4.7 Article

Someone's rooting for you: Continuity, advocacy and street-level bureaucracy in UK maternal healthcare

Journal

SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE
Volume 69, Issue 8, Pages 1228-1235

Publisher

PERGAMON-ELSEVIER SCIENCE LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2009.07.029

Keywords

UK; Street-level bureaucrats; Advocacy; Maternity care; Continuity; Midwives

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Continuity and advocacy are widely held to be important elements in maternal healthcare, yet they are often lacking from the care women receive. In order to understand this disparity, we draw upon interviews and ethnographic observational findings from The One-to-One Caseload Project, a study exploring the impacts of a caseload model of maternity care within an urban National Health Service provider in Britain. Drawing on Lipsky's (1980) and Prottas's (1979) theories of street-level bureaucracy, this paper attempts to understand how midwives, working on the frontline within caseload and standard care models, manage the competing demands of delivering a personalised service within a bureaucratic organisation. The caseload care model serves as a case study for how a client-centred model of working can assist street-level bureaucrats to manage the administrative pressures of public service organisations and provide their clients with a personalised, responsive service. Nevertheless, despite such benefits, client-centred models of working may have unintended consequences for both health carers and healthcare systems. (c) 2009 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Nursing

Navigating uncertainty alone: A grounded theory analysis of women?s psycho-social experiences of pregnancy and childbirth during the COVID-19 pandemic in London

Elsa Montgomery, Kaat De Backer, Abigail Easter, Laura A. Magee, Jane Sandall, Sergio A. Silverio

Summary: The study explores the psycho-social experiences of women who received maternity care and gave birth in South London during the COVID-19 pandemic. Through virtual interviews with 23 women, data were collected, analyzed, and a theory of 'Navigating uncertainty alone' was developed. Findings suggest that women's pregnancy and childbirth journeys during the pandemic had both positive and negative experiences, with issues such as lack of relational care, denial of embodied experiences, and being removed from support networks being significant.

WOMEN AND BIRTH (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

A continuity of care programme for women at risk of preterm birth in the UK: Process evaluation of a hybrid randomised controlled pilot trial

Cristina Fernandez Turienzo, Louise H. Hull, Kirstie Coxon, Mary Bollard, Pauline Cross, Paul T. Seed, Andrew H. Shennan, Jane Sandall

Summary: This study evaluated the implementation and effectiveness of the POPPIE care model, which combines midwifery continuity of care with a specialist obstetric clinic, for pregnant women at risk of preterm birth in London, UK. The results showed that the POPPIE model was feasible, acceptable, and implemented with high fidelity and sustainability. The importance of this study lies in providing a new care model for improving the care of pregnant women at risk of preterm birth.

PLOS ONE (2023)

Article Obstetrics & Gynecology

How are hospitals in England caring for women at risk of preterm birth in 2021? The influence of national guidance on preterm birth care in England: a national questionnaire

Naomi Carlisle, Angharad Care, Dilly O. C. Anumba, Sonia Dalkin, Jane Sandall, Andrew H. Shennan

Summary: This study aimed to investigate the number of preterm birth surveillance clinics in England and the management of care for women at risk of preterm birth. The results of an online survey showed a 160% increase in preterm birth surveillance clinics in the past four years. While variations in care still exist, the majority of hospitals have managed to increase their services under the challenging circumstances of the COVID pandemic without additional funding.

BMC PREGNANCY AND CHILDBIRTH (2023)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Scale-up of a novel vital signs alert device to improve maternity care in Sierra Leone: a mixed methods evaluation of adoption

Sophie Bright, Francis Moses, Alex Ridout, Betty Sam, Mariama Momoh, Venetia Goodhart, Francis Smart, Margaret Mannah, Sattu Issa, Simren Herm-Singh, Fiona Reid, Paul T. Seed, James Bunn, Andrew Shennan, Katrin Augustin, Jane Sandall

Summary: This study retrospectively evaluated the adoption of CRADLE in Sierra Leone and found that the complexity related to the technology and organizational context influenced its adoption, resulting in inter-district variation. Key strategies mentioned to mitigate these issues included transparent communication, encouraging localized adaptations, and selecting champions with strong soft skills.

REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH (2023)

Article Nursing

Project20: Maternity care mechanisms that improve (or exacerbate) health inequalities. A realist evaluation

Hannah Rayment-Jones, James Harris, Angela Harden, Cristina Fernandez Turienzo, Jane Sandall

Summary: Specialist models of maternity care that provide continuity can improve birth outcomes for women with social risk factors, by offering practical and emotional support and personalized healthcare information. However, these models are not a solution to all social inequalities and overall improvement is needed in the maternity system.

WOMEN AND BIRTH (2023)

Article Nursing

She was there all the time. A qualitative study exploring how women at higher risk for preterm birth experience midwifery continuity of care

L. Brigante, K. Coxon, C. Fernandez Turienzo, J. Sandall

Summary: There is a lack of research on the experiences and views of women at higher risk of preterm birth regarding midwifery continuity of care. However, findings suggest that midwifery continuity of care can improve maternal outcomes and reduce the occurrence of preterm birth and stillbirths. Therefore, it is important to explore the experiences and views of high-risk women regarding this type of care.

WOMEN AND BIRTH (2023)

Editorial Material Pediatrics

Innovations to reduce maternal mortality and improve health and wellbeing of adolescent girls and their babies in Sierra Leone

Cristina Fernandez Turienzo, Lucy November, Mangenda Kamara, Philemon Kamara, Venetia Goodhart, Alexandra Ridout, Betty Sam, Suzanne Thomas, Prince T. Williams, Jane Sandall, Andrew H. Shennan, CRIBS Collaborative Grp

LANCET CHILD & ADOLESCENT HEALTH (2023)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Strengthening open disclosure after incidents in maternity care: a realist synthesis of international research evidence

Mary Adams, Julie Hartley, Natalie Sanford, Alexander Edward Heazell, Rick Iedema, Charlotte Bevan, Maria Booker, Maureen Treadwell, Jane Sandall

Summary: Open Disclosure (OD) is a right for service-users, an aspect of their recovery, and an important dimension of service safety improvement. This study provides a theoretical understanding of how OD works, identifies five key mechanisms for successful OD, and explores the contextual factors that influence it.

BMC HEALTH SERVICES RESEARCH (2023)

Article Obstetrics & Gynecology

Reflective, pragmatic, and reactive decision-making by maternity service providers during the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic health system shock: a qualitative, grounded theory analysis

Sergio A. A. Silverio, Kaat De Backer, Jeremy M. M. Brown, Abigail Easter, Nina Khazaezadeh, Daghni Rajasingam, Jane Sandall, Laura A. A. Magee

Summary: This study investigated the experiences and perceptions of maternity care staff in South London who provided care during the pandemic. The findings revealed three types of decision-making: reflective, pragmatic, and reactive. Reflective decision-making was seen as beneficial, leading to high-quality care and innovation.

BMC PREGNANCY AND CHILDBIRTH (2023)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

Project20: maternity care mechanisms that improve access and engagement for women with social risk factors in the UK - a mixed-methods, realist evaluation

Hannah Rayment-Jones, Kathryn Dalrymple, James M. Harris, Angela Harden, Elidh Parslow, Thomas Georgi, Jane Sandall

Summary: The study evaluates access and engagement with different models of maternity care and finds that women with more social risk factors are more likely to choose specialist models that provide continuity of care. Women who receive hospital-based antenatal care are more likely to seek care late and have fewer appointments compared to community-based care. However, women accessing specialist models are more likely to have appointments with known healthcare professionals. The study highlights the importance of community-based specialist models in improving access and reducing inequalities.

BMJ OPEN (2023)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

Understanding challenges as they impact on hospital-level care for pre-eclampsia in rural Ethiopia: a qualitative study

Tanya Robbins, Andrew Shennan, Jane Sandall, Tigist Eshetu Guangul, Rahel Demissew, Ahmed Abdella, Rosie Mayston, Charlotte Hanlon

Summary: This study identifies systemic barriers to providing quality, person-centered care for pre-eclampsia in Ethiopian hospitals. Inconsistent availability of resources and support undermine staff efforts, and the application of policies exacerbates inequities in care. Staff improvise with limited resources and knowledge, and social hierarchies and punitive cultures challenge communication, documentation, and supportive environments for quality improvement.

BMJ OPEN (2023)

Article Medicine, Research & Experimental

The feasibility of team care for women seeking to plan a vaginal breech birth (OptiBreech 1): an observational implementation feasibility study in preparation for a pilot trial

Shawn Walker, Emma Spillane, Kate Stringer, Amy Meadowcroft, Tisha Dasgupta, Sian M. Davies, Jane Sandall, Andrew Shennan

Summary: OptiBreech Care is a feasible approach for providing care to breech presentation at term, with the goal of supporting physiologic breech birth attended by trained professionals. The study aimed to assess the feasibility of implementing OptiBreech team care prior to a planned pilot randomized controlled trial.

PILOT AND FEASIBILITY STUDIES (2023)

Article Medicine, Research & Experimental

CRADLE-5: a stepped-wedge type 2 hybrid implementation-effectiveness cluster randomised controlled trial to evaluate the real-world scale-up of the CRADLE Vital Signs Alert intervention into routine maternity care in Sierra Leone-study protocol

Alexandra E. Ridout, Francis L. Moses, Simren Herm-Singh, Cristina Fernandez Turienzo, Paul T. Seed, Venetia Goodhart, Nicola Vousden, Betty Sam, Mariama Momoh, Daniel Kamara, Katy Kuhrt, Sorie Samura, Candace Beoku-Betts, Alice Hurrell, Kate Bramham, Sartie Kenneh, Francis Smart, Lucy Chappell, Jane Sandall, Andrew Shennan

Summary: The CRADLE-5 trial aims to investigate the effectiveness of national scale-up of the CRADLE intervention in reducing maternal and fetal mortality and severe maternal adverse outcomes, while understanding the strategies for adoption, integration, and sustainability in low-resource settings.

TRIALS (2023)

Review Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Targeted health and social care interventions for women and infants who are disproportionately impacted by health inequalities in high-income countries: a systematic review

Zahra Khan, Zoe Vowles, Cristina Fernandez Turienzo, Zenab Barry, Lia Brigante, Soo Downe, Abigail Easter, Seeromanie Harding, Alison McFadden, Elsa Montgomery, Lesley Page, Hannah Rayment-Jones, Mary Renfrew, Sergio A. A. Silverio, Helen Spiby, Nazmy Villarroel-Williams, Jane Sandall

Summary: The study aims to identify and evaluate the evidence for targeted health and social care service interventions in high-income countries that can improve health inequalities among disadvantaged populations. The findings suggest that various intervention types, such as midwifery models of care, interdisciplinary care, and community-centered services, have positive associations with both primary and secondary outcomes, although the significance and impact vary. Multi-interventional approaches, combining midwifery models of care with community-centered approaches, may enhance the effectiveness of targeted interventions for at-risk populations.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL FOR EQUITY IN HEALTH (2023)

Letter Obstetrics & Gynecology

Re.The web-based application QUiPP v.2 for the prediction of preterm birth in symptomatic women is not yet ready for worldwide clinical use: ten reflections on development, validation and use.

Jenny Carter, Naomi Carlisle, Anna David, Jane Sandall, Paul Seed, Andrew Shennan, Rachel Tribe, Helena Watson

ARCHIVES OF GYNECOLOGY AND OBSTETRICS (2023)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Using curiosity to counter health information avoidance

Samantha Horn, Yana Litovsky, George Loewenstein

Summary: This study suggests that curiosity can be a useful tool in increasing demand for and engagement with aversive health information. By manipulating curiosity through various methods, researchers found that participants were more likely to view and engage with information about their drinking habits, cancer risk, and the sugar content in drinks. Overall, curiosity prompts provide a simple and effective way to increase engagement with aversive health information.

SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE (2024)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

We're implementing AI now, so why not ask us what to do? - How AI providers perceive and navigate the spread of diagnostic AI in complex healthcare systems

Sandra Gillner

Summary: Despite high expectations, the extensive and rapid adoption of AI in medical diagnostics has not been realized. This study investigates the perception and navigation of AI providers in complex healthcare systems, revealing their self-organization to increase adaptability and the practices utilized to mitigate tensions within the healthcare subsystems.

SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE (2024)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Exploring the impact of social protest on mental health: A study of the 2019 Social Uprising in Chile

Fabian Duartea, Alvaro Jimenez-Molina

Summary: This study found that violence related to social protest has a significant impact on depressive symptoms, leading to an increase in depression among the population in Chile. The effect varies by gender and age, with a stronger influence on men and young adults.

SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE (2024)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

The impacts of rent burden and eviction on mortality in the United States, 2000-2019

Nick Graetz, Carl Gershenson, Sonya R. Porter, Danielle H. Sandler, Emily Lemmerman, Matthew Desmond

Summary: Investments in stable, affordable housing may be an important tool for improving population health. This study, using administrative data, found that high rent burden, increases in rent burden during midlife, and evictions were associated with increased mortality.

SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE (2024)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Beyond the patient-doctor dyad: Examining other patient engagement in Traditional Chinese Medicine consultations

Wan Wei

Summary: This study explores the phenomenon of other patient participation in Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), uncovering the various roles that third parties can assume during medical interactions. The findings contribute to existing research on patient resistance and triadic medical interactions, providing insights into the dynamics and implications of third-party involvement in medical consultations.

SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE (2024)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Mobilizing pilot-based evidence for the spread and sustainability of innovations in healthcare: The role of innovation intermediaries

Harry Scarbrough, Katie Rose M. Sanfilippo, Alexandra Ziemann, Charitini Stavropoulou

Summary: This paper examines the contribution of pilot implementation studies to the wider spread and sustainability of innovation in healthcare systems. Through an empirical examination of an innovation intermediary organization in the English NHS, the study finds that their work in mobilizing pilot-based evidence involves configuring to context, transitioning evidence, and managing the transition. The findings contribute to theory by showing how intermediary roles can support the effective transitioning of pilot-based evidence, leading to more widespread adoption and sustainability of innovation.

SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE (2024)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Perinatal health in Spain during and after the Great Recession: Educational selection into fertility as a protective factor in high unemployment contexts

Marta Seiz, Leire Salazar, Tatiana Eremenko

Summary: This study examines the impact of maternal educational selection on birth outcomes during an economic recession, and finds that more educated mothers are more likely to give birth during high unemployment periods. Additionally, maternal education mitigates the adverse effects of unemployment on birth outcomes and is consistently associated with better perinatal health.

SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE (2024)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Cultural tightness-looseness and normative social influence in eight Asian countries: Associations of individual and collective norms with vaccination intentions

Jingyuan Shi, Hye Kyung Kim, Charles T. Salmon, Edson C. Tandoc Jr, Zhang Hao Goh

Summary: This study examines the influence of individual and collective norms on COVID-19 vaccination intention across eight Asian countries. The findings reveal nuanced patterns of how individual and collective social norms influence health behavioral decisions, depending on the degree of cultural tightness-looseness.

SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE (2024)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Social connectedness, functional capacity, and longevity: A focus on positive relations with others

Elliot Friedman, Melissa Franks, Elizabeth Teas, Patricia A. Thomas

Summary: This study found that positive relations with others have a significant impact on functional limitations and longevity in aging adults, independent of social integration and social support.

SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE (2024)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Age-friendly neighbourhood environment, functional abilities and life satisfaction: A longitudinal analysis of older adults in urban China

Zhuolin Pan, Yuqi Liu, Ye Liu, Ziwen Huo, Wenchao Han

Summary: This study examines the effects of age-friendly neighbourhood environment and functional abilities on life satisfaction among older adults in urban China. The findings highlight the importance of transportation, housing, and social and physical environment factors in influencing functional abilities and life satisfaction. The study provides valuable insights for policymakers in enhancing older adults' life satisfaction in the Chinese urban context.

SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE (2024)