4.7 Article

Comparison of enigmatic diamonds from the Tolbachik arc volcano (Kamchatka) and Tibetan ophiolites: Assessing the role of contamination by synthetic materials

Journal

GONDWANA RESEARCH
Volume 75, Issue -, Pages 16-27

Publisher

ELSEVIER
DOI: 10.1016/j.gr.2019.04.007

Keywords

Cuboctahedral diamond; Synthetic diamond; HPHT growth; Kamchatka; Basalts; Magma

Funding

  1. RFBR [17-05-00935]
  2. Japan Society for the Promotion of Science [S18109]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The enigmatic appearance of cuboctahedral diamonds in ophiolitic and arc volcanic rocks with morphology and infrared characteristics similar to synthetic diamonds that were grown from metal solvent requires a critical reappraisal. We have studied 15 diamond crystals and fragments from Tolbachik volcano lava flows, using Fourier transform infrared spectrometry (FTIR), transmission electron microscopy (TEM), synchrotron X-ray fluorescence (SRXRF) and laser ablation inductively coupled plasma mass-spectrometry (LA-ICP-MS). FTIR spectra of Tolbachik diamonds correspond to typical type Ib patterns of synthetic diamonds. In TEM films prepared using focused ion beam technique, we find Mn-Ni and Mn-Si inclusions in Tolbachik diamonds. SRXRF spectra indicate the presence of Fe-Ni and Fe-Ni-Mn inclusions with Cr, Ti, Cu, and Zn impurities. LA-ICP-MS data show variable but significantly elevated concentrations of Mn, Fe, Ni, and Cu reaching up to 70 ppm. These transition metal concentration levels are comparable with those determined by LA-ICP-MS for similar diamonds from Tibetan ophiolites. Mn-Ni (+Fe) solvent was widely used to produce industrial synthetic diamonds in the former USSR and Russia with very similar proportions of these metals. Hence, it appears highly probable that the cuboctahedral diamonds recovered from Kamchatka arc volcanic rocks represent contamination and are likely derived from drilling tools or other hard instruments. Kinetic data on diamond dissolution in basaltic magma or in fluid phase demonstrate that diamond does not form under the pressures and temperature conditions prevalent within the magmatic system beneath the modern-day Klyuchevskoy group of arc volcanoes. We also considered reference data for inclusions in ophiolitic diamonds and compared them with the composition of solvent used in industrial diamond synthesis in China. The similar inclusion chemistry close to Ni70Mn25Co5 for ophiolitic and synthetic Chinese diamonds scrutinized here suggests that most diamonds recovered from Tibetan and other ophiolites are not natural but instead have a synthetic origin. In order to mitigate further dubious reports of diamonds from unconventional tectonic settings and source rocks, we propose a set of discrimination criteria to better distinguish natural cuboctahedral diamonds from those produced synthetically in industrial environments and found as contaminants in mantle- and crust-derived rocks. (c) 2019 International Association for Gondwana Research. Published by Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Pyroxene-carbonate reactions in the CaMgSi2O6 ± NaAlSi2O6 + MgCO3 ± Na2CO3 ± K2CO3 system at 3-6 GPa: Implications for partial melting of carbonated peridotite

Anton Shatskiy, Ivan V. Podborodnikov, Anton V. Arefiev, Altyna Bekhtenova, Yulia G. Vinogradova, Konstantin M. Stepanov, Konstantin D. Litasov

Summary: The study found that the reactions between pyroxenes and carbonates vary under different pressure and temperature conditions, with the solidus loci primarily influenced by temperature and pressure.

CONTRIBUTIONS TO MINERALOGY AND PETROLOGY (2021)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Formation of Mg-Orthocarbonate through the Reaction MgCO3 + MgO = Mg2CO4 at Earth's Lower Mantle P-T Conditions

Pavel N. Gavryushkin, Dinara N. Sagatova, Nursultan Sagatov, Konstantin D. Litasov

Summary: Orthocarbonates of alkaline earth metals are a newly discovered class of compounds stabilized at high pressures. Mg2CO4, a potential carbon host phase, can be formed in the lower mantle at pressures above 50 GPa and high temperatures. It has two stable crystal structures, with higher melting temperatures and stronger anisotropy compared to magnesite, and its Raman spectra can aid in its identification in high-pressure experiments.

CRYSTAL GROWTH & DESIGN (2021)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Phase Relations in CaSiO3 System up to 100 GPa and 2500 K

D. N. Sagatova, A. F. Shatskiy, N. E. Sagatov, K. D. Litasov

Summary: Phase relations of CaSiO3 in different pressure and temperature conditions were comprehensively studied using density functional theory and lattice dynamics method. The stability of CaSiO3 in various structures under different conditions was revealed, along with the variations in phase equilibrium curve slopes.

GEOCHEMISTRY INTERNATIONAL (2021)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Thermodynamic Analysis of Reactions of CO2 Fluid with Garnet and Clinopyroxene at 3-6 GPa

Y. G. Vinogradova, A. F. Shatskiy, K. D. Litasov

Summary: The research findings suggest the existence of molecular CO2 inclusions in diamonds, and thermodynamic calculations indicate that the formation of solid solutions expands the stability field of CO2 fluid with mantle minerals. Preliminary experiments with model mixtures validate these relationships at high pressures and temperatures.

GEOCHEMISTRY INTERNATIONAL (2021)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Origin of micrometer-sized impact diamonds in ureilites by catalytic growth involving Fe-Ni-silicide: The example of Kenna meteorite

Anna Barbaro, Maria Chiara Domeneghetti, Konstantin D. Litasov, Ludovic Ferriere, Lidia Pittarello, Oliver Christ, Sofia Lorenzon, Matteo Alvaro, Fabrizio Nestola

Summary: The investigation of a fragment of Kenna ureilite revealed the presence of microdiamonds, nanographite, and magnetite in the carbon-bearing areas, indicating a shock event with peak pressure at least 15 GPa. Additionally, nanocrystalline carletonmooreite with formula Ni3Si was identified for the first time in a ureilite, supporting the hypothesis of Fe-Ni Alloys catalytic involvement in the growth process of diamond from graphite during shock events in the ureilite parent body.

GEOCHIMICA ET COSMOCHIMICA ACTA (2021)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Solidus and melting of carbonated phlogopite peridotite at 3-6.5 GPa: Implications for mantle metasomatism

Anton Shatskiy, Altyna Bekhtenova, Anton Arefiev, Ivan Podborodnikov, Yulia G. Vinogradova, Dmitriy Rezvukhin, Konstantin D. Litasov

Summary: The study found that the infiltration of water-rich carbonate melts into the mantle rocks can lead to the consumption of minerals like garnet and orthopyroxene, producing new minerals like phlogopite and K-richterite. This metasomatic process may weaken the lithosphere and promote the formation of continental rifts.

GONDWANA RESEARCH (2022)

Article Chemistry, Inorganic & Nuclear

γ-BaB2O4: High-Pressure High-Temperature Polymorph of Barium Borate with Edge-Sharing BO4 Tetrahedra

Tatyana B. Bekker, Ivan Podborodnikov, Nursultan E. Sagatov, Anton Shatskiy, Sergey Rashchenko, Dinara N. Sagatova, Alexey Davydov, Konstantin D. Litasov

Summary: The alpha- and beta-modifications of barium metaborate are important functional materials used in optoelectronic devices. A new high-pressure modification, gamma-BaB2O4, has been successfully synthesized and studied for its unique structure and excellent optical properties.

INORGANIC CHEMISTRY (2022)

Article Chemistry, Physical

Luminescence properties of rare-earth-doped fluoride borate crystals

Tatyana B. Bekker, Alexey A. Ryadun, Alexey V. Davydov, Vladimir P. Solntsev, Veronika D. Grigorieva

Summary: Single crystals of undoped and rare-earth-doped Ba-12(BO3)(6)[BO3][LiF4] were grown from high-temperature solutions. The luminescence of these crystals at specific excitation wavelengths shows potential for converting LED emissions into white light.

JOURNAL OF ALLOYS AND COMPOUNDS (2022)

Article Chemistry, Physical

Mechanisms of Photoluminescence in Copper-Containing Fluoride Borate Crystals

Talgat M. Inerbaev, Yulun Han, Tatyana B. Bekker, Dmitri S. Kilin

Summary: Mechanisms of photoluminescence in antizeolitefluoride borates (AFBs) doped by copper ions are interpreted based on a comparison between experimental and computational approaches. Doped AFBs demonstrate the effect of thermally stimulated photoluminescence and hold a promise for the use as radiation detectors. The electronic and optical properties of Cu-containing fluoride borates with different anionic groups are modeled, and the results show the significant influence of the oxidation state of copper ions on the properties. Theoretical calculations of photoluminescence spectra contribute to the interpretation of experimental data and provide insights for designing materials with desired properties for radiation detectors.

JOURNAL OF PHYSICAL CHEMISTRY C (2022)

Article Physics, Multidisciplinary

The systems KCl-CaCO3 and KCl-MgCO3 at 6 GPa

Ivan Podborodnikov, Anton Shatskiy, Anton Arefiev, Altyna Bekhtenova, Konstantin D. Litasov

Summary: Continuous variations in the composition of melt inclusions in diamonds suggest their possible genetic relationship and provide interest in the study of chloride-carbonate systems at high pressure. Experimental data show that the KCl-CaCO3 and KCl-MgCO3 systems have eutectic characteristics.

HIGH PRESSURE RESEARCH (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

New High-Pressure Structures of Transition Metal Carbonates with O3C-CO3 Orthooxalate Groups

Nursultan E. Sagatov, Dinara N. Sagatova, Pavel N. Gavryushkin, Konstantin D. Litasov

Summary: Based on density functional theory and crystal structure prediction, we discovered a novel high-pressure structure of Fe2CO4-P(1) over bar. It contains ethane-like O3C-CO3 groups or orthooxalate groups, which were previously proposed in melts and aqueous carbonate solutions but not in inorganic crystalline materials. This structure is dynamically and thermally stable at pressures of 50 GPa and similar structures were also predicted for Mn2CO4, Ni2CO4, and Co2CO4. FeCO3 was found to transform into a similar structure at pressures above 275 GPa. Additionally, we observed the self-diffusion of metal atoms in carbonates at high pressure and high temperatures for the first time. The prediction of novel carbonate structures expands the crystal chemistry of inorganic carbonates beyond the known structures with [CO3] triangles, [C2O5] pyro-groups, and [CO4] tetrahedra.

SYMMETRY-BASEL (2023)

Article Chemistry, Applied

Continuous Synthesis of Epoxides from Alkenes by Hydrogen Peroxide with Titanium Silicalite-1 Catalyst Using Flow Reactors

Yoshihiro Kon, Takuya Nakashima, Yoshiki Makino, Hiroki Nagashima, Shun-ya Onozawa, Shu Kobayashi, Kazuhiko Sato

Summary: Continuous-flow epoxidation of aliphatic and aromatic alkenes using a fixed-bed liquid flow reactor equipped with a solid titanium silicalite-1 (TS-1) catalyst column and hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) as the oxidant was achieved. The developed flow reaction allowed for the continuous synthesis of 4-phenyl-1,2-epoxybutane with high yields (90%-98%) for 150 hours. By using a mixed solution of MeCN and MeOH, the reaction enabled the epoxidation of less-reactive long-chain terminal alkenes and multifunctional alkenes with good selectivity (78%-99%) and yields (12%-98%).

ADVANCED SYNTHESIS & CATALYSIS (2023)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

The NaCl-CaCO3 and NaCl-MgCO3 systems at 6 GPa: Link between saline and carbonatitic diamond forming melts

Anton Shatskiy, Ivan V. Podborodnikov, Anastasia S. Fedoraeva, Anton Arefiev, Altyna Bekhtenova, Konstantin D. Litasov

Summary: The phase relations in the NaCl-CaCO3 and NaCl-MgCO3 systems were experimentally studied using a multi-anvil press at 6 GPa and temperatures ranging from 1000 to 1600 degrees C. Both systems were found to have eutectic type phase diagrams, with subsolidus assemblages of halite + aragonite and halite + magnesite. The composition of the halite-aragonite eutectic was determined to be 40 wt% NaCl and 60 wt% CaCO3 at temperatures below 1200 degrees C, while the halite-magnesite eutectic had a composition of 72 wt% NaCl and 28 wt% MgCO3 at 1300 degrees C. Complete miscibility between carbonate and chloride liquids was observed up to 1600 degrees C.

AMERICAN MINERALOGIST (2023)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Phonolite-Carbonatite Liquid Immiscibility at 3-6 GPa

Anton V. V. Arefiev, Anton Shatskiy, Altyna Bekhtenova, Konstantin D. D. Litasov

Summary: Liquid immiscibility is significant in the formation of carbonatites and alkaline Si-undersaturated magmas. The miscibility gap between carbonate and silicate is determined by pressure and differs between sodium carbonate-aluminosilicate and potassium-rich carbonate-aluminosilicate systems. This study investigates the immiscibility range under intermediate pressures and finds that the compositions of immiscible phonolite and carbonatite melts change with pressure, indicating different depth and mantle conditions.

MINERALS (2023)

Article Chemistry, Analytical

Rapid and sensitive determination of leached platinum group elements in organic reaction solution of metal-catalyzed reactions by laser ablation-ICP-MS with spot-drying on paper

Yoshiki Makino, Hiroki Matsuo, Koichiro Masuda, Shun-ya Onozawa, Tetsuya Nakazato

Summary: The evaluation of metal leaching in metal-catalyzed reactions is crucial, but current analytical methods for trace metal determination in organic reaction solutions are time-consuming and require high purity reagents. In this study, a rapid and sensitive method using LA-ICP-MS was developed for the determination of platinum group elements (PGEs) in organic reaction solutions. The proposed method allows for quick detection without the need for pre-treatment and can be completed in a short amount of time. The accuracy and adaptability of this method were confirmed through comparison with conventional methods.

JOURNAL OF ANALYTICAL ATOMIC SPECTROMETRY (2022)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Ongoing India-Asia convergence controlled differential growth of the eastern Tibetan Plateau

Bin Zhang, Jiaqi Liu, Wen Chen, Zhiliang Zhang, Li Yang, Lei Zhang, Zeyang Zhu, Chunqing Sun, Zhihao Sun

Summary: The eastern Tibetan Plateau is a region with unique topography and active tectonics, making it crucial for studying geodynamics and lithosphere-atmosphere interaction. By integrating new and reported thermochronological data, as well as paleo-crustal thickness reconstruction, this study sheds light on the tectonic deformation, climate-tectonic coupling, and geodynamics of the area.

GONDWANA RESEARCH (2024)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Direct method to estimate the gas loss characteristics and in-situ gas contents of shale

Zhenhua Tian, Shangwen Zhou, Songtao Wu, Sai Xu, Junping Zhou, Jianchao Cai

Summary: This paper presents a modified method for calculating the lost gas content of shale by analyzing the coring and on-site desorption processes. The method accurately depicts the loss characteristics of free and adsorbed gas and identifies parameters that influence the calculation of in-situ shale gas content. The results demonstrate that the method shows satisfactory applicability in gas loss curve prediction and in-situ gas content estimation.

GONDWANA RESEARCH (2024)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Impact of sectoral mix on environmental sustainability: How is heterogeneity addressed?

Pengcheng Li, Jaffar Abbas, Daniel Balsalobre-Lorente, Qingren Wang, Qianxiao Zhang, Syed Ale Raza Shah

Summary: This study explores the factors contributing to sustainability in Pakistan from 1974 to 2018 and finds that emissions from industrial and agriculture sectors have significantly decreased, while the financial sector has not effectively reduced environmental pressure. Therefore, Pakistan needs to adjust its economic policies and ensure the green allocation of financial resources.

GONDWANA RESEARCH (2024)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Effect of montmorillonite and humic acid on cotransport of g-C3N4 and lead: The role of triazine ring in lead adsorption and deposition in soil components

Shi Zhou, Ting Zhou, Duo Guan, Yong Yao, Huimin Sun, Ahmed Ali Mosa, Yajie Zuo, Xianqiang Yin

Summary: Graphitic carbon nitride (g-C3N4) has been widely used due to its excellent optical properties and physicochemical stability. The risk of g-C3N4 transport in the environment has been overlooked, but this study investigated its transport behavior in various media. The results showed that flow rate and ionic strength influenced the transport, and the presence of lead (Pb) affected the outflow of g-C3N4. The unique structure of g-C3N4 particles allowed them to deposit in certain media and act as carriers for Pb release.

GONDWANA RESEARCH (2024)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

An empirical appraisal of the non-linear nexus between foreign remittance receipts and carbon emissions intensities

Xiaolong Qiao, Muntasir Murshed, Mohammad Mahtab Alam, Narasingha Das, Kurshid Khudoykulov, Salman Tariq

Summary: This study examines how macroeconomic factors influence India's carbon emission intensity levels and confirms the impact of factors such as foreign remittance receipts, energy consumption, urbanization, and technological progress. The findings provide policy recommendations for India's carbon emission reduction targets.

GONDWANA RESEARCH (2024)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Carbon flux from hydrothermal skarn ore deposits and its potential impact to the environment

Wei Liu, Bo Wan

Summary: Magmatic-hydrothermal systems play a crucial role in transporting materials and potentially affecting Earth's long-term environment. This study investigates the duration of prograde metamorphism induced by fluid infiltration and the amount of carbon released by skarn ore deposits. The findings reveal that skarn ore deposits can efficiently decarbonize CO2 at a high rate, surpassing volcanism in different tectonic settings. The CO2 flux of skarn deposits increases over time and reaches a maximum value at the J/K boundary, providing an important previously unquantified source of outgassing in the subduction zone.

GONDWANA RESEARCH (2024)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

A world-class source rock in southern China formed during the periods from Katian to Rhuddanian: Biostratigraphic distribution, depositional model and shale gas potential

Haikuan Nie, Pei Li, Qing Chen, Zhijun Jin, Quanyou Liu, Wei Dang, Qian Chen, Jianghui Ding, Changbo Zhai

Summary: This study investigates the shale quality and shale gas potential in the upper Ordovician to lower Silurian formations in the Sichuan Basin of southern China. The distribution and characteristics of organic-rich shale are analyzed, aiding in the assessment of shale gas potential and identification of sweet spots.

GONDWANA RESEARCH (2024)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Leveraging environmental ICT for carbon neutrality: Analyzing the impact of financial development, renewable energy and human capital in top polluting economies

Najia Saqib, Shujaat Abbas, Ilhan Ozturk, Muntasir Murshed, Malgorzata Tarczynska-Luniewska, Mohammad Mahtab Alam, Waldemar Tarczynski

Summary: This study examines the impact of economic growth, financial development, eco-friendly ICT, renewable energy, and human capital on lowering carbon footprint in the world's top polluting economies from 1993 to 2020. The findings suggest that eco-friendly ICT has the potential to effectively alleviate pollution, and financial development, renewable energy, and environmental technology are proposed as potential solutions for reducing carbon emissions.

GONDWANA RESEARCH (2024)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Kahi mélange complex in Kurram and Waziristan, NW Pakistan: An integrated approach for tectonic implications to India-Afghan suturing

Hikmat Salam, Syed Ali Turab, Asghar Ali, M. Qasim Jan, Norasiah Sulaiman, Mohd Basril Iswadi Basori

Summary: The Kahi melange complex in NW Pakistan is an important record of the tectonic evolution between the Indian plate and the Afghan block, consisting of highly dismembered ophiolitic and sedimentary units.

GONDWANA RESEARCH (2024)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Episodic water-fluxed anatexis recorded by migmatites from the Paleozoic Wuyi-Yunkai Orogeny in South China

Er-Kun Xue, Wei Wang, David Chew, Manoj K. Pandit, Xin Deng, Yang Tian, Xi-Run Tong, Jun-Hong Zhao

Summary: The study reveals the presence of water-fluxed melting during the Wuyi-Yunkai Orogeny in South China. These water-fluxed melting quartzo-feldspathic migmatites formed during the early Paleozoic and were melted through reactions involving water-saturated quartz, feldspar, biotite, and K-feldspar. The findings highlight the significance of water-fluxed anatexis in the differentiation of the continental crust during orogenesis.

GONDWANA RESEARCH (2024)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Neoproterozoic to early Paleozoic crustal growth, recycling, and the changing geodynamics of North Gondwana

Hadi Shafaii Moghadam, Qiu-Li Li, William L. Griffin, Xian-Hua Li, Orhan Karsli, Christopher J. Spencer, Jose F. Santos, Maria Kirchenbaur, Sobhi Nasir, Suzanne Y. O'Reilly

Summary: Understanding the crustal growth, reworking, and geodynamics of the northern continental margin of Gondwana during the Ediacaran to Silurian times is crucial for the paleogeographic reconstruction of Gondwana. This study uses various analytical methods to evaluate the magmatic history of this region and obtain relevant detrital zircon data. The results provide valuable insights into the crustal evolution and tectonic activities in the northern Gondwana region.

GONDWANA RESEARCH (2024)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Seismic structure of the Eastern European crust and upper mantle from probabilistic ambient noise tomography

Laura Petrescu, Felix Borleanu, Emanuel Kaestle, Randell Stephenson, Anica Placinta, Oleksandr Ivanovich Liashchuk

Summary: This study investigates the seismic structure of the Eastern European lithosphere and the transition from Precambrian to Phanerozoic Europe. The results show that the crust thickens across the Trans European Suture Zone boundary and the mantle is seismically faster beneath younger terranes. The Precambrian building blocks exhibit contrasting seismic fabrics, with the Baltic orogens characterized by uniform crust and the Sarmatia region showing alternating high and low velocity layers.

GONDWANA RESEARCH (2024)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Modification of Archean lower crust of the North China Craton by magma underplating during the Mesozoic: Evidence from zircon U-Pb-Hf-O isotopes of granulite xenoliths

Dongya Zou, Hongfu Zhang

Summary: This study analyzes the U-Pb-Hf-O isotopes of zircons in felsic granulite xenoliths from the Fuxin late Cretaceous basalts in the North China Craton to evaluate the role of magma underplating in modifying the Archean lower crust. The results show that long-lived magma underplating occurred beneath the Fuxin region during the Mesozoic, with underplated magmas originating from the lithospheric mantle and later from the depleted asthenospheric mantle. This study concludes that magma underplating not only provided heat for remelting, but also added exotic material and weakened the lower crust, leading to its destruction.

GONDWANA RESEARCH (2024)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Continental climate variability during the middle Eocene global warming

Yu Han, Yingchang Cao, Chao Liang, Keyu Liu, Fang Hao

Summary: A paleoclimate reconstruction based on high-resolution records from lacustrine shale in the Bohai Bay Basin reveals a shift in orbital variability and a humidification event at -41.9 Ma in East Asia. The intensification of the East Asian monsoons at this time was likely a response to the elevated atmospheric pCO2 during the concurrent global warming.

GONDWANA RESEARCH (2024)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Carbonatite and ultrabasic magmatism at Toro Ankole and Virunga, western branch of the East African Rift system

Francesca Innocenzi, Sara Ronca, Stephen Foley, Samuele Agostini, Michele Lustrino

Summary: This study investigates two volcanic provinces in the western branch of the East African Rift and finds that the volcanic products show wide variability in chemical and mineralogical characteristics. Petrographic and geochemical analysis reveals enriched and heterogeneous sub-lithospheric mantle sources. The differences in isotopic features between the two volcanic provinces may indicate changes in the composition, mineralogy, and depth of melting in the lithospheric mantle source.

GONDWANA RESEARCH (2024)