4.6 Article

How to Select Balance Measures Sensitive to Parkinson's Disease from Body-Worn Inertial Sensors-Separating the Trees from the Forest

Journal

SENSORS
Volume 19, Issue 15, Pages -

Publisher

MDPI
DOI: 10.3390/s19153320

Keywords

feature selection; balance dysfunction; objective measures; Parkinson's disease; inertial measurement unit; wearable technology

Funding

  1. National Institutes of Health [R01AG006457]
  2. Department of Veterans Affairs Merit Award [5I01RX001075]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This study aimed to determine the most sensitive objective measures of balance dysfunction that differ between people with Parkinson's Disease (PD) and healthy controls. One-hundred and forty-four people with PD and 79 age-matched healthy controls wore eight inertial sensors while performing tasks to measure five domains of balance: standing posture (Sway), anticipatory postural adjustments (APAs), automatic postural responses (APRs), dynamic posture (Gait) and limits of stability (LOS). To reduce the initial 93 measures, we selected uncorrelated measures that were most sensitive to PD. After applying a threshold on the Standardized Mean Difference between PD and healthy controls, 44 measures remained; and after reducing highly correlated measures, 24 measures remained. The four most sensitive measures were from APAs and Gait domains. The random forest with 10-fold cross-validation on the remaining measures (n = 24) showed an accuracy to separate PD from healthy controls of 82.4%-identical to result for all measures. Measures from the most sensitive domains, APAs and Gait, were significantly correlated with the severity of disease and with patient-related outcomes. This method greatly reduced the objective measures of balance to the most sensitive for PD, while still capturing four of the five domains of balance.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.6
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Neurosciences

Dual-Task Costs of Quantitative Gait Parameters While Walking and Turning in People with Parkinson's Disease: Beyond Gait Speed

Rodrigo Vitorio, Naoya Hasegawa, Patricia Carlson-Kuhta, John G. Nutt, Fay B. Horak, Martina Mancini, Vrutangkumar V. Shah

Summary: This study aimed to identify the best measures to distinguish between individuals with Parkinson's disease and healthy individuals based on dual-task gait and turning costs. The findings suggest that people with Parkinson's disease rely more on executive-attentional resources to control arm swing, foot strike, and turning, but not gait speed. Arm range of motion was found to be the most discriminative measure of dual-task costs between Parkinson's disease patients and healthy individuals.

JOURNAL OF PARKINSONS DISEASE (2021)

Article Neurosciences

Does gait bout definition influence the ability to discriminate gait quality between people with and without multiple sclerosis during daily life?

Vrutangkumar V. Shah, James McNames, Graham Harker, Carolin Curtze, Patricia Carlson-Kuhta, Rebecca Spain, Mahmoud El-Gohary, Martina Mancini, Fay B. Horak

Summary: This study investigated the impact of different gait bout definitions on distinguishing walking quality between individuals with multiple sclerosis (MS) and healthy controls (HC) during daily life monitoring. The results showed that despite significant differences in total number of gait bouts across definitions, there was no difference in discriminating gait quality measures between MS and HC. Thus, gait quality measures in people with MS and controls can be compared across studies using different gait bout definitions with pause lengths ≤ 5 s.

GAIT & POSTURE (2021)

Article Neurosciences

Functional limits of stability and standing balance in people with Parkinson's disease with and without freezing of gait using wearable sensors

Naoya Hasegawa, Kas C. Maas, Vrutangkumar V. Shah, Patricia Carlson-Kuhta, John G. Nutt, Fay B. Horak, Tadayoshi Asaka, Martina Mancini

Summary: People with Parkinson's disease and freezing of gait have smaller functional limits of stability compared to non-freezers and healthy controls, indicating task-specific postural impairments. However, individuals with Parkinson's disease, with or without freezing of gait, have similar difficulties standing on an unstable surface compared to healthy controls.

GAIT & POSTURE (2021)

Article Engineering, Biomedical

Inertial Sensor Algorithms to Characterize Turning in Neurological Patients With Turn Hesitations

Vrutangkumar V. Shah, Carolin Curtze, Martina Mancini, Patricia Carlson-Kuhta, John G. Nutt, Christopher M. Gomez, Mahmoud El-Gohary, Fay B. Horak, James McNames

Summary: This study validated and determined the generalizability of algorithms designed for inertial sensors to detect turns in different directions and account for hesitations. The Discrete Turn Algorithm showed improved accuracy compared to previous algorithms, while the Merged Turn Algorithm was recommended for clinical tasks where single-turn angles are known. Specific metrics were proposed to capture turn hesitations in patients with movement disorders.

IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON BIOMEDICAL ENGINEERING (2021)

Article Clinical Neurology

Gait Variability in Spinocerebellar Ataxia Assessed Using Wearable Inertial Sensors

Vrutangkumar V. Shah, Roberto Rodriguez-Labrada, Fay B. Horak, James McNames, Hannah Casey, Kyra Hansson Floyd, Mahmoud El-Gohary, Jeremy D. Schmahmann, Liana S. Rosenthal, Susan Perlman, Luis Velazquez-Perez, Christopher M. Gomez

Summary: This study identified gait variability as the most discriminative feature of SCA, with measures like toe-out angle and double-support time variability showing high sensitivity and specificity. These variability measures were also correlated with disease severity, suggesting their potential utility as clinical trial outcome measures for both manifest and prodromal SCAs.

MOVEMENT DISORDERS (2021)

Article Neurosciences

Surrogates for rigidity and PIGD MDS-UPDRS subscores using wearable sensors

Delaram Safarpour, Marian L. Dale, Vrutangkumar V. Shah, Lauren Talman, Patricia Carlson-Kuhta, Fay B. Horak, Martina Mancini

Summary: This study explored the feasibility of using quantified data from wearable sensors as surrogate measures of MDS-UPDRS rigidity and PIGD subscores. Through both at-home and laboratory assessments of gait and balance, correlations between parameters such as number of walking bouts, turns, and postural sway with MDS-UPDRS subscores were identified. The results showed significant correlation between objective sensor data and clinical scores, paving the way for future larger studies evaluating the use of objective sensor data in supplementing remote MDS-UPDRS assessments.

GAIT & POSTURE (2022)

Article Chemistry, Analytical

Inertial Sensor Algorithm to Estimate Walk Distance

Vrutangkumar V. Shah, Carolin Curtze, Kristen Sowalsky, Ishu Arpan, Martina Mancini, Patricia Carlson-Kuhta, Mahmoud El-Gohary, Fay B. Horak, James McNames

Summary: This study developed an algorithm based on inertial sensors to estimate the total distance walked during a walking test, and tested the algorithm's validity and generalizability in two studies. The results showed that the algorithm accurately estimated the total distance walked and has potential clinical applications.

SENSORS (2022)

Article Chemistry, Analytical

Fall Prediction Based on Instrumented Measures of Gait and Turning in Daily Life in People with Multiple Sclerosis

Ishu Arpan, Vrutangkumar V. Shah, James McNames, Graham Harker, Patricia Carlson-Kuhta, Rebecca Spain, Mahmoud El-Gohary, Martina Mancini, Fay B. Horak

Summary: This study investigated the potential of passive monitoring of gait and turning in daily life to identify individuals with multiple sclerosis (PwMS) who are at risk of falls. The study found that objective monitoring of gait and turning can predict future falls, with the pitch at toe-off being the most significant predictor. This suggests that interventions aimed at improving muscle strength and range of motion may benefit individuals at risk of falls.

SENSORS (2022)

Article Clinical Neurology

Effect of Levodopa and Environmental Setting on Gait and Turning Digital Markers Related to Falls in People with Parkinson's Disease

Vrutangkumar V. Shah, James McNames, Patricia Carlson-Kuhta, John G. Nutt, Mahmoud El-Gohary, Kristen Sowalsky, Martina Mancini, Fay B. Horak

Summary: Using body-worn sensors, digital measures of turning were found to be better at discriminating fallers from non-fallers in people with Parkinson's disease, compared to gait measures. This difference was observed in the off medication state and during daily life.

MOVEMENT DISORDERS CLINICAL PRACTICE (2023)

Article Clinical Neurology

Should we use both clinical and mobility measures to identify fallers in Parkinson?s disease?

Rodrigo Vitorio, Martina Mancini, Patricia Carlson-Kuhta, Fay B. Horak, Vrutangkumar V. Shah

Summary: This study found that considering both clinical factors and objective balance and gait characteristics is important for distinguishing fallers from non-fallers in Parkinson's disease.

PARKINSONISM & RELATED DISORDERS (2023)

Article Chemistry, Analytical

Feasibility of a Novel Therapist-Assisted Feedback System for Gait Training in Parkinson's Disease

Carla Silva-Batista, Graham Harker, Rodrigo Vitorio, Fay B. Horak, Patricia Carlson-Kuhta, Sean Pearson, Jess VanDerwalker, Mahmoud El-Gohary, Martina Mancini

Summary: This study tested the feasibility of using a physical therapist assisted system (Mobility Rehab) with wearable sensors for one session of treadmill training in 10 people with Parkinson's disease (PD). The training significantly improved foot-strike angle, trunk coronal range-of-motion (RoM), and arm swing RoM during overground walking. Participants perceived moderate to excellent effects on their gait. One session of treadmill training with Mobility Rehab is feasible for people with mild-to-moderate PD.

SENSORS (2023)

Article Chemistry, Analytical

Opal Actigraphy (Activity and Sleep) Measures Compared to ActiGraph: A Validation Study

Vrutangkumar V. Shah, Barbara H. Brumbach, Sean Pearson, Paul Vasilyev, Edward King, Patricia Carlson-Kuhta, Martina Mancini, Fay B. Horak, Kristen Sowalsky, James McNames, Mahmoud El-Gohary

Summary: The aim of this study was to establish concurrent validity for the new Opal Actigraphy solution in relation to the widely used ActiGraph GT9X for measuring physical activity and sleep in daily life. The results showed that Opal Actigraphy demonstrated comparable performance to ActiGraph, supporting its use in research and clinical studies to quantify activity and monitor sleep patterns.

SENSORS (2023)

Article Clinical Neurology

Exploring mobility dysfunction in people with and without impaired cognition in Parkinson disease

Natalia Mariano Barboza, Martina Mancini, Suhaila Mahmoud Smaili, Fay B. Horak, Patricia Carlson-Kuhta, Rosie Morris, Laurie A. King

Summary: This study compared different aspects of gait and balance between individuals with Parkinson's disease who have normal cognition and those with impaired cognition. The results showed that dynamic balance during gait was more impaired in individuals with impaired cognition. No differences were found in other balance domains.

PARKINSONISM & RELATED DISORDERS (2023)

Article Clinical Neurology

Effects of a Cognitively Challenging Agility Boot Camp Program on Balance and Gait in People With Parkinson's Disease: Does Freezing of Gait Status Matter?

Vrutangkumar V. Shah, Rodrigo Vitorio, Naoya Hasegawa, Patricia Carlson-Kuhta, John G. Nutt, Laurie A. King, Martina Mancini, Fay B. Horak

Summary: This study revealed that individuals with and without freezing of gait in Parkinson's disease (PD) show improvements in gait performance after participating in the Agility Boot Camp with Cognitive Challenges (ABC-C) program. The program was effective in improving dual-task gait speed, arm range of motion, and other gait measures in both groups. However, balance performance did not improve. The results suggest that the ABC-C program can benefit individuals with PD, regardless of the presence of freezing of gait.

NEUROREHABILITATION AND NEURAL REPAIR (2022)

No Data Available