4.7 Article

Comprehensive resilience assessment of electricity supply security for 140 countries

Journal

ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS
Volume 110, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

ELSEVIER
DOI: 10.1016/j.ecolind.2019.105731

Keywords

Resilience; Security of electricity supply; Composite indicator; Index; Country ranking; Decision support

Funding

  1. Polish Ministry of Science and Higher Education [0296/IP2/2016/74]
  2. Future Resilient Systems (FRS) at the Singapore-ETH Centre (SEC) [FI 370074011]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Indicator-based approaches are suitable to assess multi-dimensional problems. In order to compare a set of alternatives, one strategy is to normalize individual indicators to a common scale and aggregate them into a comprehensive score. This study proposes the Electricity Supply Resilience Index (ESRI), which is a measure of a nation's electricity supply resilience. Starting from an initial set of individual indicators derived through a structured selection process, the ESRI is calculated for 140 countries worldwide. To account for robustness of the resulting resilience index, 38 combinations of eight normalization methods and six aggregation functions were considered. Results show a clear country ranking trend, with robust top- and low-performing countries across all combinations. However, the ranking disparity becomes large for average performing countries, especially if their indicators show high variability. Furthermore, the differences of the rankings are quantified through the Rank Difference Measure (RDM), which identifies the categorical scales and the minimum aggregator as the most different ones. Finally, the effects of different compensation levels of the aggregation functions are discussed. The findings of the present study aim to provide recommendations for policymakers on how composite indexes results depend on assumptions and chosen approaches.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Management

Multicriteria decision support for the evaluation of electricity supply resilience: Exploration of interacting criteria

Eleftherios Siskos, Peter Burgherr

Summary: This paper proposes a comprehensive multicriteria decision support methodological framework to evaluate the electricity supply resilience of European countries. The framework evaluates and ranks 35 European countries based on their performance on 17 interacting evaluation criteria. The Choquet Integral and Simos method are used in synergy to provide guidance and areas for improvement for energy policymakers.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF OPERATIONAL RESEARCH (2022)

Article Management

Recommending multiple criteria decision analysis methods with a new taxonomy-based decision support system

Marco Cinelli, Milosz Kadzinski, Grzegorz Miebs, Michael Gonzalez, Roman Slowinski

Summary: A new methodology for selecting Multiple Criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) methods is introduced, implemented in the Multiple Criteria Decision Analysis Methods Selection Software (MCDA-MSS). The software provides guidance for analysts in choosing the most suitable MCDA method for a given decision problem, offering a comprehensive evaluation of over 200 MCDA methods based on problem characteristics.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF OPERATIONAL RESEARCH (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Dynamics of severe accidents in the oil & gas energy sector derived from the authoritative ENergy-related severe accident database

Arnaud Mignan, Matteo Spada, Peter Burgherr, Ziqi Wang, Didier Sornette

Summary: This study constructs an accident graph for the oil & gas industry and investigates the chains of events leading to severe accidents using graph theory, Markov analysis, and catastrophe dynamics. The findings show that human error consistently contributes to accidents and explosion, fire, toxic release, and element rupture are the primary sinks and catalysts. The study also reveals that chains of up to five events play a significant role in severe accidents, including secondary events that are not directly identifiable from the graph topology.

PLOS ONE (2022)

Article Management

Performance evaluation of emergency department physicians using robust value-based additive efficiency model

Anna Labijak-Kowalska, Milosz Kadzinski, Inga Spychala, Luis C. Dias, Javier Fiallos, Jonathan Patrick, Wojtek Michalowski, Ken Farion

Summary: This study proposes a novel variant of the value-based additive data envelopment analysis model and conducts a comprehensive robustness analysis of physicians' performance using mathematical programming and the Monte Carlo simulation. The results indicate a strong dependence of physicians' performances on the selected weight vectors, and provide a basis for identifying overall good performers, developing improvement plans, and recognizing challenging patients' complaints.

INTERNATIONAL TRANSACTIONS IN OPERATIONAL RESEARCH (2023)

Article Engineering, Civil

Quantifying disaster resilience of a community with interdependent civil infrastructure systems

Nikola Blagojevic, Fiona Hefti, Jonas Henken, Max Didier, Bozidar Stojadinovic

Summary: Disaster resilient civil infrastructure systems are crucial for resilient communities. Measuring their resilience is challenging due to their complexity, different impacts from various disasters, and dynamic interdependencies among components.

STRUCTURE AND INFRASTRUCTURE ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Management

Deep preference learning for multiple criteria decision analysis

Krzysztof Martyn, Milosz Kadzinski

Summary: This study proposes preference learning algorithms for inferring the parameters of a sorting model from large sets of examples, with application in Multiple Criteria Decision Analysis. By utilizing artificial neural networks and gradient descent optimization algorithms, the study achieves high predictive accuracy.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF OPERATIONAL RESEARCH (2023)

Article Engineering, Geological

Seismic fatality risk evaluation framework for existing buildings in Switzerland

Safak Arslanturkoglu, Bozidar Stojadinovic

Summary: This paper presents a graphical framework for evaluating seismic fatality risk of existing buildings. The framework provides a transparent view of the contributions of different sources of hazard and risk, and takes uncertainty into account to help engineers and building owners make better, risk-based decisions.

BULLETIN OF EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Computer Science, Artificial Intelligence

Proper and improper uses of MCDA methods in energy systems analysis

Marco Cinelli, Peter Burgherr, Milosz Kadzinski, Roman Slowinski

Summary: The current selection of Multiple Criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) methods in energy systems analysis is problematic, primarily due to the misuse of weighting methods, inappropriate selection of MCDA techniques, and failure to address obvious interactions in preference models. A newly developed methodology can assist decision makers and analysts in choosing the most suitable MCDA method.

DECISION SUPPORT SYSTEMS (2022)

Article Engineering, Geological

Ductility-strength and strength-ductility relations for a constant yield displacement seismic design procedure

Andreia H. A. da Silva, Anastasios Tsiavos, Bozidar Stojadinovic

Summary: The modern engineering approach allows for inelastic response of structures to rare but intense earthquakes. Models and tools are essential for accurately assessing the inelastic response and controlling the performance of the structures. In this study, we develop closed-form relations between ductility μ and strength reduction factor R*, as well as their inverses, which are functions of the yield displacement S-d,S-y. We also formulate dimensionless relations for ductility-strength and strength-ductility, independent of seismic hazard intensity.

BULLETIN OF EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Engineering, Civil

The role of risk measures in relating earthquake risks at building and portfolio levels

Lukas Bodenmann, Marco Broccardo, Panagiotis Galanis, Bozidar Stojadinovic

Summary: The consideration of seismic risk at a regional, building portfolio level is important due to the potential large spatial impact of earthquake disasters and the concentration of population and values in urban areas. The relationship between building-level seismic risk and portfolio-level seismic risk is helpful in meeting specific regional seismic risk tolerance levels. Subadditive risk measures, such as Expected Shortfall, allow for estimating conservative upper bounds of portfolio-level seismic risk. However, nonsubadditive risk measures commonly used in earthquake engineering can lead to counter-intuitive and nonconservative perceptions of regional seismic risk.

EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING & STRUCTURAL DYNAMICS (2023)

Article Management

Probabilistic ordinal regression methods for multiple criteria sorting admitting certain and uncertain preferences

Zice Ru, Jiapeng Liu, Milosz Kadzinski, Xiuwu Liao

Summary: This article proposes a family of probabilistic ordinal regression methods for multiple criteria sorting. It introduces Bayesian Ordinal Regression and Subjective Stochastic Ordinal Regression to derive the class assignments of alternatives based on provided preference information. The introduced approaches are evaluated through an experimental study involving real-world datasets.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF OPERATIONAL RESEARCH (2023)

Article Operations Research & Management Science

Exact and stochastic methods for robustness analysis in the context of Imprecise Data Envelopment Analysis

Anna Labijak-Kowalska, Milosz Kadzinski

Summary: This study proposes a ratio-based model for measuring the efficiency of decision-making units and introduces a robustness analysis framework that considers both interval and ordinal performances on inputs and outputs. The methodology takes advantage of the uncertainty related to imprecise data and considers all feasible input/output weight vectors determined by linear constraints. Methods are provided to verify the robustness of efficiency scores, efficiency preference relations, and efficiency ranks. Mathematical programming models are formulated to compute extreme, necessary, and possible results, and stochastic analysis using Monte Carlo simulations is incorporated to derive the probability distribution of different outcomes. The framework is implemented in R and made available as open-source software. Its use is illustrated through case studies on Chinese ports and industrial robots.

OPERATIONAL RESEARCH (2023)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Robust Additive Value-Based Efficiency Analysis with a Hierarchical Structure of Inputs and Outputs

Anna Labijak-Kowalska, Milosz Kadzinski, Weronika Mrozek

Summary: We propose a new methodological framework based on additive value-based efficiency analysis, which considers inputs and outputs organized hierarchically. This approach decomposes the problem into manageable pieces and allows us to determine the strengths and weaknesses of the analyzed units. By analyzing feasible weight vectors at different hierarchy levels, we provide robust outcomes. The analysis includes three complementary perspectives: distances to the efficient unit, ranks, and pairwise preference relations. For each perspective, we determine the extreme results and the distribution of probabilistic results. We apply this method to a case study on the performance of healthcare systems in 16 Polish provinces, discussing the results based on the entire factor set and three subcategories: health improvement, efficient financial management, and consumer satisfaction. Lastly, we reveal practical conclusions derived from the hierarchical decomposition of the problem and robustness analysis.

APPLIED SCIENCES-BASEL (2023)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

A Framework to Navigate Eco-Labels in the Textile and Clothing Industry

Paula Ziyeh, Marco Cinelli

Summary: This paper examines the assessment methods employed by eco-labels in the textile and clothing industry and proposes a classification framework based on these methods. The framework aims to improve the consistency and traceability of eco-labels.

SUSTAINABILITY (2023)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Modeling Contingent Decision Behavior: A Bayesian Nonparametric Preference-Learning Approach

Jiapeng Liu, Milosz Kadzinski, Xiuwu Liaoa

Summary: We propose a preference-learning algorithm that uncovers Decision Makers' (DMs') contingent evaluation strategies in multiple criteria sorting. Our method uses holistic assignment examples derived from the analysis of performance vectors and textual descriptions. Using a mixture of threshold-based, value-driven preference models and latent topics, we construct a probabilistic model. The method automatically identifies components representing the evaluation strategies of all DMs.

INFORMS JOURNAL ON COMPUTING (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Identification of critical ecological restoration and early warning regions in the five-lakes basin of central Yunnan

Yongcui Lan, Jinliang Wang, Qianwei Liu, Fang Liu, Lanfang Liu, Jie Li, Mengjia Luo

Summary: This study focuses on the five major plateau lake basins in central Yunnan, China, and constructs an ecological security pattern using the source-resistance surface-corridor-pinch point framework. The study simulates land use/cover change in the region and identifies early warning regions where future urban expansion poses a threat to current ecological source areas and corridors.

ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS (2024)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Active microeukaryotes hold clues of effects of global warming on benthic diversity and connectivity in the coastal sediments

Pingping Huang, Feng Zhao, Bailing Zhou, Kuidong Xu

Summary: This study investigates the distribution of benthic microeukaryotes in the China Seas and finds that they can stride over the ecological barrier of 32 degrees N. The study also highlights the significant influence of depth, temperature, and latitude on communities in the China Seas.

ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS (2024)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Which bird traits most affect the goodness-of-fit of species distribution models?

Federico Morelli, Yanina Benedetti, Jesse Stanford, Leszek Jerzak, Piotr Tryjanowski, Paolo Perna, Riccardo Santolini

Summary: Species distribution models (SDMs) are numerical tools used for predicting species' spatial distribution. This study found that ecological characteristics, such as habitat specialization, play a role in improving the accuracy of SDMs.

ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS (2024)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Exploring the spatiotemporal evolution dynamic and influencing factor of green ecology transition for megacities: A case study of Chengdu, China

Xiaoxuan Wu, Hang Liu, Wei Liu

Summary: Global climate change, urbanization, and economic development have increased the need for sustainable human development, urban ecological governance, and low-carbon energy transformation. This study analyzes the green ecological transition in Chengdu based on panel data from 2010 to 2020, exploring its spatiotemporal evolution and key factors. The results show an overall upward trend in Chengdu's green ecological development and positive spatial autocorrelation in certain districts.

ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS (2024)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

A multi-indicator approach to compare the sustainability of organic vs. integrated management of grape production

Castaldi Simona, Formicola Nicola, Mastrocicco Micol, Morales Rodriguez Carmen, Morelli Raffaella, Prodorutti Daniele, Vannini Andrea, Zanzotti Roberto

Summary: Sustainable agricultural practices are increasingly important for global and national environmental policies and economy. This study compared the sustainability of grape production under integrated and organic management using multiple indicators. The results showed that organic management was more beneficial for most environmental aspects of the agroecosystem compared to integrated management, without affecting grape yield.

ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS (2024)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Comparing ground below-canopy and satellite spectral data for an improved and integrated forest phenology monitoring system

Gaia Vaglio Laurin, Alexander Cotrina-Sanchez, Luca Belelli-Marchesini, Enrico Tomelleri, Giovanna Battipaglia, Claudia Cocozza, Francesco Niccoli, Jerzy Piotr Kabala, Damiano Gianelle, Loris Vescovo, Luca Da Ros, Riccardo Valentini

Summary: Phenology monitoring is important for understanding forest functioning and climate impacts. This research compares the phenological behavior of European beech forests using Tree-Talker (TT+) and Sentinel 2 satellite data. The study finds differences in the information derived by the two sensor types, particularly in terms of season length, phenology changepoints, and leaf period variability. TT+ with its higher temporal resolution demonstrates precision in capturing the phenological changepoints, especially when satellite image availability is limited.

ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS (2024)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Assessing the coupling coordination dynamics between land use intensity and ecosystem services in Shanxi's coalfields, China

Huanhuan Pan, Ziqiang Du, Zhitao Wu, Hong Zhang, Keming Ma

Summary: The land use and cover changes resulting from coal mining activities and ecological restoration have had a significant impact on ecosystem services in mining areas. This study investigates the relationship between ecosystem services and land use intensity in coal mining areas, emphasizing the importance of understanding this interdependence for balanced human-land system development. The research examines the evolving relationship across different reclamation stages in Shanxi, China, using a coupling coordination degree model. The findings suggest the need for timely and judicious reclamation of coalfields, considering the land's bearing capacity.

ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS (2024)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

An investigation on the impact of blue and green spatial pattern alterations on the urban thermal environment: A case study of Shanghai

Jingjuan He, Yijun Shi, Lihua Xu, Zhangwei Lu, Mao Feng

Summary: This study examines the spatial interplay between changes in the blue-green spatial distribution and modifications in land surface temperature grades in Shanghai. The findings reveal that the transformation of the blue-green spatial pattern differs between different sectors of the city, and the impact on the thermal environment varies spatially.

ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS (2024)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Prediction of phytoplankton biomass and identification of key influencing factors using interpretable machine learning models

Yi Xu, Di Zhang, Junqiang Lin, Qidong Peng, Xiaohui Lei, Tiantian Jin, Jia Wang, Ruifang Yuan

Summary: This study analyzed the response relationship between phytoplankton growth and water environmental parameters in the Middle Route of the South-to-North Water Diversion Project in China using long-term monitoring data and machine learning models. The results revealed the differences between monitoring sites and identified the key parameters that affect phytoplankton growth.

ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS (2024)