4.1 Article

Cautionary considerations for positive dingo management: a response to the Johnson and Ritchie critique of Fleming et al. (2012)

Journal

AUSTRALIAN MAMMALOGY
Volume 35, Issue 1, Pages 15-22

Publisher

CSIRO PUBLISHING
DOI: 10.1071/AM12036

Keywords

Canidae; experimental design; inference; mesopredator release hypothesis; wildlife management

Categories

Funding

  1. Invasive Animals CRC

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Johnson and Ritchie (2012) have provided a criticism of our opinion piece (Fleming et al. 2012). There is some common ground, but we remain unconvinced by their view that our reasoning was unsound or beside the point. In this response, we discuss where Johnson and Ritchie have provided unconvincing evidence to refute our seven considerations, and reiterate and demonstrate why these considerations remain important. The mesopredator release or suppression hypothesis in Australian ecosystems must be objectively evaluated before positive management of dingoes and other free-ranging dogs is recommended or implemented. Adaptive comanagement of free-ranging dogs can be used for both biodiversity conservation and the mitigation of livestock predation but caution must be exercised when considering using free-ranging dogs as a conservation tool.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.1
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Biodiversity Conservation

The virtue of compassion in compassionate conservation

Christopher Bobier, Benjamin Allen

Summary: Compassionate conservationists advocate against intentionally harming animals in conservation policies, but in practice they may face challenges related to ethical principles and virtues.

CONSERVATION BIOLOGY (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Identifying and prioritising climate change adaptation actions for greater one-horned rhinoceros (Rhinoceros unicornis) conservation in Nepal

Ganesh Pant, Tek Maraseni, Armando Apan, Benjamin L. Allen

Summary: Climate change poses a serious threat to global biodiversity, including the greater one-horned rhinoceros in Nepal. However, the impacts of climate change have not been well integrated into formal conservation planning for the rhinoceros. This study identified adaptation actions, such as identifying and protecting climate refugia and restoring existing habitats, which could help reduce the vulnerability of the rhinoceros to climate change.

PEERJ (2022)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Top-predator removal does not cause trophic cascades in Australian rangeland ecosystems

Geoff Castle, Deane Smith, Lee R. Allen, John Carter, Peter Elsworth, Benjamin L. Allen

Summary: Increased demand for livestock products has led to conflicts with predators, prompting the implementation of predation management practices, such as the erection of exclusion fences in Australia. Concerns have been raised about the potential cascading effects on wildlife populations. However, experimental results show that the removal of apex predators does not routinely cause trophic cascades in Australian rangeland ecosystems. This suggests that there are opportunities to promote the recovery of threatened species in predator-free areas used for livestock production.

FOOD WEBS (2022)

Article Zoology

Habitat use by the endangered spotted-tailed quoll in a fragmented landscape

T. Henderson, B. A. Fancourt, R. Rajaratnam, K. Vernes, G. Ballard

Summary: The spotted-tailed quoll is an endangered mesopredator in Australia that is generally associated with large, intact forested habitats. However, recent research has shown that they can also thrive in fragmented agricultural landscapes, suggesting that their habitat preferences may be more flexible than previously assumed.

MAMMAL RESEARCH (2023)

Article Agriculture, Dairy & Animal Science

Efficacy of Management Efforts to Reduce Food-Related Dingo-Human Interactions and Conflict on K'gari (Fraser Island), Australia

Linda Behrendorff, Rachel King, Benjamin L. Allen

Summary: This study collected and analyzed reports of human-dingo interactions on K'gari Island since 1990. The results showed that food influences dingo behavior and that nonlethal management actions can reduce food-related interactions. Further innovations are needed to reduce serious incidents involving dingoes and humans.

ANIMALS (2023)

Article Zoology

Brushtail possum terrestrial activity patterns are driven by climatic conditions, breeding and moonlight intensity

Michal Krzysztof Smielak, Guy Ballard, Peter John Sabine Fleming, Gerhard Kortner, Karl Vernes, Nick Reid

Summary: By analyzing a large dataset collected over 3 years from 133 camera traps, researchers found that common brushtail possums are primarily nocturnal and their terrestrial activity peaks in winter during the breeding season. Ambient temperature and moonlight intensity significantly influence their activity patterns, with lower temperatures and brighter moonlight promoting activity. Rain and higher temperatures, on the other hand, decrease possum activity. The findings also show that possums prefer higher moonlight intensity and adjust their activity accordingly.

MAMMAL RESEARCH (2023)

Article Agriculture, Dairy & Animal Science

Investigating the Market Value of Brumbies (Equus caballus) in the Australian Riding Horse Market

Victoria Condon, Bethany Wilson, Peter J. S. Fleming, Brooke P. A. Kennedy, Tamara Keeley, Jamie Barwick, Paul McGreevy

Summary: Feral horses in Australia, also known as brumbies, are managed by human intervention. Rehoming of suitable feral horses following passive trapping is widely accepted, but their numbers in the horse market are minimal compared to other cohorts. Further research is needed to determine appropriate target markets and improve the sustainability of rehoming as a management tool.

ANIMALS (2023)

Article Agriculture, Dairy & Animal Science

Attitudes towards the Potential Use of Aversive Geofencing Devices to Manage Wild Elephant Movement

Surendranie J. Cabral de Mel, Saman Seneweera, Ashoka Dangolla, Devaka K. Weerakoon, Tek Maraseni, Benjamin L. Allen

Summary: This study assessed the opinions of stakeholders on the potential use of aversive geofencing devices (AGDs) on Asian elephants. Most respondents expressed positive opinions on the effectiveness of AGDs in managing elephant movement and believed that shock collars could be a useful tool to mitigate human-elephant conflict.

ANIMALS (2023)

Article Ecology

Use of density-impact functions to inform and improve the environmental outcomes of feral horse management

David McKenzie Berman, Jill Pickering, Deane Smith, Benjamin L. Allen

Summary: Based on our study in two regions, we found that the impact of feral horses on the environment is directly related to their population density. However, further research is needed to determine the optimal level of control required to achieve conservation objectives.

WILDLIFE BIOLOGY (2023)

Article Ecology

The Sentinel Bait Station: an automated, intelligent design pest animal baiting system

G. Charlton, G. Falzon, A. Shepley, P. J. S. Fleming, G. Ballard, P. D. Meek

Summary: This study developed and tested a novel baiting technique called Sentinel Bait Station, which can automatically provide baits to target species and save resources. Field testing showed promising results, with high accuracy and precision of the image recognition algorithm.

WILDLIFE RESEARCH (2023)

Article Zoology

Activity of free-ranging dogs (Canis familiaris) in the Arcadia Valley, Queensland

Paul D. Meek, Guy Ballard, Darren Marshall, Lachlan Marshall, Deane Smith, Peter J. S. Fleming

Summary: GPS tracking collars were used on five free-ranging dogs in Arcadia Valley, Queensland to collect movement data in a unique topographical landscape. Three home range methods were employed to generate activity areas using seasonally constrained fixes. Activity areas (Brownian Bridge and Utilisation Distribution) ranged from 2.9 to 689 km(2) in this landscape, showing that previously perceived barriers to dog movement were not limiting habitat use.

AUSTRALIAN MAMMALOGY (2023)

Article Ecology

Recounting bias can affect abundance estimates from intensive helicopter surveys of feral goats

John P. Tracey, Peter J. S. Fleming

Summary: Investigated biases caused by animal movement during intensive helicopter surveys of feral goats. Found that goats did not move randomly in response to helicopters and that animals within the survey transects were more likely to move. It was also observed that a significant number of goats were available for recounting in adjacent transects, leading to potential overestimation.

WILDLIFE RESEARCH (2023)

Article Zoology

Observer differences in individual identification of feral cats from camera trap images

Jessica Sparkes, Peter J. S. Fleming

Summary: Feral cats pose a significant threat to Australian native fauna. The use of camera traps for individual identification is important for evaluating management actions. However, observer bias and camera trap settings can affect identification rates. This study compared the individual identification of feral cats by two observers with different levels of experience. The results showed that the experienced observer attributed more events to known individuals and daytime events had higher identification rates and match success.

AUSTRALIAN MAMMALOGY (2023)

No Data Available