Understanding MODIS dark-target collection 5 and 6 aerosol data over China: Effect of surface type, aerosol loading and aerosol absorption

For regions where limited in-situ observations are available for use as a reference, such as in China, the understanding of how changes in the Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS) aerosol retrieval algorithm impact the data quality is limited. In this paper, the MODIS-Aqua Aerosol Optical Thickness (AOT) Collection 5 (C5) and 6 (C6) Dark-Target (DT) products are evaluated by comparison with similar products from the China Aerosol Remote Sensing NETwork (CARSNET) and the Aerosol Robotic Network (AERONET) in China for the year 2008. The validation data are analyzed for key factors affecting the results of the MODIS-DT aerosol retrieval algorithm, including surface type, aerosol loading and aerosol absorption. The impacts of the change from the C5 to the C6 versions of the MODIS AOT retrieval algorithm are discussed in detail. The main findings are: (1) The agreement from retrieval aspects between both MODIS C5/C6 and CARSNET-AERONET for most AOT values over distinct regions indicates that the conclusions obtained from C5 hold for C6; (2) MODIS-DT has an extended coverage (more retrievals) with good quality due to the change of upstream data (calibration, cloud masking, etc); (3) About 64% of the MODISDT C6 AOT data over China fall within the (+/- 0.15 AOT +/- 0.05) error envelope; (4) positive AOT differences between C6 and C5 over relatively dark surfaces and negative differences over relatively bright surfaces due to the change of surface parameterization have been observed; (5) the AOT difference between MODIS and CARSNET-AERONET relating to AOT loading is not significant, especially for large AOT; (6) MODIS-DT performs well for absorbing aerosol over relatively bright surfaces.