4.7 Article

Multi-functional assessment of soil health under Conservation Agriculture in Cambodia

Journal

SOIL & TILLAGE RESEARCH
Volume 194, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

ELSEVIER
DOI: 10.1016/j.still.2019.104349

Keywords

Soil biological functioning; Biofunctool (R); Annual cropping system; Soil Quality Index; In-field assessment; Red Oxisol

Categories

Funding

  1. French Agency for Development (AFD)
  2. National Council for Sustainable Development
  3. Cambodia Climate Change Alliance - Phase 2 (European Union/Sweden/UNDP)
  4. ACTAE project (Towards Agroecological Transition in South-East Asia)
  5. ACTAE
  6. American people through United States Agency for International Development Feed the Future Innovation Labs for Collaborative Research on Sustainable Intensification, Centre of Excellence on Sustainable Agricultural Intensification and Nutrition [AID-OAA-L-14-00006]
  7. French Global Environment Funds
  8. PAMPA, French Agency for Development, Ministry of Foreign affairs

Ask authors/readers for more resources

As a response to the worldwide challenge raised by soil degradation, Conservation Agriculture (CA) was proposed to help restoring the three main soil functions, i.e. carbon transformation, nutrient cycling and structure maintenance. However, there is still a lack of integrative studies that assess the overall impact of CA on soil health. To fill the gap, Biofunctooll (R), a set of in-field indicators, was developed to monitor changes in soil biological functioning. In this study, Biofunctool (R) was used to assess the impact of a conventional tillage (CT) and three CA annual-based cropping systems on soil health on a Cambodian Oxisol. Eight indicators related to the three soil functions were monitored and integrated into a Soil Quality index (SQI), i.e. the Biofunctool (R) Index. Overall, we found that soil health was twice higher under the CA treatments than under CT treatment. Although it was similar in the three CA treatments, the contribution of each soil function to the soil health diverged. An analysis of soil carbon dynamics also showed that CA support short-term soil organic carbon stabilization compared to CT. This study demonstrates that Biofunctool (R) is a robust, relevant, time-and cost-effective in-field assessment tool that can be used in multiple ways including cropping system management, capacity building of local stakeholders, and policy dialogue.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Environmental Sciences

Can no-till restore soil organic carbon to levels under natural vegetation in a subtropical and tropical Typic Quartzipisamment?

Ademir de Oliveira Ferreira, Joao Carlos de Moraes Sa, Rattan Lal, Telmo Jorge Carneiro Amado, Thiago Massao Inagaki, Clever Briedis, Florent Tivet

Summary: The study found that the adoption of no-till system along with intensive cropping and high carbon input is an effective strategy for organic carbon restoration in sandy soils.

LAND DEGRADATION & DEVELOPMENT (2021)

Article Ecology

Relationships between physico-chemical, biological and functional approaches for soil quality assessment. A case study along a gradient of disturbance

Pusanisa Heepngoen, Alexis Thoumazeau, Marie-Sophie Renevier, Kannika Sajjaphan, Frederic Gay, Alain Brauman

Summary: Assessing the impacts of land management on soil quality is crucial, with functional methods being more sensitive in reflecting the abiotic-biotic interactions of the soil system over a gradient of disturbance, compared to traditional physical, chemical, and biological parameters.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF SOIL BIOLOGY (2021)

Article Soil Science

Effects of conservation agriculture maize-based cropping systems on soil health and crop performance in New Caledonia

Remy Kulagowski, Alexis Thoumazeau, Audrey Leopold, Pascal Lienhard, Stephane Boulakia, Aurelie Metay, Tobias Sturm, Philippe Tixier, Alain Brauman, Bruno Fogliani, Florent Tivet

Summary: By assessing the relationships between soil health and cropping system performance in three maize-based cropping systems in New Caledonia, it was found that Conservation Agriculture (CA) can improve soil health and lead to increased productivity in maize crops.

SOIL & TILLAGE RESEARCH (2021)

Article Environmental Studies

Investigating farmers' decision-making in adoption of conservation agriculture in the Northwestern uplands of Cambodia

Rada Kong, Jean-Christophe Castella, Vuthy Suos, Vira Leng, Sovann Pat, Jean-Christophe Diepart, Raksmey Sen, Florent Tivet

Summary: In the Northwestern uplands of Cambodia, the commodification of agriculture in the 2000s led to the substitution of traditional cropping systems with monocropping of commercial crops, resulting in severe land degradation. The study revealed that farmers were still trapped in a boom-bust cycle with commercial crops, where market opportunities and short-term economic returns played a key role in decision-making, often overlooking environmental considerations.

LAND USE POLICY (2021)

Article Environmental Sciences

Rubber, rubber and rubber: How 75 years of successive rubber plantation rotations affect topsoil quality?

Phantip Panklang, Alexis Thoumazeau, Rawee Chiarawipa, Sayan Sdoodee, David Sebag, Frederic Gay, Philippe Thaler, Alain Brauman

Summary: The long-term cultivation of rubber has negative effects on soil quality, particularly on physico-chemical properties and carbon dynamics. Deforestation for rubber plantations leads to severe soil degradation. After three rotations of rubber cultivation, the soil quality is very low, emphasizing the need for more sustainable planting practices to limit these impacts.

LAND DEGRADATION & DEVELOPMENT (2022)

Article Agronomy

How 75 years of rubber monocropping affects soil fauna and nematodes as the bioindicators for soil biodiversity quality index

Phantip Panklang, Philippe Thaler, Alexis Thoumazeau, Rawee Chiarawipa, Sayan Sdoodee, Alain Brauman

Summary: The long-term impact of continuous rubber monocropping on soil biodiversity, specifically soil macrofauna and nematode diversity, was assessed in this study. The results showed negative effects on soil biodiversity, particularly in old age rubber plantations, indicating that a maximum of two rotations of rubber monocropping (around 50 years) may be the limit for soil biodiversity recovery.

ACTA AGRICULTURAE SCANDINAVICA SECTION B-SOIL AND PLANT SCIENCE (2022)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Enrichment in biodiversity and maturation of the soil food web under conservation agriculture is associated with suppression of rice-parasitic nematodes

Anne-Sophie Masson, Marie-Liesse Vermeire, Vira Leng, Marie Simonin, Florent Tivet, Hue Nguyen Thi, Caroline Brunel, Malyna Suong, Fidero Kuok, Lionel Moulin, Stephane Bellafiore

Summary: This study investigated the effects of conservation agriculture (CA) practices on plant-parasitic nematodes (PPNs) and rhizosphere microbial communities in a Cambodian field. The results demonstrated that CA practices significantly reduced the abundance of PPNs in the roots, improved soil quality, and enriched microbial communities in the rhizosphere.

AGRICULTURE ECOSYSTEMS & ENVIRONMENT (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Can C-budget of natural capital be restored through conservation agriculture in a tropical and subtropical environment?

Joao Carlos de Moraes Sa, Rattan Lal, Clever Briedis, Ademir de Oliveira Ferreira, Florent Tivet, Thiago Massao Inagaki, Daniel Ruiz Potma Goncalves, Lutecia Beatriz Canalli, Josiane Burkner dos Santos, Jucimare Romaniw

Summary: This study investigates the restoration of carbon (C) lost from natural capital by conversion to agricultural land through a no-till cropping system with high biomass-C input. The results show that the quantity, diversity, and frequency of biomass-C input play a critical role in recovering the natural capital. Particulate organic C and mineral associate organic C are indicators of C restoration through the no-till cropping system.

ENVIRONMENTAL POLLUTION (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Logging residues promote rapid restoration of soil health after clear-cutting of rubber plantations at two sites with contrasting soils in Africa

Thibaut Perron, Aymard Kouakou, Charlotte Simon, Louis Mareschal, Gay Frederic, Mouman Soumahoro, Daouda Kouassi, Nancy Rakotondrazafy, Bruno Rapidel, Jean-Paul Laclau, Alain Brauman

Summary: This study assessed the effects of clear-cutting on soil functions and their restoration after replanting rubber trees. Clear-cutting and land preparation significantly disturbed carbon transformation, nutrient cycling, and structure maintenance functions. However, carbon transformation and structure maintenance functions were fully restored within 12 to 18 months after the disturbance when logging residues were applied. No restoration of nutrient cycling was observed over the study period. A legume cover crop improved the restoration of carbon transformation. There was a strong relationship between soil macrofauna diversity and soil health.

SCIENCE OF THE TOTAL ENVIRONMENT (2022)

Editorial Material Soil Science

Soil priorities: Opportunities and challenges in Thailand

Suvannang Nopmanee, Hartmann Christian, Iwai Chuleemas Boonthai, Jaiarree Sathaporn, Daungkamol Kridsopon, Polsrakhu Payattika, Sukchan Somsak, Sapet Amonrat, Pierret Alain, Brauman Alain, Hammecker Claude, Robain Henri

GEODERMA REGIONAL (2022)

Article Agricultural Engineering

EFFECTS OF DIFFERENT MANAGEMENT METHODS FOR SUNN-HEMP COVER CROP ON CORN PRODUCTION IN A NO-TILL SYSTEM IN CAMBODIA

Lyhour Hin, Ted S. Kornecki, Manuel R. Reyes, Borarin Bunthong, Lyda Hok, Lytour Lor, Florent Tivet, Vira Leng, Vuthy Suos, Horace Clemmons

Summary: Conservation agriculture (CA) is becoming popular in Cambodia to maintain soil fertility, productivity, and profits, but the adoption remains slow due to limited local service engagement. A study compared different no-till seeders and residue retention methods for corn sowing, showing that the Brazilian seeder saved seed and time while improving plant population, diameter, and kernel characteristics. The combination of the Brazilian seeder and Cambodia-made crimper resulted in larger ears.

APPLIED ENGINEERING IN AGRICULTURE (2021)

Article Soil Science

Determination of soil water retention curves from thermal conductivity curves, texture, bulk density, and field capacity

Lin Liu, Yili Lu, Robert Horton, Tusheng Ren

Summary: A new approach is presented in this study to estimate the parameters of the soil water retention curve (SWRC). The new method accurately estimates SWRCs by using measured thermal conductivity-water content curves, soil texture, bulk density, and field capacity water content.

SOIL & TILLAGE RESEARCH (2024)

Article Soil Science

Impacts of long-term organic manure inputs on cultivated soils with various degradation degrees

Zhongshan Dai, Yong Zhang, Yujie Wei, Chongfa Cai

Summary: This study investigates the effects of erosion degradation and long-term manure fertilization on soil properties and crop yield in Northeast China. Results show that erosion degradation and manure fertilization have lasting impacts on soil physical structure throughout the soil profile, while their effects on soil nutrient properties are focused in shallow layers. Manure fertilization significantly improves soil functional index (ISI) and maize yield for degraded soils. Erosion degradation has a greater influence on ISI and maize yield than manure fertilization.

SOIL & TILLAGE RESEARCH (2024)

Article Soil Science

Organic substitutions enhanced soil carbon stabilization and reduced carbon footprint in a vegetable farm

Xintong Xu, Ruiyu Bi, Mengxin Song, Yubing Dong, Ying Jiao, Bingxue Wang, Zhengqin Xiong

Summary: The substitution of organic fertilizers for inorganic fertilizers has a significant impact on soil organic carbon (SOC) and can help combat soil degradation and climate change in intensive vegetable production.

SOIL & TILLAGE RESEARCH (2024)

Article Soil Science

Wind erosion after steppe conversion in Kazakhstan

Moritz Koza, Roger Funk, Julia Poehlitz, Christopher Conrad, Olga Shibistova, Tobias Meinel, Kanat Akshalov, Gerd Schmidt

Summary: Semi-arid regions in Central Asia are experiencing wind erosion due to steppe conversion and unsustainable farming practices. A study conducted in Kazakhstan used a mobile wind tunnel to assess soil erodibility under real conditions. The results showed significant differences in soil erosion based on initial conditions and mechanical stress, emphasizing the importance of proper soil management to prevent severe events.

SOIL & TILLAGE RESEARCH (2024)

Article Soil Science

Crop diversification increases soil extracellular enzyme activities under no tillage: A global meta-analysis

Tong Li, Guorui Li, Zhiqiang Lu, Deqiang Zhao, Yuze Li, Ziting Wang, Xiaoxia Wen, Yuncheng Liao

Summary: Conservation agriculture with three management principles is effective in mitigating soil erosion and nutrient loss. This study found that no tillage significantly increased soil extracellular enzyme activities, while legume incorporation only had a significant effect on phosphorus-acquiring enzymes. Crop diversity positively influenced the no tillage-induced increase in enzyme activities.

SOIL & TILLAGE RESEARCH (2024)

Article Soil Science

Assessing soil structural quality as an indicator of productivity under semi-arid climate

Zahra Khasi, Mohammad Sadegh Askari, Setareh Amanifar, Kamran Moravej

Summary: This research aims to evaluate the applicability of visual soil evaluation methods for agricultural systems in semi-arid regions and assess the relationship between soil physical quality and crop yield. The results indicate that visual evaluation methods can effectively assess soil conditions, and optimal soil structural quality is crucial for sustainable crop production.

SOIL & TILLAGE RESEARCH (2024)

Article Soil Science

Comparative analysis of rhizobial and bacterial communities in experimental cotton fields: Impacts of conventional and conservation soil management in the Texas High Plains

Amin Jannatul Ferdous, Xiaolin Wang, Katie Lewis, John Zak

Summary: Conservative agricultural management strategies can enhance crop productivity by altering soil microbiome, and incorporating legumes into cover crops in semi-arid regions can improve the dynamics of rhizobial communities. There is a strong underlying relationship between soil management and bacterial diversity in the soil.

SOIL & TILLAGE RESEARCH (2024)

Article Soil Science

The impact of paleoclimatic on the structural strength of loess paleosol sequences and its implications for tillage on the Loess Plateau: A case study from Luochuan profile

Haiman Wang, Wankui Ni, Haisong Liu, Kangze Yuan

Summary: This study investigates the structural strength of the Loess-Paleosol Sequence (LPS) and finds that the strength tends to increase with burial depth, with the loess layer weaker than the paleosol layer. The microstructure of the LPS also undergoes significant transformations with increased burial depth, transitioning from an overhead structure to a matrix structure. These findings highlight the importance of climate conditions on the structural strength of the LPS.

SOIL & TILLAGE RESEARCH (2024)

Article Soil Science

Change in phosphorus availability, fractions, and adsorption-desorption by 46-years of long-term nutrient management in an Alfisol of eastern India

Ranabir Chakraborty, V. K. Sharma, Debarup Das, D. R. Biswas, P. Mahapatra, D. K. Shahi, M. Barman, K. A. Chobhe, D. Chakraborty

Summary: This study aimed to evaluate the impact of long-term nutrient management practices on P fractions and P adsorption-desorption behaviour of an acid soil with a soybean-wheat cropping system. The findings revealed that amorphous Fe and Al, which play a significant role in P fixation, increased due to cultivation. The NPK+Lime treatment offered the most balanced approach, improving both crop yield and P uptake while effectively managing P dynamics in the soil. On the contrary, long-term application of NPK+FYM in an acid soil may result in faster P saturation of adsorption sites and increase the chances of leaching and eutrophication. Tailored P fertilization strategies should be developed to better utilize the PFe and PAl fractions and supplementing applied P.

SOIL & TILLAGE RESEARCH (2024)

Article Soil Science

Enhancing soil carbon and nitrogen through grassland conversion from degraded croplands in China: Assessing magnitudes and identifying key drivers of phosphorus reduction

Yuan Li, Ying Li, Qingping Zhang, Gang Xu, Guopeng Liang, Dong-Gill Kim, Carmen Rosa Carmona, Mei Yang, Jianming Xue, Yangzhou Xiang, Bin Yao, Yuying Shen

Summary: Agricultural intensification has led to severe degradation of croplands in China. Converting degraded croplands to grasslands can increase soil organic carbon and nitrogen content, but may decrease soil pH and available phosphorus. The duration of conversion and mean annual precipitation are major factors influencing soil changes.

SOIL & TILLAGE RESEARCH (2024)

Article Soil Science

A new method for disentangling the coupling effect of slaking and mechanical breakdown on aggregate stability: Validation on splash erosion

Xinliang Wu, Sixu Yao, Jinxing Zhou

Summary: The coupling effect of slaking and mechanical breakdown on aggregate stability was evaluated using a new method. This method can partition the unique and shared effects of these two breakdown mechanisms and showed better performance in predicting soil erosion compared to existing methods.

SOIL & TILLAGE RESEARCH (2024)

Article Soil Science

Impacts of the soil pore structure on infiltration characteristics at the profile scale in the red soil region

Xinni Ju, Lei Gao, Dongli She, Yuhua Jia, Zhe Pang, Yaji Wang

Summary: This study linked soil pore structures quantified by X-ray computed tomography (CT) scanning and infiltration processes traced using stable hydrogen and oxygen isotopes under different land uses in the red soil region of southern China. The results showed that soil pore characteristics mainly affected soil water transport, while other soil properties played more important roles in soil water retention. CT-based porosity and soil texture were considered crucial indicators in the evaluation of water exchange during infiltration processes.

SOIL & TILLAGE RESEARCH (2024)

Article Soil Science

Impact of drought on terrestrial ecosystem C-N-P stoichiometry and microbial nutrient limitation

Hongwei Xu, Qing Qu, Jiaping Yang, Zhen Wang, Minggang Wang, Rentao Liu, Sha Xue

Summary: This study systematically analyzed the effects of drought on terrestrial ecosystem C-N-P stoichiometry on a global scale. The results showed that drought significantly decreased the C:N ratio in soil, enzymes, shoots, and roots. Soil microbes were limited by N, whereas plants were restricted by P under drought stress. Drought intensity and duration were negatively correlated with shoot N:P and vector angle.

SOIL & TILLAGE RESEARCH (2024)

Article Soil Science

Short-term effects of subsoil management by strip-wise loosening and incorporation of organic material

Sara L. Bauke, Sabine J. Seidel, Miriam Athmann, Anne E. Berns, Melanie Braun, Martina I. Gocke, Julien Guigue, Timo Kautz, Ingrid Koegel-Knabner, Juliette Ohan, Matthias Rillig, Michael Schloter, Oliver Schmittmann, Stefanie Schulz, David Uhlig, Andrea Schnepf, Wulf Amelung

Summary: Agricultural production in Central Europe is increasingly affected by extreme drought events. This study found that incorporating organic matter, especially biowaste compost, into the subsoil significantly increased root growth and subsequently improved crop nutrient uptake, biomass, and grain yield. The incorporation of green waste compost had less pronounced effects.

SOIL & TILLAGE RESEARCH (2024)

Article Soil Science

Loss and conservation of soil organic carbon and nutrients in arid and semiarid China during aeolian dust emissions

Xi Chen, Xuesong Wang

Summary: Based on the application of the integrated wind erosion modeling system, this study comprehensively simulated the loss and conservation of nutrients during aeolian dust emissions in the arid and semiarid areas of China. The results showed a decreasing trend in nutrient losses over the past two decades, with the ecosystems playing a crucial role in preventing these losses. The prevention rates of different land cover types were generally high, indicating the effectiveness of conservation measures.

SOIL & TILLAGE RESEARCH (2024)