4.7 Article

Potassium isotope fractionation during magmatic differentiation of basalt to rhyolite

Journal

CHEMICAL GEOLOGY
Volume 525, Issue -, Pages 37-45

Publisher

ELSEVIER
DOI: 10.1016/j.chemgeo.2019.07.017

Keywords

Potassium Isotopes; MC-ICP-MS; Hekla; Magmatic differentiation; Isotope fractionation

Funding

  1. McDonnell Center for the Space Sciences
  2. UK National Environment Research Council (NERC)
  3. NERC [NE/R002134/1]
  4. NERC [NE/R002134/1] Funding Source: UKRI

Ask authors/readers for more resources

High-temperature equilibrium and kinetic stable isotope fractionation during partial melting, fractional crystallization, and other igneous differentiation processes has been observed in many isotope systems, but due to the relative nascence of high-precision analytical capabilities for K, it is still unclear whether igneous processes induce systematic and resolvable K isotope fractionation. In this study, we look to the natural laboratory of Hekla volcano in Iceland to investigate the behavior of K isotopes during magmatic differentiation of basalt to rhyolite. Using a novel MC-ICP-MS method, we analyzed 24 geochemically diverse samples from Hekla, including 7 basalts, 8 basaltic andesites, 3 andesites, 4 dacites, and 2 rhyolites, along with 2 additional samples from Burfell, Iceland, for comparison (1 basalt and 1 trachyte). We observed extremely limited variation of K-41/K-39 ratios throughout our suite of samples, which is not resolvable within the best current analytical uncertainty. The average value of all samples is delta K-41(NIST SRM3141a) = -0.46 +/- 0.07 parts per thousand (2sd). This value agrees with the Bulk Silicate Earth value previously defined by average global oceanic basalts in literature. The lack of variation throughout this suite of samples from a single volcano system indicates that K does not fractionate during magmatic differentiation (of basalt to rhyolite) through processes such as partial melting and fractional crystallization. This conclusion is important to the estimation of the Bulk Silicate Earth K isotope composition, to placing a more robust estimate on the composition bulk continental crust, and to fostering a better understanding of the behavior of K isotopes during differentiation of the terrestrial planets.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Experiments quantifying elemental and isotopic fractionations during evaporation of CAI-like melts in low-pressure hydrogen and in vacuum: Constraints on thermal processing of CAIs in the protoplanetary disk

Ruslan A. Mendybaev, Michiru Kamibayashi, Fang-Zhen Teng, Paul S. Savage, R. Bastian Georg, Frank M. Richter, Shogo Tachibana

Summary: Experimental results show that the evaporation rates and isotopic fractionation factors of magnesium and silicon remain consistent under vacuum and low-pressure hydrogen gas conditions. This suggests that the existing vacuum evaporation experimental database can be used to model evaporation under solar nebula conditions.

GEOCHIMICA ET COSMOCHIMICA ACTA (2021)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Early solar system aqueous activity: K isotope evidence from Allende

Yun Jiang, Piers Koefoed, Olga Pravdivtseva, Heng Chen, Chun-Hui Li, Fang Huang, Li-Ping Qin, Jia Liu, Kun Wang

Summary: The potassium isotopes can be used to distinguish primary and secondary processes in the solar nebula. Components in Allende carbonaceous chondrite, such as CAIs and chondrules, exhibit different K2O content and K isotope compositions, indicating alkali enrichment during metasomatism and aqueous processing. Most components in Allende have undergone aqueous alteration, as shown by their K isotopic compositions.

METEORITICS & PLANETARY SCIENCE (2021)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Potassium isotopic composition of various samples using a dual-path collision cell-capable multiple-collector inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometer, Nu instruments Sapphire

Frederic Moynier, Yan Hu, Kun Wang, Ye Zhao, Yvan Gerard, Zhengbin Deng, Julien Moureau, Weiqiang Li, Justin I. Simon, Fang-Zhen Teng

Summary: The Nu SapphireTM MC-ICP-MS is a high-precision instrument for measuring potassium isotopes, effectively addressing major isobaric interferences and providing high potassium sensitivity. The precision and accuracy of potassium isotopic data are influenced by several parameters, including total potassium concentration, matching of potassium intensities between sample and standard, and the presence of matrix elements.

CHEMICAL GEOLOGY (2021)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Silicon Isotope Analyses of Soil and Plant Reference Materials: An Inter-Comparison of Seven Laboratories

Camille Delvigne, Abel Guihou, Jan A. Schuessler, Paul Savage, Franck Poitrasson, Sebastian Fischer, Jade E. Hatton, Katharine R. Hendry, Germain Bayon, Emmanuel Ponzevera, Bastian Georg, Alisson Akerman, Oleg S. Pokrovsky, Jean-Dominique Meunier, Pierre Deschamps, Isabelle Basile-Doelsch

Summary: The use of silicon isotopes has led to significant advancements in understanding silicon cycling in various environments. This inter-laboratory comparison exercise provided soil and plant reference materials with organic material, resulting in excellent agreement among seven laboratories using different analytical setups. The data obtained will serve as valuable resources for future research on silicon isotopes.

GEOSTANDARDS AND GEOANALYTICAL RESEARCH (2021)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

A copper isotope investigation of methane cycling in Late Archaean sediments

Natalya A. Zavina-James, Aubrey L. Zerkle, Robert C. J. Steele, Matthew R. Warke, Gareth Izon, Paul S. Savage

Summary: The rise of oxygenic photosynthesis is considered the most important evolutionary step in Earth's history, but recent studies suggest that biological feedbacks also heavily influenced Earth's pre-oxidative atmosphere. Copper isotopes in Late Archaean rocks can potentially serve as biomarkers, providing valuable insights into the evolution of aerobic methane oxidation.

PRECAMBRIAN RESEARCH (2021)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

High temperature evaporation and isotopic fractionation of K and Cu

Mason Neuman, Astrid Holzheid, Katharina Lodders, Bruce Fegley, Bradley L. Jolliff, Piers Koefoed, Heng Chen, Kun Wang

Summary: The study conducted twenty heating experiments to investigate the behavior of K, Cu, and Zn evaporation and isotopic fractionation from basaltic melts at high temperatures. Results show that Zn is the most volatile element followed by Cu and K. However, partitioning of Zn into spinel layers affects the Zn isotope fractionation factor. Higher temperatures and lower oxygen fugacities promote evaporation, and the experimentally determined fractionation factors for K and Cu are significantly larger than the apparent observed fractionation factors from lunar basalts.

GEOCHIMICA ET COSMOCHIMICA ACTA (2022)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

High-Temperature Inter-Mineral Potassium Isotope Fractionation: Implications for K-Ca-Ar Chronology

W. Wilson Kuhnel, Stein B. Jacobsen, Yonghui Li, Yaray Ku, Michail Petaev, Shichun Huang, Zhongqing Wu, Kun Wang

Summary: Recent high-precision potassium isotopic analysis revealed significant inter-mineral K isotope fractionation in mineral separates from three well-preserved igneous rocks, as well as smaller but measurable fractionation between mineral-melt K isotopes. The results suggest isotopic disequilibrium due to kinetic processes and larger fractionations than calculated, indicating the potential impact on K-Ar and 40Ar-39Ar dating precision. Additionally, modeling of K isotopic fractionation during the formation of lunar anorthositic crust showed negligible effect on the K isotopic compositions, challenging the idea that the K isotopic difference between the Earth and the Moon is solely due to lunar magma ocean differentiation.

ACS EARTH AND SPACE CHEMISTRY (2021)

Article Spectroscopy

New Quartz and Zircon Si Isotopic Reference Materials for Precise and Accurate SIMS Isotopic Microanalysis

Yu Liu, Xian-Hua Li, Paul S. Savage, Guo-Qiang Tang, Qiu-Li Li, Hui-Min Yu, Fang Huang

Summary: This study reports on the Si isotope compositions of four potential reference materials for in-situ Si isotopic microanalysis. The results show that these materials are more homogeneous in Si isotopes compared to the commonly used quartz standard. The study also suggests that synthetic quartz glass can be used as an alternative, more homogeneous standard.

ATOMIC SPECTROSCOPY (2022)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Homogenising the upper continental crust: The Si isotope evolution of the crust recorded by ancient glacial diamictites

Madeleine E. Murphy, Paul S. Savage, Nicholas J. Gardiner, Anthony R. Prave, Richard M. Gaschnig, Roberta L. Rudnick

Summary: By analyzing the silicon isotope composition of glacial diamictites from different geological ages, researchers have established the long-term secular record of the compositional evolution of upper continental crust. The study shows that the variability of silicon isotopes in diamictites decreases over time, indicating the diminishing importance of glacially milled banded iron formation and tonalite-trondhjemite-granodiorites in post-Archaean continental crust. The research also suggests that the upper continental crust becomes increasingly homogeneous through atmospheric oxygenation and crustal reworking.

EARTH AND PLANETARY SCIENCE LETTERS (2022)

Article Astronomy & Astrophysics

Zinc isotope anomalies in primitive meteorites identify the outer solar system as an important source of Earth's volatile inventory

Paul S. Savage, Frederic Moynier, Maud Boyet

Summary: The source and timing of delivery of volatile elements to Earth are crucial for understanding the planet's evolution. Recent research suggests that primitive meteorites have provided insights into the isotopic anomalies of zinc from the terrestrial reservoir. The study shows that carbonaceous chondrites from the outer Solar System have distinct characteristics compared to other meteorites, and Earth falls in between these two components. Modeling based on these findings indicates that around 30% of Earth's zinc budget is derived from a small percentage of carbonaceous chondrite-like materials, with the remaining coming from other meteorites.

ICARUS (2022)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

The formation and aqueous alteration of CM2 chondrites and their relationship to CO3 chondrites: A fresh isotopic (O, Cd, Cr, Si, Te, Ti, and Zn) perspective from the Winchcombe CM2 fall

R. C. Greenwood, R. Findlay, R. Martins, R. C. J. Steele, K. M. M. Shaw, E. Morton, P. S. Savage, M. E. Murphy, M. Rehkamper, I. A. Franchi, T. Elliott, M. D. Suttle, A. J. King, M. Anand, J. Malley, K. T. Howard, X. Zhao, D. Johnson, M. -C. Liu, K. A. McCain, N. R. Stephen

Summary: In this study, whole rock isotopic measurements of O, Cd, Cr, Si, Te, Ti, and Zn were conducted on the Winchcombe CM2 meteorite. The results showed that the isotopic compositions of Winchcombe are consistent with published data for CM2s, indicating their correlation. Oxygen isotope analysis demonstrated extensive aqueous alteration in Winchcombe's parent body, supporting the hypothesis that the snow line is significant in planetesimal accretion.

METEORITICS & PLANETARY SCIENCE (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

A primary magmatic source of nitrogen to Earth's crust

Toby J. Boocock, Sami Mikhail, Adrian J. Boyce, Julie Prytulak, Paul S. Savage, Eva E. Stueken

Summary: Geochemical analyses of igneous rocks from the Hekla volcanic system in Iceland suggest that the formation of continental crust has trapped significant amounts of magmatic nitrogen over Earth's history. Identifying the sources of crustal nitrogen is important for accurately reconstructing Earth's atmospheric pressure and habitability over geologic timescales. The findings indicate that nitrogen in the continental crust is of magmatic origin and suggest that the degassing of nitrogen from Earth's interior to the atmosphere may have been previously overestimated.

NATURE GEOSCIENCE (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Eoarchean and Hadean melts reveal arc-like trace element and isotopic signatures

Wriju Chowdhury, Dustin Trail, Martha Miller, Paul Savage

Summary: Constraining the lithological diversity and tectonics of the earliest Earth is critical to understanding our planet's evolution. By analyzing the composition of Jack Hills zircon (3.7 - 4.2 Ga), we found that the parent melts of these zircons were influenced by the assimilation of terrigenous sediments, serpentinites, cherts, and silicified basalts, followed by igneous differentiation, leading to the formation of intermediate to felsic melts in the early Earth. Trace element measurements also show that the formational regime had an arc-like chemistry, implying the presence of mobile-lid tectonics in the Hadean. These findings indicate a lithologically diverse and chemically similar formational regime for Jack Hills zircons, depicting complicated geodynamics of the early Earth, which contradicts the currently proposed stagnant-lid model.

NATURE COMMUNICATIONS (2023)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Boron isotopes in Central American volcanics indicate a key role for the subducting oceanic crust

Stephen J. Turner, Mattison H. Barickman, Julian Rodriguez, David A. Fike, Clive M. Jones, Kun Wang, Ivan P. Savov, Samuele Agostini, Michael J. Krawczynski, Rita Parai

Summary: The geochemistry of arc magmas provides insight into the chemical outfluxes from subducting slabs. Boron (B) abundances and isotope ratios act as tracers of slab-derived components, with new measurements in Nicaraguan volcanic centers indicating a B-rich slab component primarily sourced from subducted altered oceanic crust (AOC) and minor input from subducted sediments. This finding suggests that the volatile element budget delivered to the volcanic arc is mostly derived from the ocean crust and that volatiles may be recycled into the deeper mantle beneath Central America.

EARTH AND PLANETARY SCIENCE LETTERS (2023)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Potassium isotope evidence for slab-derived fluids in the sub-arc mantle

Kun Wang, Dmitri A. Ionov

Summary: Subduction plays a major role in recycling water, volatiles, and incompatible elements into Earth's mantle, and the isotopic signatures of potassium (K) can be used as a new tracer in subduction events. A study on mantle harzburgite xenoliths from Avacha volcano in Kamchatka, Russia, shows that slab-derived fluids infiltrated the sub-arc mantle and can significantly fractionate K isotopes. This provides direct evidence for the impact of subduction dehydration and fluid percolation on K isotopes in the mantle lithosphere.

EARTH AND PLANETARY SCIENCE LETTERS (2023)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Metasomatized mantle source of nascent oceanic crust in the Guaymas Basin, Gulf of California

Zhen-Min Ge, Xiao-Long Huang, Wei Xie, Tobias W. Hofig, Fan Yang, Yang Yu, S. Khogenkumar Singh

Summary: The mantle source composition of the nascent oceanic crust in the central part of the Gulf of California has been investigated using basaltic glass samples. These samples show trace element patterns similar to enriched mid-ocean ridge basalts, suggesting that the nascent oceanic crust in the Guaymas Basin might be generated through partial melting of a depleted mantle source metasomatized by subducted slab materials.

CHEMICAL GEOLOGY (2024)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Effect of mineral growth rate on Zinc incorporation into calcite and aragonite

Jean-Michel Brazier, Katja E. Goetschl, Martin Dietzel, Vasileios Mavromatis

Summary: This study estimated the distribution coefficient of Zn2+ between calcite/aragonite and reactive fluids and found that the growth rate strongly influences D-Zn(2+) in both minerals. Additionally, a linear correlation was found between D-Zn(2+) and the saturation degree of the reactive fluid.

CHEMICAL GEOLOGY (2024)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Miocene olivine leucitites in southern Tibet: Implications for the recycling of carbonates into the mantle during continental subduction

Ming Lei, Michele Lustrino, Jifeng Xu, Zhiqiang Kang, Zhengfu Guo, Jianlin Chen

Summary: This study presents a comprehensive geochronological, mineralogical, and geochemical analysis of olivine leucitites in the Maiga area of southern Tibet, suggesting that these rocks originate from a carbonated peridotite mantle source and highlighting the possibility of carbonates being recycled deep into the mantle during continental subduction.

CHEMICAL GEOLOGY (2024)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Phosphate oxygen isotopes constrain Mesoproterozoic marine temperatures and the paucity of phosphorite

Yuntao Ye, Xiaomei Wang, Huajian Wang, Haifeng Fan, Zhigang Chen, Qingjun Guo, Ziteng Wang, Chaodong Wu, Donald E. Canfield, Shuichang Zhang

Summary: Phosphorus is an essential element for life and its cycle in the ocean is closely connected with the carbon and oxygen cycles. The study of phosphate oxygen isotopes can provide insights into various reactions related to phosphorus. By analyzing carbonate fluorapatite samples from the Mesoproterozoic Era in North China, it was found that the oxygen isotope values were lower compared to modern samples, indicating a warmer climate during that time period and a potential reason for the scarcity of phosphorite.

CHEMICAL GEOLOGY (2024)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Preservation of organic C and N isotope signatures from water column to sediments in the anoxic and ferruginous Pavin lake

Vincent Busigny, Oanez Lebeau, Didier Jezeduel, Carine Chaduteau, Sean Crowe, Magali Ader

Summary: This study conducted high-precision Mo isotope research on hydrothermal metal sulfides from a porphyry copper deposit in Southwest China and found that different stages of mineralization have distinct Mo isotope compositions, providing valuable insights into the behavior of Mo isotopes in magmatic-hydrothermal systems.

CHEMICAL GEOLOGY (2024)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Geochemical variations of anatectic melts in response to changes of P-T-H2O conditions: Implication for the relationship between dehydration and hydration melting in the Himalayan orogen

Min Ji, Xiao-Ying Gao, Yong-Fei Zheng, Bing Gong

Summary: The study examines the anatectic mechanisms in the Himalayan orogen, finding that pressure and temperature control the reaction, while water content mainly affects the solid-phase composition. Dehydration and hydration melting likely occur at different depths in the crust. This research provides important insights into the melting processes in collisional orogens.

CHEMICAL GEOLOGY (2024)