4.5 Article

A feasibility study to assess the individual and combined effects of financial incentives and monetary contingency contracts on physical activity

Journal

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE
Volume 44, Issue -, Pages 42-50

Publisher

ELSEVIER
DOI: 10.1016/j.psychsport.2019.04.021

Keywords

Behavioural economics; Behaviour change; Financial incentives; Money contingency contracts; Physical activity; Walking behaviour

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Objectives: To assess the feasibility, and demonstrate the preliminary relative efficacy of, individual and/or combined financial incentives interventions for physical activity. Design: Eighty participants were randomised to conditions receiving either: (i) a monetary contingency contract (where individuals deposit money, forfeited or returned depending on goal achievement) plus a standard financial incentive (simple reward upon achievement), (ii) a monetary contingency contract only, (iii) a standard incentive only, or controls groups (iv) with or (v) without a set behavioural goal. Feasibility was investigated through assessment of intervention acceptability, cost-effectiveness, study retention, contamination and missing data. The effects of the interventions on (i) physical activity (daily steps over 2-weeks) and (ii) potential mediators (e.g. intentions) were assessed also. Results: Indicators of feasibility were generally positive, with high acceptability ratings, low drop-out and low missing data. Participants receiving monetary contingency contracts plus standard financial incentives had (i) increased steps above controls (with some evidence of superiority over monetary contingency contract-only participants), (ii) the highest prevalence of goal achievement and cost-effectiveness (being between 57 and 317% cheaper per goal achiever versus other conditions) and (iii) larger deposits than contingency contract-only participants (with some evidence that higher deposits increased steps). There was evidence of contamination between participants, but the results were mostly robust after excluding 'contaminated' participants. No differences were observed on psychological mediators. Conclusion: This feasibility trial found promising results for a combined strategy approach to physical activity incentivisation, though a larger confirmatory trial is required.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Psychology, Clinical

Health Effects of Psychological Interventions for Worry and Rumination: A Meta-Analysis

Dane McCarrick, Andrew Prestwich, Arianna Prudenzi, Daryl B. O'Connor

Summary: Research suggests that psychological interventions can influence perseverative cognition. Medium-sized negative effects of perseverative cognition correspond with small but positive effects on health behaviors.

HEALTH PSYCHOLOGY (2021)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Do socio-structural factors moderate the effects of health cognitions on COVID-19 protection behaviours?

Benjamin Schuez, Mark Conner, Sarah Wilding, Rana Alhawtan, Andrew Prestwich, Paul Norman

Summary: Factors such as gender, ethnicity, and deprivation moderate the effects of health cognitions on COVID-19 protection behaviors, with intentions being less predictive of behavior in more deprived groups.

SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE (2021)

Review Psychology, Clinical

Stress and eating behaviours in healthy adults: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Deborah Hill, Mark Conner, Faye Clancy, Rachael Moss, Sarah Wilding, Matt Bristow, Daryl B. O'Connor

Summary: The meta-analysis found that stress has a small positive effect on overall food intake, with increased consumption of unhealthy foods and decreased consumption of healthy foods. Only one significant moderator (restraint on stress-unhealthy eating) was identified.

HEALTH PSYCHOLOGY REVIEW (2022)

Review Clinical Neurology

Group-based acceptance and commitment therapy interventions for improving general distress and work-related distress in healthcare professionals: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Arianna Prudenzi, Christopher D. Graham, Faye Clancy, Deborah Hill, Ruairi O'Driscoll, Fiona Day, Daryl B. O'Connor

Summary: This study found that Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) is effective in improving general distress and reducing work-related distress in healthcare professionals, with the number of treatment sessions being a moderator of intervention effectiveness.

JOURNAL OF AFFECTIVE DISORDERS (2021)

Article Psychology, Clinical

Goal Prioritization and Behavior Change: Evaluation of an Intervention for Multiple Health Behaviors

Mark Conner, Sarah Wilding, Andrew Prestwich, Russell Hutter, Robert Hurling, Frenk van Harreveld, Charles Abraham, Paschal Sheeran

Summary: The present research provides evidence that goal prioritization is an effective strategy for promoting health behavior change. Prioritizing one or two health behavior goals leads to significant behavior change without compromising the performance of nonprioritized behaviors.

HEALTH PSYCHOLOGY (2022)

Review Health Policy & Services

Co-production practice and future research priorities in United Kingdom-funded applied health research: a scoping review

Helen Smith, Luke Budworth, Chloe Grindey, Isabel Hague, Natalie Hamer, Roman Kislov, Peter van der Graaf, Joe Langley

Summary: This study systematically mapped recent literature on co-production in applied health research in the UK and provided suggestions for co-production practice and future research.

HEALTH RESEARCH POLICY AND SYSTEMS (2022)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Perseverative cognition and health behaviours: exploring the role of intentions and perceived behavioural control

Dane McCarrick, Andrew Prestwich, Daryl B. O'Connor

Summary: Objective worry and rumination are associated with health behaviors, particularly sleep quality. Intentions and perceived behavioral control mediate and moderate the relationship between worry and rumination and health behavior.

PSYCHOLOGY & HEALTH (2022)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

The role of perseverative cognition in the job strain-health outcome relationship

Dane McCarrick, Andrew Prestwich, Daryl B. O'Connor

Summary: Job strain is associated with adverse health outcomes, potentially due to maladaptive coping strategies. This study found that perseverative cognition, specifically rumination and worry, mediates the relationship between job strain and psychological health outcomes.

PSYCHOLOGY & HEALTH (2023)

Article Nursing

Critical care nursing workforce in crisis: A discussion paper examining contributing factors, the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic and potential solutions

Katharina Sophie Vogt, Ruth Simms-Ellis, Angela Grange, Megan Elizabeth Griffiths, Rebecca Coleman, Reema Harrison, Nathan Shearman, Claire Horsfield, Luke Budworth, Jayne Marran, Judith Johnson

Summary: This paper examines the problem of critical care nurses intending to leave their roles and the impact of poor wellbeing on healthcare systems. It suggests that evidence-based interventions focusing on resilience and organisational change can address the workforce crisis.

JOURNAL OF CLINICAL NURSING (2023)

Review Multidisciplinary Sciences

In-hospital stress and patient outcomes: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Daniel A. Ford, Luke B. Budworth, Rebecca Lawton, Elizabeth Teale, Daryl O'Connor

Summary: Hospital inpatients are exposed to high levels of stress during hospitalisation that may increase susceptibility to major adverse health events post-hospitalisation. This systematic review and meta-analysis found a small-to-medium association between in-hospital stress and patient outcomes, which was stronger for in-hospital versus post-hospital outcomes and subjective versus objective outcome measures. However, more high-quality, larger scale studies are needed to better understand the association.

PLOS ONE (2023)

Meeting Abstract Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

CAUSAL INFERENCE-INFORMED RE-ANALYSES OF FACTORS ASSOCIATED WITH DROPOUT FROM WEIGHT-LOSS PROGRAMMES FOR ADULTS

Ridda Ali, Andrew Prestwich, Jiaqi Ge, Georgia D. Tomova, Claire Griffiths, Mark S. Gilthorpe

JOURNAL OF EPIDEMIOLOGY AND COMMUNITY HEALTH (2022)

Article Medicine, Research & Experimental

Study protocol for the online adaptation and evaluation of the 'Reboot' (Recovery-boosting) coaching programme, to prepare critical care nurses for, and aid recovery after, stressful clinical events

K. S. Vogt, A. Grange, J. Johnson, J. Marran, L. Budworth, R. Coleman, R. Simms-Ellis

Summary: This study aims to assess the feasibility of delivering a psychological coaching program remotely and to preliminarily evaluate whether it can increase critical care nurses' confidence and resilience in coping with adverse events. The results will help determine if a remote version of the coaching program can be provided and evaluated, and will indicate its association with increased confidence, resilience, and well-being.

PILOT AND FEASIBILITY STUDIES (2022)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Cross-sectional and prospective associations between stress, perseverative cognition and health behaviours

Faye Clancy, Andrew Prestwich, Eamonn Ferguson, Daryl B. O'Connor

Summary: This study examines the associations between components of perseverative cognition and health behaviors. The results show that worry, brooding, and reflection are related to sleep and unhealthy snacking. Controlling for stress, the association between brooding and unhealthy snacking remains significant.

PSYCHOLOGY & HEALTH (2022)

Meeting Abstract Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

CAUSAL INFERENCE-INFORMED RE-ANALYSIS TO GAIN INSIGHTS INTO FACTORS ASSOCIATED WITH DROP-OUT FROM WEIGHT-LOSS PROGRAMMES

Ridda Ali, Andrew J. Prestwich, Jiaqi Ge, Mark S. Gilthorpe

JOURNAL OF EPIDEMIOLOGY AND COMMUNITY HEALTH (2021)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Defining the scope and content of mental health guidelines for community sport in Australia: A Delphi study

Caitlin Liddelow, Matthew J. Schweickle, Jordan T. Sutcliffe, Christian Swann, Richard Keegan, Simon Rice, Anthony Okely, Stewart A. Vella

Summary: Regular sport participation has physical and psychological health benefits, but some sport environments may contribute to the development of mental health disorders. To ensure psychologically safe sport environments for all participants, mental health guidelines for recreational sport are needed, and collaboration with experts is crucial.

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE (2024)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Does messaging matter? A registered report on appearance-versus health-based message framing in exercise appeals targeted towards women

Kimberly R. More, Curt More, Kayla A. Burd, Aikaterini Mentzou, L. Alison Phillips

Summary: This study aimed to investigate the prediction of psychological reactance through the matching of message framing and health message outcomes, and its impact on cognitive and behavioral outcomes related to exercise.

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE (2024)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Perfectionism and performance in sport: Exploring non-linear relationships with track and field athletes

Sanna M. Nordin-Bates, Daniel J. Madigan, Andrew P. Hill, Luke F. Olsson

Summary: This study explored the relationship between perfectionism and athletic performance and found a nonlinear relationship. In some cases, perfectionistic strivings may have both positive and negative effects on sport performance.

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE (2024)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

A psychosocial investigation of exercise preferences in real and virtual environments

Robyn L. Moffitt

Summary: These three studies examined exercise preferences in real-world and virtual environments and their relationship with social physique anxiety, social comparison, and self-presentational efficacy. The results showed that individuals who preferred exercising at home tended to have lower exercise behavior and more negative fitness-related social comparisons. Those with lower exercise behavior, negative social comparisons, lower self-presentational efficacy, or higher social physique anxiety were more likely to choose virtual reality exercise over real-world exercise. In a virtual reality exercise setting, individuals with higher social physique anxiety and more negative social comparisons preferred embodying a nonhuman and fantasy avatar. The findings suggest that individuals who value self-presentation and have low belief in their competence to project a positive image are more likely to prefer exercise contexts that minimize physique and fitness evaluations. Additionally, virtual reality may offer a less threatening environment for individuals who feel self-conscious or inferior during exercise.

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE (2024)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Golf skill learning: An external focus of attention enhances performance and motivation

Jongseong An, Gabriele Wulf

Summary: The study demonstrates that an external focus improves performance and learning of motor skills compared to an internal focus. Through a golf pitch shot experiment, it is found that external focus instructions enhance skill learning, increase positive affect, reduce negative affect, and improve self-efficacy. These findings support assumptions of the OPTIMAL theory and emphasize the attentional and motivational benefits of an external focus.

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE (2024)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Improving physical activity using a single personalized consequence-based approach-avoidance training: Effects on self-reported behaviors, attitudes, and choices

Silvio Maltagliati, Philippe Sarrazin, Dominique Muller, Layan Fessler, Thibaud Ferry, Reinout W. Wiers, Boris Cheval

Summary: This study examined the effects of a personalized consequence-based approach-avoidance training (ABC training) on physical activity (PA). The results showed that although the ABC training did not significantly improve PA, it had positive effects on choices and automatic attitudes, suggesting that this intervention still has potential. Further research with intensive training and device-based measures of PA is needed.

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE (2024)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Dual career (DC) experiences of Korean elite judokas before and at university

Hee Jung Hong, Seung Han Hong

Summary: The present study explores the experiences of Korean elite judokas in managing dual career during their pre-university years, at university, and in preparation for the transition to post-university life. The study focuses on a particular case, utilizing interviews and thematic analysis to identify key themes. It discusses the unique challenges and barriers faced by Korean judokas in their career development and highlights the importance of sociocultural context in their experiences.

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE (2024)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

A moderated mediation analysis on the influence of social support and cognitive flexibility in predicting mental wellbeing in elite sport

R. M. Davies, M. A. Knoll, M. N. Kyranides

Summary: This study aimed to examine the mechanism by which social support influences mental wellbeing, using cognitive flexibility as a mediator, and analyzing the consistency of this pathway between elite athletes, retired athletes, and non-athletes. The results showed a significant indirect effect from social support to mental wellbeing through cognitive flexibility, but the effectiveness of cognitive flexibility interventions may be less significant for elite athletes compared to other groups.

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE (2024)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Wellbeing in high-performance swimming: A grounded theory study

Katie S. Uzzell, Camilla. J. Knight, Kurtis Pankow, Denise M. Hill

Summary: The demands of elite sport have the potential to negatively impact athletes' wellbeing. However, not all athletes are affected in the same way. This study used grounded theory methodology to examine the processes of change in high-performance swimmers' wellbeing. The findings illustrate how a dominant performance narrative influences the development and maintenance of an exclusive swimmer identity tied to performance. Transitions were identified as critical points where wellbeing is likely to be affected, but proactive coping strategies and appropriate support can help minimize the impact.

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE (2024)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Peer and parent influences on youth skateboarding and factors that affect their decision to return to the sport after injury

Barbara A. Morrongiello, Mackenzie Seasons, Emillie Erum, Emilie Arbour

Summary: Despite the high risk of injuries, skateboarding is increasingly popular among youth. The study found that youth value the psychological well-being, companionship, and sense of community that comes from sharing this activity with peers. They are motivated to return to the sport even after serious injury.

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE (2024)

Review Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Martial arts, combat sports, and mental health in adults: A systematic review

Simone Ciaccioni, Oscar Castro, Fatimah Bahrami, Phillip D. Tomporowski, Laura Capranica, Stuart J. H. Biddle, Ineke Vergeer, Caterina Pesce

Summary: This systematic review examined the relationship between martial arts and combat sports training and the mental health of adult practitioners. The findings suggest inconclusive associations between martial arts and combat sports practice and self-related constructs, limited evidence of significant associations with sub-domains of ill-being and well-being, and consistent evidence of positive association with perceptual and inhibition abilities. However, the evidence on attention, memory, and the negative associations of boxing with changes in brain structure integrity was limited and inconclusive. The multifaceted nature of martial arts and combat sports may produce different outcomes on mental health, and factors such as activity exposure, expertise, level of competitive engagement, sex, and type of practice may moderate these effects. Further research is needed to enhance theoretical and practical approaches in this field.

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE (2024)

Review Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Professional development of sport psychology practitioners: From systematic review to a model of development

Janaina Lima Fogaca, Alessandro Quartiroli, Christopher R. D. Wagstaff

Summary: This article systematically reviews the professional development of sport psychology practitioners (SPPs) and creates a process model of professional development. Through reflexive thematic analysis, the researchers identify four developmental phases, four facilitating processes, and nine developmental elements. This model has potential contributions to future research, supervision, and training programs.

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE (2024)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Automatic processes moderate the association between reflective processes and movement behavior: A cross-sectional study

Andressa de Oliveira Araujo, Gledson Tavares Amorim Oliveira, Felipe de Oliveira Matos, Fivia de Araujo Lopes, Rodrigo Alberto Vieira Browne, Hassan Mohamed Elsangedy

Summary: This study investigated the influence of reflective and automatic processes on physical activity and sedentary behavior, and found direct associations and moderating effects between the two. The findings underline the importance of considering the interplay between reflective and automatic processes in shaping movement behavior.

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE (2024)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Investigating the day-level associations between affective variability and physical activity using ecological momentary assessment

Bridgette Do, Donald Hedeker, Wei-Lin Wang, Tyler B. Mason, Britni R. Belcher, Kimberly A. Miller, Alexander J. Rothman, Stephen S. Intille, Genevieve F. Dunton

Summary: There is an association between affective variability and daily physical activity levels, with individuals experiencing greater fluctuations in affect engaging in more physical activity on the same day.

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE (2024)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Effects of task difficulty on performance and event-related bradycardia during preparation for action

Jennifer Henderson, Maria Kavussanu, Germano Gallicchio, Christopher Ring

Summary: This study examines the relationship between heart rate changes and golf putting performance, finding that task difficulty affects heart rate deceleration characteristics and correlates with task performance.

PSYCHOLOGY OF SPORT AND EXERCISE (2024)