4.7 Review

Learning from generations of sustainability concepts*

Journal

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH LETTERS
Volume 15, Issue 8, Pages -

Publisher

IOP Publishing Ltd
DOI: 10.1088/1748-9326/ab7766

Keywords

planetary boundaries concept; sustainable development; safe operating space; cassandra's dilemma; consumer-resource model; resource-consumer-producer-waste model

Funding

  1. Swedish Research Council Formas [2012-742, 2018-02371]
  2. GRAID program at Stockholm Resilience Centre
  3. Chinese Scholarship Council (CSC)
  4. Vinnova [2018-02371] Funding Source: Vinnova
  5. Formas [2018-02371] Funding Source: Formas

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Background: For decades, scientists have attempted to provide a sustainable development framework that integrates goals of environmental protection and human development. The Planetary Boundaries concept (PBc)-a framework to guide sustainable development-juxtaposes a 'safe operating space for humanity' and 'planetary boundaries', to achieve a goal that decades of research have yet to meet. We here investigate if PBc is sufficiently different to previous sustainability concepts to have the intended impact, and map how future sustainability concept developments might make a difference.Design: We build a genealogy of the research that is cited in and informs PBc. We analyze this genealogy with the support of two seminal and a new consumer-resource models, that provide simple and analytically tractable analogies to human-environment relationships. These models bring together environmental limits, minimum requirements for populations and relationships between resource-limited and waste-limited environments.Results: PBc is based on coherent knowledge about sustainability that has been in place in scientific and policy contexts since the 1980s. PBc represents the ultimate framing of limits to the use of the environment, as limits not to single resources, but to Holocene-like Earth system dynamics. Though seldom emphasized, the crux of the limits to sustainable environmental dynamics lies in waste (mis-)management, which sets where boundary values might be. Minimum requirements for populations are under-defined: it is thedistributionof resources, opportunities and waste that shape what is a safe space and for whom.Discussion: We suggest that PBc is not different or innovative enough to break 'Cassandra's dilemma' and ensure scientific research effectively guides humanity towards sustainable development. For this, key issues of equality must be addressed, un-sustainability must be framed as a problem of today, rather than projected into the future, and scientific foundations of frameworks such as PBc must be broadened and diversified.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Letter Biodiversity Conservation

Transformative scenarios for biodiversity conservation and sustainability

Carolyn Lundquist, Shizuka Hashimoto, Machteld Schoolenberg

CONSERVATION LETTERS (2021)

Article Ecology

A global agenda for advancing freshwater biodiversity research

Alain Maasri, Sonja C. Jaehnig, Mihai C. Adamescu, Rita Adrian, Claudio Baigun, Donald J. Baird, Angelica Batista-Morales, Nuria Bonada, Lee E. Brown, Qinghua Cai, Joao Campos-Silva, Viola Clausnitzer, Topiltzin Contreras-MacBeath, Steven J. Cooke, Thibault Datry, Gonzalo Delacamara, Luc De Meester, Klaus-Douwe B. Dijkstra, Van Tu Do, Sami Domisch, David Dudgeon, Tibor Eros, Hendrik Freitag, Joerg Freyhof, Jana Friedrich, Martin Friedrichs-Manthey, Juergen Geist, Mark O. Gessner, Peter Goethals, Matthew Gollock, Christopher Gordon, Hans-Peter Grossart, Georges Gulemvuga, Pablo E. Gutierrez-Fonseca, Peter Haase, Daniel Hering, Hans Juergen Hahn, Charles P. Hawkins, Fengzhi He, Jani Heino, Virgilio Hermoso, Zeb Hogan, Franz Hoelker, Jonathan M. Jeschke, Meilan Jiang, Richard K. Johnson, Gregor Kalinkat, Bakhtiyor K. Karimov, Aventino Kasangaki, Ismael A. Kimirei, Bert Kohlmann, Mathias Kuemmerlen, Jan J. Kuiper, Benjamin Kupilas, Simone D. Langhans, Richard Lansdown, Florian Leese, Francis S. Magbanua, Shin-ichiro S. Matsuzaki, Michael T. Monaghan, Levan Mumladze, Javier Muzon, Pierre A. Mvogo Ndongo, Jens C. Nejstgaard, Oxana Nikitina, Clifford Ochs, Oghenekaro Nelson Odume, Jeffrey J. Opperman, Harmony Patricio, Steffen U. Pauls, Rajeev Raghavan, Alonso Ramirez, Bindiya Rashni, Vere Ross-Gillespie, Michael J. Samways, Ralf B. Schaefer, Astrid Schmidt-Kloiber, Ole Seehausen, Deep Narayan Shah, Subodh Sharma, Janne Soininen, Nike Sommerwerk, Jason D. Stockwell, Frank Suhling, Ram Devi Tachamo Shah, Rebecca E. Tharme, James H. Thorp, David Tickner, Klement Tockner, Jonathan D. Tonkin, Mireia Valle, Jean Vitule, Martin Volk, Ding Wang, Christian Wolter, Susanne Worischka

Summary: Global freshwater biodiversity is declining dramatically, with investments in research and conservation lagging behind terrestrial and marine realms. Through a global consultation, 15 pressing priority needs have been identified to support informed stewardship of freshwater biodiversity. The proposed agenda aims to advance freshwater biodiversity research globally for its sustainable management and conservation.

ECOLOGY LETTERS (2022)

Article Anthropology

Need-Based Transfers Enhance Resilience to Shocks: An Agent-Based Model of a Maasai Risk-Pooling System

Marco Campenni, Lee Cronk, Athena Aktipis

Summary: The study compared the impacts of need-based and debt-based transfers on herd survival, and found that using need-based transfers, larger network size, and decreased correlation among shocks were associated with increased survival rates.

HUMAN ECOLOGY (2022)

Article Development Studies

Improving the design of climate insurance: combining empirical approaches and modelling

Meike Will, Annika Backes, Marco Campenni, Lee Cronk, Gunnar Dressler, Christoph Gornott, Jurgen Groeneveld, Lemlem Teklegiorgis Habtemariam, Kati Kraehnert, Martin Kraus, Friederike Lenel, Daniel Osgood, Masresha Taye, Birgit Mueller

Summary: Extreme weather conditions caused by climate change disproportionately affect the most vulnerable members of society, and agricultural insurance programs designed for smallholders in developing countries are valuable tools. Combining different methods, especially by linking empirical analysis and modeling, can enhance the effectiveness of climate insurance products, especially under changing climatic conditions.

CLIMATE AND DEVELOPMENT (2022)

Article Ecology

Unlocking the unsustainable rice-wheat system of Indian Punjab: Assessing alternatives to crop-residue burning from a systems perspective

Andrea S. Downing, Manish Kumar, August Andersson, Amar Causevic, Orjan Gustafsson, Niraj U. Joshi, Chandra Kiran B. Krishnamurthy, Bert Scholtens, Beatrice Crona

Summary: Crop residue burning in Indian Punjab has detrimental impacts on health, climate, and agricultural production. Despite existing legal and technological barriers to burning, it continues due to lack of financial incentives for change. This study provides a systems perspective on the issue, highlighting the need for crop diversification, circular business models, and green financing. Financial institutions can play a crucial role in driving transformative changes by setting sustainability conditions on loans.

ECOLOGICAL ECONOMICS (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Nature futures for the urban century: Integrating multiple values into urban management

Andressa Mansur, Robert McDonald, Burak Guneralp, HyeJin Kim, Jose A. Puppim de Oliveira, Corey T. Callaghan, Perrine Hamel, Jan J. Kuiper, Manuel Wolff, Veronika Liebelt, Ines S. Martins, Thomas Elmqvist, Henrique M. Pereira

Summary: This paper introduces the Urban Nature Futures Framework (UNFF), which uses participatory methods and quantitative models to help stakeholders in cities build visions for three Nature Futures perspectives and explore different options for integrating nature into urban areas. It also evaluates how different community preferences result in various cityscapes and the distribution of associated benefits from nature.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2022)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Exploring desirable nature futures for Nationaal Park Hollandse Duinen

Jan J. Kuiper, Dianneke van Wijk, Wolf M. Mooij, Roy P. Remme, Garry D. Peterson, Sylvia Karlsson-Vinkhuyzen, Charlotte J. Mooij, Georgette M. Leltz, Laura M. Pereira

Summary: Achieving global sustainability goals requires redefining the relationship between people and nature. This paper presents a new approach, developed through an application in Nationaal Park Hollandse Duinen, that explores desirable futures for nature and people. The approach, co-designed with key stakeholders, combines frameworks for human-nature relationships and future development to catalyze sustainable change processes.

ECOSYSTEMS AND PEOPLE (2022)

Article Mathematical & Computational Biology

Bridging Theories for Ecosystem Stability Through Structural Sensitivity Analysis of Ecological Models in Equilibrium

Jan J. Kuiper, Bob W. Kooi, Garry D. Peterson, Wolf M. Mooij

Summary: Ecologists face the challenge of integrating different approaches and theories to understand ecosystems in a changing world. Food web theory and regime shift theory provide insights into stability mechanisms from different perspectives. The stability of empirical food web models and the vulnerability of ecosystems to collapse are not consistently related. Further research is needed to bridge alternative modeling approaches in ecology.

ACTA BIOTHEORETICA (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

A plea for more freshwater experts in IPBES

Jan J. Kuiper

Summary: Freshwater ecosystems are experiencing biodiversity loss at a faster rate than terrestrial or marine ecosystems, but they are not given equal priority in global environmental governance. The IPBES relies on voluntary contributions from independent experts to support international environmental agreements. Freshwater experts can contribute to IPBES through various avenues, including participating in the development of assessment reports, filling knowledge gaps, and implementing IPBES outcomes.

AQUATIC CONSERVATION-MARINE AND FRESHWATER ECOSYSTEMS (2023)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Bringing the Nature Futures Framework to life: creating a set of illustrative narratives of nature futures

America Paz Duran, Jan J. Kuiper, Ana Paula Dutra Aguiar, William W. L. Cheung, Mariteuw Chimere Diaw, Ghassen Halouani, Shizuka Hashimoto, Maria A. Gasalla, Garry D. Peterson, Machteld A. Schoolenberg, Rovshan Abbasov, Lilibeth A. Acosta, Dolors Armenteras, Federico Davila, Mekuria Argaw Denboba, Paula A. Harrison, Khaled Allam Harhash, Sylvia Karlsson-Vinkhuyzen, HyeJin Kim, Carolyn J. Lundquist, Brian W. Miller, Sana Okayasu, Ramon Pichs-Madruga, Jyothis Sathyapalan, Ali Kerem Saysel, Dandan Yu, Laura M. Pereira

Summary: In order to stop further destruction of the biosphere, it is necessary for most people and societies around the world to change their relationships with nature. The convention of Biological Diversity has set the vision of living in harmony with nature by 2050, valuing biodiversity, conserving and restoring it, and using it wisely to maintain ecosystem services and sustain a healthy planet. To explore different perspectives on achieving this vision, the Nature Futures Framework has been developed to facilitate the development of new scenarios and models that embrace a variety of desirable futures for nature and people.

SUSTAINABILITY SCIENCE (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

CLD4SDGs: Integrated assessment of progress and impacts on Sustainable Development Goals using Causal Loop Diagrams

Andrea S. Downing

Summary: This article describes a method for understanding how local sustainable processes in social-ecological systems contribute to or hinder the achievement of the United Nations' Sustainable Development Goals. The method involves constructing causal-loop diagrams, simplifying the diagrams for analysis, and providing a template for documentation and analysis.

METHODSX (2022)

Article Ecology

Integrated and innovative scenario approaches for sustainable development planning in The Bahamas

Katherine H. Wyatt, Katie K. Arkema, Stacey Wells-Moultrie, Jessica M. Silver, Brett Lashley, Adelle Thomas, Jan J. Kuiper, Anne D. Guerry, Mary Ruckelshaus

Summary: Using alternative future scenarios in development planning helps integrate diverse perspectives and consider the needs of humans and nature. Through a collaborative process involving stakeholder participation and risk assessment, this approach can inform investments in sustainable development.

ECOLOGY AND SOCIETY (2021)

Article Environmental Studies

An Earth system law perspective on governing social-hydrological systems in the Anthropocene

Hanna Ahlstrom, Jacob Hileman, Lan Wang-Erlandsson, Maria Mancilla Garcia, Michele-Lee Moore, Krisztina Jonas, Agnes Pranindita, Jan J. Kuiper, Ingo Fetzer, Fernando Jaramillo, Uno Svedin

Summary: The global hydrological cycle is influenced by complex interdependencies and self-regulating feedbacks, with increasing human impacts in the Anthropocene altering the dynamics of the cycle and posing challenges for water governance. Earth system law has the potential to bridge the gap between the global hydrological cycle and dispersed regulatory architecture, offering a solution to core problems in water governance. Through merging concepts from Earth system law with existing policy and legal principles, a framework is outlined for addressing hydrological issues in the Anthropocene and enhancing institutional compatibility between established governance systems and the global hydrological cycle.

EARTH SYSTEM GOVERNANCE (2021)

Article Environmental Studies

Mapping the benefits of nature in cities with the InVEST software

P. Hamel, A. D. Guerry, S. Polasky, B. Han, J. A. Douglass, M. Hamann, B. Janke, J. J. Kuiper, H. Levrel, H. Liu, E. Lonsdorf, R. I. McDonald, C. Nootenboom, Z. Ouyang, R. P. Remme, R. P. Sharp, L. Tardieu, V. Viguie, D. Xu, H. Zheng, G. C. Daily

Summary: The article introduces an approach to support urban greening by quantifying and mapping the diverse benefits of natural infrastructure. Through three case studies, the spatially explicit information about the benefits of nature is shown to enhance urban management.

NPJ URBAN SUSTAINABILITY (2021)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Advancing a toolkit of diverse futures approaches for global environmental assessments

Laura Pereira, Jan J. Kuiper, Odirilwe Selomane, Ana Paula D. Aguiar, Ghassem R. Asrar, Elena M. Bennett, Reinette Biggs, Katherine Calvin, Steve Hedden, Angel Hsu, Jason Jabbour, Nicholas King, Alexandre C. Koberle, Paul Lucas, Jeanne Nel, Albert V. Norstrom, Garry Peterson, Nadia Sitas, Christopher Trisos, Detlef P. van Vuuren, Joost Vervoort, James Ward

Summary: To effectively contribute to global environmental decision-making, GEAs need diverse future tools operating at multiple scales to address challenges like anticipating unpredictable conditions, being relevant at different levels, including diverse actors and perspectives, and leveraging imagination to inspire action. By utilizing a toolbox of future-oriented approaches and methods, GEAs can better meet the information needs of policymakers and stakeholders.

ECOSYSTEMS AND PEOPLE (2021)

No Data Available