4.4 Article

Wilfully out of sight? A literature review on the effectiveness of cancer-related decision aids and implementation strategies

Journal

Publisher

BMC
DOI: 10.1186/s12911-016-0273-8

Keywords

Decision aids; Implementation; Neoplasm

Funding

  1. University of Newcastle International Postgraduate Research Scholarship (UNIPRS)
  2. University of Newcastle/Hunter Cancer Research Alliance Research Scholarship
  3. Sydney Catalyst scholarship
  4. Strategic Research Partnership Grant from Cancer Council NSW [CSR 11-02]
  5. University of Newcastle and Hunter Medical Research Institute

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Background: There is evidence to suggest that decision aids improve a number of patient outcomes. However, little is known about the progression of research effort in this area over time. This literature review examined the volume of research published in 2000, 2007 and 2014 which tested the effectiveness of decision aids in improving cancer patient outcomes, coded by cancer site and decision type being targeted. These numbers were compared with the volume of research examining the effectiveness of strategies to increase the adoption of decision aids by healthcare providers. Methods: A literature review of intervention studies was undertaken. Medline, Embase, PsychInfo and Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews were searched. The search was limited to human studies published in English, French, or German. Abstracts were assessed against eligibility criteria by one reviewer and a random sample of 20 % checked by a second. Eligible intervention studies in the three time periods were categorised by: i) whether they tested the effectiveness of decision aids, coded by cancer site and decision type, and ii) whether they tested strategies to increase healthcare provider adoption of decision aids. Results: Over the three time points assessed, increasing research effort has been directed towards testing the effectiveness of decision aids in improving patient outcomes (p < 0.0001). The number of studies on decision aids for cancer screening or prevention increased statistically significantly (p < 0.0001) whereas the number of studies on cancer treatment did not (p = 1.00). The majority of studies examined the effectiveness of decision aids for prostate (n = 10), breast (n = 9) or colon cancer (n = 7). Only two studies assessed the effectiveness of implementation strategies to increase healthcare provider adoption of decision aids. Conclusions: While the number of studies testing the effectiveness of decision aids has increased, the majority of research has focused on screening and prevention decision aids for only a few cancer sites. This neglects a number of cancer populations, as well as other areas of cancer care such as treatment decisions. Also, given the apparent effectiveness of decision aids, more effort needs to be made to implement this evidence into meaningful benefits for patients.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.4
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Otorhinolaryngology

Improving screening for physical impairments and access to early physiotherapy after neck dissection surgery: a translational controlled trial

Aoife C. McGarvey, Peter G. Osmotherly, Gary R. Hoffman, Alix Hall

Summary: The study aimed to increase post-operative physical screening of neck dissection patients and improve physiotherapy referral rates by implementing an intervention targeting physiotherapists and surgeons. Results showed that the translational intervention conducted by physiotherapists significantly increased screening and referral rates for physiotherapy of post-operative neck dissection patients.

EUROPEAN ARCHIVES OF OTO-RHINO-LARYNGOLOGY (2021)

Article Nutrition & Dietetics

The impact of school uniforms on primary school student's physical activity at school: outcomes of a cluster randomized controlled trial

Nicole Nathan, Nicole McCarthy, Kirsty Hope, Rachel Sutherland, Christophe Lecathelinais, Alix Hall, Cassandra Lane, Stewart Trost, Sze Lin Yoong, Luke Wolfenden

Summary: The study aimed to increase girls' physical activity by modifying student uniforms, but the results showed that the intervention had no significant impact on girls' moderate-to-vigorous physical activity and total physical activity. However, exploratory analysis revealed small improvements in some measures and further research is needed to determine the effectiveness of the intervention in larger samples.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF BEHAVIORAL NUTRITION AND PHYSICAL ACTIVITY (2021)

Review Health Care Sciences & Services

Associations Between Digital Health Intervention Engagement, Physical Activity, and Sedentary Behavior: Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

Matthew Mclaughlin, Tessa Delaney, Alix Hall, Judith Byaruhanga, Paul Mackie, Alice Grady, Kathryn Reilly, Elizabeth Campbell, Rachel Sutherland, John Wiggers, Luke Wolfenden

Summary: The study found a weak but consistent positive association between engagement with a physical activity digital health intervention and physical activity outcomes. No studies have targeted sedentary behavior outcomes. The findings were consistent across most constructs of engagement; however, the associations were weak.

JOURNAL OF MEDICAL INTERNET RESEARCH (2021)

Article Geriatrics & Gerontology

Participation in future planning by community-dwelling older Australians receiving aged care services: Findings from a cross-sectional survey

Jamie Bryant, Breanne Hobden, Amy Waller, Matthew Clapham, Robert Sanson-Fisher

Summary: One third of older people residing in the community have completed an ACD, with higher participation in financial planning than medical planning, especially in terms of wills and enduring power of attorney. The diagnosis of a life-limiting illness is most likely to prompt completion of an ACD.

AUSTRALASIAN JOURNAL ON AGEING (2021)

Letter Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Learnings from efforts to synthesise evidence on the COVID-19 incubation period

A. Hall, K. O'Brien, S. McCrabb, K. Kypri, S. Brown, M. Wilczynska, J. Wiggers, R. Wyse, C. Dalton, L. Wolfenden

PUBLIC HEALTH (2021)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

An exploratory analysis to identify behavior change techniques of implementation interventions associated with the implementation of healthy canteen policies

Sze Lin Yoong, Alix Hall, Fiona Stacey, Nicole Nathan, Kathryn Reilly, Tessa Delaney, Rachel Sutherland, Rebecca Hodder, Sharon Straus, Luke Wolfenden

Summary: This study conducted a secondary data analysis from three randomized controlled trials to examine the association between interventions targeting canteen managers and the implementation of a healthy canteen policy in schools, identifying unique behavior change techniques (BCTs) associated with the policy implementation.

TRANSLATIONAL BEHAVIORAL MEDICINE (2021)

Article Oncology

Referral and uptake of services by distressed callers to the Cancer Council Information and Support telephone service

Jo Taylor, Elizabeth A. Fradgley, Tara Clinton-McHarg, Alix Hall, Christine L. Paul

Summary: This study investigated the usage of services by distressed cancer patients and caregivers calling a cancer information and support service. The majority of patients and caregivers received referrals to various services, with the highest uptake for information materials and call-back services. Older age was associated with reduced uptake of services, suggesting a need for tailored support for this demographic.

ASIA-PACIFIC JOURNAL OF CLINICAL ONCOLOGY (2022)

Review Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

A Systematic Review of the Recent Consumption Levels of Sugar-Sweetened Beverages in Children and Adolescents From the World Health Organization Regions With High Dietary-Related Burden of Disease

Jia Ying Ooi, Luke Wolfenden, Rachel Sutherland, Nicole Nathan, Christopher Oldmeadow, Matthew Mclaughlin, Courtney Barnes, Alix Hall, Lana Vanderlee, Sze Lin Yoong

Summary: This review aimed to investigate national estimates of sugar-sweetened beverage (SSB) consumption in children and adolescents from countries burdened by dietary-related chronic illnesses. Analysis of 48 studies covering 51 countries found that while there is variability between countries, overall children and adolescents globally have high consumption of SSBs.

ASIA-PACIFIC JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH (2022)

Article Sport Sciences

Multi-strategy intervention increases school implementation and maintenance of a mandatory physical activity policy: outcomes of a cluster randomised controlled trial

Nicole Nathan, Alix Hall, Nicole McCarthy, Rachel Sutherland, John Wiggers, Adrian E. Bauman, Chris Rissel, Patt-Jean Naylor, Angie Cradock, Cassandra Lane, Kirsty Hope, Benjamin Elton, Adam Shoesmith, Christopher Oldmeadow, Penny Reeves, Karen Gillham, Bernadette Duggan, James Boyer, Christophe Lecathelinais, Luke Wolfenden

Summary: The study assessed a multi-strategy intervention's effectiveness in increasing structured physical activity implementation by teachers, with results showing a greater increase in implementation minutes among intervention group teachers at 12 and 18 months, although the effect size decreased slightly at 18 months.

BRITISH JOURNAL OF SPORTS MEDICINE (2022)

Review Health Care Sciences & Services

Barriers and facilitators influencing the sustainment of health behaviour interventions in schools and childcare services: a systematic review

Adam Shoesmith, Alix Hall, Luke Wolfenden, Rachel C. Shelton, Byron J. Powell, Hannah Brown, Sam McCrabb, Rachel Sutherland, Serene Yoong, Cassandra Lane, Debbie Booth, Nicole Nathan

Summary: This study focuses on factors influencing the sustainment of interventions in schools and childcare services, revealing that barriers and facilitators to sustain intervention were mostly similar across school and childcare settings, especially those related to the 'inner contextual factors' of the organization.

IMPLEMENTATION SCIENCE (2021)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Exploring the effect of a school-based cluster-randomised controlled trial to increase the scheduling of physical activity for primary school students on teachers' physical activity

Beatrice Murawski, Kathryn L. Reilly, Kirsty Hope, Alix E. Hall, Rachel L. Sutherland, Stewart G. Trost, Sze Lin Yoong, Nicole McCarthy, Christophe Lecathelinais, Luke Wolfenden, Nicole K. Nathan

Summary: The study found that supporting teachers with scheduling physical activities for students may affect their own physical activity levels. However, further fully powered studies are needed to better understand the impact of the intervention on teachers' physical activity.

HEALTH PROMOTION JOURNAL OF AUSTRALIA (2022)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Efficacy of a school-based physical activity and nutrition intervention on child weight status: Findings from a cluster randomized controlled trial

Courtney Barnes, Alix Hall, Nicole Nathan, Rachel Sutherland, Nicole McCarthy, Matthew Pettet, Alison Brown, Luke Wolfenden

Summary: This study evaluated the impact of physical activity and nutrition interventions on child weight status and quality of life, finding that the nutrition intervention led to higher odds of students being classified as underweight/healthy weight and the physical activity intervention resulted in a smaller waist circumference. However, these interventions did not significantly affect child BMI scores or quality of life. Future research is needed to assess the long-term impact of these interventions on child health.

PREVENTIVE MEDICINE (2021)

Article Environmental Sciences

Adaptation and Validation of the Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) for Use in the Elementary School Setting

Alix Hall, Adam Shoesmith, Rachel C. Shelton, Cassandra Lane, Luke Wolfenden, Nicole Nathan

Summary: The study aimed to adapt and evaluate the Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) for use in elementary school setting, but found mixed results in terms of adaptability and reliability. Further work is needed to develop and improve measures specific to public health program sustainment in elementary school settings.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH AND PUBLIC HEALTH (2021)

Article Geriatrics & Gerontology

Do health assessments affect time to permanent residential aged care admission for older women with and without dementia?

Julie Byles, Dominic Cavenagh, Jamie Bryant, Mariko Carey, Daniel Mazza, Rob Sanson-Fisher

Summary: The aim of this study was to investigate the effect of health assessments on permanent residential aged care admission for older Australian women with and without dementia. The results showed that women who had health assessments were less likely to be admitted to residential aged care in the short term (100 days), regardless of dementia status. However, there were no significant differences at 500- and 1000-days follow-up. At 2000-days follow-up, women who had a health assessment were more likely to be admitted to residential aged care, regardless of dementia status.

GERIATRICS & GERONTOLOGY INTERNATIONAL (2023)

Article Psychology, Social

Gaps in patient-centered follow-up cancer care: a cross sectional study

Breanne Hobden, Heidi Turon, Amy Waller, Mariko Carey, Anthony Proietto, Rob Sanson-Fisher

Summary: The study found that there is a gap between some aspects of optimal patient-centered care and the actual care received by oncology patients, especially in terms of the role of the GP and cancer recurrence symptoms.

JOURNAL OF PSYCHOSOCIAL ONCOLOGY (2021)

No Data Available