4.3 Article

Gender differences in the perception of safety in public transport

Publisher

OXFORD UNIV PRESS
DOI: 10.1111/rssa.12558

Keywords

Behavioural responses; Buses; Customer satisfaction; Gender; Metros; Public transport; Safety

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Concerns over women's safety on public transport systems are commonly reported in the media. We develop statistical models to test for gender differences in the perception of safety and satisfaction on urban metros and buses by using large-scale unique customer satisfaction data for 28 world cities over the period 2009-2018. Results indicate a significant gender gap in the perception of safety, with women being 10% more likely than men to feel unsafe in metros (6% for buses). This gender gap is larger for safety than for overall satisfaction (3% in metros and 2.5% in buses), which is consistent with safety being one dimension of overall satisfaction. Results are stable across specifications and robust to inclusion of city level and time controls. We find heterogeneous responses by sociodemographic characteristics. Data indicate that 45% of women feel secure in trains and metro stations (and 55% in buses). Thus the gender gap encompasses more differences in transport perception between men and women rather than an intrinsic network fear. Additional models test for the influence of metro characteristics on perceived safety levels and find that more acts of violence, larger carriages and emptier vehicles decrease women's feeling of safety.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.3
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Engineering, Civil

Social distancing in public transport: mobilising new technologies for demand management under the Covid-19 crisis

Daniel Horcher, Ramandeep Singh, Daniel J. Graham

Summary: Amid the pandemic, public transport operators face declining demand, leading to the need for effective demand management strategies such as advance booking and queueing control.

TRANSPORTATION (2022)

Article Management

Model-based adjustment for conditional benchmarking

Daniel J. Graham, Ramandeep Singh

Summary: This paper proposes a model-based adjustment approach for comparative benchmarking, allowing the recovery of targeted metrics for specific aspects of intrinsic performance. The managerial relevance of the method is demonstrated through real-world applications.

IMA JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT MATHEMATICS (2022)

Article Social Sciences, Mathematical Methods

A dynamic choice model to estimate the user cost of crowding with large-scale transit data

Prateek Bansal, Daniel Horcher, Daniel J. Graham

Summary: This study proposes a dynamic choice model to estimate passenger valuation of service attributes using large-scale data, providing valuable insights for supply-side decisions of transit operators.

JOURNAL OF THE ROYAL STATISTICAL SOCIETY SERIES A-STATISTICS IN SOCIETY (2022)

Article Economics

Preferences for using the London Underground during the COVID-19 pandemic

Prateek Bansal, Roselinde Kessels, Rico Krueger, Daniel J. Graham

Summary: The COVID-19 pandemic has changed people's travel behavior and created uncertainty in the demand for public transportation, particularly the London Underground. A study conducted a choice experiment among pre-pandemic users to understand their preferences during the pandemic. The analysis showed that travel time valuation increased when the Underground operated at technical capacity and that mandatory face masks were a significant driver for recovering demand. The study also revealed preference heterogeneity among users.

TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH PART A-POLICY AND PRACTICE (2022)

Article Physics, Multidisciplinary

Optimal congestion control strategies for near-capacity urban metros: Informing intervention via fundamental diagrams

Anupriya, Daniel J. Graham, Prateek Bansal, Daniel Hoercher, Richard Anderson

Summary: Congestion is a growing problem for metro systems, caused by passenger congestion and train-queuing, which leads to negative consequences and potential shifts in transportation modes. Alleviating congestion requires strategies such as regulating passenger inflow at bottleneck stations. The study proposes an empirical model to analyze station-level passenger congestion and develop fundamental diagrams (FDs) using large-scale smartcard and train movement data. The analysis demonstrates the existence of concave FDs at bottleneck stations, indicating a critical level of boarding-alightings above which congestion occurs.

PHYSICA A-STATISTICAL MECHANICS AND ITS APPLICATIONS (2023)

Review Transportation

Performance of urban rail transit: a review of measures and interdependencies

Farah A. A. Awad, Daniel J. J. Graham, Laila AitBihiOuali, Ramandeep Singh

Summary: In recent years, there has been significant growth in the literature on performance measurement in public transit systems, focusing on financial and quality-of-service aspects. The shift towards considering quality-of-service as an important performance measure is evident, given its impact on ridership. However, there is a gap in the literature due to the segmentation of these two performance aspects and their interdependencies. This study provides a comprehensive review of methodologies and empirical findings on both aspects, highlighting the importance of linking cost efficiency and service quality.

TRANSPORT REVIEWS (2023)

Article Economics

On the effects of airport capacity expansion under responsive airlines and elastic passenger demand

Zhenwei Gong, Fangni Zhang, Wei Liu, Daniel J. Graham

Summary: This paper investigates the effect of airport expansion on air traffic and its implications on airport congestion, airline competition, and social welfare under various administrative regimes, airline market structures, and passenger demand patterns. The analysis suggests that airport capacity expansion may lead to over-scheduled flights and increased congestion, especially in less competitive airline markets. Furthermore, the objective of the airport operator (i.e., profit-maximization, social welfare-maximization, or budget-constrained social welfare-maximization) affects the likelihood of congestion. Market power in airlines allows them to internalize a portion of airport congestion, while leader airlines with knowledge of follower responses manipulate airfare to maximize profits. Additionally, increasing airport charges always reduce aggregate traffic volume under different market structures and fixed airport capacity.

TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH PART B-METHODOLOGICAL (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

An evaluation framework for operational interventions on urban mass public transport during a pandemic

Ramandeep Singh, Daniel Horcher, Daniel J. Graham

Summary: Decision making in a rapidly changing context necessitates a dynamic assessment of multiple factors. This paper presents a flexible data-driven simulation framework to increase safe mobility and economic interactions while reducing Covid-19 contagion. Using a case study of the London Underground, the model demonstrates significant performance gains in metro service provision during the pandemic.

SCIENTIFIC REPORTS (2023)

Article Economics

Subsidised transport services in a fiscal federation: Why local governments may be against decentralised service provision

Daniel Horcher, Bruno De Borger, Daniel J. Graham

Summary: In this paper, the authors examine the impact of decentralised provision of loss-generating public services with benefit spillovers to other regions in a fiscal federation. Using public transport provision as an example, they demonstrate that local governments may benefit more when a higher-level government or a neighbouring region provides these services. The model highlights the importance of the tax exporting mechanism in determining the outcomes.

ECONOMICS OF TRANSPORTATION (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Using Explainable Machine Learning to Interpret the Effects of Policies on Air Pollution: COVID-19 Lockdown in London

Liang Ma, Daniel J. Graham, Marc E. J. Stettler

Summary: By analyzing activity changes during the first UK national lockdown, we found that road traffic significantly decreased and had varying impacts on air pollution in London. The changes in air pollution were correlated with spatial features, residents' income, and access to public transport services. Furthermore, existing inequalities in air pollution exposure were exacerbated during the lockdown.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY (2023)

Article Statistics & Probability

Semiparametric Bayesian doubly robust causal estimation

Yu Luo, Daniel J. Graham, Emma J. McCoy

Summary: Frequentist semiparametric theory has been widely used in the development of doubly robust causal estimation. In this paper, a fully semiparametric Bayesian framework is proposed for DR causal inference. The framework combines nonparametric Bayesian procedures with empirical likelihood via semiparametric linear regression, allowing for consistent parameter estimation even with correct specification of only one model.

JOURNAL OF STATISTICAL PLANNING AND INFERENCE (2023)

Article Economics

Congestion in cities: Can road capacity expansions provide a solution?

Prateek Anupriya, Prateek Bansal, Daniel J. Graham

Summary: Road network congestion is a major issue in urban areas worldwide, and building more roads to reduce congestion is controversial. This paper uses causal statistical modeling to quantify congestion technology in road networks in twenty-four cities globally, and finds that increasing network capacity is generally not an efficient solution to manage congestion.

TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH PART A-POLICY AND PRACTICE (2023)

Article Transportation

Benchmarking the performance of urban rail transit systems: a machine learning application

Farah A. Awad, Daniel J. Graham, Laila AitBihiOuali, Ramandeep Singh, Alexander Barron

Summary: This study compares urban rail transit (URT) systems using a data-driven approach, highlighting efficiency differences among operators and the complexity of defining service quality in the transit sector.

TRANSPORTMETRICA A-TRANSPORT SCIENCE (2023)

Article Engineering, Civil

The Impact of Periodic Passenger Vehicle Safety Inspection Programs on Roadway Fatalities: Evidence from US States Using Panel Data

Prithvi S. Acharya, Laila AitBihiOuali, H. Scott Matthews, Daniel J. Graham

Summary: This paper presents a data-driven analysis of the effects of safety inspection and maintenance programs (I/M programs) on road fatalities in the United States. The study uses the largest available data set covering all 50 states over a 44-year period and finds that states with I/M programs have lower roadway fatality rates.

JOURNAL OF TRANSPORTATION ENGINEERING PART A-SYSTEMS (2023)

Article Economics

Multimodal Substitutes in Public Transport Efficient Variety or Wasteful Competition?

Daniel Hoercher, Daniel J. Graham

Summary: This paper discusses the desirability of running multiple public transport services (such as buses and trains) under public ownership along a transport corridor, when these modes are imperfect substitutes. With a focus on welfare-oriented public transport provision, the paper applies the theory of product differentiation and argues that modal variety can be beneficial for society if consumer preferences are widely spread and scale economies in service provision are limited. The argument is supported by theory and exemplified through an agent-based simulation model.

JOURNAL OF TRANSPORT ECONOMICS AND POLICY (2022)

No Data Available