4.6 Article

Integrating ecosystem services considerations within a GIS-based habitat suitability index for oyster restoration

Journal

PLOS ONE
Volume 14, Issue 1, Pages -

Publisher

PUBLIC LIBRARY SCIENCE
DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0210936

Keywords

-

Funding

  1. North Carolina Sea Grant [R12-HCE-2]
  2. North Carolina Space Grant Fellowship
  3. National Defense Science and Engineering Graduate Fellowship - Department of Defense, Air Force Office of Scientific Research [FA9550-11-C-0028]
  4. National Defense Science and Engineering Graduate Fellowship - American Society for Engineering Education [32 CFR 168a]
  5. North Carolina Coastal Conservation Association Scholarship
  6. Beneath the Sea Foundation Scholarship
  7. National Science Foundation, Division of Ocean Sciences [OCE-1155609]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Geospatial habitat suitability index (HSI) models have emerged as powerful tools that integrate pertinent spatial information to guide habitat restoration efforts, but have rarely accounted for spatial variation in ecosystem service provision. In this study, we utilized satellite-derived chlorophyll a concentrations for Pamlico Sound, North Carolina, USA in conjunction with data on water flow velocities and dissolved oxygen concentrations to identify potential restoration locations that would maximize the oyster reef-associated ecosystem service of water filtration. We integrated these novel factors associated with oyster water filtration ecosystem services within an existing, 'Metapopulation Persistence' focused GIS-based, HSI model containing biophysical (e.g., salinity, oyster larval connectivity) and logistical(e.g., distance to nearest restoration material stockpile site) factors to identify suitable locations for oyster restoration that maximize long-term persistence of restored oyster populations and water filtration ecosystem service provision. Furthermore, we compared the 'Water Filtration' optimized HSI with the HSI optimized for 'Metapopulation Persistence,' as well as a hybrid model that optimized for both water filtration and metapopulation persistence. Optimal restoration locations (i.e., locations corresponding to the top 1% of suitability scores) were identified that were consistent among the three HSI scenarios (i.e., win-win locations), as well as optimal locations unique to a given HSI scenario (i.e., tradeoff locations). The modeling framework utilized in this study can provide guidance to restoration practitioners to maximize the cost-efficiency and ecosystem services value of habitat restoration efforts. Furthermore, the functional relationships between oyster water filtration and chlorophyll a concentrations, water flow velocities, and dissolved oxygen applied in this study can guide field- and lab-testing of hypotheses related to optimal conditions for oyster reef restoration to maximize water quality enhancement benefits.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.6
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Hurricane impacts on a coral reef soundscape

Kayelyn R. Simmons, David B. Eggleston, DelWayne R. Bohnenstiehl

Summary: Soundscape ecology is a new and powerful approach for assessing habitat quality and ecological response of sound-producing species. This study focused on the impacts of Hurricane Irma on the coral reef soundscape using passive acoustic data collected before, during, and after the storm. The results showed that the coral reef soundscape was relatively resilient to acoustic energy exposure and environmental changes caused by the hurricane on short time scales.

PLOS ONE (2021)

Article Environmental Sciences

Spatiotemporal Variability in Sedimentation Drives Habitat Loss on Restored Subtidal Oyster Reefs

Olivia N. Caretti, DelWayne R. Bohnenstiehl, David B. Eggleston

Summary: The study found that the short-term persistence of restored oyster reefs in Pamlico Sound, North Carolina was influenced by factors such as sediment burial, with reefs in different environmental conditions being affected to varying degrees. Sediment dynamics play a key role in the success of these reefs, with reefs in high-energy environments potentially having limited long-term economic and ecosystem benefits.

ESTUARIES AND COASTS (2021)

Article Environmental Sciences

Opportunities and Challenges for Including Oyster-Mediated Denitrification in Nitrogen Management Plans

Julie M. Rose, J. Stephen Gosnell, Suzanne Bricker, Mark J. Brush, Allison Colden, Lora Harris, Eric Karplus, Alix Laferriere, Nathaniel H. Merrill, Tammy B. Murphy, Joshua Reitsma, Johnny Shockley, Kurt Stephenson, Seth Theuerkauf, Dan Ward, Robinson W. Fulweiler

Summary: Nitrogen pollution poses a significant threat to coastal water quality globally, leading to an increasing demand for governmental regulations and marine policy to address nitrogen pollution. In situ nitrogen reduction practices, including the potential contributions of coastal bivalve shellfish to enhanced denitrification, are being considered as complementary management approaches. However, the incorporation of bivalve-enhanced denitrification into water quality policy remains limited, despite evidence suggesting its effectiveness in nitrogen removal.

ESTUARIES AND COASTS (2021)

Article Ecology

Seascape ecology: identifying research priorities for an emerging ocean sustainability science

S. J. Pittman, K. L. Yates, P. J. Bouchet, D. Alvarez-Berastegui, S. Andrefouet, S. S. Bell, C. Berkstrom, C. Bostrom, C. J. Brown, R. M. Connolly, R. Devillers, D. Eggleston, B. L. Gilby, M. Gullstrom, B. S. Halpern, M. Hidalgo, D. Holstein, K. Hovel, F. Huettmann, E. L. Jackson, W. R. James, J. B. Kellner, C. Y. Kot, V Lecours, C. Lepczyk, I Nagelkerken, J. Nelson, A. D. Olds, R. O. Santos, K. L. Scales, D. C. Schneider, H. T. Schilling, C. Simenstad, I. M. Suthers, E. A. Treml, L. M. Wedding, P. Yates, M. Young

Summary: Seascape ecology, as a marine-centric interdisciplinary science, lacks a coherent prioritization of key research questions. Using a 2-stage Delphi method, this study identified priority research themes including seascape change, connectivity, scale, ecosystem-based management, and emerging technologies. The analysis revealed congruence and discrepancies in priority rankings across different respondent groups.

MARINE ECOLOGY PROGRESS SERIES (2021)

Article Ecology

Testing ecological theories in the Anthropocene: alteration of succession by an invasive marine species

Kayla A. Christianson, David B. Eggleston

Summary: Ecologists use a variety of theories to explain ecological patterns and processes, testing their consistency in an ever-changing world. The recent study in North Carolina found that the colonial tunicate Clavelina oblonga has become a dominant component of the marine fouling community, leading to changes in community structure and reduction in species diversity.

ECOSPHERE (2021)

Review Fisheries

Habitat value of bivalve shellfish and seaweed aquaculture for fish and invertebrates: Pathways, synthesis and next steps

Seth J. Theuerkauf, Luke T. Barrett, Heidi K. Alleway, Barry A. Costa-Pierce, Adam St Gelais, Robert C. Jones

Summary: Aquaculture can negatively impact coastal ecosystems but can also provide valuable ecosystem goods and services, including increasing the abundance and species richness of wild, mobile macrofauna. The cultivation of bivalve shellfish and seaweed can positively influence the structure and function of faunal communities through various mechanisms such as providing structured habitat and food resources.

REVIEWS IN AQUACULTURE (2022)

Article Ecology

Metapopulation dynamics of oysters: sources, sinks, and implications for conservation and restoration

Seth J. Theuerkauf, Brandon J. Puckett, David B. Eggleston

Summary: This study applied a spatially explicit model to simulate the dynamics of an Eastern oyster metapopulation in the Albemarle-Pamlico Estuarine System, showing an overall stable but slightly declining metapopulation, reef type-specific population trajectories depending on larval recruitment variation, greater importance of inter-reef larval connectivity on metapopulation dynamics than local larval retention, and the need for continued protection of oyster sanctuaries.

ECOSPHERE (2021)

Article Ecology

Reef design and site hydrodynamics mediate oyster restoration and marsh stabilization outcomes

Emory H. Wellman, Christopher J. Baillie, Brandon J. Puckett, Sarah E. Donaher, Stacy N. Trackenberg, Rachel K. Gittman

Summary: To protect coastal areas and minimize the negative ecological impacts of artificial shoreline protection methods, the use of natural and nature-based infrastructure (NNBI) is recommended. By studying reefs constructed from different substrates in varying environmental conditions, it was found that oyster-based NNBI provided shoreline protection in high-energy environments but not in low-energy environments. Both high-energy and low-energy shorelines experienced retreat and decline in marsh vegetation density.

ECOLOGICAL APPLICATIONS (2022)

Article Biology

A global and regional view of the opportunity for climate-smart mariculture

Heidi K. Alleway, Alice R. Jones, Seth J. Theuerkauf, Robert C. Jones

Summary: This study evaluated the vulnerabilities of mariculture in 171 coastal countries to climate change and the opportunities for climate mitigation outcomes. Regions such as Northern America and Europe were found to have lower vulnerability and higher impact on climate mitigation, with countries like Australia, Canada, and France well-positioned to advance strategies linked to mariculture.

PHILOSOPHICAL TRANSACTIONS OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY B-BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES (2022)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Spatiotemporal Variation in Coral Assemblages and Reef Habitat Complexity among Shallow Fore-Reef Sites in the Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary

Kayelyn R. Simmons, DelWayne R. Bohnenstiehl, David B. Eggleston

Summary: This study characterizes the changes in abiotic and biotic features of coral reefs in the Florida Keys, USA, and finds that protected sites generally have higher live coral cover compared to fished sites with complex physical features. The study also highlights the importance of within-site variation in driving site separation.

DIVERSITY-BASEL (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Spatial Variation in Nursery Habitat Use by Juvenile Blue Crabs in a Shallow, Wind-Driven Estuary

Erin P. Voigt, David B. Eggleston

Summary: This study highlights how regional postlarval dispersal patterns and local-scale factors affect nursery habitat use by blue crabs when multiple habitats are present in a seascape.

ESTUARIES AND COASTS (2023)

Article Fisheries

Timing and route of migration of mature female blue crabs in a large, wind-driven estuary

Geoffrey W. Bell, David B. Eggleston

Summary: The study used mark-recapture data collected by commercial crabbers to quantify the timing and routes of mature female blue crab migration in the CAPES in North Carolina. The results showed that mature female blue crabs consistently moved towards the Oregon Inlet spawning sanctuary in early summer. The majority of recaptures were concentrated in the area where Albemarle, Currituck, and Croatan sounds merge.

TRANSACTIONS OF THE AMERICAN FISHERIES SOCIETY (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

What evidence exists on the performance of nature-based solutions interventions for coastal protection in biogenic, shallow ecosystems? A systematic map protocol

Avery B. Paxton, Trevor N. Riley, Camille L. Steenrod, Carter S. Smith, Y. Stacy Zhang, Rachel K. Gittman, Brian R. Silliman, Christine A. Buckel, T. Shay Viehman, Brandon J. Puckett, Jenny Davis

Summary: This study aims to fill gaps in our understanding of the performance of nature-based solutions (NBS) for coastal protection. We will identify and collate evidence on the performance of active NBS interventions in salt marsh, seagrass, kelp, mangrove, shellfish reef, and coral reef systems. The resulting knowledge will inform future coastal protection efforts.

ENVIRONMENTAL EVIDENCE (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

A Novel Multitemporal Approach for Satellite-Derived Bathymetry for Coastal Waters of Palau

Chunyue Wei, Seth J. Theuerkauf

Summary: This study utilized a novel multitemporal workflow to estimate accurate bathymetry in Palau. Among various methodological options, the polynomial model built upon bilinearly interpolated mean composition data performed the best, accurately estimating water depth up to 13.7 m. This multitemporal approach could be applied to other regions for gap-free and accurate bathymetry estimations.

JOURNAL OF COASTAL RESEARCH (2021)

No Data Available