4.4 Article

A Reexamination of the Classical PKN Model of Hydraulic Fracture

Journal

TRANSPORT IN POROUS MEDIA
Volume 81, Issue 2, Pages 317-339

Publisher

SPRINGER
DOI: 10.1007/s11242-009-9403-4

Keywords

Hydraulic fracture; PKN model

Funding

  1. American Chemical Society [ACS-PRF43081-AC8]
  2. Schlumberger Moscow Research

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This article reexamines the classical PKN model of hydraulic fracture Perkins and Kern (J. Pet. Tech. Trans. AIME, 222:937-949 (1961)) and Nordgren (J. Pet. Tech. 253:306-314 (1972)) using novel approaches, which have recently been developed to tackle this class of problems that are characterized by a moving boundary and strong non-linearities in the governing equations. First, we demonstrate, using scaling arguments only, that a PKN hydraulic fracture has two limiting time asymptotic behaviors: storage-dominated at small time, and leak-off-dominated at large time. Next, we investigate the multiscale nature of the tip asymptotics and its implication for the construction of a robust and efficient numerical algorithm. In particular, we show that in the storage-dominated regime the tip aperture w behaves according to w similar to x (1/3) (where x is the distance from the tip), and in the leak-off-dominated regime according t similar to x (3/8). However, the solution in the leak-off-dominated regime has a boundary layer structure at the tip, with w similar to x (3/8) acting as an intermediate asymptote that matches an inner solution with a w similar to x (1/3) asymptote to the outer (global) solution. Finally, we describe an efficient numerical algorithm with the multiscale tip asymptotics embedded in the tip element, which is used to compute the transient solution that connects the small- and large-time asymptotes.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.4
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Mechanics

Fracture toughness interpretation from breakdown pressure

Yue Gao, Emmanuel Detournay

Summary: Experimental evidence shows that the measured toughness increases with confining stress. However, interpreting the observed breakdown pressure relies on assuming uniform fluid pressure in the cracks and identifying the peak pressure with fracture initiation pressure. The model challenges these assumptions by considering fluid lag and hydraulic compliance, indicating that the actual toughness may be overestimated when the breakdown pressure is used to interpret it.

ENGINEERING FRACTURE MECHANICS (2021)

Article Mechanics

Force on a moving liquid blister

Zhi-Qiao Wang, Emmanuel Detournay

Summary: This paper investigates the motion of a liquid blister trapped between an elastic sheet and a rigid substrate, driven by a frictionless blade. The study aims to evaluate the force applied by the blade on the moving blister, with solutions depending on two controlling numbers. The results show that for small gaps, the force is dominated by viscous dissipation, while for larger gaps, the force depends on both toughness and gap size.

JOURNAL OF FLUID MECHANICS (2021)

Article Engineering, Geological

Hydraulic fracturing of weak rock during waterflooding

Emmanuel Detournay, Yera Hakobyan

Summary: The paper presents a KGD-type model for hydraulic fracture in weak, poorly consolidated rocks, with a key assumption that the hydraulic fields are quasi-stationary. The model shows the growth of fracture as a square root of time and the transition between early and late time asymptotic flow regimes.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL FOR NUMERICAL AND ANALYTICAL METHODS IN GEOMECHANICS (2022)

Article Engineering, Multidisciplinary

Eshelbian force on a steadily moving liquid blister

Zhi-Qiao Wang, Emmanuel Detournay

Summary: This paper investigates the dynamics of a liquid blister forced to advance between a thin elastic sheet and a rigid substrate by the dual action of a piston and a flat frictionless sleeve. The study focuses on the dependence of external driving force on blister velocity, fluid viscosity, elastic properties of the sheet, and interface toughness, with a particular emphasis on the Eshelbian nature of the horizontal driving force. The numerical and asymptotic solutions predict the scaled horizontal force on the moving liquid blister and highlight the importance of three key numbers in controlling the solution.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ENGINEERING SCIENCE (2022)

Article Engineering, Geological

Drag bit/rock interface laws for the transition between two layers

Arviandy G. Aribowo, Roeland Wildemans, Emmanuel Detournay, Nathan Van de wouw

Summary: This paper extends the drag (PDC) bit interface laws for homogeneous rocks to the transition between two rock layers with distinct mechanical properties. A model is formulated to establish the relationships between the weight-on-bit, torque-on-bit, depth-of-cut per bit revolution, and engagement parameter of the bit in the lower rock layer. The paper shows that the drilling efficiency depends nonlinearly on the bit engagement between the two rock layers.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ROCK MECHANICS AND MINING SCIENCES (2022)

Article Mechanics

Hydraulic fracture induced by water injection in weak rock

Yue Gao, Emmanuel Detournay

Summary: This paper describes a two-dimensional model of a hydraulic fracture propagating in a weakly consolidated, highly permeable reservoir rock during a waterflooding operation. The model highlights essential differences from conventional hydraulic fracturing treatments of oil and gas wells and reveals the non-monotonic evolution of injection pressure over time. Poroelasticity significantly affects the response of the system, increasing injection pressure and delaying the time at which the peak pressure occurs.

JOURNAL OF FLUID MECHANICS (2021)

Article Energy & Fuels

Influence of PDC bit cutter layout on stick-slip vibrations of deep drilling systems

Kaixiao Tian, Emmanuel Detournay

Summary: This paper extends the class of models simulating self-excited vibrations in a rotary drilling system by considering different types of PDC bits, and proposes algorithms to address technical challenges. Linear stability analysis is based on geometric variations of the bit/rock engagement surfaces to determine critical rotation speeds for different stability regions.

JOURNAL OF PETROLEUM SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING (2021)

Article Robotics

A Simple Free-Fold Test to Measure Bending Stiffness of Slender Soft Actuators

Gillian J. McDonald, Emmanuel Detournay, Timothy M. Kowalewski

Summary: A reliable estimate for bending stiffness is crucial for predicting various aspects of soft robot performance. Current methods rely on accurate material knowledge, and measuring actuator stiffness can be costly and complex.

IEEE ROBOTICS AND AUTOMATION LETTERS (2021)

Article Engineering, Manufacturing

An Alternative Approach to Compute Chip Thickness in Milling

Kaidong Chen, He Zhang, Nathan van de Wouw, Emmanuel Detournay

Summary: This paper introduces a method for describing the milled surface using a surface function and accurately computing the instantaneous undeformed chip thickness (IUCT). The method overcomes the inaccuracies of traditional models and shows promise for computing the IUCT in milling processes.

JOURNAL OF MANUFACTURING SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING-TRANSACTIONS OF THE ASME (2022)

Article Mathematics, Applied

A high-dimensional model to study the self-excited oscillations of rotary drilling systems

He Zhang, Emmanuel Detournay

Summary: This paper analyzes the self-excited axial and torsional vibrations of rotary drilling systems using a complex mathematical model that combines the drilling structure with a rate-independent bit-rock interface law. By utilizing an algorithm to convert the system of PDE-ODEs into a system of coupled ODEs and linearizing the system for stability analysis, the paper concludes that the effects of damping on the stability of drilling system is generally negligible in the range of practical drilling parameters. Extensive parametric studies have shown that bit wearflats play a crucial role in delaying or suppressing torsional stick-slip oscillations.

COMMUNICATIONS IN NONLINEAR SCIENCE AND NUMERICAL SIMULATION (2022)

Article Mechanics

An experimental investigation of brittle failure mechanisms in scratch tests of rock

He Zhang, Jia-Liang Le, Emmanuel Detournay

Summary: This paper reports the results of scratch tests on three different rocks, showing the existence of three cutting regimes with different fragment shapes and specific energy-depth relationships. It also provides evidence from video recording and fractography to distinguish different failure modes.

ENGINEERING FRACTURE MECHANICS (2022)

Article Mechanics

The arrest and recession dynamics of a deflating hydraulic fracture in a permeable elastic medium in a state of plane strain

Anthony Peirce, Emmanuel Detournay

Summary: The deflation dynamics of a fluid-driven fracture in a permeable elastic medium are investigated in this study. The research findings show that the deflation of the fracture is influenced by the leak-off characteristics of the porous medium and the stress intensity factor of the fracture. A numerical scheme is established to explore the deflation dynamics of plane strain hydraulic fractures, and scaling analysis reveals the existence of asymptotic power law behaviors for various quantities.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SOLIDS AND STRUCTURES (2022)

Article Mechanics

Multiscale tip asymptotics for a deflating hydraulic fracture with leak-off

Anthony Peirce, Emmanuel Detournay

Summary: This paper discusses the construction of tip asymptotes for a hydraulic fracture in a permeable elastic medium. It describes the changing nature of the asymptotic fields during the arrest and recession phases of the fracture after fluid injection has ended. The paper shows that as the fracture deflates, the dominance of the linear elastic fracture mechanics tip asymptote shrinks, giving way to an intermediate asymptote. The front velocity affects the development of a linear asymptote at the fracture tip, with the intermediate asymptote reappearing. These universal multiscale asymptotes are crucial for determining the decaying stress intensity factor, transition from arrest to recession, and front velocity during recession using computational algorithms.

JOURNAL OF FLUID MECHANICS (2022)

Article Engineering, Geological

Fluid injection-induced cavity expansion in dry porous medium

Jithin S. Kumar, Abhijit Chaudhuri, Emmanuel Detournay, Ramesh Kannan Kandasami

Summary: In this study, a model is proposed to analyze the deformation around a cylindrical cavity caused by fluid injection. The study investigates the solution in different phases and introduces a time-dependent permeation coefficient and four time-dependent variables to solve the problem. A parametric analysis of the influence of material stiffness and strength on the solution is conducted.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL FOR NUMERICAL AND ANALYTICAL METHODS IN GEOMECHANICS (2023)

Article Mechanics

Sunset similarity solution for a receding hydraulic fracture

Anthony Peirce, Emmanuel Detournay

Summary: This paper explores approximate 'sunset' similarity solutions for receding hydraulic fractures in permeable elastic media. It shows that the linear aperture of a receding hydraulic fracture has a linear asymptote and can be described by polynomial solutions. The paper also demonstrates that the sunset solution forms an attractor for a wide range of hydraulic fractures as they approach closure. Furthermore, the paper finds that the sunset solution is dependent on only one material parameter, the leak-off coefficient, which can be determined through laboratory or field measurements.

JOURNAL OF FLUID MECHANICS (2022)

No Data Available