4.7 Article

Attenuation of Storm Surges by Coastal Mangroves

Journal

GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH LETTERS
Volume 46, Issue 5, Pages 2680-2689

Publisher

AMER GEOPHYSICAL UNION
DOI: 10.1029/2018GL081636

Keywords

mangrove; flood; coastal protection; inundation; analytic; vegetation

Funding

  1. Natural Hazards Platform [C05X0907]
  2. Marsden Fund [14-UOW-011]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The interaction between mangroves and storm surges is explored using an analytical solution. A simplified momentum equation, balancing vegetation drag and pressure gradient, is combined with the continuity equation resulting in a diffusion equation. Assuming a simplified environment, a one-dimensional analytical solution is obtained to predict peak surge level across a forest. The solution accurately reproduces peak water level of a 10-year return period flood event in mangroves in the Firth of Thames, New Zealand, and in Ten Thousand Islands, Florida, during Hurricane Charley. Vegetation properties that determine the capacity of mangroves to reduce surges are forest density and cross-shore extent. Storm characteristicsflood duration and peak water level at the forest fringealso influence surge attenuation. Mangroves are shown to be an effective form of coastal flood protection if forests are sufficiently wide/dense, relative to the surge decay length scale, to restrict water exchange during a storm. Plain Language Summary Storm-driven flooding is a major hazard in low-lying coastal areas. Mangroves have previously been shown to provide effective coastal protection from storm waves. However, there is sparse evidence that mangroves reduce storm surge, which is the temporary increase in water level resulting from the combination of high winds and low atmospheric pressure during a weather event. Here we demonstrate that mangroves can reduce water flow and store water, thus helping to reduce peak surge water levels. We show that if forests are sufficiently wide, water levels within (and landward of) the mangroves are substantially lower than for a scenario in which mangroves are absent. The density of the vegetation, cross-shore extent of the forest, and characteristics of the surge (duration and amplitude) all influence water-level reduction in the forest.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Geography, Physical

Relating millimeter-scale turbulence to meter-scale subtidal erosion and accretion across the fringe of a coastal mangrove forest

Benjamin K. Norris, Julia C. Mullarney, Karin R. Bryan, Stephen M. Henderson

Summary: The spatial variability in vegetation density controls sediment transport at sub-meter scales within a wave-exposed mangrove forest. Infragravity waves are likely drivers of sediment transport within the mangrove forest. Near-bed turbulent kinetic energy is correlated with bed level changes in both the mangrove forest and the unvegetated mudflat.

EARTH SURFACE PROCESSES AND LANDFORMS (2021)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

A Multiscale Approach to Shoreline Prediction

Jennifer Montano, Giovanni Coco, Laura Cagigal, Fernando Mendez, Ana Rueda, Karin R. Bryan, Mitchell D. Harley

Summary: Shorelines respond to various drivers on different time-scales, with changes at longer time-scales often superimposed on shorter ones. A new approach using Complete Ensemble Empirical Mode Decomposition successfully predicted shoreline evolution from storm events to decadal timescales. By linking model drivers with shoreline position on multiple time-scales, the approach outperformed common shoreline models when using SLP and wave information. Prediction of shoreline changes over months, years, or decades remains a challenging task due to the complex interplay of different factors influencing beach dynamics.

GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2021)

Article Geography, Physical

Drag variations, tidal asymmetry and tidal range changes in a mangrove creek system

Erik M. Horstman, Karin R. Bryan, Julia C. Mullarney

Summary: The interaction between creek flow and sheet flow in a mangrove creek system plays a crucial role in driving tidal asymmetries and reducing high-water conditions.

EARTH SURFACE PROCESSES AND LANDFORMS (2021)

Article Geography, Physical

The effects of wind-generated currents on velocity asymmetry in tidal basins with varying geometries

Peter J. de Ruiter, Julia C. Mullarney, Karin R. Bryan

Summary: The study reveals that wind plays a significant role in influencing velocity asymmetry in shallow tidal basins, with higher wind speeds leading to more extreme asymmetry patterns. Wind primarily affects mean and peak flow velocities in the basins, with limited impact on tidal harmonics. The depth-dependent velocity asymmetry patterns are most pronounced for wind speeds of 6 m/s and greater, and for wind directions parallel to the main axes of the basins' tidal channels.

EARTH SURFACE PROCESSES AND LANDFORMS (2022)

Review Environmental Sciences

Nature-Based Engineering: A Review on Reducing Coastal Flood Risk With Mangroves

Rik Gijsman, Erik M. M. Horstman, Daphne van der Wal, Daniel A. A. Friess, Andrew Swales, Kathelijne M. M. Wijnberg

Summary: Mangroves are increasingly recognized as a sustainable and cost-effective alternative for reducing coastal flood risk due to their functionality and persistence. However, the complex implementation of mangroves in flood risk reduction requires improving insights, advancing tools, and adopting an adaptive management approach to enhance their functionality and persistence. Further research efforts on quantifying the variability and uncertainty of mangrove functionality and persistence are necessary for successful integration into coastal flood risk management.

FRONTIERS IN MARINE SCIENCE (2021)

Article Geography, Physical

Decadal-scale impacts of changing mangrove extent on hydrodynamics and sediment transport in a quiescent, mesotidal estuary

Hannah E. Glover, Debra J. Stokes, Andrea S. Ogston, Karin R. Bryan, Conrad A. Pilditch

Summary: This study investigates the impact of mangrove extent on the Waikaraka Estuary in Tauranga Harbor, New Zealand, using in-situ observations and numerical modeling. The results show that fine sediment is unlikely to be flushed out of the estuary after mangrove removal and the hydrodynamics are mainly controlled by tidal interactions with bathymetry rather than the presence of mangrove vegetation.

EARTH SURFACE PROCESSES AND LANDFORMS (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Facilitating Salt Marsh Restoration: The Importance of Event-Based Bed Level Dynamics and Seasonal Trends in Bed Level Change

Pim W. J. M. Willemsen, Erik M. Horstman, Tjeerd J. Bouma, Martin J. Baptist, Marinka E. B. van Puijenbroek, Bas W. Borsje

Summary: This study aims to assess event-based and seasonal bed level dynamics for vegetation presence in natural and semi-natural salt marshes and to provide generic thresholds for vegetation presence. The study found that short-term bed level dynamics have a significant impact on vegetation presence, while seasonal dynamics do not have a clear threshold for vegetation presence. These findings are important for the management and restoration of salt marsh ecosystems.

FRONTIERS IN MARINE SCIENCE (2022)

Article Soil Science

Climatic influences on active layer depth between 2000 and 2018 in the McMurdo Dry Valleys, Ross Sea Region, Antarctica

A. G. Carshalton, M. R. Balks, T. A. O'Neill, K. R. Bryan, C. A. Seybold

Summary: The maximum seasonal depth of thaw in permafrost soils, known as the active layer depth, is influenced by various soil and atmospheric variables. Monitoring data from soil climate stations in the McMurdo Dry Valleys between 1999 and 2012 revealed significant variations in active layer depth and temperature at the top of the permafrost. However, there were no clear trends of increase or decrease during the period from 2000 to 2018. Wavelet analysis showed correlations between global and regional climate systems and de-seasonalized permafrost temperatures. Although the dataset is currently too short to draw conclusions about long-term changes, it serves as a valuable baseline for future assessments.

GEODERMA REGIONAL (2022)

Review Geochemistry & Geophysics

Marshes and Mangroves as Nature-Based Coastal Storm Buffers

Stijn Temmerman, Erik M. Horstman, Ken W. Krauss, Julia C. Mullarney, Ignace Pelckmans, Ken Schoutens

Summary: Tidal wetlands are popular for mitigating coastal storm impacts, but their effectiveness varies depending on the conditions and types of hazards. While they can attenuate short-period storm-induced waves effectively, they are less effective in mitigating long-period storm surges. Storm damage to vegetation, especially mangrove trees, can be significant and recovery may take years. Combined with other stressors, wetland persistence can be compromised, emphasizing the need for adaptive management strategies in nature-based coastal defense projects.

ANNUAL REVIEW OF MARINE SCIENCE (2023)

Article Oceanography

Modeling the effects of aerial temperature and exposure period on intertidal mudflat profiles

Hieu M. Nguyen, Karin R. Bryan, Zeng Zhou, Conrad A. Pilditch

Summary: This research demonstrates how the effect of exposure to air on intertidal flat profile development in cohesive coastal environments can be incorporated into applied numerical modelling. The findings show that the stabilizing effect of exposure leads to a more flat-topped shape of intertidal mudflats, and higher air temperatures have a greater impact on bed level change.

CONTINENTAL SHELF RESEARCH (2022)

Article Oceanography

The role of mangroves in coastal flood protection: The importance of channelization

J. M. Montgomery, K. R. Bryan

Summary: The extent of flood protection provided by mangrove forests varies due to differences in tree growth characteristics and local geomorphology. A model experiment in Tauranga, New Zealand, showed that the distribution and channelization of vegetation have a greater impact on flood attenuation than vegetation density. Additionally, a forest with sloping topography reduces the rate at which long wave attenuation occurs.

CONTINENTAL SHELF RESEARCH (2022)

Article Fisheries

The advantages and limitations of biophysical modelling as a tool for informing limit setting in New Zealand's barrier-enclosed estuaries

Karin R. Bryan, Benjamin T. Stewart, Alex M. Port, Hannah F. E. Jones, Conrad A. Pilditch

Summary: Estuaries are complex environments where catchment-derived contaminants interact with estuarine geomorphology and hydrodynamics. Biophysical modelling can help understand spatial variations in water quality, but decision-making based on specific details may be limited by nonlinear interactions and inherent constraints.

NEW ZEALAND JOURNAL OF MARINE AND FRESHWATER RESEARCH (2022)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

On the Influence of Antecedent Morphology on Development of Equilibrium Bathymetry in Estuaries Past and Future

Amin Rahdarian, Karin R. Bryan, Mick Van der Wegen

Summary: This study examines the impact of initial bathymetry on the establishment of estuarine equilibrium and the response to sea-level rise. The findings highlight the importance of initial bathymetric conditions in predicting coastal response to changes such as sea-level rise.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-EARTH SURFACE (2022)

Article Ecology

Protective structures as adaptive management strategy in Nature-based Solutions to mitigate sea level rise effects

Tynke R. Siegersma, Pim W. J. M. Willemsen, Erik M. Horstman, Zhan Hu, Bas W. Borsje

Summary: This study examines the integration of salt marshes with traditional coastal protection structures as nature-based solutions (NbS) in the face of climate change and analyzes the combined impact of sea level rise and marsh-supporting management measures on vegetation establishment. The research identifies thresholds for vegetation establishment in terms of monthly inundation percentages and bed level changes and shows that the implementation of a brushwood dam can facilitate the establishment of vegetation further seaward. However, predicted sea level rise may cause vegetation retreat, which can be delayed by the presence and positioning of a protective structure.

ECOLOGICAL ENGINEERING (2023)

No Data Available