4.6 Review Book Chapter

Reconciling Conflict and Cooperation in Environmental Governance: A Social Network Perspective

Journal

Publisher

ANNUAL REVIEWS
DOI: 10.1146/annurev-environ-011020-064352

Keywords

social network analysis; conflict; cooperation; collaboration; environmental governance; social-ecological networks

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Most if not all environmental problems entail conflicts of interest. Yet, different actors and opposing coalitions often but certainly not always cooperate in solving these problems. Hence, processes of conflict and cooperation often work in tandem, albeit much of the scholarly literature tends to focus on either of these phenomena in isolation. Social network analysis (SNA) provides opportunities to study cooperation and conflict together. In this review, we demonstrate how SNA has increased our understanding of the promises and pitfalls of collaborative approaches in addressing environmental problems. The potential of SNA to investigate conflicts in environmental governance, however, remains largely underutilized. Furthermore, a network perspective is not restricted to the social domain. A multilevel social-ecological network perspective facilitates integration of social and environmental sciences in understanding how different patterns of resource access can trigger both cooperation and conflict.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.6
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Review Agronomy

Networking agrobiodiversity management to foster biodiversity-based agriculture. A review

Vanesse Labeyrie, Martine Antona, Jacques Baudry, Didier Bazile, Orjan Bodin, Sophie Caillon, Christian Leclerc, Christophe Le Page, Selim Louafi, Juliette Mariel, Francois Massol, Mathieu Thomas

Summary: Biodiversity-based agriculture, practiced by smallholder farmers, relies on planned and associated biodiversity. There are increasing calls to support this agriculture as an alternative to industrial agriculture, with a focus on enhancing farmers' access to agrobiodiversity through improved governance and management systems. Research on the role of social networks in farmers' access to agrobiodiversity is crucial for developing new participatory approaches for agrobiodiversity management and governance.

AGRONOMY FOR SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT (2021)

Article Environmental Sciences

Spatial diversification as a mechanism to adapt to environmental changes in small-scale fisheries

Blanca Gonzalez-Mon, Orjan Bodin, Emilie Lindkvist, Timothy H. Frawley, Alfredo Giron-Nava, Xavier Basurto, Mateja Nenadovic, Maja Schluter

Summary: This study examines the challenges faced by small-scale fisheries, the importance of diversification strategies, and how spatial diversification is influenced by environmental and institutional factors. The results highlight spatial diversification as a dynamic process that is influenced by a combination of factors.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2021)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Why care about theories? Innovative ways of theorizing in sustainability science

Maja Schluter, Guido Caniglia, Kirill Orach, Orjan Bodin, Nicolas Magliocca, Patrick Meyfroidt, Belinda Reyers

Summary: The complex nature of sustainability problems demands a rethinking of how theories are constructed and utilized in order to support interdisciplinary and transdisciplinary processes. Four ideal modes of theorizing and the concept of 'ecologies of theories' are proposed to meet the challenges and needs of sustainability science.

CURRENT OPINION IN ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY (2022)

Article Environmental Studies

Ten years of experience with ecological connectivity analysis and urban planning in Sweden

Marten Karlsson, Orjan Bodin

Summary: The use of quantitative analysis in assessing ecological impacts in urban planning is not common. However, in recent years, Sweden has started using quantitative modeling to analyze ecological connectivity. The study found that despite the use of quantitative analysis, most connectivity analysis reports (CARs) still mainly rely on qualitative aspects. The majority of CARs only partially meet the proposed criteria, and only a few reports address issues related to modeling transparency. The results indicate that the primary achievement in the past decade is the increased awareness and acceptance of ecological connectivity among practitioners and decision-makers.

IMPACT ASSESSMENT AND PROJECT APPRAISAL (2022)

Review Ecology

Conceptualizing ecosystem services using social-ecological networks

Maria R. Felipe-Lucia, Angela M. Guerrero, Steven M. Alexander, Jaime Ashander, Jacopo A. Baggio, Michele L. Barnes, Orjan Bodin, Aletta Bonn, Marie-Josee Fortin, Rachel S. Friedman, Jessica A. Gephart, Kate J. Helmstedt, Aislyn A. Keyes, Kailin Kroetz, Francois Massol, Michael J. O. Pocock, Jesse Sayles, Ross M. Thompson, Spencer A. Wood, Laura E. Dee

Summary: This article discusses the challenges and opportunities of using social-ecological networks (SENs) in ecosystem service research, and proposes a typology to represent ecosystem services in SENs. The typology provides guidance for improving research design and addressing a wider range of questions regarding human-nature interdependencies.

TRENDS IN ECOLOGY & EVOLUTION (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Impacts of climate change on global food trade networks

Johanna Hedlund, Henrik Carlsen, Simon Croft, Chris West, Orjan Bodin, Emilie Stokeld, Jonas Jagermeyr, Christoph Mueller

Summary: This study investigates the potential impacts of climate change on global food trade networks. The research finds that the stability of trade networks varies for different crops, with maize trade being the least stable under climate change impacts. The threats to global food security may depend on production changes in major global producers and the ability of trade communities to balance production and import losses in vulnerable countries.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2022)

Article Fisheries

Tracking integrated ecosystem assessments in the ICES network: a social network analysis of the ICES expert groups

Jessica L. Fuller, Harry Strehlow, Jorn O. Schmidt, Orjan Bodin, Dorothy J. Dankel

Summary: The advice provided by ICES to its member countries is crucial for the sustainable management of shared marine resources and the conservation of relevant marine ecosystems. ICES has integrated marine and social sciences into a new assessment framework called integrated ecosystem assessments (IEA) to provide advice on societal trade-offs between different policy options. A social network analysis (SNA) was conducted to track the progression of IEAs within the ICES network, and the study showed that some IEA groups became more connected over time while others declined. Workshops were found to play an important role in the development of IEA knowledge and network connectivity within ICES.

ICES JOURNAL OF MARINE SCIENCE (2023)

Review Multidisciplinary Sciences

A network perspective of human-nature interactions in dynamic and fast-changing landscapes

Orjan Bodin, Haibin Chen

Summary: This study reviews and synthesizes recent interdisciplinary research utilizing a network perspective to inform on governance and adaptation processes in regions undergoing rapid social, economical, and environmental changes. By using a network perspective, the study shows how rangeland managers in a dynamic pastoral region in China form social relationships based on geographic proximity, social status, and shared grazing areas. The results highlight that adaption to biophysical and socioeconomic changes is partly a social process, as rangeland managers develop their adaptive capacity jointly and in concert with others they trust and share grazing areas with. The study suggests further development of the network perspective to provide important new insights on sustainable land use in dynamic landscapes undergoing rapid change.

NATIONAL SCIENCE REVIEW (2023)

Article Political Science

Building blocks of polycentric governance

Tiffany H. Morrison, Orjan Bodin, Graeme S. Cumming, Mark Lubell, Ralf Seppelt, Tim Seppelt, Christopher M. Weible

Summary: The success or failure of a polycentric system depends on complex political and social processes, such as coordination between actors and venues to solve specialized policy problems. However, there is currently no accepted method to isolate distinct coordination processes or understand how their variance affects polycentric governance performance. Researchers in Australia have developed and tested a building-blocks approach using different patterns or motifs to measure and compare coordination over time on the Great Barrier Reef. Their approach confirms that polycentric governance involves interdependent venues and actors that evolve over time, but mobilizing venues to improve issue specialization and actor participation can also fragment the overall capacity of polycentric governance to resolve conflicts and adapt to new problems. This building-blocks approach enhances understanding and practice of polycentric governance by enabling a more precise diagnosis of internal dynamics in complex environmental governance systems.

POLICY STUDIES JOURNAL (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Exploring the role of boundary work in a social-ecological synthesis initiative

Barbara Schroeter, Claudia Sattler, Jean Paul Metzger, Jonathan R. Rhodes, Marie-Josee Fortin, Camila Hohlenwerger, L. Roman Carrasco, Oerjan Bodin

Summary: Inter- and transdisciplinary collaboration in environmental studies face the challenge of effectively communicating across disciplines to address pressing environmental challenges. This research brief evaluates the use of a boundary work approach in a synthesis group on socio-ecological systems, and discusses how it can integrate the knowledge of natural and social scientists. The results show that strategic selection of members, inclusion of boundary spanners, and prior identification of boundary concepts and objects can enhance collaboration and problem-solving in multidisciplinary teams.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL STUDIES AND SCIENCES (2023)

Article Physiology

Optimizing Wearable Device and Testing Parameters to Monitor Running-Stride Long-Range Correlations for Fatigue Management in Field Settings

Joel T. Fuller, Dominic Thewlis, Jodie A. Wills, Jonathan D. Buckley, John B. Arnold, Eoin Doyle, Tim L. A. Doyle, Clint R. Bellenger

Summary: This study investigated the methodological considerations for translating wearable-based gait-monitoring data to field settings and used dynamical systems variables for athlete monitoring. The results showed that a 100 Hz sampling rate and signal lengths of 200 to 300 strides can be used to detect gait changes following intensive training. Additionally, using mean data from two sessions can lower the smallest detectable change values.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SPORTS PHYSIOLOGY AND PERFORMANCE (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

'Bunkering down': How one community is tightening social-ecological network structures in the face of global change

Michele L. Barnes, Lorien Jasny, Andrew Bauman, Jon Ben, Ramiro Berardo, Orjan Bodin, Joshua Cinner, David A. Feary, Angela M. Guerrero, Fraser A. Januchowski-Hartley, John T. Kuange, Jacqueline D. Lau, Peng Wang, Jessica Zamborain-Mason

Summary: This study examines the evolution of a social-ecological network in a common-pool resource system over the past two decades. The results show that the community members are increasingly forming bonding social-ecological network structures and interacting with like-minded others, but there is limited evidence supporting the presence of resourceful actors that can promote innovation.

PEOPLE AND NATURE (2022)

Article Environmental Studies

An Earth system law perspective on governing social-hydrological systems in the Anthropocene

Hanna Ahlstrom, Jacob Hileman, Lan Wang-Erlandsson, Maria Mancilla Garcia, Michele-Lee Moore, Krisztina Jonas, Agnes Pranindita, Jan J. Kuiper, Ingo Fetzer, Fernando Jaramillo, Uno Svedin

Summary: The global hydrological cycle is influenced by complex interdependencies and self-regulating feedbacks, with increasing human impacts in the Anthropocene altering the dynamics of the cycle and posing challenges for water governance. Earth system law has the potential to bridge the gap between the global hydrological cycle and dispersed regulatory architecture, offering a solution to core problems in water governance. Through merging concepts from Earth system law with existing policy and legal principles, a framework is outlined for addressing hydrological issues in the Anthropocene and enhancing institutional compatibility between established governance systems and the global hydrological cycle.

EARTH SYSTEM GOVERNANCE (2021)

Article Environmental Studies

Assessing Policy Issue Interdependencies in Environmental Governance

Johanna Hedlund, Orjan Bodin, Daniel Nohrstedt

Summary: The study highlights the importance of considering policy issue interdependencies, particularly when the overall level of interdependency is moderate. Stakeholder validation confirmed the reliability of the methodological procedure, which identifies different patterns of policy issue interdependencies associated with biophysical and governance spheres. The study also raises questions about policy actors' perception of policy issue interdependencies, and whether reinforcing or counteracting interdependencies are easier to comprehend and act on.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF THE COMMONS (2021)

Article Sociology

The Cod and the Cut: Intra-Active Intuitions

Tilman Hertz, Maria Mancilla Garcia

Summary: This article discusses the complexity of causality in social-ecological dynamics, argues for deeper investigation and transformation in understanding social-ecological systems. By re-examining cases, rejecting the separation of nature from society, adopting a process-relational perspective, and introducing the concept of intuition, it explores alternative methods to untangle causal dynamics and explain social-ecological phenomena.

FRONTIERS IN SOCIOLOGY (2021)

No Data Available