4.5 Article

Designing quality improvement initiatives: the action effect method, a structured approach to identifying and articulating programme theory

Journal

BMJ QUALITY & SAFETY
Volume 23, Issue 12, Pages 1040-1048

Publisher

BMJ PUBLISHING GROUP
DOI: 10.1136/bmjqs-2014-003103

Keywords

-

Funding

  1. Improvement Science Fellowships
  2. Health Foundation

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Background The identification and articulation of programme theory can support effective design, execution and evaluation of quality improvement (QI) initiatives. Programme theory includes an agreed aim, potential interventions to achieve this aim, anticipated cause/effect relationships between the interventions and the aim and measures to monitor improvement. This paper outlines the approach used in a research and improvement programme to support QI initiatives in identifying and articulating programme theory: the action effect method. Background to method development Building on a previously used QI method, the driver diagram, the action effect method was developed using co-design and iteration over four annual rounds of improvement initiatives. This resulted in a specification of the elements required to fully articulate the programme theory of a QI initiative. The action effect method The action effect method is a systematic and structured process to identify and articulate a QI initiative's programme theory. The method connects potential interventions and implementation activities with an overall improvement aim through a diagrammatic representation of hypothesised and evidenced cause/effect relationships. Measure concepts, in terms of service delivery and patient and system outcomes, are identified to support evaluation. Discussion and conclusions The action effect method provides a framework to guide the execution and evaluation of a QI initiative, a focal point for other QI methods and a communication tool to engage stakeholders. A clear definition of what constitutes a well-articulated programme theory is provided to guide the use of the method and assessment of the fidelity of its application.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Review Health Care Sciences & Services

Conceptualising interventions to enhance spread in complex systems: a multisite comprehensive medication review case study

Laura Lennox, Susan Barber, Neil Stillman, Sophie Spitters, Emily Ward, Vanessa Marvin, Julie E. Reed

Summary: This study advances the conceptualisation of interventions by explicitly considering how evidence-based practices are operationalised in complex systems. The proposed new conceptualisation describes intervention components in relation to their proximity to the evidence base, component interdependence, function, adaptation, and effort.

BMJ QUALITY & SAFETY (2022)

Review Health Care Sciences & Services

Implementation Frameworks for Artificial Intelligence Translation Into Health Care Practice: Scoping Review

Fabio Gama, Daniel Tyskbo, Jens Nygren, James Barlow, Julie Reed, Petra Svedberg

Summary: This literature review demonstrates that the implementation of AI in healthcare practice is still in its early stages of development. Existing frameworks do not fully consider the unique needs of AI implementation, highlighting the need for further research to develop comprehensive implementation frameworks.

JOURNAL OF MEDICAL INTERNET RESEARCH (2022)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Toward Successful Implementation of Artificial Intelligence in Health Care Practice: Protocol for a Research Program

Petra Svedberg, Julie Reed, Per Nilsen, James Barlow, Carl Macrae, Jens Nygren

Summary: This research program aims to bridge the gap between knowledge and practice in the implementation of AI in healthcare by developing a theoretically-informed framework and conducting empirical studies. The program also seeks to apply the framework in clinical practice to build regional capacity for AI implementation. The program will use a logic model and involve collaboration between researchers, healthcare professionals, and other stakeholders.

JMIR RESEARCH PROTOCOLS (2022)

Article Geriatrics & Gerontology

Factors associated with accessing long-term adult social care in people aged 75 and over: a retrospective cohort study

Mable Nakubulwa, Cornelia Junghans, Vesselin Novov, Clare Lyons-Amos, Derryn Lovett, Azeem Majeed, Paul Aylin, Thomas Woodcock

Summary: This study describes risk factors for long-term adult social care (ASC) in two inner London boroughs and develops a risk prediction model. The findings indicate that age, socioeconomic deprivation, preexisting mental health conditions, and prior health service use are associated with accessing long-term ASC. However, the predictive power of a prognostic model based on risk factors is limited, suggesting the need for a paradigm shift towards more relational, personalized approaches.

AGE AND AGEING (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

To what extent do callers follow the advice given by a non-emergency medical helpline (NHS 111): A retrospective cohort study

Mable Angela Nakubulwa, Geva Greenfield, Elena Pizzo, Andreas Magusin, Ian Maconochie, Mitch Blair, Derek Bell, Azeem Majeed, Ganesh Sathyamoorthy, Thomas Woodcock

Summary: This study examines patient and call-related characteristics associated with compliance with advice given in NHS 111 calls. The results show that overall compliance with advice given was 49%, with higher compliance among children, women, and those from Asian/Asian British ethnicity. The study provides valuable insights for improving caller compliance with advice and developing remote healthcare services.

PLOS ONE (2022)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

The Association Between Sleep Disturbance and Suicidality in Psychiatric Inpatients Transitioning to the Community: Protocol for an Ecological Momentary Assessment Study

Lindsay H. Dewa, Sofia Pappa, Talya Greene, James Cooke, Lizzie Mitchell, Molly Hadley, Martina Di Simplicio, Thomas Woodcock, Paul Aylin

Summary: This study aims to examine the relationship between sleep and suicidality in discharged patients using ecological momentary assessment (EMA) with wearable devices. The study will assess sleep quality and collect data on suicidal ideation and mental states in discharged patients. The results are expected to contribute to a better understanding of the association between suicidality and sleep.

JMIR RESEARCH PROTOCOLS (2022)

Article Health Policy & Services

Measuring with quality: the example of person-centred care

Alan Cribb, Thomas Woodcock

Summary: Qualitative data analysis should be routinely integrated into health service measurement, management, and organizational practices. Its proper use is crucial in ensuring appropriate care and reinforcing the validity and usefulness of quantitative measurement.

JOURNAL OF HEALTH SERVICES RESEARCH & POLICY (2022)

Article Respiratory System

Patient outcomes following emergency admission to hospital for COVID-19 compared with influenza: retrospective cohort study

Thomas Woodcock, Geva Greenfield, Ajit Lalvani, Azeem Majeed, Paul Aylin

Summary: This study compares posthospitalisation outcomes and health system resource use between patients hospitalised with COVID-19 and influenza. The findings show that COVID-19 patients are more likely to die, have longer hospital stays, and interact more with primary care after discharge compared to influenza patients.

THORAX (2023)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Grand rounds in methodology: four critical decision points in statistical process control evaluations of quality improvement initiatives

Perla J. Marang-van de Mheen, Thomas Woodcock

Summary: This article discusses how to use statistical process control (SPC) charts in quality improvement (QI) projects. It emphasizes four often overlooked critical decision points and explains their interrelationships and their impact on drawing inferences about the effectiveness of interventions.

BMJ QUALITY & SAFETY (2023)

Article Primary Health Care

Characteristics associated with influenza vaccination uptake in pregnancy: a retrospective cohort study

Thomas Woodcock, Vesselin Novov, Helen Skirrow, James Butler, Derryn Lovett, Yewande Adeleke, Mitch Blair, Sonia Saxena, Azeem Majeed, Paul Aylin

Summary: This study investigated the uptake of seasonal influenza vaccination among pregnant women in North West London and found that younger and older age groups, Black and unknown ethnicity, living in deprived areas, and having no known risk factors for severe influenza were associated with lower vaccination rates. Targeted approaches and interventions are needed to reduce the disparities in vaccine access, particularly for Black pregnant women, younger and older women, and women living in deprived areas.

BRITISH JOURNAL OF GENERAL PRACTICE (2023)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Effect of implementing a heart failure admission care bundle on hospital readmission and mortality rates: interrupted time series study

Thomas Woodcock, Dionne Matthew, Raffaele Palladino, Mable Nakubulwa, Trish Winn, Hugh Bethell, Stephen Hiles, Susan Moggan, Jackie Dowell, Paul Sullivan, Derek Bell, Martin R. Cowie

Summary: This study evaluates the impact of a care bundle intervention on improving care for patients with acute heart failure. The intervention includes testing NT-proBNP, transthoracic Doppler echocardiography, and specialist evaluation. The study finds that this intervention is associated with reduced emergency readmissions and improved in-hospital mortality for acute heart failure patients.

BMJ QUALITY & SAFETY (2023)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

Identifying potential biases in code sequences in primary care electronic healthcare records: a retrospective cohort study of the determinants of code frequency

Thomas Beaney, Jonathan Clarke, David Salman, Thomas Woodcock, Azeem Majeed, Mauricio Barahona, Paul Aylin

Summary: The frequency of diagnostic codes for newly diagnosed LTCs is influenced by factors including patient sociodemographics, disease inclusion in QOF, GP practice, and the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic. Natural language processing or other methods using temporally ordered code sequences should account for these factors to minimise potential bias.

BMJ OPEN (2023)

Article Cardiac & Cardiovascular Systems

Hospital admissions for stroke and bleeding in Hounslow following a quality improvement initiative

Kam Ying Wong, Bethan Davies, Yewande Adeleke, Thomas Woodcock, Dionne Matthew, Sara Sekelj, Andi Orlowski, Bradley Porter, Sophia Hashmy, Ammu Mathew, Ron Grant, Agnes Kaba, Brigitte Unger-Graeber, Bruno Petrungaro, Jordan Wallace, Derek Bell, Martin R. Cowie, Sadia Khan

Summary: The study observed a decrease in stroke admissions following the AF QI initiative in Hounslow, suggesting a potential positive impact. However, the lack of significant changes in bleeding admissions and the diminishing effect over time indicate that other factors may have contributed to the observed decrease in stroke rates.

OPEN HEART (2021)

Article Psychology, Applied

How to design, implement and evaluate organizational interventions for maximum impact: the Sigtuna Principles

Ulrica von Thiele Schwarz, Karina Nielsen, Kasper Edwards, Henna Hasson, Christine Ipsen, Carl Savage, Johan Simonsen Abildgaard, Anne Richter, Caroline Lornudd, Pamela Mazzocato, Julie E. Reed

Summary: This paper presents a set of principles to guide researchers in designing, implementing, and evaluating organizational interventions. Developed through a transdisciplinary, participatory, and iterative process, these principles emphasize the importance of addressing both real-world impact and scientific rigor simultaneously.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF WORK AND ORGANIZATIONAL PSYCHOLOGY (2021)

Article Health Policy & Services

Working together to co-produce better health: The experience of the Collaboration for Leadership in Applied Health Research and Care for Northwest London

Cicely A. Marston, Rachel Matthews, Alicia Renedo, Julie E. Reed

Summary: Improving healthcare provision involves collaboration between clinicians, academics, and patients. However, challenges such as differing ideas between partners and institutional opposition can hinder this collaboration. Factors that can enhance collaboration include ongoing dialogue, risk-taking, creating an enabling environment, and maintaining a shared end goal.

JOURNAL OF HEALTH SERVICES RESEARCH & POLICY (2021)

No Data Available