4.7 Article

Facultative hybrid RO-PRO concept to improve economic performance of PRO: Feasibility and maximizing efficiency

Journal

DESALINATION
Volume 478, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

ELSEVIER
DOI: 10.1016/j.desal.2019.114268

Keywords

Water energy nexus; Efficiency; Module configurations; Optimization; Membrane geometry

Ask authors/readers for more resources

A facultative hybrid reverse osmosis (RO) - pressure retarded osmosis (PRO) system can switch its operation between i) RO mode, where high quality water is produced from waste-water treatment plant effluent and ii) PRO mode, where the salinity difference between seawater desalination brine and wastewater is converted to energy. This system takes advantage of fluctuating energy pricing, by consuming low cost energy to produce water and producing high value energy. The system was modeled by a local concentration polarization and solution diffusion model, considering several geometries. The system was optimized and for different ratios of the economic value of electricity vs water, to find process settings and switch points. A necessary condition for the feasibility of the facultative hybrid RO-PRO concept is that the permeate value satisfies: i) low enough, to justify electricity production and ii) high enough, to justify water production. With a maximum energy price of 0.25 USD/kWh, the first condition translates into < 0.10-0.17 USD/m(3) (ALFS) or < 0.20-0.28 USD/m(3) (ALDS). The facultative hybrid RO-PRO concept is only feasible as improvement to a PRO system, where there is a limited demand for purified WWTP-effluent. It is expected that it is usually preferred to produce purified WWTP-effluent.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Nanoscience & Nanotechnology

Deployment of Superhydrophilic and Super-antifouling Cr-soc-MOF-1-Based Membrane for Ultrafast Separation of Stabilized Oil-in-Water Emulsions

M. Obaid, Norah Alsadun, Osama Shekhah, Sarah Almahfoodh, Sheng Zhou, Noreddine Ghaffour, Mohamed Eddaoudi

Summary: Despite progress in oil-water separation, challenges like low permeance and fouling problems still exist. Superwettable materials, particularly metal-organic frameworks (MOFs), are potential candidates for oily wastewater treatment. However, MOFs have been rarely explored for separating stabilized oil-in-water emulsions, calling for the development of better MOF materials.

ACS APPLIED MATERIALS & INTERFACES (2023)

Article Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

A Fouling Comparison Study of Algal, Bacterial and Humic Organic Matters in Seawater Desalination Pretreatment Using Ceramic UF Membranes

Mohammed Al Namazi, Sheng Li, Noreddine Ghaffour, TorOve Leiknes, Gary Amy

Summary: This study compares three types of organic matter (AOM, BOM, and HOM) in terms of their content, fouling behavior, and removal efficiency in ceramic UF filtration. It found that the 5 kDa membrane removed more transparent exopolymer particles (TEP)/organics than the 50 kDa membrane, but had less fouling formation for all three types of organic matter. The study also revealed that AOM had the highest MFI-UF and TMP values among the three organics and exhibited high fouling potential.

MEMBRANES (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Performance Evaluation of a Pilot-Scale Aerobic Granular Sludge Integrated with Gravity-Driven Membrane System Treating Domestic Wastewater

Muhammad Ali, Yogesh Singh, Luca Fortunato, Zahid Ur Rehman, Sarvajith Manjunath, Johannes S. Vrouwenvelder, Mario Pronk, Mark C. M. van Loosdrecht, Pascal E. Saikaly

Summary: A pilot-scale wastewater treatment process integrating aerobic granular sludge with a gravity-driven membrane system showed superior performance compared to a conventional aerobic MBR system. This novel process is a promising solution for decentralized wastewater treatment and reuse in water-scarce regions. It demonstrated superior nutrient removal and stable operation without the need for frequent cleaning.

ACS ES&T WATER (2023)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Selected physical and chemical cleanings remove biofilm in seawater membrane distillation without causing pore wetting

Najat A. Amin, Harun Elcik, Alla Alpatova, Graciela Gonzalez-Gil, Bastiaan Blankert, Nadia Farhat, Johannes S. Vrouwenvelder, Noreddine Ghaffour

Summary: This study explores the efficiency of different cleaning strategies in biofilm removal during seawater membrane distillation (MD). The results showed that chemical cleanings were more effective in removing biofilm, and the post-cleaning permeate conductivities were low, indicating stable membrane performance.

NPJ CLEAN WATER (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Airfoil-shaped filament feed spacer for improved filtration performance in water treatment

Adnan Qamar, Sarah Kerdi, Johannes S. Vrouwenvelder, Noreddine Ghaffour

Summary: Optimal spacer design, such as the proposed novel airfoil feed spacer design, plays a crucial role in enhancing filtration performance in spiral-wound modules. The airfoil spacers are found to provide steady-state and uniform flow characteristics, resulting in improved permeate flux, reduced energy consumption, and minimized biofouling development. Controlling the Angle of Attack (AOA) of the airfoil filaments allows for effective control of localized hydrodynamics based on the filtration type and operating conditions.

SCIENTIFIC REPORTS (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

A comprehensive evaluation of the temporal and spatial fouling characteristics of RO membranes in a full-scale seawater desalination plant

Chao Chen, Yu Yang, Nigel J. D. Graham, Zhenyu Li, Xingtao Yang, Zhining Wang, Nadia Farhat, Johannes S. Vrouwenvelder, Li -an Hou

Summary: The fouling of seawater reverse osmosis membranes is a persistent challenge in desalination. This study monitored the operational performance of a desalination plant for 7 years and the fouling development in different areas of membrane modules. The findings showed that operational performance declined over time and fouling mainly occurred at the feed side of the modules, with the highest microbial diversity. Keystone species like Chloroflexi and Planctomycetes played an important role in maintaining community structure and biofilm maturation. Polysaccharides, soluble microbial products, marine humic acid-like substances, and inorganic substances contributed to fouling. Overall, biofouling had a significant impact on membrane fouling after 7 years of operation.

WATER RESEARCH (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Advanced structures of reversal multi-stage flash desalination

Emad Ali, Jamel Orfi, Hany AlAnsary, Saleh Baakeem, Ahmad S. Alsaadi, Noreddine Ghaffour

Summary: Three different modifications of the reversal multi-stage flash (MSF) plant were proposed and compared. The hybrid MSF and membrane distillation (MD) configuration showed promising results, while the cascaded MSF blocks had different advantages and disadvantages.

DESALINATION (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Advanced 3D multiscale modeling of forward osmosis-membrane distillation integrated designs

Sofiane Soukane, Muhammad Saqib Nawaz, M. Obaid, Veerabhadraiah Gudideni, Ali Al-Qahtani, Noreddine Ghaffour

Summary: The development of eco-friendly desalination and water reuse is crucial for securing water resources for future generations. Numerical modeling, specifically the integration of forward osmosis (FO) and membrane distillation (MD), plays a key role in accelerating the design and scale-up of hybrid processes. This study presents an advanced 3D multiscale modeling approach that combines heat and mass transfer calculations with computational fluid dynamics, leading to effective process scale-up evaluation.

DESALINATION (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Concept and analysis of hybrid reversal multi-stage flash and membrane distillation desalination system

Emad Ali, Jamel Orfi, Hany Alansary, Saleh Baakeem, Ahmad S. Alsaadi, Noreddine Ghaffour

Summary: This study presents the concept and analysis of integrating membrane distillations with reversal once-through Multistage Flash desalination. The analysis is based on numerical simulation. The results show that integrating MD vessels into the terminal ends of the RV-MSF system can leverage thermal energy and increase the overall production rate. Hybridisation at stage one, by utilizing the energy of the MSF reject brine, has a greater impact on production rate compared to hybridisation at the last MSF stage.

ENVIRONMENTAL TECHNOLOGY (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Recent progress on the application of capacitive deionization for wastewater treatment

Enas Taha Sayed, M. Obaid, A. G. Olabi, Mohammad Ali Abdelkareem, Muaz Al Radi, Amer Al-Dawoud, Sameer Al-Asheh, Noreddine Ghaffour

Summary: This review summarizes the principles, applications, and future development of capacitive deionization (CDI) technology in wastewater treatment, highlighting the significant advancements in removing various contaminants from water using CDI.

JOURNAL OF WATER PROCESS ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Removal of polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) from water using hydrophobic natural deep eutectic solvents (NADES): A proof of concept study

Luca Fortunato, Lamya Al Fuhaid, Sapia Murgolo, Cristina De Ceglie, Giuseppe Mascolo, Laura Falivene, Johannes S. Vrouwenvelder, Geert-Jan Witkamp, Andreia Farinha

Summary: This study investigated the use of natural deep eutectic solvents (NADES) for the extraction of Polyfluoroalkyl Substances (PFAS) from aqueous solutions. The results showed that a hydrophobic NADES, menthol-acetic acid, was effective in extracting perfluoroheptanoic acid (PFHpA) from water. The extraction efficiency was high and not affected by PFHpA concentration or the initial pH of the solution. Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations provided insights into the interaction mechanism between PFHpA and NADES.

JOURNAL OF WATER PROCESS ENGINEERING (2023)

Review Engineering, Chemical

Emerging MXenes: Revolutionizing oily wastewater treatment - a comprehensive and critical review

I. Ihsanullah, Muhammad Bilal, Muhammad Sajid, Abdul Wahab Mohammad, Muataz A. Atieh, Noreddine Ghaffour

Summary: This review critically summarizes the successful applications of MXene materials in the separation of oily emulsions. The unique characteristics of MXene materials position them as ideal candidates for oil/water separation applications. The paper evaluates the separation mechanisms, regeneration performance, stability, and durability of MXene-based materials and identifies current challenges and research gaps. Future prospects for advancing MXene-based oil/water separation technology are also presented.

SEPARATION AND PURIFICATION TECHNOLOGY (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Observation and mitigation of perimeter artefacts in bench scale membrane characterization

Bastiaan Blankert, Fernan D. Martinez, Johannes S. Vrouwenvelder, Cristian Picioreanu

Summary: Perimeter artefacts, such as membrane damage and unrepresentative hydrodynamics, can significantly affect bench scale performance evaluation. However, the effect can be mitigated by measuring salt rejection from only the central area of the coupon.

DESALINATION (2023)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Comparative analysis of integrating standalone renewable energy sources with brackish water reverse osmosis plants: Technical and economic perspectives

Arvin Sohrabi, Mousa Meratizaman, Shuli Liu

Summary: This paper simulates and discusses possible solutions to improve the economic and technical performances of a battery-less renewable energy-powered BWRO system under real climate conditions. The study finds that the photovoltaic-based system performs better in terms of specific energy consumption and unused energy ratio.

DESALINATION (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

An innovative process design of seawater desalination toward hydrogen liquefaction applied to a ship's engine: An economic analysis and intelligent data-driven learning study/optimization

Chunlan Pan, Xiaoyin Hu, Vishal Goyal, Theyab R. Alsenani, Salem Alkhalaf, Tamim Alkhalifah, Fahad Alturise, Hamad Almujibah, H. Elhosiny Ali

Summary: This paper introduces a novel waste heat recovery method using the hot flue gas from a ship's engine to produce liquefied hydrogen while meeting the ship's air-conditioning requirement. A comprehensive feasibility assessment is conducted and an artificial neural network with a multiobjective grey wolf optimization method is used for optimization. The findings indicate the highest mean sensitivity index of the flash temperature and the best optimization scenario for exergy efficiency, CO2 emission reduction, and liquefied hydrogen cost.

DESALINATION (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Selective separation of nitrate from chloride using PVDF-based anion-exchange membranes

Daniele Chinello, Jan Post, Louis C. P. M. de Smet

Summary: In this study, PVDF-based anion-exchange membranes were designed to selectively separate nitrate from chloride. Experimental data showed that increasing the concentration of PVDF enhanced nitrate transport but also increased the membrane electrical resistance. The selectivity of nitrate was found to be independent of the membrane thickness and mainly driven by the increased affinity between the anion and the membrane.

DESALINATION (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Functionalized carbon 1D/2D nanomaterials for effective water desalination: Synthesis, applications and cost issues. An overview

Umar Noor, Muhammad Fayyaz Farid, Ammara Sharif, Amna Saleem, Zubair Nabi, Muhammad Furqan Mughal, Kiran Abbas, Toheed Ahmed

Summary: Global water scarcity is increasing, and water desalination is an important solution. Multifunctional advanced materials, such as membrane materials and solar-driven desalination, play a crucial role in water desalination. Additionally, these materials can be used for water purification, wastewater treatment, and pollutant elimination.

DESALINATION (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

sCO2 power cycle/reverse osmosis distillation system for water-electricity cogeneration in nuclear powered ships and submarines

Emrah Gumus

Summary: With growing global concerns about climate change and environmental impacts, the use of nuclear energy in naval vessels offers a cleaner and more efficient solution to reduce emissions and address water and energy supply challenges. This study explores a novel system that combines a nuclear-driven supercritical carbon dioxide power cycle with reverse osmosis cogeneration to meet the water and electricity demands in maritime operations, enhancing the sustainability, efficiency, and self-sufficiency of naval vessels. The results indicate that the system has the potential to be a viable and effective solution for naval operations.

DESALINATION (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Zwitterionic material for construction of an antifouling polyamide thin film composite membrane

Dao Thi Thanh Huyen, Saikat Sinha Ray, Young -Nam Kwon

Summary: This study focuses on the modification of a commercially available polyamide thin-film composite membrane with a zwitterionic material to enhance its fouling resistance. The modified membrane shows improved salt rejection and reduced permeability compared to the pristine membrane. Fouling tests demonstrate that the modified membrane has a lower fouling ratio and higher recovery ratio. The enhanced antifouling characteristics are attributed to the improved hydrophilicity resulting from the zwitterionic brushes and the salting-in effect.

DESALINATION (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Towards pilot scale flow-electrode capacitive deionization

Niklas Koeller, Lukas Mankertz, Selina Finger, Christian J. Linnartz, Matthias Wessling

Summary: This study presents a methodology to scale up Flow-electrode Capacitive Deionization (FCDI) technology from lab-scale to pilot-scale systems. By increasing membrane area and using a stacking approach, the FCDI modules were successfully scaled up and achieved a salt transfer rate comparable to lab-scale systems. This provides a foundation for future assessments of energy demand and economics.

DESALINATION (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Efficient lithium recovery from simulated brine using a hybrid system: Direct contact membrane distillation (DCMD) and electrically switched ion exchange (ESIX)

Mona Gulied, Sifani Zavahir, Tasneem Elmakki, Hyunwoong Park, Guillermo Hijos Gago, Ho Kyong Shon, Dong Suk Han

Summary: This study introduces a novel hybrid system that combines direct contact membrane distillation (DCMD) and electrically switched ion exchange (ESIX) to facilitate seawater reverse osmosis (SWRO) brine enrichment and selective lithium recovery.

DESALINATION (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Enhanced ammonia recovery from strong ammonia wastewater via a transmembrane electro-chemisorption system with authigenic acid and base

Zhiqiang Zhang, Ruifeng Deng, Jiao Zhang, Lu She, Guangfeng Wei, Renyong Jia, Pengyu Xiang, Siqing Xia

Summary: A transmembrane electro-chemisorption system with authigenic acid and base was developed for enhancing ammonia recovery from strong ammonia wastewater. The system efficiently transformed ammonium into free ammonia, which was then adsorbed and recovered through transmembrane chemisorption. This system yielded pure (NH4)2SO4 product and produced valuable byproducts of pure hydrogen and oxygen. Higher applied voltage resulted in better ammonia recovery.

DESALINATION (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Development of high-integrity reverse osmosis membranes for enhanced removal of microorganisms

Alena Popova, Sandrine Boivin, Takuji Shintani, Takahiro Fujioka

Summary: This study aimed to produce a high-integrity RO membrane by forming a polyamide skin layer on a TE support layer, in order to enhance the integrity of the membrane and improve the microbiological safety of potable water reuse.

DESALINATION (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Reducing the specific energy use of seawater desalination with thermally enhanced reverse osmosis

Sanjana Yagnambhatt, Saber Khanmohammadi, Jonathan Maisonneuve

Summary: This study investigates the concept of using heat to enhance reverse osmosis (RO) desalination. The effect of temperature on water permeate flux, specific energy, permeate quality, and applied operating pressures is evaluated using an analytical model. The results suggest that under specific conditions, the tradeoff between savings in mechanical pump work and thermal energy input in thermally-enhanced RO can be favorable, leading to overall energy savings.

DESALINATION (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Selective membrane capacitive deionization for superior lithium recovery

Jiangju Si, Chenrui Xue, Shun Li, Linchao Yang, Weiwei Li, Jie Yang, Jihong Lan, Ningbo Sun

Summary: To meet the huge demand for lithium resources, there is an urgent need to develop a new efficient technology for lithium recovery from salt-lake brines. In this study, a selective membrane capacitive deionization system is reported, which achieves high lithium recovery capacity and rate through the use of materials with efficient intercalated pseudo-capacitance and a high specific area porous carbon. The use of a modified thin-coated membrane allows for selective Li+ recovery, and adjusting the concentrations of Li+ and Mg2+ in the feed solution enables higher Li+/Mg2+ selectivity.

DESALINATION (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Augmentation of solar still distillation performance using waste heat energy and guiding vanes: A field study

Mohamed R. Salem, R. Y. Sakr, Ghazy M. R. Assassa, Omar A. Aly

Summary: This research proposes a new method of using wasted thermal energies as an additional heating source for solar still distillation units (SSDUs) to increase productivity and reduce pollution and global warming. By testing two SSDUs, the study shows that heating airflow can raise temperatures, enhance freshwater production, and improve system thermal efficiency.

DESALINATION (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Novel fabric-based 3D photothermal evaporator with advanced light-harvesting and thermal management design

Qimeng Sun, Miao Sun, Linyan Yang, Yuan Gao, Xinghai Zhou, Lihua Lyu, Chunyan Wei

Summary: This study presents an innovative design and fabrication of a fabric-based conical roll (FCR) evaporator, which enables low-temperature evaporation and achieves high evaporation efficiency with excellent thermal management ability. The evaporator has demonstrated advanced light-harvesting capability and can produce freshwater that meets drinking water standards, showing great potential for applications in desalination and sewage treatment.

DESALINATION (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

A dual-functional lignin containing pulp foam for solar evaporation and contaminant adsorption

Yidong Zhang, Wangfang Deng, Meiyan Wu, Chao Liu, Guang Yu, Qiu Cui, Pedram Fatehi, Chunlin Xu, Bin Li

Summary: In this study, a novel polydopamine-functionalized lignin-containing pulp foam evaporator with high-efficiency desalination and multi-contaminant adsorption capabilities was designed. The foam evaporator showed excellent light absorption, water absorption, thermal conductivity, and chelation abilities, allowing for solar evaporation and contaminant adsorption synergistically. It also exhibited potential applications in metal ion concentration and contaminated seawater treatments, and demonstrated superior biodegradability compared to poly-styrene foam. This foam material holds promise for developing multifunctional photo-thermal systems for solar-driven water purification.

DESALINATION (2024)