4.5 Article

Hypothesis awareness as a demand characteristic in laboratory-based eating behaviour research: An experimental study

Journal

APPETITE
Volume 141, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

ACADEMIC PRESS LTD- ELSEVIER SCIENCE LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.appet.2019.104318

Keywords

-

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Demand characteristics are thought to undermine the validity of psychological research, but the extent to which participant awareness of study hypotheses affects laboratory-measured eating behaviour studies has received limited attention. Participants (N = 84) attended two laboratory sessions in which food intake was measured. In session 1 baseline food intake was measured. In session 2 participants were allocated to either a 'hypothesis aware' or 'hypothesis unaware' condition. Participants were led to believe in the 'hypothesis aware' condition that they were expected to increase their food intake in session 2 relative to session 1. Participants in the 'hypothesis unaware' condition were not provided with hypothesis information. Contrary to our pre-registered predictions, the experimental manipulation of hypothesis awareness did not affect session 2 food intake. However, the manipulation was less effective than anticipated as some participants did not appear to believe the hypothesis information provided. Post-hoc exploratory analyses revealed that participants who believed the study hypothesis was that their food intake would increase in session 2 ate more in session 2 than participants who did not believe this was the study hypothesis. Further confirmatory research is required to understand the causal effect that participant awareness of study hypotheses has on laboratory measured eating behaviour.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Psychology, Clinical

Translation of Findings From Laboratory Studies of Food and Alcohol Intake into Behavior Change Interventions: The Experimental Medicine Approach

Matt Field, Paul Christiansen, Charlotte A. Hardman, Ashleigh Haynes, Andrew Jones, Allecia Reid, Eric Robinson

Summary: This article applies the experimental medicine framework to laboratory studies on food and alcohol intake, aiming to translate research findings into effective behavior change interventions in the real world. The article highlights systematic failures in the translation process and provides recommendations for improving the effectiveness of interventions. Consideration of the experimental medicine framework is crucial in ensuring promising interventions identified in laboratory studies can successfully translate into behavior change interventions.

HEALTH PSYCHOLOGY (2021)

Article Endocrinology & Metabolism

The mediating role of comorbid conditions in the association between type 2 diabetes and cognition: A cross-sectional observational study using the UK Biobank cohort

Victoria Whitelock, Femke Rutters, Judith J. M. Rijnhart, Arie Nouwen, Suzanne Higgs

Summary: This study aimed to examine the association between type 2 diabetes and cognition using the UK Biobank cohort, with comorbid conditions mediating the relationship. Participants with type 2 diabetes showed shorter digit span but no differences in other cognitive measures compared to those without diabetes. The association between type 2 diabetes and cognitive deficits is primarily mediated by macrovascular problems and depressive symptoms.

PSYCHONEUROENDOCRINOLOGY (2021)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Out of the lab and into the wild: The influence of portion size on food intake in laboratory vs. real-world settings

Thomas Gough, Ashleigh Haynes, Katie Clarke, Amy Hansell, Mahrukh Kaimkhani, Bethan Price, Araby Roberts, Charlotte A. Hardman, Eric Robinson

Summary: External influences on eating behavior, such as portion size, may have a greater impact on food intake in a real-world setting compared to a laboratory setting. Participants in their own homes experienced a larger effect of portion size on food intake and reported feeling more relaxed compared to consuming food in a laboratory. However, when comparing a semi-naturalistic laboratory setting to a standard laboratory setting, the effect of portion size on food intake did not differ significantly.

APPETITE (2021)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

Cancer symptom experience and help-seeking behaviour during the COVID-19 pandemic in the UK: a cross-sectional population survey

Harriet D. Quinn-Scoggins, Rebecca Cannings-John, Yvonne Moriarty, Victoria Whitelock, Katriina L. Whitaker, Detelina Grozeva, Jacqueline Hughes, Julia Townson, Kirstie Osborne, Mark Goddard, Grace M. McCutchan, Jo Waller, Michael Robling, Julie Hepburn, Graham Moore, Ardiana Gjini, Kate Brain

Summary: During the COVID-19 pandemic in the UK, many individuals avoided seeking healthcare services despite experiencing potential cancer symptoms. Barriers to seeking help included concerns about wasting the doctor's time, putting strain on healthcare services, and not wanting to make a fuss. Interviewees reported reluctance to contact GPs due to concerns about COVID-19 and fear of attending hospitals, and described putting their health concerns on hold.

BMJ OPEN (2021)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Prevalence and Correlates of Observed Sun Protection Behaviors Across Different Public Outdoor Settings in Melbourne, Australia

Ashleigh Haynes, Andrea Nathan, Clover Maitland, Helen Dixon, Anna Nicholson, Melanie Wakefield, Suzanne Dobbinson

Summary: The study found that females and older adults were better protected from sun exposure compared to males and adolescents. Physical activity was negatively associated with shade cover. Weather was more strongly correlated with sun protection at outdoor streets/cafes and parks/gardens, but actual usage of sun protection measures was low, highlighting the need for continued public education to promote routine use of sun protection during outdoor activities.

HEALTH EDUCATION & BEHAVIOR (2022)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Intentions to participate in cervical and colorectal cancer screening during the COVID-19 pandemic: A mixed-methods study

Rebecca Wilson, Harriet Quinn-Scoggins, Yvonne Moriarty, Jacqueline Hughes, Mark Goddard, Rebecca Cannings-John, Victoria Whitelock, Katriina L. Whitaker, Detelina Grozeva, Julia Townson, Kirstie Osborne, Stephanie Smits, Michael Robling, Julie Hepburn, Graham Moore, Ardiana Gjini, Kate Brain, Jo Waller

Summary: The COVID-19 pandemic disrupted cancer screening globally in 2020, potentially leading to changes in public attitudes towards screening. However, a study in the UK found that the majority still intended to participate in cervical and colorectal cancer screening following the first national lockdown. Previous non-participation was the strongest predictor of low intentions for screening, but as screening services recover, intentions to participate in future screening remain high and are strongly associated with previous engagement. Participants expressed concerns about visiting healthcare settings but were keen to participate once screening programmes resumed.

PREVENTIVE MEDICINE (2021)

Review Substance Abuse

Print and online textual news media coverage of UK low-risk drinking guidelines from 2014 to 2017: A review and thematic analysis

Inge Kersbergen, Penny Buykx, Alan Brennan, Jamie Brown, Susan Michie, John Holmes

Summary: This study investigated the scale and content of news media coverage of drinking guidelines in England and found that while the coverage was generally neutral and accurate, in-depth reporting often sought to discredit the guidelines using scientific and ethical arguments.

DRUG AND ALCOHOL REVIEW (2022)

Article Substance Abuse

Health-Oriented Marketing on Alcoholic Drinks: An Online Audit and Comparison of Nutrition Content of Australian Products

Ashleigh Haynes, Yan Jun Michelle Chen, Helen Dixon, Shannon Ng Krattli, Lisa Gu, Melanie Wakefield

Summary: This study systematically examined the prevalence of health-oriented marketing on alcohol products in the Australian market. The results showed that a majority of beer, cider, and ready-to-drink products featured health-oriented marketing, primarily through natural imagery or references to fruit ingredients. Nutrition information for alcohol products was found to be poor, and products with health-oriented marketing were lower in energy and alcohol content but still classified as full-strength alcohol on average. This suggests that health-oriented marketing on alcohol products in Australia may mislead consumers about product healthiness and detract from the perceived harm associated with alcohol consumption.

JOURNAL OF STUDIES ON ALCOHOL AND DRUGS (2022)

Article Substance Abuse

The Effect of Alcohol Packaging Size and Strength on UK Alcohol Consumers' Classification of Alcohol Products as Containing a Single or Multiple Drinks

Inge Kersbergen, Magdalena Opazo Breton, Matt Field, Petra Meier

Summary: This study investigates the characteristics of alcohol products that influence whether they are considered as single drinks or multiple drinks, and identifies the thresholds at which products are considered to contain multiple drinks. The results show that larger packaging sizes, bottled drinks, and higher alcohol content are more likely to be classified as containing multiple drinks. These thresholds are important for promoting more accurate monitoring of alcohol consumption.

PSYCHOLOGY OF ADDICTIVE BEHAVIORS (2022)

Article Substance Abuse

The health halo effect of 'low sugar' and related claims on alcoholic drinks: an online experiment with young women

Shuyan Cao, Changyuan Tang, Isla Carboon, Cassie Hayward, Hannah Capes, Yan Jun Michelle Chen, Emily Brennan, Helen Dixon, Melanie Wakefield, Ashleigh Haynes

Summary: Low sugar claims on alcoholic drinks can create a health halo effect, causing consumers to generalize the favorable attribute of low sugar to other health-related attributes. This may mislead consumers.

ALCOHOL AND ALCOHOLISM (2023)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Exploring changes in temporary abstinence in increasing and higher risk drinkers in England and Dry January participation in users of the Try Dry app in the UK between 2020 and 2021

Melissa Oldham, Inge Kersbergen, Sharon Cox, Jamie Brown, Richard Piper, Claire Garnett

Summary: The study shows that there is an increased proportion of higher risk drinkers attempting to reduce their alcohol consumption through temporary abstinence following the COVID-19 pandemic. Additionally, there is higher participation in Dry January among users of the official app in 2021 compared to 2020, with a slightly older age profile. This indicates increased engagement with temporary abstinence during the lockdowns in England and the UK, which is positive considering the overall increase in alcohol consumption during the pandemic.

BMC PUBLIC HEALTH (2022)

Article Health Policy & Services

Obesity prevention and related public health advertising versus competing commercial advertising expenditure in Australia

Ashleigh Haynes, Megan Bayly, Helen Dixon, Alison McAleese, Jane Martin, Yan Jun Michelle Chen, Melanie Wakefield

Summary: This study compares the advertising expenditure on public health campaigns with competing commercial categories and finds that the expenditure on public health campaigns is significantly lower. This highlights the need for increased funding and government regulation to rebalance the advertising ratio and support public health.

HEALTH PROMOTION INTERNATIONAL (2022)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Food purchasing practices in various retail settings and dietary intake: A cross-sectional survey of Australian adolescents

Yan Jun Michelle Chen, Ashleigh Haynes, Maree Scully, Claudia Gascoyne, Alison McAleese, Helen Dixon, Belinda Morley, Melanie Wakefield

Summary: This study examines the associations between food purchasing practices in various retail settings and dietary intake among Australian adolescents. The results showed that purchasing lunch from school or nearby outlets was associated with higher intake of discretionary food and sugary drinks and lower fruit and vegetable intake. Buying food or drinks on the school commute, outside school grounds during school hours, from supermarket checkouts, and using mobile phone apps were each associated with higher discretionary food and sugary drink intake.

HEALTH PROMOTION JOURNAL OF AUSTRALIA (2023)

Editorial Material Substance Abuse

Temporary abstinence challenges: What do we need to know?

Anna Butters, Inge Kersbergen, John Holmes, Matt Field

Summary: Participation in temporary abstinence challenges (TAC) is increasing, and it is associated with ongoing benefits such as reduced alcohol consumption. This paper identifies three research priorities regarding TACs. First, the role of temporary abstinence itself is unclear, and it is necessary to determine to what extent it contributes to changes in consumption. Second, little is known about the psychological changes underlying these changes in alcohol consumption. Third, it is important to establish for whom or in what circumstances participation in a TAC may result in unintended negative consequences. Focusing research in these areas would increase confidence in participation and enable effective long-term change.

DRUG AND ALCOHOL REVIEW (2023)

Correction Nutrition & Dietetics

With Appreciation(vol 117, pg 207, 2023)

Philip Calder, Alan L. Fernandes, Daniela Freitas, Edward A. Frongillo, Teresa Fung, Nina Rica Wium Geiker, William S. Harris, Ashleigh Haynes, Lindsay F. Holzapfel, Laura Katus, Marko Kerac, Jia Li, Kevin Maki, Bodo C. Melnik, Anne Marie Minihane, Michael Muller, Kristina S. Petersen, Sergio Polakof, Elliot O'Brian Smith, Meir Stampfer, Qi Sun, Miriam Vos, Shannon Whaley

AMERICAN JOURNAL OF CLINICAL NUTRITION (2023)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Food fussiness is associated with family environmental factors in 1-3-year-old children: A large-scale cross-sectional study

Hugues Piloquet, Benoit Berge, Pascal Maigret, Veronique Hospital

Summary: This study aimed to explore the effects of environmental factors on eating behavior and food intake in toddlers. The results showed that food fussiness was more common in older children, children conceived with medical assistance, children exposed to distractions during meals, rewarded by parents to finish meals, free to eat at will, and those who ate only occasionally with the whole family. Unsatisfactory dietary diversification was not significantly associated with any variable.

APPETITE (2024)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Fibre4life: Investigating older adults dietary fibre preferences and the role of targeted educational materials on modulating future dietary fibre intake

Victoria Norton, Julie A. Lovegrove, Marcus Tindall, Julia Rodriguez Garcia, Stella Lignou

Summary: The UK's aging population requires promotion of balanced nutrition, with a particular focus on increasing dietary fiber intake. Surveys involving older adults showed their willingness to learn about dietary fiber and the need for accessible information. Educational materials proved effective in engaging older adults and were perceived as useful. A holistic approach, involving support from various sources, can aid in improving dietary fiber consumption and overall health outcomes among older adults.

APPETITE (2024)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Reasons for meal termination, eating frequency, and typical meal context differ between persons with and without a spinal cord injury

Gary J. Farkas, Paige M. Cunningham, Alicia M. Sneij, John E. Hayes, Mark S. Nash, Arthur S. Berg, David R. Gater, Barbara J. Rolls

Summary: Overeating associated with neurogenic obesity after spinal cord injury (SCI) may be related to how persons with SCI experience satiation, their eating frequency, and the context in which they eat their meals. Those with SCI rely less on physiological satiation cues for meal termination and instead rely more on hedonic cues. There are differences in meal contexts and eating frequency between SCI individuals and controls, with SCI individuals consuming fewer meals but having a higher overall eating frequency due to increased snacking. These factors likely contribute to overeating associated with neurogenic obesity after SCI.

APPETITE (2024)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Sex-specific impulsivity, but not other facets of executive function, predicts fat and sugar intake two-years later amongst adolescents with a healthy weight: Findings from the ABCD study

Shana Adise, Kerri N. Boutelle, Panteha Hayati Rezvan, Eric Kan, Kyung E. Rhee, Michael I. Goran, Elizabeth R. Sowell

Summary: This study investigated the relationship between executive functions and cognition during adolescence, and the intake of fat and sugar two years later. The study found that higher impulsivity and reward-seeking behaviors were related to greater fat and sugar intake in males, while higher negative urgency and BMI were related to greater intake in both sexes. These findings suggest that individuals with certain traits may be more at risk for weight gain due to overconsumption of unhealthy foods.

APPETITE (2024)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Australian adults cooked more and tried new recipes during COVID-19 restrictions and lockdowns

Claire Margerison, Gozde Aydin, Christel Larsson, Alison Booth, Anthony Worsley, Janandani Nanayakkara

Summary: The COVID-19 pandemic and associated lockdowns resulted in changes in food accessibility and availability, leading to shifts in food habits and behaviors among people worldwide. A study conducted in Australia examined the self-reported changes in food habits and behaviors of adults during the COVID-19 restrictions in 2020. The majority of respondents reported developing positive food habits, such as trying new recipes, cooking from scratch, and reducing take-away meals. The study also found that family involvement in food preparation and eating together increased during the restrictions. However, there were negative experiences, including difficulties in purchasing certain foods and limited access to food outlets.

APPETITE (2024)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Differential effects of nutritive and non-nutritive sweet mouth rinsing on appetite in adults with obesity

Betsy Cogan, Jamie A. Cooper

Summary: This study aimed to assess the effect of dietary sweetness on appetite in adults with and without obesity. The results showed that the response of ghrelin to unsweetened rinses was energy-specific for all adults, while rinses containing sucralose led to greater cephalic phase cholecystokinin release in adults with a BMI between 18.5 and 24.9 kg/m(2).

APPETITE (2024)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Is being anti-vegan a distinct dietarian identity? An investigation with omnivores, vegans, and self-identified anti-vegans

Rebecca Gregson, Jared Piazza, Heather Shaw

Summary: Recent scholarship has identified a group of individuals who self-identify as anti-vegan, and they have distinct dietarian identities and ideological profiles. Anti-vegans show higher levels of commitment to their dietary patterns compared to omnivores, and they also score higher on various ideological measures.

APPETITE (2024)

Review Behavioral Sciences

How are overweight and obesity associated with reinforcement learning deficits? A systematic review

Gibson Weydmann, Patricia Maidana Miguel, Nour Hakim, Laurette Dube, Patricia Pelufo Silveira, Lisiane Bizarro

Summary: This study systematically reviewed the association between obesity and overweight with reinforcement learning performance. It was found that obesity might be associated with impairments in utilizing aversive outcomes to change behavior, but further research is needed to confirm this association.

APPETITE (2024)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Experiences of emotional eating in an Acceptance and Commitment Therapy based weight management intervention (SWiM): A qualitative study

Laura Kudlek, Rebecca A. Jones, Carly Hughes, Robbie Duschinsky, Andrew Hill, Rebecca Richards, Megan Thompson, Ann Vincent, Simon J. Griffin, Amy L. Ahern

Summary: This study explored how participants of an ACT-based weight management intervention (WMI) experience emotional eating and highlighted the importance of self-awareness and alternative coping strategies in improving emotional eating. It also emphasized the need for ongoing and personalized interventions to support individuals with external locus of control and complex emotional eating experiences.

APPETITE (2024)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Is it all due to peers? The influence of peers on children's snack purchase decisions

Stefanie C. Landwehr, Monika Hartmann

Summary: This study examines the influence of peers on children's snack purchasing decisions, finding that the presence of peers strongly impacts children's brand awareness and price perception, highlighting the crucial role of social influence in shaping children's decision-making processes.

APPETITE (2024)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Interactive effects of information and trust on consumer choices of organic food: Evidence from China

Rao Yuan, Shaosheng Jin, Wenchao Wu

Summary: This study examines the interactive effects of information and consumer trust on consumer preferences for organic food. The results show that consumers are willing to pay a higher price for organic food, especially those with higher levels of trust. The introduction of information significantly increases consumers' willingness to pay, with a greater increase observed among high-trust consumers.

APPETITE (2024)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Validation of the adult eating behavior questionnaire in a Norwegian sample of adolescents

Oda Bjorklund, Lars Wichstrom, Clare Llewellyn, Silje Steinsbekk

Summary: This study tests the psychometric properties of the Adult Eating Behavior Questionnaire (AEBQ) in a sample of 14-year-olds and examines its construct validity using the parent-reported Children's Eating Behavior Questionnaire (CEBQ). The results show that a 7-factor solution of the AEBQ without the Hunger scale is a better fitting model, and there are small-to-moderate correlations between the AEBQ and CEBQ scales.

APPETITE (2024)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Baby food pouches and Baby-Led Weaning: Associations with energy intake, eating behaviour and infant weight status

Alice M. Cox, Rachael W. Taylor, Jillian J. Haszard, Kathryn L. Beck, Pamela R. von Hurst, Cathryn A. Conlon, Lisa A. Te Morenga, Lisa Daniels, Jenny Mcarthur, Rebecca Paul, Neve H. McLean, Emily A. Jones, Ioanna Katiforis, Kimberley J. Brown, Madeline Gash, Madeleine Rowan, Elizabeth A. Fleming, Rosario Jupiterwala, Bailey R. Bruckner, Anne-Louise M. Heath

Summary: Although concerns are often raised about the potential impact of baby food pouch use and Baby-Led Weaning (BLW) on infant health, there is limited research in this area. This study found that frequent pouch use was associated with increased food fussiness and more selective eating, while BLW was associated with higher energy intake and a range of eating behaviors.

APPETITE (2024)

Article Behavioral Sciences

You eye what you eat: BMI, consumption patterns, and dieting status predict temporal attentional bias to food-associated images

Briana L. Kennedy, Andrew M. Camara, Dominic M. D. Tran

Summary: This study investigated the relationship between obesity, overconsumption, and oversensitivity to rewards, and how it affects attentional biases towards food-related stimuli. The results showed that individuals with higher BMI had lower attentional priority for food and food logos, while increased consumption of HFHS foods and dieting predicted increased attentional priority for food and food logo images.

APPETITE (2024)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Association between sensory reactivity and feeding problems in school-aged children: InProS Study

Irene Campos-Sanchez, Rocio Munoz-Sanchez, Eva-Maria Navarrete-Munoz, Maria Sofia Molina-Inigo, Miriam Hurtado-Pomares, Paula Fernandez-Pires, Alicia Sanchez-Perez, Daniel Prieto-Botella, Iris Juarez-Leal, Paula Peral-Gomez, Cristina Espinosa-Sempere, Desiree Valera-Gran

Summary: This study aimed to investigate the association between sensory reactivity and feeding problems in young children. The results showed that taste/smell sensitivity was significantly associated with difficulties in texture transition/introduction, limited variety of foods, and both feeding problems. Additionally, children with total sensory reactivity or auditory filtering sensory reactivity had a higher prevalence of consuming a limited variety of foods. These findings highlight the importance of considering sensory reactivity as a potential predictor of feeding problems.

APPETITE (2024)