4.4 Article

Drivers of farm-level adaptation to climate change in Africa: an evaluation by a composite index of potential adoption

Journal

Publisher

SPRINGER
DOI: 10.1007/s11027-014-9626-8

Keywords

Adaptation strategies; Adoption; Africa; Climate change; Composite index; Farm-level

Funding

  1. European Commission [KBBE-266018]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Over recent decades, there has been increasing levels of research dedicated to assess drivers of farm-level uptake of adaptation strategies to climate change. The main purpose of this research being to determine how policy intervention can most effectively increase adoption. This paper aims to synthesise this past research in order to scale up uptake of farm-level adaptation strategies through a composite index of potential adoption in Africa. In doing so, we review the estimated coefficients of econometric regressions in 42 case studies published in peer-review journals to identify the factors that regularly explain adoption. We find that these common factors can be grouped into seven components, that is human capital, financial resources, infrastructure and technology, social interaction and governance, food security, dependence on agriculture and attitudes towards the environment. Using national-level indicators of these seven categories, we develop a composite index to inform potential adoption and test the robustness of the index in an in-depth sensitivity analysis. The results show that the highest likelihood of adoption of farm-level adaptation strategies is in Northern African countries namely Tunisia, Egypt, Algeria and Morocco and in Southern African countries such as South Africa and Botswana. Conversely, they indicate that the lowest likelihood of adoption is situated in nations of the Sahel and Horn of Africa and in nations that have recently experienced conflict. We conclude that adoption is associated predominantly with governance, civil rights, financial resources and education. However, it is not necessarily driven by the magnitude of climate change impacts on agricultural production.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.4
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Review Agronomy

Effects of management practices on legume productivity in smallholder farming systems in sub-Saharan Africa

Tarirai Muoni, Mattias Jonsson, Alan J. Duncan, Christine A. Watson, Goran Bergkvist, Andrew P. Barnes, Ingrid Oborn

Summary: Legumes play a crucial role in smallholder farming in sub-Saharan Africa, providing livestock feed and enhancing soil fertility. However, the productivity of legumes varies greatly due to the heterogeneous environmental conditions and management practices. A meta-analysis of 128 publications was conducted to assess the effects of intercropping, rhizobia inoculation, minimum tillage, and phosphorus application on legume grain and biomass yield and nitrogen fixation in different contexts. The results showed that intercropping improved overall productivity, while inoculation and phosphorus application increased legume yield. The effects varied depending on legume species, soil type, and other environmental factors.

FOOD AND ENERGY SECURITY (2022)

Article Environmental Studies

Farmer intentional pathways for net zero carbon: Exploring the lock-in effects of forestry and renewables

A. P. Barnes, J. McMillan, L-A Sutherland, J. Hopkins, S. G. Thomson

Summary: The study found that path dependency constrains farmers' intentions towards adopting climate smart approaches, and therefore agricultural policies need to differentiate their support for past adopters and those who are reluctant to adopt.

LAND USE POLICY (2022)

Article Environmental Studies

What are the priority research questions for digital agriculture?

Julie Ingram, Damian Maye, Clive Bailye, Andrew Barnes, Christopher Bear, Matthew Bell, David Cutress, Lynfa Davies, Auvikki de Boon, Liz Dinnie, Julian Gairdner, Caitlin Hafferty, Lewis Holloway, Daniel Kindred, David Kirby, Bethany Leake, Louise Manning, Ben Marchant, Aimee Morse, Simon Oxley, Martin Phillips, Aine Regan, Karen Rial-Lovera, David C. Rose, Juliette Schillings, Fiona Williams, Hefin Williams, Lucy Wilson

Summary: This study aims to identify key existing and emerging issues in digital agriculture and prioritize research questions through a participatory methodology. The study identifies 27 priority research questions across 7 themes and emphasizes the importance of value dimensions and social and institutional arrangements in supporting digital agriculture.

LAND USE POLICY (2022)

Article Food Science & Technology

The effect of ENSO on common bean production in Colombia: a time series approach

Hernan Botero, Andrew P. Barnes

Summary: This study analyzes the impact of El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO) on common bean production in Colombia. The results show that El Nino has a negative effect on yields, while La Nina does not. Additionally, deviations in precipitation from its long-run value due to ENSO in the short-term decrease yields and increase farmers' income from common bean production. The findings suggest the need for countercyclical policies to mitigate price spikes in the Colombian common bean market.

FOOD SECURITY (2022)

Article Agricultural Economics & Policy

The role of family life-cycle events on persistent and transient inefficiencies in less favoured areas

Andrew P. Barnes

Summary: Family farms dominate less favoured areas in Europe and family life-cycle conditions play a vital role in farm adaptation. A study on Scottish farms reveals that planned succession leads to higher farm efficiency, while farmers nearing retirement show lower levels. Factors such as subsidy dependence, off-farm activity, and severity of disadvantage also contribute to lower efficiencies. These findings emphasize the importance of considering life-cycle conditions in farm efficiency studies.

JOURNAL OF AGRICULTURAL ECONOMICS (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Increasing the adoption intensity of sustainable agricultural practices in Europe: Farm and practice level insights

Bethan Thompson, Andrew P. Barnes, Luiza Toma

Summary: Understanding the factors that influence the adoption intensity of sustainable farming practices is crucial for the sustainable development of the food system. This study found that dispositional influences play a significant role in adoption intensity at the farm level, while productivity objectives have a negative association and value chain support has a positive association with adoption intensity. Participation in agri-environment schemes is not associated with farm-level adoption intensity.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2022)

Article Veterinary Sciences

The consequential costs of bovine tuberculosis (bTB) breakdowns in England and Wales

Andrew P. Barnes, Andrew Moxey, Sarah Brocklehurst, Alyson Barratt, Iain J. McKendrick, Giles Innocent, Bouda Vosough Ahmadi

Summary: Control measures for bovine tuberculosis in Great Britain include testing and culling diseased animals, but farmers are not compensated for the consequential costs of complying with these measures. A survey of 1,600 farm holdings found that while most farms incur modest costs, some experience significant costs.

PREVENTIVE VETERINARY MEDICINE (2023)

Article Agricultural Economics & Policy

Creating Conditions for Harnessing the Potential of Transitions to Agroecology in Europe and Requirements for Policy

David Miller, Sophie Legras, Andrew Barnes, Mara Cazacu, Oriana Gava, Janne Helin, Katherine Irvine, Jochen Kantelhardt, Jan Landert, Laure Latruffe, Andreas Mayer, Andreas Niedermayr, Andrea Povellato, Lena Schaller, Gerald Schwarz, Pete Smith, Francesco Vanni, Lionel Vedrine, Davide Viaggi, Audrey Vincent, George Vlahos

Summary: Food systems need to be reoriented to take into account interactions with the environment, economy, health, and society. Transitions to agroecological farming practices and systems can help connect policy areas and achieve environmental, economic, and social goals.

EUROCHOICES (2022)

Article Agricultural Economics & Policy

European Farmer Perspectives and their Adoption of Ecological PracticesPerspektiven der europaischen Landwirte und Landwirtinnen und die Anwendung okologischer Wirtschaftsweisen

Andrew Barnes, Helena Hansson, Larissa Billaudet, Gaelle Leduc, Gordana Manevska Tasevska, Mary Ryan, Bethan Thompson, Luiza Toma, Sabine Duvaleix-Treguer, Irene Tzouramani

Summary: Delivering an agricultural policy that addresses ecosystem and climatic pressures and weaknesses in our food system is complex. This study examines the barriers and motivations behind farmers' adoption of ecological practices in Europe. It finds that personal, technical, and institutional factors influence adoption, with tensions between environmental and production motivations being a key barrier. Coordinated efforts between the public and private sectors can help alleviate these tensions.

EUROCHOICES (2022)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Identifying best practice in Less Favoured Area mixed livestock systems

Andrew P. Barnes, Kev Bevan, Andrew Moxey, Sascha Grierson, Luiza Toma

Summary: This study assesses the heterogeneity in carbon emissions, resource usage, and financial performance of mixed LFA livestock farms in Scotland. Three profiles were identified, representing different levels of performance, including a group with low emissions intensity, high carbon productivity, high technical efficiency, and strong financial resilience.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2023)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

An innovation systems approach to understanding forage adoption intensity in the dairy systems of Kenya and Ethiopia

Rosie Morrison, Nils Teufel, Alan Duncan, Andrew Barnes

Summary: The use of cultivated forages in smallholder dairy systems can effectively increase livestock productivity. Despite the ambition of the Kenyan and Ethiopian governments to promote forage adoption, policies have not achieved widespread results. This study explores the innovation environment and identifies a potential relationship between milk buyers and forage intensity in Ethiopia, which has not been addressed in previous research. Additionally, the study highlights the importance of informal institutions and farmer-to-farmer information transmission in adoption decisions in Kenya.

OUTLOOK ON AGRICULTURE (2023)

Article Entomology

Silvopastoral systems benefit invertebrate biodiversity on tropical livestock farms in Caquetá, Colombia

Lois Kinneen, Maria Paula Escobar, Luis Miguel Hernandez, Jill Thompson, Yardany Ramos-Pastrana, Eric Cordoba-Suarez, Miguel Romero-Sanchez, Andrew Barnes, Marcela Quintero, Michael P. D. Garratt

Summary: Silvopastoral practices can help address the long-term loss of primary forests and their impacts on biodiversity and climate change mitigation in the Colombian Amazon. A study in Caqueta, Colombia found that silvopasture areas act as intermediate habitats, supporting similar invertebrate communities to traditional pasture and forest edges. This has positive implications for invertebrate conservation and ecosystem services.

AGRICULTURAL AND FOREST ENTOMOLOGY (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

The hidden carbon impact of animal disease

Tarek Soliman, Andrew Barnes, Irmelin Slettemoen Helgesen

Summary: Livestock disease outbreaks have indirect costs and carbon impact on greenhouse gas emissions. The severity of outbreaks determines the extent of indirect costs and their effect on carbon emissions. Foot and mouth disease outbreaks have the highest indirect costs and largest reduction in GHG emissions, while African swine fever has the smallest reduction in emissions.

PLOS ONE (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Examining factors for the adoption of silvopastoral agroforestry in the Colombian Amazon

C. O. Alvarado Sandino, A. P. Barnes, I. Sepulveda, M. P. D. Garratt, J. Thompson, M. P. Escobar-Tello

Summary: Current land use systems in the Amazon mainly consist of conventional productivist livestock operations that drive deforestation. Silvopastoral systems (SPS) can support a transition to low carbon production if they are intensified in line with biophysical and socio-economic contexts. Despite being promoted as an alternative livestock production system for decades, widespread adoption of SPS has yet to be seen. A context-specific approach is needed for the implementation of SPS in the Caqueta region of the Colombian Amazon, considering factors that are unique to this region. Managing increased market access and opportunities for SPS producers is crucial to prevent additional deforestation, and understanding the underlying factors that influence perceptions of silvopastoral systems can help avoid unintended policy outcomes.

SCIENTIFIC REPORTS (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Finding the ecological farmer: A farmer typology to understand ecological practice adoption within Europe

Andrew P. Barnes, Bethan Thompson, Luiza Toma

Summary: This article explores the attitudes of farmers towards ecological farming and categorizes them into four types based on their ecological self-identities. The study finds that the acceptance of ecological approaches among farmers is influenced by social pressure and the acceptance of ecological practices within their supply chains. The authors argue for clear policy intent and supply chain dialogue to target specific groups of farmers for behavioral change.

CURRENT RESEARCH IN ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY (2022)

No Data Available