4.7 Article

Documenting Context-Based Quality Assessment of Controlled Vocabularies

Journal

Publisher

IEEE-INST ELECTRICAL ELECTRONICS ENGINEERS INC
DOI: 10.1109/TETC.2018.2865094

Keywords

Vocabulary; Electronic government; Metadata; Measurement; Data integrity; Quality assessment; Controlled vocabularies; data quality; metadata; analytic hierarchy process; context; workflow provenance

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The paper discusses evaluating and documenting the quality of controlled vocabularies to promote comparison and enhance semantic interoperability. Using the Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP), overall quality and ranks of controlled vocabularies can be assessed by integrating different quality dimensions based on decision maker's needs. Selecting a set of e-Government controlled vocabularies as a testbed and providing updated quality values as Linked Data can facilitate interoperability while multi-step guidelines for W3C recommendations can ensure machine-readable quality metadata, promoting reliability and re-usability.
Access to e-Government data is challenging due to the heterogeneity and complexity of the public information ecosystem. Controlled Vocabularies (CVs) provide a key to disclosing the potential of Open Government data, by supplying common terms for marking up metadata and data in a consistent and coherent way. However, quality information is needed to help public institutions decide whether to adopt an existing or newly created CV. The paper discusses how to evaluate and document CV quality thus facilitating a comparison of different controlled vocabularies based on contextual information. The Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) is adopted to assess the overall quality and rank of a controlled vocabulary, by integrating various quality dimensions according to the decision maker's needs. A set of e-Government controlled vocabularies that facilitate the semantic interoperability of e-Government data are selected as a testbed, and updated quality values are made available as Linked Data. Multi-step guidelines are also defined promoting and complementing the adoption of W3C recommendations to provide machine-readable quality metadata. This fosters reliability and re-usability by providing consumers with information on the assessment process carried out and the outcomes achieved. We illustrate the application of these guidelines by focusing on provenance and quality documentation.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Computer Science, Information Systems

Do researchers use open research data? Exploring the relationships between usage trends and metadata quality across scientific disciplines from the Figshare case

Alfonso Quarati, Juliana E. Raffaghelli

Summary: Open research data (ORD) are important for scientific transparency, but they often suffer from low usage due to data friction. This study analyzed ORD published on the Figshare repository and found that most ORD are underutilized regardless of their metadata quality.

JOURNAL OF INFORMATION SCIENCE (2022)

Article Computer Science, Artificial Intelligence

Introducing the Data Quality Vocabulary (DQV)

Riccardo Albertoni, Antoine Isaac

Summary: This paper provides an in-depth understanding of the Data Quality Vocabulary (DQV), discussing its key design principles, components, and comparing it to previous quality documentation vocabularies. It also demonstrates the early uptake of DQV through collected tools, papers, and projects that have utilized and extended it.

SEMANTIC WEB (2021)

Article Computer Science, Information Systems

Geospatial Open Data Usage and Metadata Quality

Alfonso Quarati, Monica De Martino, Sergio Rosim

Summary: This research aims to provide an overview of the usage of Open Government Data portals, measured in terms of datasets views and downloads, and assess the possible influence of metadata quality on the use of geospatial datasets. The results show a significant underutilization of geospatial datasets and a generally poor quality of their metadata, with a weak correlation between use and metadata quality.

ISPRS INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF GEO-INFORMATION (2021)

Article Computer Science, Information Systems

Open Government Data: Usage trends and metadata quality

Alfonso Quarati

Summary: Open Government Data (OGD) have the potential to support social and economic progress, but this potential may not be realized if these data remain unused. Through analysis of 400,000 data sets from 28 national, municipal, and international OGD portals, it was found that most OGD data sets are underutilized and there is variation in the attention given to metadata quality by OGD portals. However, there is no clear evidence of a positive correlation between data set usage and better metadata publishing practices.

JOURNAL OF INFORMATION SCIENCE (2023)

Article Computer Science, Information Systems

Copernicus User Uptake: From Data to Applications

Lorenza Apicella, Monica De Martino, Alfonso Quarati

Summary: The European Programme Copernicus aims to sustain social and economic advancements to the European Union by providing free and open Earth Observation data. User Uptake initiatives have been undertaken to increase awareness and competencies of Copernicus, supporting the development of downstream applications. This article presents application scenario workflows and practical recommendations to promote the use of Copernicus resources and improve data providers' publication practices.

ISPRS INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF GEO-INFORMATION (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Use of ICEsat-2 and Sentinel-2 Open Data for the Derivation of Bathymetry in Shallow Waters: Case Studies in Sardinia and in the Venice Lagoon

Massimo Bernardis, Roberto Nardini, Lorenza Apicella, Maurizio Demarte, Matteo Guideri, Bianca Federici, Alfonso Quarati, Monica De Martino

Summary: Despite the limitations of conventional acoustic hydrographic systems and airborne LiDAR, remote sensing provides a fast, reproducible, and low-cost alternative for mapping shallow-water bathymetry. Satellite-derived bathymetry (SDB) has shown promise in providing depth information, although it typically requires in situ observations for calibration and validation. This paper demonstrates the potential for deriving bathymetry solely from open satellite data, using multispectral images from Sentinel-2 and bathymetric data from NASA's ICESat-2.

REMOTE SENSING (2023)

Article Engineering, Marine

Deriving Coastal Shallow Bathymetry from Sentinel 2-, Aircraft- and UAV-Derived Orthophotos: A Case Study in Ligurian Marinas

Lorenza Apicella, Monica De Martino, Ilaria Ferrando, Alfonso Quarati, Bianca Federici

Summary: Bathymetric surveys in shallow waters are important for navigational safety and environmental studies. In situ surveys with floating acoustic sensors provide high-accuracy data, but are often unfeasible or expensive. Advances in optical imaging from UAVs, aircraft, and satellites allow for bathymetric reconstruction using algorithms. This study applied a reconstruction procedure to orthophotos and Sentinel-2 images, with aircraft-derived bathymetry showing higher accuracy compared to UAV-derived and Sentinel-2 data.

JOURNAL OF MARINE SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING (2023)

Proceedings Paper Computer Science, Theory & Methods

Copernicus Users Uptake: An Overview of Downstream Applications

Lorenza Apicella, Alfonso Quarati, Silvia Gorni, Roderic Molina, Monica De Martino

Summary: This paper introduces the progress of the EO-UPTAKE project, which aims to bridge the skills gap between intermediate and end-users and promote the use and integration of Copernicus data and services.

GEOMATICS AND GEOSPATIAL TECHNOLOGIES, ASITA 2021 (2022)

Proceedings Paper Computer Science, Information Systems

Analysing the Surface Urban Heat Island Effect with Copernicus Data

Lorenza Apicella, Alfonso Quarati, Monica De Martino

Summary: The article focuses on how to ensure that European citizens, companies, and public administrations fully grasp the great opportunities offered by Copernicus satellite data, as well as how initiatives are implemented to promote their application and disseminate the results. It discusses the study of the Urban Heat Island effect, highlighting the strengths and weaknesses in the use of Copernicus data and services, aiming to provide guidelines for analyzing similar phenomena in other urban contexts.

ELECTRONIC GOVERNMENT AND THE INFORMATION SYSTEMS PERSPECTIVE, EGOVIS 2021 (2021)

No Data Available