4.3 Article

Eye movements and non-canonical reading: Comments on Kennedy and Pynte (2008)

Journal

VISION RESEARCH
Volume 49, Issue 17, Pages 2232-2236

Publisher

PERGAMON-ELSEVIER SCIENCE LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.visres.2008.10.013

Keywords

Reading; Eye movement control; Models of eye movement control in reading

Funding

  1. MRC [G0601757] Funding Source: UKRI
  2. Medical Research Council [G0601757] Funding Source: Medline
  3. NICHD NIH HHS [R01 HD026765, R01 HD053639, R37 HD026765, R37 HD026765-17] Funding Source: Medline
  4. Medical Research Council [G0601757] Funding Source: researchfish

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Kennedy and Pynte [Kennedy, A., & Pynte, J. (2008). The consequences of violations to reading order: An eye movement analysis. Vision Research, 48, 2309-2320] presented data that they suggested pose problems for models of eye movement control in reading in which words are encoded serially. They focus on situations in which pairs of words are fixated out of order (i.e., the first word is skipped and the second fixated prior to a regression back to the first word). We strongly disagree with their claims and contest their arguments. We argue that their data set was obtained selectively and the events they believe are problematic do not occur frequently during reading. Furthermore, we do not consider that Kennedy and Pynte's arguments pose serious difficulties for serial models of reading such as E-Z Reader. (C) 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.3
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Psychology

Are There Preferred Viewing Locations in Chinese Reading? Evidence From Eye-Tracking and Computer Simulations

Xinyi Xia, Yanping Liu, Lili Yu, Erik D. Reichle

Summary: The Chinese writing system poses challenges to readers in terms of eye movement control due to the lack of clear word boundaries. This article reports two eye-movement experiments that aim to investigate the default-targeting hypothesis in Chinese reading. The results suggest the absence of preferred-viewing locations (PVLs) and support the dynamic-adjustment hypothesis as the best account of saccadic-targeting during Chinese reading.

JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY-LEARNING MEMORY AND COGNITION (2023)

Article Psychology

A Multitask Comparison of Word- and Character-Frequency Effects in Chinese Reading

Jianping Xiong, Lili Yu, Aaron Veldre, Erik D. Reichle, Sally Andrews

Summary: This study examined the effects of word and character frequency on word identification tasks. Word frequency had a facilitatory effect across all tasks, while character frequency had different effects depending on the task. Participants' performance varied across tasks but was relatively reliable within certain tasks.

JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY-LEARNING MEMORY AND COGNITION (2023)

Article Psychology, Multidisciplinary

Conversation dynamics in a multiplayer video game with knowledge asymmetry

James Simpson, Patrick Nalepka, Rachel W. Kallen, Mark Dras, Erik D. Reichle, Simon G. Hosking, Christopher Best, Deborah Richards, Michael J. Richardson

Summary: This study investigates the verbal and behavioral coordination of player teams in cooperative online video games. It shows that demands on coordination can be manipulated by adjusting players' visibility of the game environment, and that categorical recurrence quantification analysis (catRQA) is an effective tool for measuring team communication dynamics.

FRONTIERS IN PSYCHOLOGY (2022)

Article Psychology, Experimental

Understanding the Visual Constraints on Lexical Processing: New Empirical and Simulation Results

Aaron Veldre, Erik D. Reichle, Lili Yu, Sally Andrews

Summary: This article translates and summarizes a study on the effects of visual constraints on lexical processing. Through eye-movement experiments and simulations, the study provides accurate estimates and insights into eye-movement control during reading.

JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY-GENERAL (2023)

Article Psychology, Experimental

Assessing Team Effectiveness by How Players Structure Their Search in a First-Person Multiplayer Video Game

Patrick Nalepka, Matthew Prants, Hamish Stening, James Simpson, Rachel W. Kallen, Mark Dras, Erik D. Reichle, Simon G. Hosking, Christopher Best, Michael J. Richardson

Summary: Teamwork allows for more efficient task completion by utilizing effective division of labor strategies and coordination among team members. The structure of search behavior was found to be sensitive to contextual factors and was associated with task performance improvements as teams developed more effective coordination strategies.

COGNITIVE SCIENCE (2022)

Article Psychology

How Do Task Demands and Aging Affect Lexical Prediction During Online Reading of Natural Texts?

Sally Andrews, Aaron Veldre, Roslyn Wong, Lili Yu, Erik D. Reichle

Summary: This study investigated the impact of task demands and aging on predictability effects for short natural texts. The results suggested that young adults utilized prediction strategies to detect errors, while older adults did not. Both age groups showed faster reading times for unexpected words in high-constraint within-sentence positions.

JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY-LEARNING MEMORY AND COGNITION (2023)

Article Education & Educational Research

The Effect of Spacing Versus Massing on Orthographic Learning

Signy Wegener, Hua-Chen Wang, Elisabeth Beyersmann, Erik D. Reichle, Kate Nation, Anne Castles

Summary: Little is known about the influence of temporal spacing on orthographic form learning. This experiment compared the spacing effect on written word form learning across three different outcome measures. The results showed that temporal spacing significantly influenced orthographic form learning, regardless of the outcome measure used.

READING RESEARCH QUARTERLY (2023)

Article Psychology

Lexical Processing Across the Visual Field

Aaron Veldre, Erik D. Reichle, Lili Yu, Sally Andrews

Summary: This article reports six experiments investigating word-identification accuracy and latency in response to speeded binary decisions about letter strings displayed for 100 versus 300 ms at different retinal eccentricities. The findings indicate that lexical-processing performance decreases with eccentricity but to a lesser degree for words displayed in the right visual field. Additionally, the effect of eccentricity is attenuated for tasks requiring deep semantic judgments compared to tasks requiring shallow letter or lexical processing.

JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY-HUMAN PERCEPTION AND PERFORMANCE (2023)

Article Education & Educational Research

Using Eye-Tracking Measures to Predict Reading Comprehension

Diane C. Meziere, Lili Yu, Erik D. Reichle, Titus von Der Malsburg, Genevieve McArthur

Summary: This study examined the potential of eye-tracking as a tool for assessing reading comprehension. The results showed that eye-tracking measures explained significantly more variance than reading-speed data, supporting the idea that reading comprehension tests measure different cognitive processes. It also suggests that eye-tracking may provide a useful alternative for measuring reading comprehension.

READING RESEARCH QUARTERLY (2023)

Article Education & Educational Research

Scanpath Regularity as an Index of Reading Comprehension

Diane C. Meziere, Lili Yu, Genevieve McArthur, Erik D. Reichle, Titus von der Malsburg

Summary: Recent research suggests that the relationship between standard eye-tracking measures and reading comprehension is influenced by differences in task demands. In this study, the researchers compared standard eye-tracking measures and scanpath regularity as predictors of reading comprehension scores. The results showed that both types of eye-tracking measures made unique contributions as predictors of comprehension, and the best set of predictors included both standard eye-tracking measures and at least one scanpath measure. These findings highlight the importance of considering reading goals and task demands when interpreting eye-tracking data.

SCIENTIFIC STUDIES OF READING (2023)

Article Psychology, Experimental

A Corpus-Based Versus Experimental Examination of Word- and Character-Frequency Effects in Chinese Reading: Theoretical Implications for Models of Reading

Lili Yu, Yanping Liu, Erik D. Reichle

Summary: This study investigates the relative roles of character versus whole-word processing in Chinese word identification through an eye-movement experiment, revealing that high-frequency initial characters may actually slow down word identification. The findings have implications for current models of Chinese reading and lead to the development of a new computational model of eye-movement control during Chinese reading.

JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY-GENERAL (2021)

Article Education & Educational Research

Using Eye Movements to Study the Reading of Subtitles in Video

Sixin Liao, Lili Yu, Erik D. Reichle, Jan-Louis Kruger

Summary: The study found that participants adjust their visual routines to prioritize reading subtitles while also viewing video content. Decisions about eye movements are influenced by both local and global task demands, indicating an integration of local and global eye movement control.

SCIENTIFIC STUDIES OF READING (2021)

Article Language & Linguistics

Insights from the study of Arabic reading

Ehab W. Hermena, Erik D. Reichle

LANGUAGE AND LINGUISTICS COMPASS (2020)

Article Psychology, Experimental

The effect of contextual plausibility on word skipping during reading

Aaron Veldre, Erik D. Reichle, Roslyn Wong, Sally Andrews

COGNITION (2020)

Article Psychology, Mathematical

The effects of parafoveal word frequency and segmentation on saccade targeting during Chinese reading

Yanping Liu, Lili Yu, Le Fu, Wenwen Li, Ziyi Duan, Erik D. Reichle

PSYCHONOMIC BULLETIN & REVIEW (2019)

Article Neurosciences

Mapping the daily rhythmic transcriptome in the diabetic retina

Ryan P. Silk, Hanagh R. Winter, Ouria Dkhissi-Benyahya, Carmella Evans -Molina, Alan W. Stitt, Vijay K. Tiwari, David A. Simpson, Eleni Beli

Summary: This study investigates whether diabetes affects the daily rhythm of gene expression in the retina. The results show that diabetic mice exhibited phase advancement in the expression of certain genes compared to non-diabetic mice. The study also identified oxygen-sensing mechanisms and HIF1alpha as potential upstream regulators. These findings provide important insights into the development of diabetic retinopathy.

VISION RESEARCH (2024)

Article Neurosciences

Alterations to foveal crowding with microsaccade preparation

Krishnamachari S. Prahalad, Daniel R. Coates

Summary: Visual stimuli presented around the time of a saccade can be perceived differently by the visual system, including a reduction in the harmful impact of flankers. This study investigated the effects of microsaccades on crowded stimuli placed 20 arc minutes from the center of gaze. The findings suggest two separate pre-saccadic benefits, one that regularizes the crowding zone and another that specifically benefits microsaccade targets surrounded by tangential flankers.

VISION RESEARCH (2024)

Article Neurosciences

Success rates, near-response patterns, and learning trends with free-fusion stereograms

Chandrika Ravisankar, Christopher W. Tyler, Clifton M. Schor, Shrikant R. Bharadwaj

Summary: This study revealed that less than one-third of adults with normal binocular vision were able to successfully free-fuse random-dot image pairs and identify the embedded stereoscopic shapes. The successful participants showed a dissociation of vergence and accommodative responses, while the unsuccessful ones either exhibited strong vergence and accommodation or weak vergence and strong accommodation. Task performance of the unsuccessful cluster improved significantly with pharmacological paralysis of accommodation. A minority of participants also learned to dissociate one direction of their vergence and accommodation crosslinks with repeated free-fusion trials, optimizing their task performance.

VISION RESEARCH (2024)