4.5 Review

Recent applications of chemometrics in one- and two-dimensional chromatography

Journal

JOURNAL OF SEPARATION SCIENCE
Volume 43, Issue 9-10, Pages 1678-1727

Publisher

WILEY-V C H VERLAG GMBH
DOI: 10.1002/jssc.202000011

Keywords

1D chromatography; 2D chromatography; chemometrics; data processing; optimization

Funding

  1. Nederlandse Organisatie voor Wetenschap-pelijk Onderzoek
  2. Agilent Technologies [4354]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The proliferation of increasingly more sophisticated analytical separation systems, often incorporating increasingly more powerful detection techniques, such as high-resolution mass spectrometry, causes an urgent need for highly efficient data-analysis and optimization strategies. This is especially true for comprehensive two-dimensional chromatography applied to the separation of very complex samples. In this contribution, the requirement for chemometric tools is explained and the latest developments in approaches for (pre-)processing and analyzing data arising from one- and two-dimensional chromatography systems are reviewed. The final part of this review focuses on the application of chemometrics for method development and optimization.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Biochemical Research Methods

Improving retention-time prediction in supercritical-fluid chromatography by multivariate modelling

Stef R. A. Molenaar, Mariyana Savova, Rebecca Cross, Paul D. Ferguson, Peter J. Schoenmakers, Bob W. J. Pirok

Summary: The prediction of chromatographic retention under supercritical-fluid chromatography conditions was studied using theoretical models. The study found that retention in SFC is strongly influenced by pressure and temperature, unlike liquid chromatography where retention models mainly consider the modifier fraction. The study explored the combination of multiple retention models to describe the effects of both modifier fraction and pressure. By using multivariate surfaces, retention-time prediction for isocratic separations at constant temperature improved significantly compared to univariate modeling when both pressure and modifier fractions were changed. The mixed-mode model with an additional exponential pressure or density parameter was able to predict retention times within 5%, with the majority of the predictions within 2%. The use of mass fraction and density further improved retention modeling compared to volume fraction and pressure, albeit requiring extra computations.

JOURNAL OF CHROMATOGRAPHY A (2022)

Article Chemistry, Analytical

Improving the accuracy of copolymer sequence length determination by pyrolysis gas chromatography: A comprehensive study

Wouter C. Knol, Sifra Vos, Till Gruendling, Bob W. J. Pirok, Ron A. H. Peters

Summary: This study proposes a comprehensive workflow to ensure the accuracy of sequence determination in styrene-acrylate copolymers using Py-GC and 13C NMR. The results show that Py-GC consistently underestimates the acrylate sequence length, and calibration with 13C NMR is necessary for accurate absolute quantification. However, NMR calibration may not be required in all cases to obtain relative information on the sequence of a copolymer.

ANALYTICA CHIMICA ACTA (2023)

Article Biochemical Research Methods

Online hyphenation of size-exclusion chromatography and pyrolysis-gas chromatography for polymer characterization

Wouter C. Knol, Jasper P. H. Smeets, Till Gruendling, Bob W. J. Pirok, Ron A. H. Peters

Summary: It is important to understand the composition and molecular heterogeneities of complex industrial polymers to control their physical properties. This study developed an online method that combines liquid polymer chromatography with pyrolysis-GC (Py-GC) to analyze the composition and molar mass distribution of industrial polymers. The method allows for fractionation of the first-dimension effluent and efficient analysis of complex samples.

JOURNAL OF CHROMATOGRAPHY A (2023)

Article Biochemical Research Methods

Composition mapping of highly substituted cellulose-ether monomers by liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry and probability-based data deconvolution

Tijmen S. Bos, Jessica S. Desport, Ab Buijtenhuijs, Jindra Purmova, Leif Karlson, Bob W. J. Pirok, Peter J. Schoenmakers, Govert W. Somsen

Summary: Cellulose ethers (CEs) are semi-synthetic polymers derived from natural cellulose, and they exhibit various properties important for pharmaceutical and industrial applications. A new method using liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS) was developed to comprehensively analyze the substitution degree and composition of CE samples. This method allowed for the identification of compositional variations and unexpected methylations in CE samples, providing valuable molecular information for studying CE structure-property relationships.

JOURNAL OF CHROMATOGRAPHY A (2023)

Article Biochemical Research Methods

Packed modulation loops to reduce band broadening in two-dimensional liquid chromatography

Wouter C. Knol, Ron A. H. Peters, Bob W. J. Pirok

Summary: This study evaluates the use of packed loops in modulation interfaces in 2D-LC and compares them to unpacked coiled and uncoiled modulation loops. The study found that packed loops reduce dispersion of chromatographic peaks compared to unpacked loops and uncoiled loops in all cases, with significantly reduced dispersion for larger loop volumes. Furthermore, countercurrent elution resulted in narrower elution profiles in all cases compared to concurrent elution. The study also suggests that packed loops are particularly useful when analytes are not refocused in the second-dimension separation.

JOURNAL OF CHROMATOGRAPHY A (2023)

Article Chemistry, Analytical

Principles and potential of solvent gradient size-exclusion chromatography for polymer analysis

Leon E. Niezen, Jordy D. Kruijswijk, Gerben B. van Henten, Bob W. J. Pirok, Bastiaan B. P. Staal, Wolfgang Radke, Harry J. A. Philipsen, Govert W. Somsen, Peter J. Schoenmakers

Summary: The properties of a polymeric material are affected by its molecular distributions, such as molecular-weight (MWD), chemical-composition (CCD), and block-length (BLD) distributions. Gradient elution liquid chromatography (LC) is commonly used to determine the CCD. In this study, the potential of gradient size-exclusion chromatography (gSEC) for CCD analysis was explored and compared with conventional gradient-elution reversed-phase LC. The influence of mobile-phase composition, stationary-phase particle pore size, and column temperature was investigated.

ANALYTICA CHIMICA ACTA (2023)

Article Chemistry, Analytical

Hyphenation of liquid chromatography and pyrolysis-flame ionization detection/mass spectrometry for polymer quantification and characterization

Wouter C. Knol, Quincy L. de Vries, Ton Brooijmans, Till Gruendling, Bob W. J. Pirok, Ron A. H. Peters

Summary: Size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) coupled with pyrolysis-gas chromatography (Py-GC) is a powerful tool for polymer analysis. However, the long analysis times of the Py-GC step limit its wider application. Therefore, an online hyphenated SECxPy-MS/FID method was developed, removing the need for GC separation and significantly reducing the second-dimension analysis time compared to SEC-Py-GC. The developed method showed no molar mass discrimination for masses above +/- 1.3 kDa, making it applicable to most commercial polymer systems. Multiple samples, including a complex industrial sample, were successfully analyzed using this method, providing information on chemical composition heterogeneity and molar mass distribution.

ANALYTICA CHIMICA ACTA (2023)

Article Chemistry, Analytical

Characterizing Non-covalent Protein Complexes Using Asymmetrical Flow Field-Flow Fractionation On-Line Coupled to Native Mass Spectrometry

Iro Konstantina Ventouri, Wayne Chang, Florian Meier, Roland Drexel, Govert W. Somsen, Peter J. Schoenmakers, Bart de Spiegeleer, Rob Haselberg, Alina Astefanei

Summary: We developed an online analytical platform combining asymmetrical flow field-flow fractionation (AF4) with native mass spectrometry (nMS) for studying labile higher-order structures (HOS) of protein biotherapeutics. The platform also utilizes UV absorbance, multi-angle light scattering (MALS), and differential refractive-index (UV-MALS-dRI) detectors. We studied the stability and dissociation pathways of the tetrameric biotherapeutic enzyme L-asparaginase (ASNase) and found the presence of intact octamers and degradation products using AF4-MALS/nMS. Exposure of ASNase to high pH disrupted the equilibrium between non-covalent species and led to HOS dissociation. The developed platform provides valuable insights for aggregation and stability studies of protein biopharmaceuticals.

ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY (2023)

Article Chemistry, Analytical

Development of a chemometric approach to improve the accuracy of copolymer sequence information obtained from pyrolysis gas-chromatography mass-spectrometry data

Stef R. A. Molenaar, Wouter C. Knol, Bob W. J. Pirok, Ron A. H. Peters

Summary: Information about the number-average copolymer sequence length can be obtained through pyrolysis-gas chromatography (Py-GC) by comparing the ratios of formed oligomers. However, the formation constants of the oligomers and their detection efficiency are not constant, leading to unreliable peak ratios in the chromatogram. To address this, an algorithm is introduced to improve the accuracy of copolymer sequence from chromatograms with unrepresentative peak areas. The algorithm even works when oligomer data is missing.

JOURNAL OF ANALYTICAL AND APPLIED PYROLYSIS (2023)

Article Chemistry, Analytical

Trapped ion mobility mass spectrometry of new psychoactive substances: Isomer-specific identification of ring-substituted cathinones

Hany A. Majeed, Tijmen S. Bos, Robert L. C. Voeten, Ruben F. Kranenburg, Arian C. van Asten, Govert W. Somsen, Isabelle Kohler

Summary: A method using trapped ion mobility spectrometry and time-of-flight mass spectrometry was developed to identify different ring-positional isomers in synthetic cathinones. The method allows for accurate ion mobility assessment and high-confidence isomer identification through narrow ion-trapping regions, internal reference mobility calibration, and a dedicated data analysis tool. The method was successfully applied to the unambiguous assignment of isomers in confiscated street samples.

ANALYTICA CHIMICA ACTA (2023)

Article Chemistry, Analytical

Capacitively coupled contactless conductivity detection to account for system-induced gradient deformation in liquid chromatography

Leon E. Niezen, Tijmen S. Bos, Peter J. Schoenmakers, Govert W. Somsen, Bob W. J. Pirok

Summary: The time required for method development in gradient-elution LC can be reduced by using empirical modelling to describe analyte retention and peak width. However, accurate prediction is hindered by system-induced gradient deformation, which needs to be corrected for optimization and method transfer. Capacitively coupled contactless conductivity detection (C4D) can measure the exact gradient profiles, improving the transferability of retention models.

ANALYTICA CHIMICA ACTA (2023)

Article Biochemical Research Methods

Algorithm for tracking peaks amongst numerous datasets in comprehensive two-dimensional chromatography to enhance data analysis and interpretation

Stef R. A. Molenaar, John H. M. Mommers, Dwight R. Stoll, Sithandile Ngxangxa, Andre J. de Villiers, Peter J. Schoenmakers, Bob W. J. Pirok

Summary: This article introduces a peak-tracking algorithm for comparing data in one-dimensional and two-dimensional chromatography. Two application strategies were investigated: simultaneous processing of all chromatograms and cumulative processing for method optimization. The accuracy and efficiency varied in different applications.

JOURNAL OF CHROMATOGRAPHY A (2023)

Article Biochemical Research Methods

Computer-driven optimization of complex gradients in comprehensive two-dimensional liquid chromatography

Stef R. A. Molenaar, Tijmen S. Bos, Jim Boelrijk, Tina A. Dahlseid, Dwight R. Stoll, Bob W. J. Pirok

Summary: This article presents an open-source algorithm for automated and interpretive method development of complex gradients in LC x LC-MS. By enabling direct interaction between the LC x LC-MS system and a data-processing computer in a closed-loop, the algorithm improves efficiency. In testing, it successfully enhances separation and accuracy.

JOURNAL OF CHROMATOGRAPHY A (2023)

Article Polymer Science

Quantitative assessment of polymer molecular shape based on changes in the slope of the Mark-Houwink plot derived from size-exclusion chromatography with triple detection

Tijmen S. Bos, Harry J. A. Philipsen, Bastiaan B. P. Staal, Jindra Purmova, Rene J. L. Beerends, Ab Buijtenhuijs, Leif Karlson, Peter J. Schoenmakers, Govert W. Somsen

Summary: A new approach is proposed to gain additional insights from polymer molecular weight distribution and intrinsic viscosity using size-exclusion chromatography in combination with refractive index, viscometry, and multiangle light scattering detectors. The approach allows for a more quantitative interpretation of the Mark-Houwink plot and can be correlated to the structural and chemical properties of the polymer. The method can be used to assess the effect of solvent system and conditions on polymer solvation behavior.

JOURNAL OF APPLIED POLYMER SCIENCE (2023)

No Data Available