4.6 Article

Long-term outcomes of a randomized clinical trial of supervised exercise, percutaneous transluminal angioplasty or combined treatment for patients with intermittent claudication due to femoropopliteal disease

Journal

BRITISH JOURNAL OF SURGERY
Volume 104, Issue 1, Pages 76-83

Publisher

OXFORD UNIV PRESS
DOI: 10.1002/bjs.10324

Keywords

-

Categories

Funding

  1. BJS Research Bursary
  2. European Society of Vascular Surgery research grant
  3. Academic Vascular Surgery Unit of the University of Hull
  4. National Institute for Health Research [CL-2014-03-001, CL-2011-03-001] Funding Source: researchfish

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Background: The aim was to compare the long-term outcomes of percutaneous transluminal angioplasty (PTA), a supervised exercise programme (SEP) and combined treatment (PTA + SEP) in patients with intermittent claudication owing to femoropopliteal disease. Methods: Patients recruited to an RCT comparing these treatments were invited for long-term follow-up from 2010 to 2011. Indicators of limb ischaemia were recorded (ankle : brachial pressure index (ABPI) and treadmill walking distances). Duplex ultrasound imaging was also done. Patients completed Short Form 36 and VascuQol quality-of-life (QoL) questionnaires. Results: Of 178 patients initially recruited to the trial, 139 were alive at the time of follow-up (PTA 46, SEP 47, PTA + SEP 46). Assessments were completed for 111 patients. Median time to follow-up was 5.2 (i.q.r. 3.8-7.4) years. Sixty-nine patients (62.2 per cent) were symptomatic; 18 (16.2 per cent) had experienced a major cardiovascular event since their last follow-up visit. Improvement was observed in ABPI in all groups. QoL outcomes were inconsistent across individual groups. PTA and PTA + SEP groups had a significantly higher ABPI than the SEP group. No significant difference was observed in treadmill walking distances, QoL outcomes, restenosis rates, and new ipsilateral and contralateral lesions on duplex imaging. Patients in all groups required reinterventions (PTA 14, SEP 10, PTA + SEP 6). The total number of reinterventions was higher after PTA (29) compared with SEP (17) and PTA + SEP (9), but failed to reach statistical significance. Conclusion: PTA, SEP and combined treatment were equally effective long-term treatment options for patients with claudication owing to femoropopliteal disease. The addition of a SEP to PTA can reduce the rate of symptomatic restenosis and reintervention.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.6
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Peripheral Vascular Disease

The Edinburgh Claudication Questionnaire has poor diagnostic accuracy in people with intermittent claudication

Said Ibeggazene, Andrew Stirrup, Sean Pymer, Joanne Palmer, Paris L. Cai, George E. Smith, Ian C. Chetter

Summary: This study investigated the diagnostic performance of the Edinburgh Claudication Questionnaire (ECQ) as a screening tool for suspected intermittent claudication patients. The results showed that the ECQ had a poor diagnostic performance and novel, low-resource diagnostic tools are needed for this population.

VASCULAR (2023)

Review Surgery

Surgical Techniques for Performing a Through-Knee Amputation: A Systematic Review and Development of an Operative Descriptive System

M. Dewi, B. L. Gwilym, A. H. Coxon, D. Carradice, D. C. Bosanquet

Summary: This systematic review aims to identify all recognized operative techniques for through-knee amputation (TKA) and develop a descriptive system for future research. A total of 906 papers were identified, with 28 included in the review. Key distinctions in operative technique include level of femur division, management of the patella, use of a muscular gastrocnaemius flap, and skin incisions. A 4-component classification system was developed to describe TKA techniques, using a shorthand nomenclature. Patient outcomes were not addressed. Importance rating: 8/10.

ANNALS OF VASCULAR SURGERY (2023)

Editorial Material Surgery

Lower Limb Superficial Venous Ablation: Does Tumescentless Axial Treatment Have a Future?

Daniel Carradice

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF VASCULAR AND ENDOVASCULAR SURGERY (2023)

Review Dermatology

Extracorporeal shockwave therapy compared with standard care for diabetic foot ulcer healing: An updated systematic review

Louise Hitchman, Joshua Totty, George E. Smith, Daniel Carradice, Maureen Twiddy, Cynthia Iglesias, David Russell, Ian C. Chetter

Summary: Emerging evidence suggests that ESWT may improve time to DFU healing, but the certainty of its effectiveness is low, limiting its translation into routine clinical practice.

INTERNATIONAL WOUND JOURNAL (2023)

Article Dermatology

Extracorporeal shockwave therapy for diabetic foot ulcers: a feasibility study

Louise H. Hitchman, Joshua P. Totty, Paris Cai, George E. Smith, Daniel Carradice, Ian C. Chetter

Summary: This study assessed the feasibility of using extracorporeal shockwave therapy (ESWT) for diabetic foot ulcers (DFUs) and explored its potential clinical effects on wound healing and patient-reported benefits. The results showed that recruiting and retaining patients for single-arm ESWT studies is feasible, with no serious adverse events or side-effects. Some DFUs healed during follow-up and quality of life (QoL) scores improved.

JOURNAL OF WOUND CARE (2023)

Review Cardiac & Cardiovascular Systems

Umbrella review and meta-analysis of reconstructed individual patient data of mortality following conventional endovascular and open surgical repair of infrarenal abdominal aortic aneurysm

Vladica M. Velickovic, Daniel Carradice, Jonathan R. Boyle, Mohamad Hamady, Trevor Cleveland, Simon Neequaye, Aleksandra Ignjatovic, Dragana Bogdanovic, Jelena Savovic, Uwe Siebert

Summary: This umbrella review aimed to assess the quality of published meta-analyses, conduct a de-novo meta-analysis of available RCTs, and test the hypothesis of long-term mortality difference between OSR and EVAR. The results showed that EVAR had significantly favorable mortality up to four years, but there was no difference between EVAR and OSR in the longest available time period. The Cox model demonstrated a non-significant hazard ratio in favor of OSR, while the best-fitting generalized gamma model showed a slightly significant hazard ratio in favor of EVAR.

EXPERT REVIEW OF CARDIOVASCULAR THERAPY (2023)

Article Surgery

PRESS survey: PREvention of surgical site infection-a global pan-specialty survey of practice protocol

J. Heinz, J. Walshaw, J. Y. Kwan, J. Long, D. Carradice, J. Totty, K. M. Kontouli, P. Lainas, L. Hitchman, G. Smith, B. Huo, H. Guadalajara, D. Garcia-Olmo, D. Sharma, C. S. Biyani, J. Tomlinson, M. Loubani, R. Galli, R. Lathan, I. Chetter, M. Yiasemidou

Summary: This study aims to identify variations in SSI prevention practices within and between different surgical fields and countries, and provide references to help standardize SSI prevention practices.

FRONTIERS IN SURGERY (2023)

Review Surgery

Clinical outcomes following mechanochemical ablation of superficial venous incompetence compared with endothermal ablation: meta-analysis

Arthur J. M. Lim, Abduraheem H. Mohamed, Louise H. Hitchman, Ross Lathan, Bharadhwaj Ravindhran, Misha M. Sidapra, George Smith, Ian C. Chetter, Daniel Carradice

Summary: This systematic review and meta-analysis compared the outcomes of mechanochemical ablation (MOCA) and endovenous thermal ablation (EVTA). MOCA had a lower rate of anatomical occlusion after 1 year and 2-3 years, but there was no difference in procedural and postprocedural pain.

BRITISH JOURNAL OF SURGERY (2023)

Review Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

Molecular mechanisms of action of negative pressure wound therapy: a systematic review

Bharadhwaj Ravindhran, Nicole Schafer, Annabel Howitt, Daniel Carradice, George Smith, Ian Chetter

Summary: This systematic review summarizes the current evidence on the molecular mechanisms of action of NPWT. The review finds that NPWT can stimulate the modulation of cytokines and growth factors, promoting an anti-inflammatory response.

EXPERT REVIEWS IN MOLECULAR MEDICINE (2023)

Article Surgery

Provision of NICE-recommended varicose vein treatment in the NHS

Louise H. Hitchman, Abduraheem Mohamed, George E. Smith, Sean Pymer, Ian C. Chetter, James Forsyth, Daniel Carradice

Summary: The study assessed access to varicose vein treatments in the NHS and the impact of EBI. Many local varicose vein commissioning policies were found not compliant with NICE CG168, leading to a significant proportion of patients not receiving the recommended treatment.

BRITISH JOURNAL OF SURGERY (2023)

No Data Available