4.1 Article

Phenologically explicit models for studying plant-pollinator interactions under climate change

Journal

THEORETICAL ECOLOGY
Volume 7, Issue 3, Pages 289-297

Publisher

SPRINGER HEIDELBERG
DOI: 10.1007/s12080-014-0218-8

Keywords

Allee effect; Flower senescence; Pollinator emigration; Non-autonomous ordinary differential equation; Temporal match-mismatch hypothesis; Phenology; Zonneveld equation

Categories

Funding

  1. US National Science Foundation [DMS-1118623, DMS-1225917]
  2. Coordenacao de Aperfeicoamento de Pessoal de nivel Superior (CAPES) [BEX 8971/11-0]
  3. Direct For Biological Sciences
  4. Division Of Environmental Biology [1354104] Funding Source: National Science Foundation
  5. Direct For Mathematical & Physical Scien
  6. Division Of Mathematical Sciences [1225917] Funding Source: National Science Foundation
  7. Direct For Mathematical & Physical Scien
  8. Division Of Mathematical Sciences [1118623] Funding Source: National Science Foundation

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Climate change is significantly influencing phenology. One potential effect is that historically interacting partners will respond to climate change at different rates, creating the potential for a phenological mismatch among previously synchronized interacting species, or even sexes of the same species. Focusing on plant demographics in a plant-pollinator interaction, we develop a hybrid dynamical model that uses a non-autonomous differential equation system (Zonneveld model) for within-season dynamics and discrete equations for season-to-season dynamics. Our model outlines how and when changes in the relative phenologies of an interacting species pair will alter the demographic outcome of the interaction. For our plant-pollinator system, we find that plant population growth rates are particularly sensitive to phenology mismatch when flowers are short-lived, when pollinators are short-lived, or when flowers and pollinators exhibit high levels of within-population synchrony in emergence or arrival dates. More generally, our aim is to introduce the use of hybrid dynamical models as a framework through which researchers can directly explore the demographic consequences of climatically driven phenological change.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.1
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Ecology

ATLANTIC POLLINATION: a data set of flowers and interaction with nectar-feeding vertebrates from the Atlantic Forest

Joice Iamara-Nogueira, Natalia Targhetta, Gina Allain, Adriano Gambarini, Alessandra R. Pinto, Ana Maria Rui, Andrea C. Araujo, Ariadna Lopes, Brenda Pereira-Silva, Bruna Bertagni de Camargo, Caio Graco Machado, Caio Missagia, Carolina Scultori, Danilo Boscolo, Erich Fischer, Evellyn Silva Araujo-Oliveira, Henrique Gava, Hipolito Ferreira Paulino-Neto, Isabel Cristina Machado, Isabela Galarda Varassin, Ivan Sazima, Jeferson Vizentin-Bugoni, Jessica Luiza Sousa Silva, Julia de Oliveira Ferreira, Juliana Narita, Juliana Silveira dos Santos, Kayna Agostini, Leandro Freitas, Luciano Elsinor Lopes, Ludimila Juliele Carvalho-Leite, Marcelo Tabarelli, Marcia Alexandra Rocca, Marcia Luzia Malanotte, Maria Alice S. Alves, Maria Bernadete F. Canela, Maria Rosa Darrigo, Marina Muniz Moreira, Marina Wolowski, Marlies Sazima, Mauro Galetti, Milton Cesar Ribeiro, Milton Groppo, Miriam Kaehler, Milson dos Anjos Batista, Oswaldo Cruz Neto, Patricia Alves Ferreira, Pedro J. Bergamo, Pietro K. Maruyama, Raquel O. Bueno, Roberta L. B. Leal, Rogerio Rodrigues Faria, Simone Bazarian, Tiago Malucelli, Silvana Buzato

Summary: The interaction between flowering plants and nectar-feeding vertebrates in the Brazilian Atlantic Forest is diverse and important. This dataset provides detailed information on the interactions between 515 species of flowering plants and 129 species of potential pollinators. It also includes information on the characteristics of both plants and vertebrates that are relevant to their interactions.

ECOLOGY (2022)

Article Ecology

Consumers' active choice behaviour promotes coevolutionary units in antagonistic networks

Allan Mauricio Sanches Baptista de Alvarenga, Marcelo Eduardo Borges, Leonardo Re Jorge, Isabela Galarda Varassin, Sabrina Borges Lino Araujo

Summary: Individual behavior and local context play a crucial role in influencing the evolution of ecological interactions and network structure. Consumers can increase their fitness by actively choosing resources in trophic interactions, and mathematical modeling is often used to understand coevolutionary dynamics. Active consumer choice behavior is shown to be important in structuring interacting communities.

JOURNAL OF EVOLUTIONARY BIOLOGY (2022)

Article Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

The structure of tropical bat-plant interaction networks during an extreme El Nino-Southern Oscillation event

Hernani F. M. Oliveira, Rafael Barros Pereira Pinheiro, Isabela Galarda Varassin, Bernal Rodriguez-Herrera, Maria Kuzmina, Stephen J. Rossiter, Elizabeth L. Clare

Summary: The structure of bat-plant networks in tropical forests is affected by precipitation levels, with higher precipitation leading to more modular and less nested networks. Contrary to expectations, drier conditions result in lower nestedness and higher modularity. The network structures are similar between El Nino and non-El Nino years in dry forests and rainforests.

MOLECULAR ECOLOGY (2022)

Article Plant Sciences

First report on generalized pollination systems in Melastomataceae for the Andean paramos

Naisla Manrique Valderrama, Isabela Galarda Varassin, Luan Salles Passos, Maria Eugenia Morales Puentes

Summary: Melastomataceae is a diverse family with species that have transitioned from specialized to generalized pollination systems. These transitions are associated with colonization of new habitats that have unpredictable or limited pollinators. In this study, the floral traits and visitors of two species in the Colombian Andes were examined to understand the generalization of their pollination systems. The breeding system of one of the species was also investigated. The results showed that flower and anther morphology, combined with nectar production, contribute to a generalist pollination system shared by the two species. This is the first report of a generalist pollination system in Miconia and Melastomataceae in the Andes, as well as the first report for species from specific sections in Colombia.

PLANT SPECIES BIOLOGY (2022)

Article Environmental Studies

Climate change and phenology

David W. Inouye

Summary: Climate change is a significant aspect of the current ecological landscape that impacts global and local environments. Researchers have progressed from basic descriptions of temporal changes to investigating the underlying causes, impacts, and consequences of these changes at both ecological and evolutionary scales. This era presents an exciting yet sometimes disheartening time for scientists.

WILEY INTERDISCIPLINARY REVIEWS-CLIMATE CHANGE (2022)

Article Ecology

Skewness in bee and flower phenological distributions

Michael Stemkovski, Rachel G. Dickson, Sean R. Griffin, Brian D. Inouye, David W. Inouye, Gabriella L. Pardee, Nora Underwood, Rebecca E. Irwin

Summary: This study provides the first comprehensive assessment of skewness in a bee community, and finds that both bee and flower phenologies tend to be right-skewed, with a more exaggerated asymmetry in bees. Early-season species tend to be the most skewed, and this relationship is also stronger in bees than in flowers. Differences in bee and flower skewness could account for up to 14% of pairwise overlap differences.

ECOLOGY (2023)

Article Ecology

Atlantic flower-invertebrate interactions: A data set of occurrence and frequency of floral visits

Danilo Boscolo, Barbara Nobrega Rodrigues, Patricia Alves Ferreira, Luciano Elsinor Lopes, Vinicius Rodrigues Tonetti, Isabela Cristhina Reis dos Santos, Juliana Akemi Hiruma-Lima, Laura Nery, Karoline Baptista de Lima, Jessica Perozi, Andre Victor Lucci Freitas, Blandina Felipe Viana, Caio Antunes-Carvalho, Dalton de Souza Amorim, Favizia Freitas de Oliveira, Milton Groppo, Maria Lucia Absy, Renata Jimenez de Almeida-Scabbia, Anderson Alves-Araujo, Felipe Wanderley de Amorim, Pablo Augusto Poleto Antiqueira, Yasmine Antonini, Camila Aoki, Daniele dos Santos Aragao, Tais Cristina Teixeira Balbino, Michele da Silva Ferreira Bandeira, Bruno Correa Barbosa, Maria Regina de Vasconcellos Barbosa, Gudryan Jackson Baronio, Levi Oliveira Barros, Mariana Beal-Neves, Victor Martins Bertollo, Antonio Diego de Melo Bezerra, Cristiano Roberto Buzatto, Liedson Tavares Carneiro, Edilson Caron, Camila Silva Carpim, Emanuela Simoura Carvalho, Tuane Leticia Carvalho, Ludimila Juliele Carvalho-Leite, Mainara Figueiredo Cascaes, Flavio Siqueira de Castro, Adriano Cavalleri, Eliana Cazetta, Monise Terra Cerezini, Luis Francisco Mello Coelho, Renato Colares, Guaraci Duran Cordeiro, Juliana Hipolito, Angela Maria da Silva Correa, Fernanda Vieira da Costa, Cleber Covre, Renata Drummond Marinho Cruz, Oswaldo Cruz-Neto, Leo Correia-da-Rocha-Filho, Jacques Hubert Charles Delabie, Marcos da Costa Dorea, Viviany Teixeira do-Nascimento, Jean Miguel Alves dos-Santos, Marcelo Duarte, Marilia Cristina Duarte, Olivia Maria Pereira Duarte, Julie Henriette Antoinette Dutilh, Betina Pereira Emerick, Gabrielly dos Santos Fabiano, Fernando Henrique Antoniolli Farache, Ana Paula Gelli de Faria, Geraldo Wilson Fernandes, Pedro Maria Abreu Ferreira, Maria Juliana Ferreira-Caliman, Livia Maria Negrini Ferreira, Tulio Freitas Filgueira de Sa, Edivani Villaron Franceschinelli, Greice Ayra Franco-Assis, Frederico de Siqueira Neves, Breno Magalhaes Freitas, Joelcio Freitas, Natalia Arias Galastri, Leonardo Galetto, Caroline Tito Garcia, Maria Teresa Amela Garcia, Nicole Luize Garcia, Carlos Alberto Garofalo, Irene Gelvez-Zuniga, Camila da Silva Goldas, Tadeu Jose Guerra, Tania Mara Guerra, Birgit Harter-Marques, Juliana Hipolito, Rafael Martins, Ricardo Pablo Klein, Elmo Borges de Azevedo Koch, Paulo Landgref-Filho, Sebastiao Laroca, Cristiane Martins Leandro, Reinanda Lima, Taysla Roberta Almeida de Lima, Luiz Wilson Lima-Verde, Elton John de Lirio, Ariadna Valentina Lopes, Andrea Pereira Luizi-Ponzo, Isabel Cristina Sobreira Machado, Tatiana Machado, Fabricio Severo Magalhaes, Thiago Mahlmann, Clea dos Santos Ferreira Mariano, Thamy Evellini Dias Marques, Felipe Martello, Celso Feitosa Martins, Mauricio Nogueira Martins, Rafael Martins, Andre Luiz Santos Mascarenhas, Geovana de Assis Mendes, Milton de Souza Mendonca, Luiz Menini Neto, Michaele Alvim Milward-de-Azevedo, Adrianne Oliveira Miranda, Paula Maria Montoya-Pfeiffer, Andreza Magro Moraes, Bruna Borges Moraes, Eduardo Freitas Moreira, Maria Santina Morini, Diego Moure-Oliveira, Leticia Fabri De Nadai, Victor Hideki Nagatani, Michelle Helena Nervo, Frederico de Siqueira Neves, Jailson Santos de Novais, Evellyn Silva Araujo-Oliveira, Joao Henrique Figueredo de Oliveira, Alipio Jose de Souza Pacheco-Filho, Luciano Palmieri, Martin Pareja, Marcella de Almeida Passarella, Nayra da Mata Passos, Hipolito Ferreira Paulino-Neto, Ariane Luna Peixoto, Luciana Carvalho Pereira, Rodrigo Augusto Santinelo Pereira, Brenda Pereira-Silva, Jimmy Pincheira-Ulbrich, Mardiore Pinheiro, Augusto Joao Piratelli, Luciana Regina Podgaiski, Diego Santos Polizello, Livia Pires do Prado, Fabio Prezoto, Franciele Rosset de Quadros, Elisa Pereira Queiroz, Zelma Glebya Maciel Quirino, Ananza Mara Rabello, Gabriela Beatriz Pereira Rabeschini, Monna Myrnna Mangueira Ramalho, Flavio Nunes Ramos, Ludmila Rattis, Luiz Henrique Goncalves de Rezende, Caroline Ribeiro, Lizandra Jaqueline Robe, Ely Marley de Souza Ribeiro Rocha, Ricardo Ribeiro Rodrigues, Gustavo Quevedo Romero, Nadia Roque, William de Oliveira Sabino, Paulo Takeo Sano, Patricia da Silva Santana Reis, Fernando Silva dos Santos, Isabel Alves dos Santos, Francisco de Assis Ribeiro dos Santos, Igor Silva dos Santos, Ricardo Sartorello, Hermes Jose Schmitz, Maria Rosangela Sigrist, Juvenal Cordeiro Silva Junior, Ana Carolina Granero e Silva, Carolina Veronese Correa da Silva, Beatriz Symara Alves Vieira Silva, Bruna Leticia de Freitas Silva, Claudia Ines Silva, Fabiana Oliveira da Silva, Jessica Luiza Souza e Silva, Nathalia Sampaio Silva, Otavio Guilherme Morais da Silva, Carlos de Melo e Silva Neto, Edito Romao Silva Neto, Denise Silveira, Maxwell Souza Silveira, Rodrigo Bustos Singer, Leiza Aparecida Souza Serafim Soares, Evelise Marcia Locatelli de Souza, Jana Magaly Tesserolli de Souza, Josefina Steiner, Mara Cristina Teixeira-Gamarra, Bruno Alves Trentin, Isabela Galarda Varassin, Gabriel Vila-Verde, Vania Nobuko Yoshikawa, Elisabete Maria Zanin, Mauro Galetti, Milton Cezar Ribeiro

Summary: Encounters between flowers and invertebrates play a crucial role in tropical forest ecosystems. This study aims to provide a comprehensive database of flower-invertebrate interactions in the Atlantic Forest. The dataset includes over 18,000 interaction records forming 482 networks, involving 641 plant genera and 581 invertebrate genera. The study highlights the knowledge gap in canopy flower-invertebrate interactions and the need for further research in remote forested areas.

ECOLOGY (2023)

Article Ecology

Evolutionary history and precipitation seasonality shape niche overlap in Neotropical bat-plant pollination networks

Luisa Fernanda Lievano-Latorre, Isabela G. Varassin, Thais B. Zanata

Summary: This study explores the effects of climate seasonality, plant and bat richness, morphological traits, and phylogenetic distance on the niche overlap of Neotropical bat-plant pollination networks. The results indicate that climate seasonality and bat evolutionary history are important drivers of niche overlap in these interactions.

BIOTROPICA (2023)

Article Ecology

Diel niche partitioning of a plant-hummingbird network in the Atlantic forest of Brazil

Andrea Nieto, Rafael O. Wuest, Catherine H. Graham, Isabela G. Varassin

Summary: Niche partitioning is crucial for species coexistence. However, the diel niche partitioning in mutualistic interactions has been overlooked. Through a study of a plant-hummingbird network in the Brazilian Atlantic forest, we found that diel partitioning was not observed for hummingbirds or plants. Instead, hummingbirds specialized in different plant species, suggesting trophic niche partitioning due to competition, while co-flowering plant species shared hummingbird visits during similar times, indicating facilitation. Our findings suggest that plants and hummingbirds have different strategies for promoting coexistence.

OECOLOGIA (2023)

Article Plant Sciences

The effect of species role and trait-matching on plant fitness in a plant-hummingbird interaction network*

Anali Bustos, Rafael O. Wuest, Catherine H. Graham, Isabela G. Varassin

Summary: This study examined the relationship between fitness and interaction selectivity at both the species and individual level in 14 hummingbird-pollinated plant species in the Atlantic Forest. At the species level, there was no relationship between plant fitness and centrality or interaction selectivity, but there was a positive relationship between plant fitness and trait-matching between bill and corolla lengths. At the individual level, individuals with higher centrality values produced fewer seeds likely due to lower pollen deposition quality, while individuals with lower interaction selectivity produced more seeds probably due to higher conspecific pollen flow.

FLORA (2023)

Letter Multidisciplinary Sciences

Brazilian Atlantic rainforest under attack

Caroline Ribeiro, Renata Ruaro, Jana Magaly Tesserolli de Souza, Thomaz Aurelio Pagioro, Isabela Galarda Varassin, Marcia Cristina Mendes Marques, Carlos Eduardo de Viveiros Grelle

SCIENCE (2023)

Article Ecology

Long-term declines in insect abundance and biomass in a subalpine habitat

Rebecca M. Dalton, Nora C. Underwood, David W. Inouye, Michael E. Soule, Brian D. Inouye

Summary: Recent reports of insect declines, attributed to anthropogenic land use intensification and climate change, have raised concerns among scientists and the public. This study provides evidence of long-term continuous declines in insect biomass and abundance in a protected subalpine meadow, which is embedded in an undisturbed natural landscape. The declines were correlated with changes in climate, specifically with less summer precipitation and winter snowfall, as well as warmer temperatures, suggesting that even relatively undisturbed habitats may not be immune to further insect declines.

ECOSPHERE (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Integrating public engagement to intensify pollination services through ecological restoration

Pedro J. Bergamo, Katia F. Rito, Blandina F. Viana, Edenise Garcia, Eimear Nic Lughadha, Marcia M. Maues, AndreR. Rech, Felipe D. S. Silva, Isabela G. Varassin, Kayna Agostini, Marcia C. M. Marques, Pietro K. Maruyama, Nirvia Ravena, Lucas A. Garibaldi, Tiffany M. Knight, Paulo E. A. M. Oliveira, Alberto K. Oppata, Antonio M. Saraiva, Leandro R. Tambosi, Rodrigo Y. Tsukahara, Leandro Freitas, Marina Wolowski

Summary: Human activities threaten nature and ecosystem services, such as pollination. Ecological restoration provides opportunities for biodiversity conservation and sustainable agriculture. However, stakeholders' interactions and power access in social arenas are often overlooked in sustainable agriculture frameworks. This perspective integrates pollination services, ecological restoration, and public engagement for biodiversity conservation and agricultural production to enhance sustainable practices at different scales.

ISCIENCE (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Like an espresso but not like a cappuccino: landscape metrics are useful for predicting coffee production at the farm level but not at the municipality level

Fernando Jeronimo, Isabela G. Varassin

Summary: This paper investigates how landscape structure can influence coffee production at different scales, and evaluates the predictive utility of landscape metrics. The study finds that the composition of the landscape surrounding coffee farms helps predict production in a spatially explicit approach, but these metrics cannot detect the impact of the landscape in an aspatial approach. The findings highlight the importance of landscape spatial structure in the stability of coffee production.

ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING AND ASSESSMENT (2023)

Review Biology

Data standardization of plant-pollinator interactions

Jose A. Salim, Antonio M. Saraiva, Paula F. Zermoglio, Kayna Agostini, Marina Wolowski, Debora P. Drucker, Filipi M. Soares, Pedro J. Bergamo, Isabela G. Varassin, Leandro Freitas, Marcia M. Maues, Andre R. Rech, Allan K. Veiga, Andre L. Acosta, Andrea C. Araujo, Anselmo Nogueira, Betina Blochtein, Breno M. Freitas, Bruno C. Albertini, Camila Maia-Silva, Carlos E. P. Nunes, Carmen S. S. Pires, Charles F. dos Santos, Elisa P. Queiroz, Etienne A. Cartolano, Favizia F. de Oliveira, Felipe W. Amorim, Francisco E. Fonturbel, Gleycon da Silva, Helder Consolaro, Isabel Alves-dos-Santos, Isabel C. Machado, Juliana S. Silva, Katia P. Aleixo, Luisa G. Carvalheiro, Marcia A. Rocca, Mardiore Pinheiro, Michael Hrncir, Nathalia S. Streher, Patricia A. Ferreira, Patricia M. C. de Albuquerque, Pietro K. Maruyama, Rafael C. Borges, Tereza C. Giannini, Vinicius L. G. Brito

Summary: This article presents a vocabulary and data model for sharing plant-pollinator interactions data based on the Darwin Core standard. It aims to fill data and knowledge gaps, enabling scientific research on the ecology and evolution of plant-pollinator communities, biodiversity conservation, ecosystem services, and the development of public policies.

GIGASCIENCE (2022)

No Data Available