4.7 Article

Pollen-mediated gene flow and seed exchange in small-scale Zambian maize farming, implications for biosafety assessment

Journal

SCIENTIFIC REPORTS
Volume 6, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

NATURE PUBLISHING GROUP
DOI: 10.1038/srep34483

Keywords

-

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Gene flow in agricultural crops is important for risk assessment of genetically modified (GM) crops, particularly in countries with a large informal agricultural sector of subsistence cultivation. We present a pollen flow model for maize (Zea mays), a major staple crop in Africa. We use spatial properties of fields (size, position) in three small-scale maize farming communities in Zambia and estimate rates of cross-fertilisation between fields sown with different maize varieties (e.g. conventional and transgene). As an additional factor contributing to gene flow, we present data on seed saving and sharing among farmers that live in the same communities. Our results show that: i) maize fields were small and located in immediate vicinity of neighboring fields; ii) a majority of farmers saved and shared seed; iii) modeled rates of pollen-mediated gene flow showed extensive mixing of germplasm between fields and farms and iv) as a result, segregation of GM and non-GM varieties is not likely to be an option in these systems. We conclude that the overall genetic composition of maize, in this and similar agricultural contexts, will be strongly influenced both by self-organised ecological factors (pollen flow), and by socially mediated intervention (seed recycling and sharing).

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Environmental Sciences

No legitimacy: A study of private sector sanitation development in the Global South

Klara Fischer, Suvi Kokko, Jennifer McConville

Summary: This paper examines the conditions necessary for the private sector to establish itself successfully as a key player in delivering sustainable sanitation in the Global South through a case study of Peepoople AB. The company failed to successfully combine sustainable sanitation development with financial gain for investors, primarily due to a lack of legitimacy in the development sector.

ENVIRONMENTAL INNOVATION AND SOCIETAL TRANSITIONS (2021)

Article Geography

Why Africa's New Green Revolution is failing - Maize as a commodity and anti-commodity in South Africa

Klara Fischer

Summary: The South African government has invested significant resources in introducing genetically modified maize to smallholders in order to alleviate poverty through agriculture. However, smallholder farming continues to decline and poverty rates are increasing in the country. This paper aims to explain the government's failure to support smallholders by examining the interplay between maize production, politics, and technological development in South African history. The study highlights the impact of maize as an agent, with its material properties influencing farming practices and wider political economies. It explores how maize has evolved as both a commodity serving settler farmers and a subsistence crop for marginalized smallholders due to interactions between maize biology and the choices made by farmers, politicians, and breeders during the colonial era and apartheid. The paper argues that despite South Africa's democratic system and significant investment in improving smallholder livelihoods, recent technological developments and market concentration have widened the gap between commodity and subsistence maize, hindering the success of a crop-led New Green Revolution.

GEOFORUM (2022)

Article Communication

The Swedish Media Debate on GMO Between 1994 and 2018: What Attention was Given to Farmers' Perspectives?

Klara Fischer, Sebastian Hess

Summary: The study found that media coverage of GMO in food and agriculture in Sweden decreased overall from the mid-1990s to 2018, with a shift towards more neutral attitudes. Farmer perspectives were given more attention than expected in the media discourse, while discussions on smallholder farming and food security in the Global South did not significantly impact media narratives in Sweden.

ENVIRONMENTAL COMMUNICATION-A JOURNAL OF NATURE AND CULTURE (2022)

Article Parasitology

Seropositivity rates of zoonotic pathogens in small ruminants and associated public health risks at informal urban markets in Zambia

Sara Lysholm, Klara Fischer, Johanna F. Lindahl, Musso Munyeme, Jonas Johansson Wensman

Summary: The study identified seropositivity rates for zoonotic pathogens in Zambia's informal small ruminant markets, including Brucella spp., Coxiella burnetii, and Rift Valley fever virus. It also revealed unsanitary procedures at slaughterhouses and various occupational hazards for slaughterhouse workers.

ACTA TROPICA (2022)

Editorial Material Geography

The political ecology of crops: From seed to state and capital

Klara Fischer, Jostein Jakobsen, Ola T. Westengen

GEOFORUM (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Whose transformation is this? Unpacking the 'apparatus of capture' in Sweden's bioeconomy

Sara Holmgren, Alexandru Giurca, Johanna Johansson, Christoffer Soderlund Kanarp, Tove Stenius, Klara Fischer

Summary: This study examines the development of the Swedish bioeconomy and the influential parties involved. It reveals that the Swedish bioeconomy is framed as an issue of innovation governance, blurring the boundaries between public and private interests in the forest sector.

ENVIRONMENTAL INNOVATION AND SOCIETAL TRANSITIONS (2022)

Article Veterinary Sciences

Diverging Discourses: Animal Health Challenges and Veterinary Care in Northern Uganda

Anna Arvidsson, Klara Fischer, Kjell Hansen, Susanna Sternberg-Lewerin, Erika Chenais

Summary: This paper examines the structure of veterinary support and its dominant development narratives in Uganda, focusing on the role of paraprofessionals. It suggests that while the public veterinary sector is under-resourced, paraprofessionals play a crucial role in providing animal health services to smallholders. However, they are often marginalized and their importance downplayed in current discourse.

FRONTIERS IN VETERINARY SCIENCE (2022)

Article Infectious Diseases

Exploring the hurdles that remain for control of African swine fever in smallholder farming settings

Erika Chenais, Klaus Depner, Ayako Ebata, Mary-Louise Penrith, Dirk U. Pfeiffer, Cortney Price, Karl Stahl, Klara Fischer

Summary: This article summarizes a webinar on African swine fever (ASF) research, discussing the history of ASF, the current global disease situation, and suggesting measures for control. The study finds that ASF is now primarily associated with domestic pigs and pork, with human-driven virus spread. Smallholders face challenges in implementing biosecurity measures due to poverty and other factors. Therefore, improving biosecurity in the smallholder sector is an important tool for preventing and controlling ASF.

TRANSBOUNDARY AND EMERGING DISEASES (2022)

Article Geography

Pigs as a shortcut to money? Social traps in smallholder pig production in northern Uganda

Anna Arvidsson, Klara Fischer, Kjell Hansen, Juliet Kiguli

Summary: This article explores how pig production as a pathway out of poverty fails in post-conflict communities in northern Uganda due to tensions created by the focus on individual wealth creation. The study suggests that poverty reduction measures should focus on raising the general level of welfare in communities and supporting the collective rather than the individual.

JOURNAL OF RURAL STUDIES (2022)

Article Social Issues

Governing Agricultural Biotechnologies in the United States, the United Kingdom, and Germany: A Trans-decadal Study of Regulatory Cultures

Adrian Ely, Beate Friedrich, Dominic Glover, Klara Fischer, Glenn Davis Stone, Ann Kingiri, Matthew A. Schnurr

Summary: Comparative studies on agricultural biotechnology regulation have identified the different roles of science and politics in decision-making. This research draws on evidence from the US, UK, and Germany to understand how regulatory cultures have evolved in response to previous generations of agricultural biotechnology and genome editing. The study finds that the US largely maintains a product-based regulatory approach, while the UK and Germany combine process-based and programmatic elements to varying degrees. By exploring the opportunity structures in each jurisdiction, this research sheds light on the long-term governance dynamics of genome editing and agricultural biotechnology.

SCIENCE TECHNOLOGY & HUMAN VALUES (2023)

Article Development Studies

Beyond the Genome: Genetically Modified Crops in Africa and the Implications for Genome Editing

Joeva Sean Rock, Matthew A. Schnurr, Ann Kingiri, Dominic Glover, Glenn Davis Stone, Adrian Ely, Klara Fischer

Summary: Genome editing technology has gained attention in Africa's agricultural development, as it is seen as a potential revolution in breeding. This article identifies the connection between genome editing and genetic modification, and offers recommendations on integrating lessons from previous GM crops into future genome editing breeding programs. The authors argue for a focus on co-development with farmers, access to non-restricted plant material, and recognition of the complexity of agroecological systems when it comes to genome editing projects.

DEVELOPMENT AND CHANGE (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

?Our burgers eat carbon?: Investigating the discourses of corporate net-zero commitments

Kirstine Lund Christiansen, Flora Hajdu, Emil Planting Mollaoglu, Alice Andrews, Wim Carton, Klara Fischer

Summary: Corporate net-zero emission pledges have increased in recent years, but critics argue that these pledges might be greenwashing if they rely on excessive offsetting and justify business-as-usual practices. In this study, we analyze the discursive aspects of net-zero logics by examining the case of MAX Burgers AB in Sweden. Our findings reveal that MAX's net-zero claim serves to justify its existing business practices and shift responsibility for climate action onto others. We conclude that even seemingly progressive corporate net-zero pledges become problematic if they distract from real emissions reductions and support carbon-intensive lifestyles.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Limitations and opportunities of smallholders' practical knowledge when dealing with pig health issues in northern Uganda

Anna Arvidsson, Klara Fischer, Erika Chenais, Juliet Kiguli, Susanna Sternberg-Lewerin, Karl Stahl

Summary: Pig production is a potential pathway out of poverty for smallholder farmers in rural Uganda, but the lack of access to veterinary services and the threat of African swine fever (ASF) pose major challenges. This study aims to understand smallholders' perceptions and responses to pig health issues, particularly ASF, and examines the potential and limitations of smallholders' practice-based knowledge. The results show that while pigs are appreciated for providing income, smallholders struggle to effectively deal with pig diseases and express a need for veterinary advice. Enhancing veterinary services and improving general conditions for smallholder pig keeping are important for the success of pig production as a poverty mitigation strategy in Uganda.

PLOS ONE (2023)

Article Veterinary Sciences

Co-created community contracts support biosecurity changes in a region where African swine fever is endemic-Part II: Implementation of biosecurity measures

Erika Chenais, Klara Fischer, Tonny Aliro, Karl Stahl, Susanna Sternberg Lewerin

Summary: Smallholder subsistence pig production is common in Uganda, however, the endemic spread of African swine fever (ASF) is driven by human activities along the smallholder value chain. Despite stakeholders' awareness and positive attitude towards biosecurity, basic biosecurity is lacking due to costs and a lack of adaptation. Engaging the community and involving stakeholders are important for improving disease prevention and control. Participatory action at the community level was investigated in Northern Uganda to improve biosecurity in the smallholder pig value chain. The methodology facilitated implementation of initially controversial measures and was positively received for strengthening community identity and cooperation.

PREVENTIVE VETERINARY MEDICINE (2023)

Article Biotechnology & Applied Microbiology

Siloed discourses: a year-long study of twitter engagement on the use of CRISPR in food and agriculture

Lauren Crossland-Marr, Alexandru Giurca, Maya Tsingos, Matthew A. Schnurr, Adrian Ely, Dominic Glover, Glenn Davis Stone, Klara Fischer

Summary: Gene editing technologies are viewed with both hope and concern in society. Analysis of English-speaking Twitter networks reveals active scientists promoting a positive image of CRISPR gene editing, while a smaller group of civil society actors voice skepticism without eliciting response. Discourse coalitions on Twitter surrounding CRISPR in food and agriculture are siloed with limited interaction between contrasting perspectives.

NEW GENETICS AND SOCIETY (2023)

No Data Available