low SRT conditions.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Conversion of seaweed waste to biochar for the removal of heavy metal ions from aqueous solution: A sustainable method to address eutrophication problem in water bodies

Gokulan Ravindiran, Sivarethinamohan Rajamanickam, Muralikrishnan Ramalingam, Gasim Hayder, Balamurugan Karupaiya Sathaiah, Madhava Krishna Reddy Gaddam, Senthil Kumar Muniasamy, Priya Arunkumar

Summary: The present study investigated the sustainable approach for wastewater treatment using waste algal blooms. The biochar produced by the marine algae Ulva reticulata was used to remove chromium, nickel, and zinc from aqueous solutions. The study examined the adsorbents' properties and stability using SEM/EDX, FTIR, and XRD. The results showed that the biochar had high removal efficiency for the toxic metals, and the packed bed column effectively removed the heavy metal ions. The Thomas and Adams-Bohart models were found to best fit the regression values, and desorption studies were conducted to understand the sorption and elution processes.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH (2024)

Review Environmental Sciences

Recent developments on advanced oxidation processes for degradation of pollutants from wastewater with focus on antibiotics and organic dyes

Vignesh Vinayagam, Kavitha Nagarasampatti Palani, Sudha Ganesh, Siddharth Rajesh, Vedha Varshini Akula, Ramapriyan Avoodaiappan, Omkar Singh Kushwaha, Arivalagan Pugazhendhi

Summary: The presence of pollutants in water contributes to global pollution and poses significant threats to humans and wildlife. Finding effective wastewater treatment techniques is crucial for reducing pollutant accumulation in the environment. This paper highlights recent advances in the electrochemical advanced oxidation method and other processes for treating pharmaceuticals, dyes, and pesticide-polluted effluents.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Promotion of phosphate release from humic acid-iron hydroxide coprecipitates in the presence of citric acid

M. M. M. Ahmed, Kai-Yue Chen, Fang-Yu Tsao, Yi-Cheng Hsieh, Yu-Ting Liu, Min Tzou

Summary: This study investigated the sorption of citric acid onto humic acid-iron hydr(o)xide coprecipitate (HAFHCP) and the reciprocal effects of citric acid and P sorption on HAFHCP. The results showed that citric acid could increase P availability and have an impact on P sorption.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

A remote sensing-based strategy for mapping potentially toxic elements of soils: Temporal-spatial-spectral covariates combined with random forest

Xibo Xu, Zeqiang Wang, Xiaoning Song, Wenjie Zhan, Shuting Yang

Summary: The selection of predictor variables is crucial in building a digital mapping model for potentially toxic elements (PTEs) in soil. Traditionally, spatial and spectral parameters have been used as predictor variables, but the temporal dimension is often overlooked. This study demonstrates the value of incorporating temporal indices in the model, leading to significant performance improvements. The temporal-spatial-spectral covariate combinations used in a random forest (RF) algorithm achieve satisfactory mapping accuracy and outperform other methods.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Heteroatom-modulated NiCo2O4 apparent energy activation of PMS for tetracycline removal: Mechanism and toxicity analysis

Yan Pei, Xun Liu, Mengbo Cao, Zijun Wang, Hongbing Yang

Summary: Heteroatom doping can reconfigure the electronic structure of heterogeneous catalysts, leading to the development of advanced oxidation water purification materials with superior performance and stability. In this study, a series of catalysts with different elemental doping were prepared using a simple and environmentally friendly method. The S-doped NiCo2O4 catalyst showed excellent catalytic performance for the removal of Tetracycline, with significantly increased kinetic constant and high oxidation and mineralization efficiency in a wide pH range. The degradation process was dominated by non-radical oxidation pathway after S doping, and the overall process moved towards low toxicity.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Biodegradation of naphthalene - Ecofriendly approach for soil pollution mitigation

Srivalli Thimmarayan, Harshavardhan Mohan, Gaddapara Manasa, Karthi Natesan, Shanmugam Mahendran, Pavithra Muthukumar Sathya, Byung-Taek Oh, R. Ravi Kumar, Rangasamy Sigamani Gandhimathi, Arul Jayaprakash, Kamala-Kannan Seralathan

Summary: This study investigated the bacterial degradation of naphthalene (NPT) isolated from crude oil-contaminated soil. Bacillus sp. GN 3.4, a potential bacteria for NPT biodegradation, was isolated and the optimal conditions for NPT degradation were determined. The study suggests that Bacillus sp. GN 3.4 could potentially aid in bioremediation by eliminating NPT from the soil.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH (2024)