4.1 Review

Virtual Reality Simulation in Nontechnical Skills Training for Healthcare Professionals A Systematic Review

Publisher

LIPPINCOTT WILLIAMS & WILKINS
DOI: 10.1097/SIH.0000000000000347

Keywords

Virtual reality simulation; nontechnical skills; healthcare training; medical education; systematic review

Funding

  1. French Ministry of Research and Education as part of the Laboratoires d'Excellence, Labex CominLabs

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This systematic review, conducted in accordance with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines, is aimed to review current research in virtual reality (VR) for healthcare training, specifically pertaining to nontechnical skills. PsycInfo and Medline databases were queried for relevant articles published through December 2017. Of the 1377 publications identified, 80 were assessed for eligibility and 26 were finally included in the qualitative synthesis. Overall, the use of virtual training for nontechnical skills is recent in healthcare education and has increased since 2010. Screen-based VR simulators or virtual worlds are the most frequently used systems. The nontechnical skills addressed in VR simulation include mainly teamwork, communication, and situation awareness. Most studies evaluate the usability and acceptability of VR simulation, and few studies have measured the effects of VR simulation on nontechnical skills development.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.1
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Review Urology & Nephrology

Ethical implications of AI in robotic surgical training: A Delphi consensus statement

Justin W. Collins, Hani J. Marcus, Ahmed Ghazi, Ashwin Sridhar, Daniel Hashimoto, Gregory Hager, Alberto Arezzo, Pierre Jannin, Lena Maier-Hein, Keno Marz, Pietro Valdastri, Kensaku Mori, Daniel Elson, Stamatia Giannarou, Mark Slack, Luke Hares, Yanick Beaulieu, Jeff Levy, Guy Laplante, Arvind Ramadorai, Anthony Jarc, Ben Andrews, Pablo Garcia, Huzefa Neemuchwala, Alina Andrusaite, Tom Kimpe, David Hawkes, John D. Kelly, Danail Stoyanov

Summary: This study provides ethical guidance on developing narrow AI applications for surgical training by seeking consensus from an expert committee. The results show consensus in multiple areas, including data protection and privacy, reproducibility and transparency, predictive analytics, inherent biases, and areas of training most likely to benefit from AI. This provides an ethical foundation for launching narrow AI applications in surgical training.

EUROPEAN UROLOGY FOCUS (2022)

Article Psychology, Multidisciplinary

Stay at home! When personality profiles influence mental health and creativity during the COVID-19 lockdown

Estelle Michinov, Nicolas Michinov

Summary: This study explored the psychological reactions of individuals during home confinement and found that personality traits have an impact on mental health and creativity. The results showed that preference for solitude and the Big Five personality traits predict individuals' mental health and creativity. Additionally, individuals were categorized into three types, each exhibiting different psychological characteristics and levels of creativity.

CURRENT PSYCHOLOGY (2023)

Article Computer Science, Artificial Intelligence

Surgical data science-from concepts toward clinical translation

Lena Maier-Hein, Matthias Eisenmann, Duygu Sarikaya, Keno Maerz, Toby Collins, Anand Malpani, Johannes Fallert, Hubertus Feussner, Stamatia Giannarou, Pietro Mascagni, Hirenkumar Nakawala, Adrian Park, Carla Pugh, Danail Stoyanov, Swaroop S. Vedula, Kevin Cleary, Gabor Fichtinger, Germain Forestier, Bernard Gibaud, Teodor Grantcharov, Makoto Hashizume, Doreen Heckmann-Noetzel, Hannes G. Kenngott, Ron Kikinis, Lars Muendermann, Nassir Navab, Sinan Onogur, Tobias Ross, Raphael Sznitman, Russell H. Taylor, Minu D. Tizabi, Martin Wagner, Gregory D. Hager, Thomas Neumuth, Nicolas Padoy, Justin Collins, Ines Gockel, Jan Goedeke, Daniel A. Hashimoto, Luc Joyeux, Kyle Lam, Daniel R. Leff, Amin Madani, Hani J. Marcus, Ozanan Meireles, Alexander Seitel, Dogu Teber, Frank Ueckert, Beat P. Mueller-Stich, Pierre Jannin, Stefanie Speidel

Summary: Surgical Data Science is a new research field aiming to improve interventional healthcare quality through data analysis, yet lacks translational success stories in surgery. An international workshop reviewed current practice, key achievements, infrastructure, data annotation and sharing, and data analytics standards and tools relevant to the field.

MEDICAL IMAGE ANALYSIS (2022)

Review Surgery

Review of automated performance metrics to assess surgical technical skills in robot-assisted laparoscopy

Sonia Guerin, Arnaud Huaulme, Vincent Lavoue, Pierre Jannin, Krystel Nyangoh Timoh

Summary: In this systematic review, 16 studies were included to assess the use of APMs in robot-assisted laparoscopic procedures. APMs were found to be useful in differentiating expertise levels, validating VR modules, predicting outcomes, and integrating datasets. Some studies also showed correlations between APMs and clinical outcomes. Further research and validation are needed to confirm these associations, especially for non-urological procedures.

SURGICAL ENDOSCOPY AND OTHER INTERVENTIONAL TECHNIQUES (2022)

Editorial Material Surgery

Bias in machine learning for computer-assisted surgery and medical image processing

John S. H. Baxter, Pierre Jannin

COMPUTER ASSISTED SURGERY (2022)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Effects of verbal and visual support on learning by tablet-based drawing

Eric Jamet, Estelle Michinov

Summary: The use of drawing as a learning strategy can enhance learning of pictorial information, but it requires suitable support. Providing visual or verbal support improves the quality of drawings and the recall of pictorial information, but does not have a significant impact on comprehension.

COMPUTERS & EDUCATION (2022)

Article Psychology, Multidisciplinary

Work-From-Home During COVID-19 Lockdown: When Employees' Well-Being and Creativity Depend on Their Psychological Profiles

Estelle Michinov, Caroline Ruiller, Frederique Chedotel, Virginie Dodeler, Nicolas Michinov

Summary: This study examines the effects of working from home on employees' well-being and performance, and whether these effects vary depending on employees' psychological profiles. The results demonstrate that employees with a preference for solitude experience higher levels of loneliness, stress, and lower levels of job satisfaction and work engagement. They also perceive themselves as less creative and produce fewer ideas compared to employees with an affinity for social interaction.

FRONTIERS IN PSYCHOLOGY (2022)

Article Psychology, Educational

Can Sitting Postures Influence the Creative Mind? Positive Effect of Contractive Posture on Convergent-Integrative Thinking

Nicolas Michinov, Estelle Michinov

Summary: This study provides empirical evidence for the impact of body postures on creative thinking, showing that sitting in a contractive posture can enhance creative performance in a convergent-integrative thinking task.

CREATIVITY RESEARCH JOURNAL (2022)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

The Moderating Role of Emotional Intelligence on the Relationship Between Conflict Management Styles and Burnout among Firefighters

Estelle Michinov

Summary: There is a relationship between conflict management style, emotional intelligence, and burnout among firefighters. The integrating conflict style and awareness and management of one's own emotions can reduce burnout.

SAFETY AND HEALTH AT WORK (2022)

Article Psychology, Applied

Workaholism and Flow at Work in French Neurosurgery Residents at Risk of Burnout: A Latent Profile Analysis

Geraldine Rouxel, Estelle Michinov, Clement Baumgarten, Vincent Bonneterre, Emmanuel Gay, Pierre-Hugues Roche

Summary: This study investigates the combined effects of flow experience and workaholism on burnout among neurosurgery residents. The results indicate that there are significant differences in burnout between individuals with high flow experience and low flow experience. Additionally, residents with higher levels of neuroticism are more susceptible to burnout due to their lower levels of flow experience at work.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF STRESS MANAGEMENT (2023)

Article Engineering, Biomedical

Virtual reality environments to train soft skills in medical and nursing education: a technical feasibility study between France and Japan

Marie Le Duff, Estelle Michinov, Marie-Stephanie Bracq, Nobutaka Mukae, Masatoshi Eto, Jeanne Descamps, Makoto Hashizume, Pierre Jannin

Summary: In order to meet the urgent and massive training needs of healthcare professionals, the use of digital technologies is becoming increasingly relevant. However, cultural differences are rarely taken into account when implementing these training environments, despite their impact on medical skills learning.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF COMPUTER ASSISTED RADIOLOGY AND SURGERY (2023)

Article Nursing

Protective resources against stress among student nurses: Influences of self-efficacy, emotional intelligence and conflict management styles

Estelle Michinov, Gael Robin, Brivael Hemon, Remi Beranger, Marielle Boissart

Summary: This study investigated the stress levels among French student nurses and the impact of personal resources on their well-being. The results showed that self-efficacy played a major role in determining stress and well-being, and these effects were partially mediated by emotional awareness.

NURSE EDUCATION IN PRACTICE (2024)

Article Psychology, Multidisciplinary

Learning by tablet-based drawing: Effects of verbal support among secondary-school students

Julie Rochat, Eric Jamet, Estelle Michinov

Summary: Recent studies have shown that learner-generated drawing has mixed effects on learning that depend on the level of support provided during the task. This study examined the effects of verbal support during tablet-based drawing and found that it had positive effects on complex drawing quality and monitoring accuracy. However, it did not have an effect on the comprehension or memorization of the textual information that had to be drawn. Furthermore, verbal support appeared to divert learners' attention from other textual elements, resulting in poorer memory performance for those elements.

ANNEE PSYCHOLOGIQUE (2022)

Article Neuroimaging

An ecological approach to identify distinct neural correlates of disinhibition in frontotemporal dementia

Delphine Tanguy, Benedicte Batrancourt, Alfonso Estudillo-Romero, John S. H. Baxter, Isabelle Le Ber, Arabella Bouzigues, Valerie Godefroy, Aurelie Funkiewiez, Celine Chamayou, Emmanuelle Volle, Dario Saracino, Armelle Rametti-Lacroux

Summary: Disinhibition is a core symptom of many neurodegenerative diseases, particularly frontotemporal dementia. This study used a semi-ecological situation to assess behavioural disinhibition and found that patients with frontotemporal dementia exhibited more compulsivity and social disinhibition than controls. The behavioural metrics were related to cognitive performance, with compulsivity correlated with semantic appraisal network and social disinhibition associated with the frontal component of the salience network.

NEUROIMAGE-CLINICAL (2022)

Article Psychology, Multidisciplinary

When emotional intelligence predicts team performance: Further validation of the short version of the Workgroup Emotional Intelligence Profile

Estelle Michinov, Nicolas Michinov

Summary: The purpose of this research was to validate the short version of the Workgroup Emotional Intelligence Profile (WEIP-S) in predicting team performance. The study conducted six research studies and found that WEIP-S has a reliable four-factor structure and can effectively predict team performance.

CURRENT PSYCHOLOGY (2022)

No Data Available