4.6 Article

Electronic monitoring in fisheries: Lessons from global experiences and future opportunities

Journal

FISH AND FISHERIES
Volume 21, Issue 1, Pages 162-189

Publisher

WILEY
DOI: 10.1111/faf.12425

Keywords

catch documentation; discard monitoring; electronic monitoring; fully documented fisheries; video-based monitoring

Categories

Funding

  1. European Union's Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme [633680]
  2. European Marine and Fisheries Fund
  3. H2020 Societal Challenges Programme [633680] Funding Source: H2020 Societal Challenges Programme

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Since the beginning of the 21st century, electronic monitoring (EM) has emerged as a cost-efficient supplement to existing catch monitoring programmes in fisheries. An EM system consists of various activity sensors and cameras positioned on vessels to remotely record fishing activity and catches. The first objective of this review was to describe the state of play of EM in fisheries worldwide and to present the insights gained on this technology based on 100 EM trials and 12 fully implemented programmes. Despite its advantages, and its global use for monitoring, progresses in implementation in some important fishing regions are slow. Within this context, the second objective was to discuss more specifically the European experiences gained through 16 trials. Findings show that the three major benefits of EM were as follows: (a) cost-efficiency, (b) the potential to provide more representative coverage of the fleet than any observer programme and (c) the enhanced registration of fishing activity and location. Electronic monitoring can incentivize better compliance and discard reduction, but the fishing managers and industry are often reluctant to its uptake. Improved understanding of the fisher's concerns, for example intrusion of privacy, liability and costs, and better exploration of EM benefits, for example increased traceability, sustainability claims and market access, may enhance implementation on a larger scale. In conclusion, EM as a monitoring tool embodies various solid strengths that are not diminished by its weaknesses. Electronic monitoring has the opportunity to be a powerful tool in the future monitoring of fisheries, particularly when integrated within existing monitoring programmes.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.6
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Seasonal depth distribution and thermal experience of the non-indigenous round goby Neogobius melanostomus in the Baltic Sea: implications to key trophic relations

Jane W. Behrens, Marie P. Ryberg, Heli Einberg, Redik Eschbaum, Ann-Britt Florin, Wlodzimierz Grygiel, Jens Peter Herrmann, Bastian Huwer, Karin Hussy, Elina Knospina, Kristiina Noomaa, Daniel Oesterwind, Patrick Polte, Szymon Smolinski, Didzis Ustups, Mikael van Deurs, Henn Ojaveer

Summary: The benthic round goby is an invasive species that can reach high densities in invaded waterbodies, significantly impacting native biota and habitats as well as coastal fishers. This species exhibits seasonal movements to different depths based on temperature preferences, with significant overlap with main prey but only moderate overlap with competitors. Further research is needed to quantify food web consequences and understand the complex trophic interactions associated with this invasion.

BIOLOGICAL INVASIONS (2022)

Article Fisheries

Fuel consumption of free-swimming school versus FAD strategies in tropical tuna purse seine fishing

Oihane C. Basurko, Gorka Gabina, Jon Lopez, Igor Granado, Hilario Murua, Jose A. Fernandes, Inigo Krug, Jon Ruiz, Zigor Uriondo

Summary: Different fishing strategies in tropical tuna purse seiners fleet, including FAD and FSC, have different carbon footprints. A study monitored energy consumption of a Spanish tuna purse seiner in the Indian Ocean and analyzed fuel use intensity of FAD vs. FSC fishing. FAD fishing is more fuel intensive but has higher success rates compared to FSC fishing.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2022)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Climate change-related changes in cephalopod biodiversity on the North East Atlantic Shelf

Daniel Oesterwind, Christopher J. Barrett, Anne F. Sell, Ismael Nunez-Riboni, Matthias Kloppmann, Uwe Piatkowski, Kai Wieland, Vladimir Laptikhovsky

Summary: Global studies suggest that cephalopods have benefited from climate change. However, in most areas, long-term cephalopod data sets specific to each species are lacking, making it difficult to analyze their response to environmental changes. Our study shows that by combining historical research with recent data sets, it is possible to fill this gap and describe long-term ecological changes. We observed significant changes in cephalopod biodiversity at the species level in the North Sea over the past 100 years.

BIODIVERSITY AND CONSERVATION (2022)

Article Fisheries

Multi-method approach shows stock structure in Loligo forbesii squid

Edel Sheerin, Leigh Barnwall, Esther Abad, Angela Larivain, Daniel Oesterwind, Michael Petroni, Catalina Perales-Raya, Jean-Paul Robin, Ignacio Sobrino, Julio Valeiras, Denise O'Meara, Graham J. Pierce, A. Louise Allcock, Anne Marie Power

Summary: Knowledge of stock structure is crucial for assessing commercially-fished cephalopods effectively. This study analyzed samples from various locations using mitochondrial and microsatellite markers, revealing that Loligo forbesii squid form distinguishable ecological groups over short timescales, with a semi-isolated breeding group at Rockall.

ICES JOURNAL OF MARINE SCIENCE (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Spatio-Temporal Distribution of Juvenile Oceanic Whitetip Shark Incidental Catch in the Western Indian Ocean

Leire Lopetegui-Eguren, Jan Jaap Poos, Haritz Arrizabalaga, Gency L. Guirhem, Hilario Murua, Nerea Lezama-Ochoa, Shane P. Griffiths, Jon Ruiz Gondra, Philippe S. Sabarros, Jose Carlos Baez, Maria Jose Juan-Jorda

Summary: The oceanic whitetip shark, currently classified as Critically Endangered, is often incidentally caught by fisheries targeting other species. This study analyzed observer data from the western Indian Ocean to understand the factors influencing the capture of this species. Sea surface temperature and nitrate concentration were found to be the most important variables predicting the probability of capturing an oceanic whitetip shark. The study also identified higher capture probabilities in fish aggregating devices compared to free schools of tuna.

FRONTIERS IN MARINE SCIENCE (2022)

Article Fisheries

Fishing tactics and the effect of resource depletion and interference during the exploitation of local patches of flatfish

A. D. Rijnsdorp, G. Aarts, N. T. Hintzen, J. C. van Rijssel, A. M. Winter, J. J. Poos

Summary: This study investigated the exploitation patterns of pulse trawl (PUL) and tickler chain beam trawl (TBT) fishers in harvesting flatfish populations. The results showed that both types of fishers concentrated their efforts in the core of the flatfish patches, using systematic fishing tactics. The catch rates in the core were higher than the background catch rates, but decreased over time due to resource depletion and interference, with interference having a larger impact on TBT fishers.

ICES JOURNAL OF MARINE SCIENCE (2022)

Article Fisheries

The fine-scale behavior of harbor porpoises towards pingers

Dennis Brennecke, Ursula Siebert, Lotte Kindt-Larsen, Henrik Skov Midtiby, Henrik Dyrberg Egemose, Sara Torres Ortiz, Katrin Knickmeier, Magnus Wahlberg

Summary: This study demonstrates that harbor porpoises exhibit strong avoidance behavior and reduced surfacing frequency in response to pinger sounds, indicating the effectiveness of pingers in reducing bycatch. However, there is also a diversity in behavioral responses, with some porpoises not reacting to pinger sounds at all. This suggests that pinger use should be carefully considered and alternative mitigation measures may need to be explored.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2022)

Article Marine & Freshwater Biology

A long-term view on recent changes in abundance of common skate complex in the North Sea

Roeland A. Bom, Aafke Brader, Jurgen Batsleer, Jan-Jaap Poos, Henk W. van der Veer, Anieke van Leeuwen

Summary: Populations of large fish in the North Sea have recently started to increase, possibly due to reduced fishing pressure. However, the recovery of these populations needs to be viewed in a long-term perspective. A study on the critically endangered common skate species complex found that its current abundance is still below historical levels and limited to the northern North Sea.

MARINE BIOLOGY (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Freshwater fish biodiversity restoration in floodplain rivers requires connectivity and habitat heterogeneity at multiple spatial scales

T. Stoffers, A. D. Buijse, G. W. Geerling, L. H. Jans, M. M. Schoor, J. J. Poos, J. A. J. Verreth, L. A. J. Nagelkerke

Summary: River restoration is crucial for combating biodiversity loss, but its efficacy depends on various environmental factors and spatial scales.

SCIENCE OF THE TOTAL ENVIRONMENT (2022)

Article Marine & Freshwater Biology

Cephalopods, a gap in the European Marine Strategy Framework Directive and their future integration

Bianca T. C. Bobowski, Anne Marie Power, Graham J. J. Pierce, Ana Moreno, Ane Iriondo, Julio Valeiras, Inna M. M. Sokolova, Daniel Oesterwind

Summary: In order to maintain or obtain good environmental status in the Northeast Atlantic and northern Mediterranean Sea, EU-MSFD was implemented in 2008. EU Member States are responsible for assessing the current state of their adjacent waters to ensure sustainable use of marine resources and healthy ecosystems. However, there are still gaps in the assessment of cephalopods and other important marine species.

MARINE BIOLOGY (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Emergent interactions in the management of multiple threats to the conservation of harbour porpoises

David Lusseau, Lotte Kindt-Larsen, Floris M. van Beest

Summary: Human activities at sea are becoming more complex, requiring adaptable management interventions to mitigate their cumulative effects on biodiversity conservation. Coastal cetaceans, particularly harbour porpoises, are threatened by bycatch and the indirect effects of repeated exposure to disturbances such as acoustic disturbances. The prevalence of pingers, used to mitigate bycatch, can affect both bycatch rate and the population consequences of noise disturbance. Understanding the physiological effects on reproductive decisions and behavioural responses to noise is crucial for evaluating the cumulative impacts of bycatch and its mitigations.

SCIENCE OF THE TOTAL ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Fisheries

Stock connectivity patterns and indications of sub-stock component structuring of cod in the Sound in the western Baltic Sea

Regitze B. C. Lundgreen, Anders Nielsen, Mikael van Deurs, Hans Jakob Olesen, Monica Mion, Stefanie Haase, Michele Casini, Uwe Krumme, Karin Huessy

Summary: Sustainable management of fish stocks requires understanding the stock structure and connectivity of habitats. Cod in the Sound in the western Baltic Sea display complex connectivity patterns with the neighbouring stock in Kattegat. Historical tagging data and contemporary growth data were used to assess the ecological connectivity between the Sound and Kattegat, revealing considerable connectivity during the spawning season. The findings emphasize the need for further examination of the stock structure of cod in the western Baltic and adjacent areas.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2023)

Article Fisheries

Avoiding grey seal depredation in the Baltic Sea while increasing catch rates of cod

Lotte Kindt-Larsen, Casper Willestofte Berg, Maria Hedgarde, Sara Konigson

Summary: This study investigates the catch rates of various cod pot designs for Baltic Sea with the aim of reducing the negative impact of seal populations on gillnet fisheries. The findings show that volume and soak time are positively correlated with catch rates, and round bottom-standing pots with a fish holding chamber, funnels, and 5 entrances have the highest catch rates. These findings are important for the development of cod pots that can be used in high seal density areas, reducing carbon emissions and minimizing bycatch of marine mammals and sea birds.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2023)

Article Marine & Freshwater Biology

Evidence of phenotypic plasticity in Alloteuthis media (Linnaeus, 1758) from morphological analyses on North Sea specimens and DNA barcoding of the genus Alloteuthis Wulker, 1920 across its latitudinal range

Edel Sheerin, Anne Marie Power, Daniel Oesterwind, David Haak, Esther Abad, Leigh Barnwall, Michael Petroni, Ignacio Sobrino, Julio Valeiras, A. Louise Allcock

Summary: DNA barcoding and morphometric analyses were used to identify different species of Alloteuthis in Guinea Bissau and along the Atlantic coast. The results showed the presence of A. africana, A. subulata, and A. media, with A. media having the northernmost distribution and being the only species identified from the Irish shelf and North Sea. The phenotypes of A. media varied substantially across its geographic range, which explains the difficulties in morphological identification and suggests the need for regional identification guides to support fisheries management.

MARINE BIOLOGY (2023)

Article Biology

Knowing the fishery to know the bycatch: bias-corrected estimates of harbour porpoise bycatch in gillnet fisheries

Lotte Kindt-Larsen, Gildas Glemarec, Casper W. Berg, Sara Konigson, Anne-Mette Kroner, Mathias Sogaard, David Lusseau

Summary: Incidental captures (bycatch) of harbour porpoise in European Union fisheries remain a significant threat to cetaceans. A long-term monitoring program in Denmark using electronic monitoring has provided detailed data on porpoise bycatch and gillnet fishing effort. The study highlights the importance of considering fishing characteristics in estimating bycatch rates and emphasizes the need for effective monitoring methods and mitigation techniques.

PROCEEDINGS OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY B-BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES (2023)

No Data Available