4.5 Article

Social Vulnerability (Re-)Assessment in Context to Natural Hazards: Review of the Usefulness of the Spatial Indicator Approach and Investigations of Validation Demands

Journal

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DISASTER RISK SCIENCE
Volume 10, Issue 2, Pages 220-232

Publisher

SPRINGER
DOI: 10.1007/s13753-019-0213-1

Keywords

Disaster risk; Indicator selection; Social vulnerability index; Validation criteria; Vulnerability indicators

Ask authors/readers for more resources

While social vulnerability assessments (SVA) use spatial indicators and indices that have become state of the art, they also receive substantial critique. This article analyzes, by means of a literature review of 63 articles, if and in which aspects such an indicator approach is regarded as useful by scientific studies. The findings indicate a need for more research on the validation and justification of indicators. This article supports the conceptual development of SVA by adding to reflection about advancements and applications, but also shortcomings. The main advancement area discussed is validation and the demand for establishing benchmark criteria for vulnerability. Based on this, longitudinal monitoring of vulnerability and validation studies are conceivable based on existing SVA, but these efforts demand more conceptual development.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Computer Science, Information Systems

A Framework for Scaling Urban Transformative Resilience through Utilizing Volunteered Geographic Information

Mahsa Moghadas, Abbas Rajabifard, Alexander Fekete, Theo Koetter

Summary: Resilience in urban context can be divided into absorptive, adaptive, and transformative capacities. Recent urban resilience initiatives have been exploring the concept of transformative resilience as a response to the limitations of conventional and top-down resilience plans. Transformative resilience emphasizes the importance of reflexive governance, inclusive co-creation of knowledge, innovative and collaborative learning, and self-organizing processes.

ISPRS INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF GEO-INFORMATION (2022)

Article Urban Studies

Urbanization, migration, and the challenges of resilience thinking in urban planning: Insights from two contrasting planning systems in Germany and Iran

Asad Asadzadeh, Theo Koetter, Alexander Fekete, Mahsa Moghadas, Mohsen Alizadeh, Esfandiar Zebardast, Dominik Weiss, Maysam Basirat, Gerard Hutter

Summary: This paper examines transformative resilience as a common challenge for urban/regional governance and planning systems in contrasting contexts of Germany and Iran. Through a comparative case study method, it reveals the pathways and trade-offs that constrain or open opportunities for transformative resilience and proposes the need for reorganizing governance structures and reorienting planning frameworks to address the challenges posed by urbanization and migration dynamics.

CITIES (2022)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Peri-urban growth into natural hazard-prone areas: mapping exposure transformation of the built environment in Nairobi and Nyeri, Kenya, from 1948 to today

Alexander Fekete

Summary: Kenya is experiencing rapid urban growth, which exposes settlements and the natural environment to natural hazards such as floods. This study compares the urban growth into hazard areas in Nairobi and Nyeri through a change assessment from 1948 to 2020. The findings highlight the need to focus on peri-urban areas and expand the understanding of urban growth and flood risk in Kenya.

NATURAL HAZARDS (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Should everyone in need be treated equally? A European survey of expert judgment on social vulnerability to floods and pandemics to validate multi-hazard vulnerability factors

Alexander Fekete, Samuel Rufat

Summary: In 2021, several European countries experienced severe floods, while Europe remained the epicenter of the COVID-19 pandemic. This study aims to identify socio-demographic groups vulnerable to floods and pandemics and compare their overlap. A survey was conducted to gather opinions from experts in disaster risk management, revealing that socially vulnerable groups should be prioritized in rescue and treatment. The findings also indicate the importance of infrastructure and economic losses in assessing vulnerability and highlight differences in vulnerability factors between floods and COVID-19.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DISASTER RISK REDUCTION (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Assessment of social vulnerability to forest fire and hazardous facilities in Germany

Alexander Fekete, Udo Nehren

Summary: In recent years, Germany has experienced an increase in forest fires, particularly in military training areas that are difficult to access. These fires pose a threat to both firefighting personnel and settlements. The impacts of climate change are expected to further increase the occurrence and spread of fires. A lack of comprehensive understanding of the spatial occurrence of forest fires and related risks currently hinders effective emergency management and spatial planning. This study conducted a spatial exposure and social vulnerability assessment of settlements to forest fires in Germany, revealing that social vulnerability plays a significant role in determining which settlements are at risk of fire exposure and providing key indicators for identifying high-risk areas.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DISASTER RISK REDUCTION (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Spatial Industrial Accident Exposure and Social Vulnerability Assessment of Hazardous Material Sites, Chemical Parks, and Nuclear Power Plants in Germany

Alexander Fekete, Steffen Neuner

Summary: This study conducted a spatial assessment of different types of industrial facilities in Germany and analyzed their vulnerability in terms of population density, foreign population, and housing unit sizes in close proximity to the sites. The results can guide emergency management planners and stakeholders in devising better disaster risk reduction strategies specifically for different social groups.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DISASTER RISK SCIENCE (2023)

Article Meteorology & Atmospheric Sciences

Disaster Risk, Climate Change, and Urbanization as Research Topics in Western Asia-A Bibliometric Literature Analysis

Alexander Fekete

Summary: Scientific analysis and documentation of climate change and related disaster risks are demanded by international organizations such as the United Nations. However, there is a lack of cross-regional overviews, especially for Western Asia. Through bibliometric literature analysis, it was found that transport accidents, floods, fires, and earthquakes are the predominant accidents and disasters in four countries in the region. However, the analysis of scientific publications revealed that earthquakes, climate change, COVID-19, and terrorism dominate the literature, with governance and management as recurring themes.

CLIMATE (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Spontaneous volunteers and the flood disaster 2021 in Germany: Development of social innovations in flood risk management

Marina Bier, Ramian Fathi, Christiane Stephan, Anke Kahl, Frank Fiedrich, Alexander Fekete

Summary: A large number of spontaneous volunteers (SVs) participated in the flood disaster response in Germany in 2021. They organized coordination services and developed emergent forms of SVs, showing potential to enhance flood management capacities. This article analyzed the findings of an online survey with the aim of discussing the challenges and potentials in developing SVs as social innovations in flood risk management. The results revealed that SVs are highly motivated by values, can experience psychological stress, and are willing to travel long distances, especially when informed through social media. Collaboration between disaster relief organizations and SVs significantly increases satisfaction with authorities. The article proposes preplanning useful concepts to consider safety aspects, utilize ICT, foster mutual respect between SVs and authorities, and support a sense of community as key results for the development of social innovations. It highlights the importance of engaging SVs, particularly in the context of pandemics, social crises like refugee movements, and climate change-related disasters.

JOURNAL OF FLOOD RISK MANAGEMENT (2023)

Review Construction & Building Technology

A Systematic Review of Integrated Frameworks for Resilience and Sustainability Assessments for Critical Infrastructures

Oscar J. Urbina Leal, Alexander Fekete, Rafael Ramirez Eudave, Jose C. Matos, Helder Sousa, Elisabete R. Teixeira

Summary: There is a growing trend to integrate the assessments of resilience and sustainability in critical infrastructures. This paper provides a state-of-the-art review of integrated assessments, examining concepts, indicators, frameworks, and methodologies. The findings suggest that integrated assessments lead to a more strategic use of resources towards more resilient critical infrastructures.

STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING INTERNATIONAL (2023)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Spatial Vulnerability Assessment of Critical Infrastructure Based on Fire Risk through GIS Systems-Case Study: Historic City Center of Guimaraes, Portugal

Oscar Urbina, Helder S. Sousa, Alexander Fekete, Jose Campos Matos, Elisabete Teixeira

APPLIED SCIENCES-BASEL (2023)

Review Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Identification of methodologies to quantify education system resilience-A scoping review

Johannes Duelks, Alexander Fekete, Harald Karutz, Johanne Kaufmann, Corinna Posingies

Summary: Schools and other educational institutions are crucial for the well-being of society, but their continuity is threatened by negative influences such as disasters and violence. To ensure their safety, researchers conducted a scoping review to identify current methodologies for quantifying education system resilience and to explore promising research directions. The review found that existing methodologies differ in scope, level of detail, and complexity, with none performing highly on all dimensions.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DISASTER RISK REDUCTION (2023)

Article Geography

Multi-risks attributed to climate change and urbanization in East Africa: a bibliometric analysis of a science gap

Alexander Fekete, Saravanan Subramanian

Summary: This study used bibliometric analysis to examine research on East Africa, multiple risks, and Climate Change. The findings indicate a lack of studies for many countries in East Africa, particularly in terms of single risk assessments. Furthermore, there is a scarcity of multi-risk assessments that analyze hazard and impact chains. The limited scientific attention focused on only a few cities. These findings are crucial for scientists and policymakers to identify research gaps and areas for further investigation in East Africa for global assessments or science policy reports.

AFRICAN GEOGRAPHICAL REVIEW (2023)

Article Geography

The wisdom of crowds for improved disaster resilience: a near-real-time analysis of crowdsourced social media data on the 2021 flood in Germany

Mahsa Moghadas, Alexander Fekete, Abbas Rajabifard, Theo Koetter

Summary: Transformative disaster resilience in times of climate change requires reflexive governance, socio-technical advancement, co-creation of knowledge, and innovative and bottom-up approaches. Utilizing Web 2.0 knowledge sharing through online social networks can complement existing approaches, understand community dynamics, and incorporate collective intelligence into disaster resilience studies.

GEOJOURNAL (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Surveying the surveyors to address risk perception and adaptive-behaviour cross-study comparability

Samuel Rufat, Mariana Madruga de Brito, Alexander Fekete, Emeline Comby, Peter J. Robinson, Iuliana Armas, W. J. Wouter Botzen, Christian Kuhlicke

Summary: One of the key challenges in risk, vulnerability, and resilience research is how to address the role of risk perceptions and their influence on behavior. The fragmentation of the field makes it difficult to cross-validate existing case studies, hindering comparability and transferability as well as policy and risk management recommendations. To improve collaboration and cumulative knowledge, researchers should establish common requirements, address context-specific aspects, and select comparable and longitudinally monitored questions. A recent international survey revealed the need to ground research design in theory, formalize methods, and compare theories, constructs, and explanations.

NATURAL HAZARDS AND EARTH SYSTEM SCIENCES (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Phasing out of nuclear - Phasing out of risk? Spatial assessment of social vulnerability and exposure to nuclear power plants in Germany

Alexander Fekete

Summary: This study conducts a geospatial analysis to investigate the exposure risk around 41 nuclear power plants in and around Germany. The results show that 40 out of 113 major cities are exposed and vulnerability patterns vary among different population groups. This information can be crucial for evacuation and emergency planning.

PROGRESS IN DISASTER SCIENCE (2022)

No Data Available