4.7 Article

Large-scale analysis of micro-level citation patterns reveals nuanced selection criteria

Journal

NATURE HUMAN BEHAVIOUR
Volume 3, Issue 6, Pages 568-575

Publisher

NATURE PUBLISHING GROUP
DOI: 10.1038/s41562-019-0585-7

Keywords

-

Funding

  1. John and Leslie McQuown Gift
  2. Department of Defense Army Research Office [W911NF-14-1-0259]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The analysis of citations to scientific publications has become a tool that is used in the evaluation of a researcher's work; especially in the face of an ever-increasing production volume(1-6). Despite the acknowledged shortcomings of citation analysis and the ongoing debate on the meaning of citations(7,8), citations are still primarily viewed as endorsements and as indicators of the influence of the cited reference, regardless of the context of the citation. However, only recently has attention(9,10) been given to the connection between contextual information and the success of citing and cited papers, primarily because of the lack of extensive databases that cover both types of metadata. Here we address this issue by studying the usage of citations throughout the full text of 156,558 articles published by the Public Library of Science (PLoS), and by tracing their bibliometric history from among 60 million records obtained from the Web of Science. We find universal patterns of variation in the usage of citations across paper sections(11). Notably, we find differences in microlevel citation patterns that were dependent on the ultimate impact of the citing paper itself; publications from high-impact groups tend to cite younger references, as well as more very young and better-cited references. Our study provides a quantitative approach to addressing the long-standing issue that not all citations count the same.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Physics, Multidisciplinary

Centrality anomalies in complex networks as a result of model over-simplification

Luiz G. A. Alves, Alberto Aleta, Francisco A. Rodrigues, Yamir Moreno, Luis A. Nunes Amaral

NEW JOURNAL OF PHYSICS (2020)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Long-term patterns of gender imbalance in an industry without ability or level of interest differences

Luis A. Nunes Amaral, Joao A. G. Moreira, Murielle L. Dunand, Heliodoro Tejedor Navarro, Hyojun Ada Lee

PLOS ONE (2020)

Editorial Material Multidisciplinary Sciences

How to build a more open justice system

Adam R. Pah, David L. Schwartz, Sarath Sanga, Zachary D. Clopton, Peter DiCola, Rachel Davis Mersey, Charlotte S. Alexander, Kristian J. Hammond, Luis A. Nunes Amaral

SCIENCE (2020)

Article Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

Conformational stability of the bacterial adhesin, FimH, with an inactivating mutation

Jenny Liu, Luis A. Nunes Amaral, Sinan Keten

Summary: Allosteric regulation of conformational states plays a key role in catch-bond behavior in adhesive proteins like FimH. By studying the molecular dynamics of the lectin domain in different states, such as the HL mutant, researchers gain insight into the transmission of allosteric information across protein domains. This information could potentially guide drug development efforts to prevent infections by inhibiting FimH adhesion.

PROTEINS-STRUCTURE FUNCTION AND BIOINFORMATICS (2021)

Article Mathematics, Interdisciplinary Applications

Multilayer networks for text analysis with multiple data types

Charles C. Hyland, Yuanming Tao, Lamiae Azizi, Martin Gerlach, Tiago P. Peixoto, Eduardo G. Altmann

Summary: The method proposed in the study is based on Multilayer Networks and Stochastic Block Models, applying the same non-parametric probabilistic framework to different types of datasets to tackle the challenge of clustering documents and finding topics. By taking into account multiple types of information, it provides a more nuanced view on topic- and document-clusters and increases the ability to predict missing links.

EPJ DATA SCIENCE (2021)

Article Computer Science, Artificial Intelligence

The Promise of AI in an Open Justice System

Adam R. Pah, David L. Schwartz, Sarath Sanga, Charlotte S. Alexander, Kristian J. Hammond, Luis A. N. Amaral

Summary: To craft effective public policy, governments need to gather data on performance and public responses. While federal administrative agencies and the Congress do this and make the data accessible, the judicial branch is an outlier, as court records are effectively out of reach behind a paywall and technical obstacles. The SCALES OKN aims to address this by transforming the transparency and accessibility of court records, facilitating the development of new AI solutions for the benefit of the judiciary, legal scholars, and the public.

AI MAGAZINE (2022)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

The first step is recognizing there is a problem: a methodology for adjusting for variability in disease severity when estimating clinician performance

Meagan Bechel, Adam R. Pah, Stephen D. Persell, Curtis H. Weiss, Luis A. Nunes Amaral

Summary: This study proposes a data-driven metric for clinician disease recognition that takes into account the variability in patient disease severity and institutional standards. By evaluating ventilatory management in patients with acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS), it was found that training background was associated with physician recognition, with non-PCCM physicians recognizing ARDS cases less frequently but expressing greater satisfaction with obtaining diagnostic information.

BMC MEDICAL RESEARCH METHODOLOGY (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Forecasting the evolution of fast-changing transportation networks using machine learning

Weihua Lei, Luiz G. A. Alves, Luis A. Nunes Amaral

Summary: The authors propose a machine learning framework for predicting connections removal in transportation networks and investigate the dynamics of edge removal in the Brazilian domestic bus transportation network and the U.S. domestic air transportation network. They find that machine learning models can accurately predict edge removals on a monthly time scale and even in the presence of external shocks. The authors also demonstrate the usefulness of their approach by forecasting the impact of a hypothetical reduction in the scale of the U.S. air transportation network due to CO2 emissions reduction policies. This forecasting approach could be valuable for future infrastructure planning.

NATURE COMMUNICATIONS (2022)

Article Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

A new approach for extracting information from protein dynamics

Jenny Liu, Luis A. N. Amaral, Sinan Keten

Summary: A promising approach to study protein dynamics is to represent it using networks and take advantage of well-established methods from network science. Most studies construct protein dynamics networks using correlation measures, which are only applicable under specific conditions. In this study, the researchers applied an inverse approach to build networks based on protein dihedral angles, resulting in physically interpretable and robust networks. By using this method, dynamical differences were identified for proteins with structural similarity. The study demonstrates the importance of using the inverse approach to extract networks from protein dynamics.

PROTEINS-STRUCTURE FUNCTION AND BIOINFORMATICS (2023)

Article Computer Science, Information Systems

A Large-Scale Characterization of How Readers Browse Wikipedia

Tiziano Piccardi, Martin Gerlach, Akhil Arora, Robert West

Summary: This article presents the first large-scale analysis of how readers navigate Wikipedia, using billions of page requests from the server logs. The study finds that navigation behavior is highly diverse, with the depth and shape of paths varying systematically with topic, device type, and time of day. The research also reveals that Wikipedia navigation paths often intersect with external pages and differ from targeted navigation in lab-based settings. Additionally, the results suggest that navigation is abandoned when readers encounter low-quality pages. These insights contribute to a better understanding of readers' information needs and can help improve their experience on Wikipedia and the Web in general.

ACM TRANSACTIONS ON THE WEB (2023)

Article Cell Biology

Aging is associated with a systemic length-associated transcriptome imbalance

Thomas Stoeger, Rogan A. Grant, Alexandra C. McQuattie-Pimentel, Kishore R. Anekalla, Sophia S. Liu, Heliodoro Tejedor-Navarro, Benjamin D. Singer, Hiam Abdala-Valencia, Michael Schwake, Marie-Pier Tetreault, Harris Perlman, William E. Balch, Navdeep S. Chandel, Karen M. Ridge, Jacob Sznajder, Richard Morimoto, Alexander Misharin, G. R. Scott Budinger, Luis A. Nunes Amaral

Summary: The length of transcripts explains the majority of transcriptional changes observed during aging in mice and humans. The relative abundance of long transcripts is lower in aging, and antiaging interventions can counter this length association. Genes with the longest transcripts are associated with lifespan extension, while genes with the shortest transcripts are associated with lifespan shortening.

NATURE AGING (2022)

Proceedings Paper Computer Science, Artificial Intelligence

Wikipedia Reader Navigation: When Synthetic Data Is Enough

Akhil Arora, Martin Gerlach, Tiziano Piccardi, Alberto Garcia-Duran, Robert West

Summary: This study examines the navigation behaviors of Wikipedia readers using clickstream data. It finds that clickstream data can effectively approximate the real navigation sequences, providing a useful resource for practical applications relying on reader data.

WSDM'22: PROCEEDINGS OF THE FIFTEENTH ACM INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON WEB SEARCH AND DATA MINING (2022)

Proceedings Paper Computer Science, Artificial Intelligence

Language-agnostic Topic Classification for Wikipedia

Isaac Johnson, Martin Gerlach, Diego Saez-Trumper

Summary: Analyzing Wikipedia dynamics poses a challenge in grouping articles into coherent topics. Past approaches have been limited in coverage, but a new language-agnostic method proposed in this paper shows promising results in simplifying classification while increasing coverage.

WEB CONFERENCE 2021: COMPANION OF THE WORLD WIDE WEB CONFERENCE (WWW 2021) (2021)

Article Physics, Fluids & Plasmas

Spreader events and the limitations of projected networks for capturing dynamics on multipartite networks

Hyojun A. Lee, Luiz G. A. Alves, Luis A. Nunes Amaral

Summary: This study compares transmission dynamics between temporal multipartite networks and their time-aggregated unipartite projections, and finds significant differences on three levels. The ratio of the number of nodes to the number of active edges over the time-aggregation scale determines the ability of projected networks to capture the dynamics on multipartite networks.

PHYSICAL REVIEW E (2021)

No Data Available