4.2 Article

A review of odonatology in freshwater applied ecology and conservation science

Journal

FRESHWATER SCIENCE
Volume 34, Issue 3, Pages 1023-1031

Publisher

UNIV CHICAGO PRESS
DOI: 10.1086/682174

Keywords

dragonflies; assessment; climate change; monitoring; landscape planning; freshwater health; biodiversity conservation

Funding

  1. National Research Foundation, South Africa

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The academic study of dragonflies and damselflies (odonatology) is well established, but relatively limited attention has been given to odonates in the context of applied ecology and conservation science. We used the Web of Science (TM) and Odonatological Abstract Service (ISSN 1438-0269) to capture trends in primary literature, characterize study features (habitats, life stages, etc.), identify research themes, and suggest future directions for odonatology in freshwater applied ecology and conservation science. We found no papers in this area prior to 1980, and 411 papers from 1980 through 2013. Nearly 75% of these papers were recent (since 2005) and >40% were very recent (since 2010). We identified several broad and overlapping research themes: 1) model taxa, 2) tools and indicators, 3) odonate-centered work, and 4) methodological issues and improvements (field sampling, data modeling/simulation, conservation/landscape-scale genetics). We found more reliance on field-based observational approaches than experiments and model-driven exercises, although the number of papers using model-driven exercises is rapidly increasing. We found a strong focus on adult stages, odonate assemblages, the Odonata as a whole, and studies of particular species. We identified research priorities in areas such as ecological valuation and management, monitoring and assessment, climate change and landscape planning, concordance with other taxa, effects of urbanization, data modeling/simulation, and rare-species ecology and conservation. To help establish an identity and facilitate communication, we suggest naming this diverse realm applied odonatology. We think applied odonatology has a good future for a range of topics from conservation genetics and population ecology to assessments of anthropogenic impacts and the conservation of biodiversity.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.2
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Taxonomic distinctness poorly reflects floristic quality in a wetland study system

Suneeti K. Jog, Jason T. Bried

Summary: This study explored the relationship between taxonomic diversity and evolutionary structure in vascular plant assemblages, finding positive correlations between ecological conservatism and native richness with average taxonomic distinctness, and a negative correlation with exotic species. However, the ambiguity and nonlinear relationship of richness suggest that it may not be a suitable bioindicator for wetlands. Further research is needed to understand how evolutionary structure plays a role in bioassessment.

ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS (2021)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Predicting the distributions of regional endemic dragonflies using a combined model approach

Wade A. Boys, Adam M. Siepielski, Brenda D. Smith, Michael A. Patten, Jason T. Bried

Summary: This study combined the predictions of two machine learning algorithms to estimate the current and future distributions of two endemic dragonflies in the Ozark-Ouachita Interior Highlands region, showing the utility of these models in guiding field surveys. Future projections under climate change scenarios support maintaining current suitable areas. The results suggest that combining outputs of multiple species distribution models is a useful tool for informing the distributions of geographically limited or rare species.

INSECT CONSERVATION AND DIVERSITY (2021)

Article Ecology

Relative importance of ecological versus biological traits in driving range sizes of African dragonflies

Charl Deacon, Michael J. Samways, James S. Pryke

Summary: Ecological and biological traits interact to shape the geographical ranges of dragonfly species in Africa. Single traits are weak predictors of species range sizes, and investigating multiple traits simultaneously is recommended for more accurate predictions.

JOURNAL OF BIOGEOGRAPHY (2021)

Review Entomology

A Review of the Impacts and Opportunities for African Urban Dragonflies

Charl Deacon, Michael J. Samways

Summary: The expansion of urban areas combined with climate change poses great threats to dragonflies in southern Africa, requiring effective mitigation measures for their protection. Dragonflies play a crucial role in freshwater ecosystems and serve as conservation umbrellas for other species.

INSECTS (2021)

Article Entomology

Research networks should improve connectivity for halting freshwater insect extinctions

Francisco Valente-Neto, Ana Claudia Piovezan-Borges, Gustavo Lima Urbieta, Michae J. Samways, Fabio de Oliveira Roque

Summary: The study revealed that developed countries played a dominant role in the research collaboration network on freshwater insect extinction, while there were varying levels of connectivity in the networks of status, threats, and solutions research. Collaboration in research should be increased to reduce inequalities between developed and developing countries, aiming to benefit freshwater insect conservation science and practice.

ECOLOGICAL ENTOMOLOGY (2022)

Article Ecology

Identifying managerial legacies within conservation corridors using remote sensing and grasshoppers as bioindicators

K. Jurie Theron, James S. Pryke, Michael J. Samways

Summary: Biodiversity conservation requires effective management of key areas, including natural grassland conservation corridors, which improve landscape connectivity and mitigate fragmentation. Grasshoppers were used as indicators, showing positive responses to historic grassland activity and the important role of habitat heterogeneity for maintaining diversity. Satellite imagery is effective for monitoring grasshopper responses to vegetation changes within corridors.

ECOLOGICAL APPLICATIONS (2022)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Improved detection of mass effect species assembly for applied metacommunity thinking

Jason T. Bried, Annika Vilmi

Summary: This article discusses the challenges and opportunities of dispersal mass effects in applied metacommunity ecology. The authors propose a new detection framework and test its applicability on a stream diatom survey. They find evidence of mass effects in the diatom groups, but due to data uncertainties, they suggest an alternate framework for more precise and robust detection.

JOURNAL OF APPLIED ECOLOGY (2022)

Article Ecology

Nonnative Species Limitation of Floristic Quality Scores in Wetland Mitigation Performance and Multimetric Health assessment

Jason T. Bried, Suneeti K. Jog

Summary: Nonnative species can limit floristic quality scores, affecting wetland restoration and ecological health goals. However, their impact may be less significant in multimetric situations.

WETLANDS (2022)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Large African herbivore diversity is essential in transformed landscapes for conserving dung beetle diversity

James S. Pryke, Francois Roets, Michael J. Samways

Summary: Mammals are declining globally due to habitat loss. Human-wildlife conflicts have led to the fencing off of ranges for many large mammal species. However, the impact of this activity on the functional associations between insects and large mammals has not been well studied.

JOURNAL OF APPLIED ECOLOGY (2022)

Article Ecology

Maintaining functional connectivity in grassland corridors between plantation forests promotes high-quality habitat and conserves range restricted grasshoppers

K. Jurie Theron, James S. Pryke, Michael J. Samways

Summary: Grassland corridors within commercial timber plantations in South Africa have the potential to connect conservation areas, but the impact of the production landscape on functional connectivity has not been investigated. This study used grasshoppers as indicators and combined species distribution modelling, functional connectivity analysis, and community analysis to understand how these corridors contribute to biodiversity conservation. The results show that wide corridors with different elevations and slopes support different grasshopper assemblages and promote species turnover. Functional connectivity depends on the availability of high-quality habitat shaped by prescribed burning, with implications for range restricted species. Not all high-quality habitat is functionally connected, suggesting the need for conservation intervention.

LANDSCAPE ECOLOGY (2022)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Interplay between amount of natural vegetation and effective vineyard management practices benefits local arthropod diversity

M. Geldenhuys, R. Gaigher, J. S. Pryke, M. J. Samways

Summary: Understanding the effects of agricultural practices on farmland biodiversity requires a landscape perspective. This study found that increasing in-crop herbaceous vegetation in vineyards can increase the species richness of overall arthropods and ubiquitous arthropods. Additionally, the interplay between the amount of natural vegetation and local-scale processes influences the composition of arthropod assemblages.

BIODIVERSITY AND CONSERVATION (2022)

Article Soil Science

Timber plantations do not homogenize soil arthropod diversity but do alter species composition

Michelle Eckert, Rene Gaigher, James S. Pryke, Charlene Janion-Scheepers, Michael J. Samways

Summary: Landscape transformation for agriculture threatens biodiversity. A study in South Africa found that large-scale timber plantations showed similar levels of biodiversity as natural vegetation for ants and springtails. The high diversity in plantations may be due to environmental variation among sites. Plantations and natural areas supported complementary assemblages.

GEODERMA (2022)

Article Ecology

The potential of trait data to increase the availability of bioindicators: A case study using plant conservatism values

Varina E. Crisfield, Cari D. Ficken, Brandon E. Allen, Suneeti K. Jog, Jason T. Bried

Summary: Biological indicators are commonly used to evaluate ecosystem condition, but their use is often constrained by the availability of species-specific indicator values. This study tests the potential of approximating missing bioindicator values using publicly accessible trait data. The results show consistency between trait values and expert-assigned ecological conservatism scores (C-scores), suggesting traits can be used to predict C-scores.

ECOLOGICAL APPLICATIONS (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Interplay between pond size and matrix extent drives odonate diversity patterns in a fragmented landscape

Charl Deacon, Michael J. Samways, James S. Pryke

Summary: Landscape fragmentation affects freshwater habitats and quality, impacting aquatic insect communities. Adjacent terrestrial areas serve as important secondary habitats for amphibiotic insects. Zygopterans are more sensitive to fragmentation, while anisopterans show more resilience and habitat selectivity based on water chemistry and vegetation characteristics.

BIODIVERSITY AND CONSERVATION (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Indigenous forest edges increase habitat complexity and refuge opportunities for grassland butterflies

Rene Gaigher, James S. Pryke, Michael J. Samways

Summary: Heterogeneity at local and landscape scales plays an important role in promoting insect diversity and mitigating insect declines caused by global change. In this study, the researchers examined the use of indigenous forest-grassland edges by butterflies. They found that forest edges supported a diverse butterfly assemblage, with forest specialists being more diverse at forest edges than in grassland. The researchers also observed more interactions and patrolling behavior at forest edges, while feeding and transient behavior were more common in grassland. The occurrence and behavioral patterns were not influenced by season, indicating that the influence of forests remains consistent under varying environmental conditions. However, certain species showed a preference for forest edges in the hot and windy season, suggesting that the shelter provided by forest edges influences butterfly habitat use. The study highlights the importance of conserving forest patches in coastal grasslands for butterfly populations in the face of global change.

JOURNAL OF INSECT CONSERVATION (2023)

No Data Available