4.7 Article

Squeezing through the Now-or-Never bottleneck: Reconnecting language processing, acquisition, change, and structure

Journal

BEHAVIORAL AND BRAIN SCIENCES
Volume 39, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

CAMBRIDGE UNIV PRESS
DOI: 10.1017/S0140525X15001235

Keywords

-

Ask authors/readers for more resources

If human language must be squeezed through a narrow cognitive bottleneck, what are the implications for language processing, acquisition, change, and structure? In our target article, we suggested that the implications are far-reaching and form the basis of an integrated account of many apparently unconnected aspects of language and language processing, as well as suggesting revision of many existing theoretical accounts. With some exceptions, commentators were generally supportive both of the existence of the bottleneck and its potential implications. Many commentators suggested additional theoretical and linguistic nuances and extensions, links with prior work, and relevant computational and neuroscientific considerations; some argued for related but distinct viewpoints; a few, though, felt traditional perspectives were being abandoned too readily. Our response attempts to build on the many suggestions raised by the commentators and to engage constructively with challenges to our approach.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Review Behavioral Sciences

Is there such a thing as a 'good statistical learner'?

Louisa Bogaerts, Noam Siegelman, Morten H. Christiansen, Ram Frost

Summary: Research on individual differences in learning statistical structure suggests the existence of variability in cognitive abilities, but the hypothesis of a general statistical learning capacity that can classify individuals as 'good' or 'bad' learners lacks strong evidence. An alternative perspective focusing on the variability of statistical environments within different cognitive domains has been proposed, leading to a different outlook on statistical learning research when considering learning tuned to real-world sensory inputs.

TRENDS IN COGNITIVE SCIENCES (2022)

Article Psychology, Multidisciplinary

Toward a Comparative Approach to Language Acquisition

Morten H. Christiansen, Pablo Contreras Kallens, Fabio Trecca

Summary: This article emphasizes the importance of conducting systematic comparisons between different languages in order to gain a better understanding of the mechanisms and processes involved in children's acquisition of their native language, offering new insights.

CURRENT DIRECTIONS IN PSYCHOLOGICAL SCIENCE (2022)

Article Psychology, Experimental

Statistically Based Chunking of Nonadjacent Dependencies

Erin S. Isbilen, Rebecca L. A. Frost, Padraic Monaghan, Morten H. Christiansen

Summary: This article investigates how individuals learn and generalize complex regularities in the environment, and shows how language learning and generalization are embedded in broader cognitive theories. The results suggest that participants are able to chunk nonadjacent dependencies and rapidly generalize this information to novel structures.

JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY-GENERAL (2022)

Article Psychology, Experimental

Quantifying Interdisciplinarity in Cognitive Science and Beyond

Pablo Contreras Kallens, Rick Dale, Morten H. Christiansen

Summary: This article emphasizes the need for a renewed understanding of interdisciplinary collaboration and introduces an information-theoretic measure to assess interdisciplinary work. The results suggest that cognitive science journals exhibit more mixed expertise compared to journals focusing on specific topics. The article argues that the perception of diminishing interdisciplinarity may be attributed to the emergence of different theoretical perspectives.

TOPICS IN COGNITIVE SCIENCE (2022)

Article Psychology, Developmental

We need a comparative approach to language acquisition: A commentary on Kidd and Garcia (2022)

Morten H. Christiansen, Pablo Contreras Kallens, Fabio Trecca

Summary: The study by Kidd and Garcia is long overdue as it highlights the lack of typological diversity in studies of language acquisition and emphasizes the urgency of more research on understudied languages. It argues for a systematic comparative approach to language acquisition, which can still benefit from investigations of well-studied languages.

FIRST LANGUAGE (2022)

Article Psychology, Experimental

Individual differences in artificial and natural language statistical learning

Erin S. Isbilen, Stewart M. McCauley, Morten H. Christiansen

Summary: Statistical learning is considered a cornerstone of cognition, but its relationship with natural language remains inconclusive. This study explored the link between statistical learning and language acquisition, finding a positive correlation between the ability to learn artificial language and sensitivity to certain structures in natural language.

COGNITION (2022)

Article Psychology, Experimental

Statistical Learning of Language: A Meta-Analysis Into 25 Years of Research

Erin S. Isbilen, Morten H. Christiansen

Summary: Statistical learning is crucial in language acquisition, but its consistency across different language properties is unclear. Infants show robust learning across stimuli, while adults have larger learning effects when multiple cues are present. However, significant publication bias and methodological factors affect the research outcomes.

COGNITIVE SCIENCE (2022)

Article Psychology, Experimental

Quantifying the Interplay of Conversational Devices in Building Mutual Understanding

Christina Dideriksen, Morten H. Christiansen, Kristian Tylen, Mark Dingemanse, Riccardo Fusaroli

Summary: Humans effortlessly engage in conversation and decision-making, but the study of the conversational devices that facilitate mutual understanding is limited. This research presents a comprehensive conceptual framework for investigating conversational devices and their adaptation to contextual demands. Two corpus studies were conducted to examine three conversational devices - backchannels, repair, and linguistic entrainment – and found that they adaptively adjust to the need for precision in different types of conversations. Task-oriented conversations displayed higher complementarity and less frequent but richer lexical and syntactic entrainment. The use of these conversational devices was observed to be potentially adaptive, as interlocutors who exhibited stronger linguistic complementarity performed better in tasks.

JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY-GENERAL (2023)

Article Psychology, Educational

Infant-directed speech does not always involve exaggerated vowel distinctions: Evidence from Danish

Christopher Cox, Christina Dideriksen, Tamar Keren-Portnoy, Andreas Roepstorff, Morten H. H. Christiansen, Riccardo Fusaroli

Summary: This study compares the acoustic properties of Danish caregivers' spontaneous speech to infants (IDS) and adults (ADS). The results show that Danish IDS conforms to cross-linguistic prosodic patterns, with higher pitch, greater pitch variability, and slower articulation rate than ADS. However, vocalic properties of Danish IDS, including reduced vowel space, higher within-vowel variability, raised formants, and lower vowel discriminability, differ from ADS. These findings suggest the need for future research to compare languages with different phonological systems.

CHILD DEVELOPMENT (2023)

Article Psychology, Experimental

Large Language Models Demonstrate the Potential of Statistical Learning in Language

Pablo Contreras Kallens, Ross Deans Kristensen-McLachlan, Morten H. Christiansen

Summary: To what extent can language be acquired solely from linguistic input? This question has puzzled scholars for thousands of years and remains a major topic of debate in cognitive science of language. The complexity of human language has hindered progress in studying it, especially in computational modeling, which has only been able to address small portions of our linguistic abilities. However, with the emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs), which are deep learning architectures trained on vast amounts of natural language data, there are now computational tools that can be utilized to empirically determine the extent to which human language abilities can be acquired from linguistic experience. Despite their semantic and pragmatic limitations, LLMs have already demonstrated that grammatically complex language similar to human language can be acquired without the need for an innate grammar. Therefore, while there is still much to explore in how humans acquire and use language, LLMs provide comprehensive computational models for cognitive scientists to empirically evaluate the power of statistical learning in explaining the full complexity of human language.

COGNITIVE SCIENCE (2023)

Article Psychology, Experimental

The Dynamic Interplay of Kinetic and Linguistic Coordination in Danish and Norwegian Conversation

James P. P. Trujillo, Christina Dideriksen, Kristian Tylen, Morten H. H. Christiansen, Riccardo Fusaroli

Summary: This study analyzes data from two language corpora and assesses the coordination between language and motion. It found that low-level linguistic (lexical) entrainment is positively associated with motion entrainment, while high-level linguistic (semantic) entrainment is negatively associated with motion entrainment. This suggests a dynamic coordination of similarity and complementarity between language and motion in conversation.

COGNITIVE SCIENCE (2023)

Article Psychology, Experimental

Measuring Cognitive Abilities in the Wild: Validating a Population-Scale Game-Based Cognitive Assessment

Mads Kock Pedersen, Carlos Mauricio Castano Diaz, Qian Janice Wang, Mario Alejandro Alba-Marrugo, Ali Amidi, Rajiv V. Basaiawmoit, Carsten Bergenholtz, Morten H. Christiansen, Miroslav Gajdacz, Ralph Hertwig, Byurakn Ishkhanyan, Kim Klyver, Nicolai Ladegaard, Kim Mathiasen, Christine Parsons, Janet Rafner, Anders R. Villadsen, Mikkel Wallentin, Blanka Zana, Jacob F. Sherson

Summary: Rapid individual cognitive phenotyping has the potential to revolutionize personalized learning, employment practices, and precision psychiatry. A game-based tool called Skill Lab was developed to assess cognitive abilities while providing an engaging narrative. Using a citizen science platform, a comprehensive validation was conducted, and reliable models were constructed to predict eight cognitive abilities based on in-game behavior. The results demonstrate the feasibility of rapid in-the-wild assessment of cognitive abilities and its potential for population-scale benchmarking and individualized mental health diagnostics.

COGNITIVE SCIENCE (2023)

Article Psychology, Experimental

Language-Specific Constraints on Conversation: Evidence from Danish and Norwegian

Christina Dideriksen, Morten H. Christiansen, Mark Dingemanse, Malte Hojmark-Bertelsen, Christer Johansson, Kristian Tylen, Riccardo Fusaroli

Summary: Establishing and maintaining mutual understanding in everyday conversations is crucial. This study compares Danish and Norwegian, two matched languages differing primarily in their sound structure, to explore whether cross-linguistic differences influence the use of conversational devices. The findings suggest that linguistic differences may lead to systematic changes in language processing and use, and pave the way for further cross-linguistic investigations.

COGNITIVE SCIENCE (2023)

Article Computer Science, Artificial Intelligence

Models of Language and Multiword Expressions

Pablo Contreras Kallens, Morten H. Christiansen

Summary: Traditional accounts of language, based on the words-and-rules framework, have proven to be useful in natural language processing and cognitive science, but they also have important shortcomings. This article reviews evidence from language acquisition, sentence processing, and computational modeling to show the central role that multiword expressions play in language organization. These expressions straddle the line between lexicon and grammar, questioning the usefulness of this distinction as a foundation for our understanding of language. The article also reviews diverse approaches to account for the role of multiword expressions in language representation, acquisition, and processing.

FRONTIERS IN ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (2022)

Article Linguistics

Memory limitations are hidden in grammar

Carlos Gomez-Rodriguez, Morten H. Christiansen, Ramon Ferrer-i-Cancho

Summary: The ability to generate and understand various sentences is a key feature of human language. Linguists have tried to define this generative capacity using formal grammars that describe syntactic dependencies. However, by sampling sentences from possible syntactic structures, it has been found that memory limitations have affected grammatical descriptions.

GLOTTOMETRICS (2022)

No Data Available