4.5 Review

Construct and criterion-related validation of nutrient profiling models: A systematic review of the literature

Journal

APPETITE
Volume 100, Issue -, Pages 26-40

Publisher

ACADEMIC PRESS LTD- ELSEVIER SCIENCE LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.appet.2016.02.001

Keywords

Nutrient profiling; Nutrition labelling; Systematic review; Validity

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Nutrient profiling (NP) is defined as the science of ranking foods according to their nutritional composition for the purpose of preventing disease or promoting health. The application of NP is ultimately to assist consumers to make healthier food choices, and thus provide a cost effective public health strategy to reduce the incidence of diet-related chronic disease. To our knowledge, no review has assessed the evidence to confirm the validity of NP models. We conducted a systematic review to investigate the construct and criterion-related validity of NP models in ranking food according to their nutritional composition for the purpose of preventing disease and promoting health. We searched peer-reviewed research published to 30 June 2015 and used PUBMED, Global Health (CABI), and SCOPUS databases. Within study bias was assessed using an adapted version of the QUADAS-2 (Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies -2) tool for all diagnostic studies and the Cochrane Collaboration's Risk of Bias tool for all non-diagnostic studies. The GRADE (Grades of Recommendation, Assessment, Development, and Evaluation) approach was used to guide our judgement of the quality of the body of evidence for each outcome measure. From a total of 83 studies, 69 confirmed the construct validity of NP models; however most of these studies contained methodological weaknesses. Six studies used objective external measures to confirm the criterion-related validity of NP models; which inherently improved quality. The overall quality of evidence on the accuracy of NP models was judged to be very low to moderate using the GRADE approach. Many carefully designed studies to establish both construct and criterion-related validity are necessary to authenticate the application of NP models and provide the evidence to support the current definition of NP. (C) 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Nutrition & Dietetics

Outcomes of a nutrition service provided by dietitians at a major multi-cultural competition event: An observational study

Fiona E. Pelly, Hattie H. Wright

Summary: The study aimed to describe the outcomes of a nutrition service led by dietitians at the 2017 Taipei Universiade, including consultations, weight checks, skinfold measures, and nutrition analysis. Most athletes seeking nutrition consultation had not received previous support, desired performance-related meal plans, and had diets adequate in micronutrients but lacking in calcium, vegetables, and dairy products. The majority of athletes did not follow a specific diet for their sport, used sports supplements, performance enhancers, and vitamin-mineral supplements, but had low confidence in their nutrition knowledge and application.

NUTRITION & DIETETICS (2021)

Article Nutrition & Dietetics

Inclusion of Nutrition Expertise in Catering Operations at a Major Global Sporting Event: A Qualitative Case Study Using a Foodservice Systems Approach

Fiona E. Pelly, Judith Tweedie

Summary: This study aimed to gain in-depth insights from key stakeholders on the integration of nutrition into catering operations of major sporting events, mapping this to the foodservice systems model. Semistructured interviews were conducted during and after the 2018 Commonwealth Games in Australia, revealing 8 themes related to planning, refining processes, menu improvement, technology, food allergies, organization controls, workforce experience, and client knowledge of nutrition. The logic model showed that the system is driven by policy and budget before and during planning, but is influenced by the environment during operation.

JOURNAL OF THE ACADEMY OF NUTRITION AND DIETETICS (2021)

Article Nutrition & Dietetics

Key concepts for dietetic curriculum: An observational study of Australian dietitians' perceptions

Judith Tweedie, Hattie H. Wright, Claire Palermo, Fiona E. Pelly

Summary: The study found that more than 65% of Accredited Practising Dietitians (APDs) agreed that all 56 concepts were relevant, but there was less agreement on certain concepts such as leadership and sustainability. Respondents working in different areas tended to have differing opinions on key concepts. No new concepts were identified.

NUTRITION & DIETETICS (2021)

Article Nutrition & Dietetics

Development and validation of a questionnaire investigating endurance athletes practices to manage gastrointestinal symptoms around exercise

Rachel Scrivin, Ricardo J. S. Costa, Fiona Pelly, Dana Lis, Gary Slater

Summary: This study developed and validated a questionnaire on endurance athletes' carbohydrate beliefs, knowledge, and dietary practices related to exercise-associated gastrointestinal symptoms. The questionnaire's validity and reliability were ensured through the Delphi technique and a five-phase validity process. Results showed that the questionnaire is a valid and reliable tool for clinicians and research purposes.

NUTRITION & DIETETICS (2021)

Article Nutrition & Dietetics

A qualitative exploration of the future of nutrition and dietetics in Australia and New Zealand: Implications for the workforce

Rachel Boak, Claire Palermo, Eleanor J. Beck, Craig Patch, Fiona Pelly, Clare Wall, Danielle Gallegos

Summary: This study aimed to explore the future roles of nutrition and dietetics professionals and identify the capabilities they would need. The results revealed that future roles include being food aficionados, diet optimizers, knowledge translators, and equity champions, among others, with science as the underlying framework. In addition, 16 critical capabilities were considered essential for practice.

NUTRITION & DIETETICS (2022)

Review Education & Educational Research

The implementation of interprofessional education: a scoping review

Fiona Bogossian, Karen New, Kendall George, Nigel Barr, Natalie Dodd, Anita L. Hamilton, Gregory Nash, Nicole Masters, Fiona Pelly, Carol Reid, Rebekah Shakhovskoy, Jane Taylor

Summary: This review study summarises the evidence for the implementation of IPE and identifies challenges and key lessons to guide faculty in the implementation process.

ADVANCES IN HEALTH SCIENCES EDUCATION (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Reliability of the Athlete Food Choice Questionnaire in Diverse Settings

Rachael L. Thurecht, Fiona E. Pelly, Sarah Burkhart

Summary: Understanding the factors that influence athletes' food choice is crucial for optimizing dietary intake. This study examined the reliability of the Athlete Food Choice Questionnaire (AFCQ) in an online setting outside of competition events. The results showed acceptable reliability for most factors, indicating that the AFCQ is a reliable tool for understanding athlete eating behaviors.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH AND PUBLIC HEALTH (2022)

Review Sport Sciences

Determinants of Food Choice in Athletes: A Systematic Scoping Review

Fiona E. Pelly, Rachael L. Thurecht, Gary Slater

Summary: This scoping review examines the determinants of food choice in athletes. The results show that athletes' food choices are influenced by various factors, including competition season, level of experience, sporting culture, athlete background, and food environment. However, further research is needed, particularly on different cohorts of athletes and specifically female athletes.

SPORTS MEDICINE-OPEN (2022)

Article Nutrition & Dietetics

The Kraft Heinz Company global nutrition targets for the innovation and reformulation of food and beverages: Current and future directions

Lynn Yu, Veronique Braesco, Sheri L. Cooper, Adam Drewnowski, Bridget Hannon Esteves, Andrea Luigi Budelli

Summary: Reforming packaged foods has the potential to improve the nutrient density of the global diet. The Kraft Heinz Company's approach to product (re)formulation aims to develop healthier product lines that are lower in saturated fats, total sugars, and sodium while containing health promoting components. The company has established global nutrition targets, taking into consideration various factors such as product characteristics, regulations, technology, sensory aspects, and safety constraints, to guide their innovation and renovation efforts.

FRONTIERS IN NUTRITION (2023)

Letter Nutrition & Dietetics

Concept-based curricula: Alignment with the 2021 National Competency Standards for Dietitians in Australia

Judith Tweedie, Fiona E. Pelly, Claire Palermo, Hattie H. Wright

NUTRITION & DIETETICS (2023)

Article Nutrition & Dietetics

Carbohydrate knowledge, beliefs, and intended practices, of endurance athletes who report exercise-associated gastrointestinal symptoms

Rachel Scrivin, Ricardo J. S. Costa, Fiona Pelly, Dana Lis, Gary Slater

Summary: This study examined the carbohydrate (CHO) knowledge, beliefs, and intended practices of endurance athletes with and without exercise-associated gastrointestinal symptoms (Ex-GIS). A total of 201 endurance athletes completed an online questionnaire, with 137 experiencing Ex-GIS and 64 without. The results showed that athletes correctly identified CHO and non-CHO food sources and believed that consuming CHO around training sessions and competitions enhances athletic performance.

FRONTIERS IN NUTRITION (2023)

Article Nutrition & Dietetics

Validation of a Turkish Version of the Athlete Food Choice Questionnaire

Yonca Sevim, Rachael L. Thurecht, Fiona E. Pelly

Summary: This study validated the Turkish Athlete Food Choice Questionnaire (Turkish-AFCQ) and identified the main factors influencing food choices for athletes. The factor that most influenced food choices was 'performance', while the factors with the least influence were 'influence of others' and 'food values and beliefs'.

NUTRIENTS (2023)

Article Nutrition & Dietetics

Evaluation of an Environmental Nutrition Intervention at the 2018 Commonwealth Games

Fiona E. Pelly, Rachael L. Thurecht

Summary: This study investigated the implementation of nutrition schemes before and during the 2018 Commonwealth Games and evaluated these schemes through staff training satisfaction, athlete feedback, and quality assurance checks. Overall, participants found the schemes helpful in meeting their dietary needs, and the majority gave positive ratings for service speed, staff politeness, and menu knowledge. By taking a whole systems approach, more suitable food provision to meet the dietary needs of athletes was achieved.

NUTRIENTS (2023)

Review Sport Sciences

Food Provision at the Olympic Games in the New Millennium: A Meta-narrative Review

Fiona E. E. Pelly, Judith Tweedie, Helen O'Connor

Summary: This meta-narrative review aims to examine the literature on food provision and nutrition support at the Olympic and Paralympic Games over the past 21 years. The results suggest that changes in athletes' dining expectations, organizing committee budgets, expert input, and global trends have influenced food delivery. The study highlights the potential of the Olympic Games' food environment to shape athletes' dietary choices and adapt to contemporary challenges such as COVID-19 and sustainability targets.

SPORTS MEDICINE-OPEN (2023)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Perceptions of the Impact of COVID-19 Countermeasures on Safe Foodservice Provision at International Sporting Competitions: A Qualitative Study

Angela C. Dufour, Fiona E. Pelly, Judith Tweedie, Hattie Wright

Summary: In the past two years, the COVID-19 pandemic has significantly affected the foodservice sector, particularly in adhering to new food provision guidelines. Communal eating areas at international sporting events are considered high-risk for infectious disease transmission. This study explored the perceptions, preparedness, and challenges of stakeholders involved in providing food at major athletic competitions during the pandemic. The findings highlighted the impact of COVID-19 on foodservice systems, including concerns about sustainability practices, increased waste management, costs, and the negative impact on the social dining experience.

SUSTAINABILITY (2023)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Food fussiness is associated with family environmental factors in 1-3-year-old children: A large-scale cross-sectional study

Hugues Piloquet, Benoit Berge, Pascal Maigret, Veronique Hospital

Summary: This study aimed to explore the effects of environmental factors on eating behavior and food intake in toddlers. The results showed that food fussiness was more common in older children, children conceived with medical assistance, children exposed to distractions during meals, rewarded by parents to finish meals, free to eat at will, and those who ate only occasionally with the whole family. Unsatisfactory dietary diversification was not significantly associated with any variable.

APPETITE (2024)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Fibre4life: Investigating older adults dietary fibre preferences and the role of targeted educational materials on modulating future dietary fibre intake

Victoria Norton, Julie A. Lovegrove, Marcus Tindall, Julia Rodriguez Garcia, Stella Lignou

Summary: The UK's aging population requires promotion of balanced nutrition, with a particular focus on increasing dietary fiber intake. Surveys involving older adults showed their willingness to learn about dietary fiber and the need for accessible information. Educational materials proved effective in engaging older adults and were perceived as useful. A holistic approach, involving support from various sources, can aid in improving dietary fiber consumption and overall health outcomes among older adults.

APPETITE (2024)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Reasons for meal termination, eating frequency, and typical meal context differ between persons with and without a spinal cord injury

Gary J. Farkas, Paige M. Cunningham, Alicia M. Sneij, John E. Hayes, Mark S. Nash, Arthur S. Berg, David R. Gater, Barbara J. Rolls

Summary: Overeating associated with neurogenic obesity after spinal cord injury (SCI) may be related to how persons with SCI experience satiation, their eating frequency, and the context in which they eat their meals. Those with SCI rely less on physiological satiation cues for meal termination and instead rely more on hedonic cues. There are differences in meal contexts and eating frequency between SCI individuals and controls, with SCI individuals consuming fewer meals but having a higher overall eating frequency due to increased snacking. These factors likely contribute to overeating associated with neurogenic obesity after SCI.

APPETITE (2024)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Sex-specific impulsivity, but not other facets of executive function, predicts fat and sugar intake two-years later amongst adolescents with a healthy weight: Findings from the ABCD study

Shana Adise, Kerri N. Boutelle, Panteha Hayati Rezvan, Eric Kan, Kyung E. Rhee, Michael I. Goran, Elizabeth R. Sowell

Summary: This study investigated the relationship between executive functions and cognition during adolescence, and the intake of fat and sugar two years later. The study found that higher impulsivity and reward-seeking behaviors were related to greater fat and sugar intake in males, while higher negative urgency and BMI were related to greater intake in both sexes. These findings suggest that individuals with certain traits may be more at risk for weight gain due to overconsumption of unhealthy foods.

APPETITE (2024)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Australian adults cooked more and tried new recipes during COVID-19 restrictions and lockdowns

Claire Margerison, Gozde Aydin, Christel Larsson, Alison Booth, Anthony Worsley, Janandani Nanayakkara

Summary: The COVID-19 pandemic and associated lockdowns resulted in changes in food accessibility and availability, leading to shifts in food habits and behaviors among people worldwide. A study conducted in Australia examined the self-reported changes in food habits and behaviors of adults during the COVID-19 restrictions in 2020. The majority of respondents reported developing positive food habits, such as trying new recipes, cooking from scratch, and reducing take-away meals. The study also found that family involvement in food preparation and eating together increased during the restrictions. However, there were negative experiences, including difficulties in purchasing certain foods and limited access to food outlets.

APPETITE (2024)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Differential effects of nutritive and non-nutritive sweet mouth rinsing on appetite in adults with obesity

Betsy Cogan, Jamie A. Cooper

Summary: This study aimed to assess the effect of dietary sweetness on appetite in adults with and without obesity. The results showed that the response of ghrelin to unsweetened rinses was energy-specific for all adults, while rinses containing sucralose led to greater cephalic phase cholecystokinin release in adults with a BMI between 18.5 and 24.9 kg/m(2).

APPETITE (2024)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Is being anti-vegan a distinct dietarian identity? An investigation with omnivores, vegans, and self-identified anti-vegans

Rebecca Gregson, Jared Piazza, Heather Shaw

Summary: Recent scholarship has identified a group of individuals who self-identify as anti-vegan, and they have distinct dietarian identities and ideological profiles. Anti-vegans show higher levels of commitment to their dietary patterns compared to omnivores, and they also score higher on various ideological measures.

APPETITE (2024)

Review Behavioral Sciences

How are overweight and obesity associated with reinforcement learning deficits? A systematic review

Gibson Weydmann, Patricia Maidana Miguel, Nour Hakim, Laurette Dube, Patricia Pelufo Silveira, Lisiane Bizarro

Summary: This study systematically reviewed the association between obesity and overweight with reinforcement learning performance. It was found that obesity might be associated with impairments in utilizing aversive outcomes to change behavior, but further research is needed to confirm this association.

APPETITE (2024)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Experiences of emotional eating in an Acceptance and Commitment Therapy based weight management intervention (SWiM): A qualitative study

Laura Kudlek, Rebecca A. Jones, Carly Hughes, Robbie Duschinsky, Andrew Hill, Rebecca Richards, Megan Thompson, Ann Vincent, Simon J. Griffin, Amy L. Ahern

Summary: This study explored how participants of an ACT-based weight management intervention (WMI) experience emotional eating and highlighted the importance of self-awareness and alternative coping strategies in improving emotional eating. It also emphasized the need for ongoing and personalized interventions to support individuals with external locus of control and complex emotional eating experiences.

APPETITE (2024)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Is it all due to peers? The influence of peers on children's snack purchase decisions

Stefanie C. Landwehr, Monika Hartmann

Summary: This study examines the influence of peers on children's snack purchasing decisions, finding that the presence of peers strongly impacts children's brand awareness and price perception, highlighting the crucial role of social influence in shaping children's decision-making processes.

APPETITE (2024)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Interactive effects of information and trust on consumer choices of organic food: Evidence from China

Rao Yuan, Shaosheng Jin, Wenchao Wu

Summary: This study examines the interactive effects of information and consumer trust on consumer preferences for organic food. The results show that consumers are willing to pay a higher price for organic food, especially those with higher levels of trust. The introduction of information significantly increases consumers' willingness to pay, with a greater increase observed among high-trust consumers.

APPETITE (2024)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Validation of the adult eating behavior questionnaire in a Norwegian sample of adolescents

Oda Bjorklund, Lars Wichstrom, Clare Llewellyn, Silje Steinsbekk

Summary: This study tests the psychometric properties of the Adult Eating Behavior Questionnaire (AEBQ) in a sample of 14-year-olds and examines its construct validity using the parent-reported Children's Eating Behavior Questionnaire (CEBQ). The results show that a 7-factor solution of the AEBQ without the Hunger scale is a better fitting model, and there are small-to-moderate correlations between the AEBQ and CEBQ scales.

APPETITE (2024)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Baby food pouches and Baby-Led Weaning: Associations with energy intake, eating behaviour and infant weight status

Alice M. Cox, Rachael W. Taylor, Jillian J. Haszard, Kathryn L. Beck, Pamela R. von Hurst, Cathryn A. Conlon, Lisa A. Te Morenga, Lisa Daniels, Jenny Mcarthur, Rebecca Paul, Neve H. McLean, Emily A. Jones, Ioanna Katiforis, Kimberley J. Brown, Madeline Gash, Madeleine Rowan, Elizabeth A. Fleming, Rosario Jupiterwala, Bailey R. Bruckner, Anne-Louise M. Heath

Summary: Although concerns are often raised about the potential impact of baby food pouch use and Baby-Led Weaning (BLW) on infant health, there is limited research in this area. This study found that frequent pouch use was associated with increased food fussiness and more selective eating, while BLW was associated with higher energy intake and a range of eating behaviors.

APPETITE (2024)

Article Behavioral Sciences

You eye what you eat: BMI, consumption patterns, and dieting status predict temporal attentional bias to food-associated images

Briana L. Kennedy, Andrew M. Camara, Dominic M. D. Tran

Summary: This study investigated the relationship between obesity, overconsumption, and oversensitivity to rewards, and how it affects attentional biases towards food-related stimuli. The results showed that individuals with higher BMI had lower attentional priority for food and food logos, while increased consumption of HFHS foods and dieting predicted increased attentional priority for food and food logo images.

APPETITE (2024)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Association between sensory reactivity and feeding problems in school-aged children: InProS Study

Irene Campos-Sanchez, Rocio Munoz-Sanchez, Eva-Maria Navarrete-Munoz, Maria Sofia Molina-Inigo, Miriam Hurtado-Pomares, Paula Fernandez-Pires, Alicia Sanchez-Perez, Daniel Prieto-Botella, Iris Juarez-Leal, Paula Peral-Gomez, Cristina Espinosa-Sempere, Desiree Valera-Gran

Summary: This study aimed to investigate the association between sensory reactivity and feeding problems in young children. The results showed that taste/smell sensitivity was significantly associated with difficulties in texture transition/introduction, limited variety of foods, and both feeding problems. Additionally, children with total sensory reactivity or auditory filtering sensory reactivity had a higher prevalence of consuming a limited variety of foods. These findings highlight the importance of considering sensory reactivity as a potential predictor of feeding problems.

APPETITE (2024)