4.6 Article

Collaborative diversity in a nanotechnology innovation system: Evidence from the EU Framework Programme

Journal

TECHNOVATION
Volume 31, Issue 9, Pages 476-489

Publisher

ELSEVIER
DOI: 10.1016/j.technovation.2011.05.003

Keywords

Nanotechnology; Research policy; EU; Framework Programme; Collaborative research networks

Funding

  1. Marie Curie European Reintegration Grant [PERG02-GA-2007-224801]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Collaborative diversity is, arguably, an intrinsic characteristic of research networks built on the emergence of general-purpose technologies such as nanotechnology. European research policy, epitomised in Framework Programmes, creates arrangements that institutionalise the development of internationally and institutionally diverse research networks. Motivated by concerns that a high degree of collaborative diversity may create managerial challenges for network members in sharing knowledge across national and institutional borders, we study the configurations of collaborative research networks and consider their international and institutional diversity. We also explore the influence of European policy mechanisms on the international and institutional diversity of collaborative research networks. We conclude that nanotechnology research networks are indeed characterised by a significant degree of collaborative diversity, which in turn exposes a need for participating members to develop strategic capabilities to manage research within diverse networks. (C) 2011 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.6
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Engineering, Multidisciplinary

Managing technologies within an industrial cluster: a case from a toolmakers cluster of Slovenia

Iztok Palcic, Krsto Pandza

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF TECHNOLOGY MANAGEMENT (2015)

Article Business

How strategy professionals develop and sustain an online strategy community - The lessons from Ericsson

Anna Plotnikova, Krsto Pandza, Heraldo Sales-Cavalcante

Summary: The study highlights three main decision areas that strategy professionals need to carefully consider when organizing an online community: the design of the community structure, cooperation of internal and external actors, and formulation of strategic content. The detailed analysis shows characteristic interdependencies among decisions and contradictory demands, making open strategy processes a significant organizational challenge.

LONG RANGE PLANNING (2021)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Exploring the asymmetric complementarity between external knowledge search and management innovation

Sofia Angelidou, Matthew Mount, Krsto Pandza

Summary: This paper examines the substitutional and complementary effects of synchronous deployment of innovation search and management innovation on innovative performance. The findings support the theoretical predictions of a substitutional effect between external search depth and management innovation, and a complementary effect between external search breadth and management innovation. The study provides new theoretical insights into the synchronicity of innovation search and management innovation.

TECHNOVATION (2022)

Article Business

Effects of ambidextrous and specialized R&D strategies on firm performance: The contingent role of industry orientation

Eva Mavroudi, Effie Kesidou, Krsto Pandza

Summary: This study investigates the performance of innovative firms and explores whether they should adopt a specialized or ambidextrous R&D strategy. By comparing a firm's strategy with industry peers, the study identifies how the advantages of these strategies change across industries and which strategy is optimal for a firm. The findings reveal that having a different R&D strategy from industry norms enhances performance, while following the same strategy as others in the industry decreases firm performance. The study also explains how certain industry environments can reduce the need for ambidexterity and help specialized firms improve performance.

JOURNAL OF BUSINESS RESEARCH (2023)

Article Business

Strategic leadership in liminal space: Framing exploration of digital opportunities at hierarchical interfaces

Fathiro H. R. Putra, Krsto Pandza, Saeed Khanagha

Summary: We studied how strategic leaders of established firms frame exploration of digital opportunities at the interfaces of organizational hierarchy. Our analysis revealed that top management teams adopt a paradoxical framing of exploration, creating a liminal space with unstable boundaries between convergence and divergence. Middle managers skillfully navigate this space by combining framing with substantive and symbolic actions to blur the boundaries of exploration. Our findings contribute to understanding the role of framing in setting boundaries for exploration between top management teams and middle managers.

STRATEGIC ENTREPRENEURSHIP JOURNAL (2023)

Article Business

Bending the pipes: Regaining attention through reinvention and renewal

Anna Plotnikova, Krsto Pandza, Richard Whittington

Summary: This study analyzes how a large telecommunication corporation, Ericsson, adapts to changes in attention structures through bottom-up communication channels, and identifies two types of organizational agency: projective agency and iterational agency.

STRATEGIC ORGANIZATION (2023)

Article Management

Could an incumbent firm develop a radically new medical technology with an old organizational capability?

Mark A. Phillips, Krsto Pandza

Summary: Our case study looks into how a pharmaceutical company develops a completely new medical technology. We question whether existing patterns of actions or new organizational capabilities are necessary for such radical innovation. We argue that a conceptual distinction between existing and new organizational capabilities is inadequate for describing radical innovation within an incumbent firm. Multiple modifications across systemic processes are required in developing radical innovation in a nascent innovation ecosystem, where small and interdependent innovations in organizational processes, practices, and structures can make a big difference. Balancing legitimacy-seeking and advantage-seeking actions is crucial in adapting organizational capability for innovation in the nascent innovation ecosystem.

INNOVATION-ORGANIZATION & MANAGEMENT (2023)

Article Education & Educational Research

Encouraging student engagement, interaction, and learning via online discussion boards: Reflections on using Yellowdig in the COVID-19 era

Eva A. Alfoldi

Summary: Yellowdig has gained increasing prominence in higher education during the COVID-19 era and remains a valuable tool for learning even after returning to face-to-face classes. However, instructors need to maintain clear purpose and realistic expectations in order to fully utilize Yellowdig's versatile platform.

JOURNAL OF EDUCATION FOR BUSINESS (2023)

Article Business

Growing pains: Paradoxical tensions and vicious cycles in new venture growth

Abdelghani Es-Sajjade, Krsto Pandza, Henk Volberda

Summary: This article explores how paradoxical tensions related to exploration-exploitation dynamics shape vicious cycles in high-growth ventures. Through a case study at a telecommunications firm in the UK, drivers for the emergence and persistence of these cycles are identified, with some associated with cycle originators and others with cycle perpetuators. The interplay between these drivers culminates in tension escalation and political turnover, demonstrating a self-reinforcing process in the cycles.

STRATEGIC ORGANIZATION (2021)

Article Business

Firm Bosses or Helpful Neighbours? The Ambiguity and Co-Construction of MNE Regional Management Mandates

Eva A. Alfoldi, Sara L. McGaughey, L. Jeremy Clegg

JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT STUDIES (2017)

Review Business

Accelerating the Innovation Process: A Systematic Review and Realist Synthesis of the Research Literature

Paul Ellwood, Paul Grimshaw, Krsto Pandza

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT REVIEWS (2017)

Article Business

Towards Common Ground and Trading Zones in Management Research and Practice

A. Georges L. Romme, Marie-Jose Avenier, David Denyer, Gerard P. Hodgkinson, Krsto Pandza, Ken Starkey, Nicolay Worren

BRITISH JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT (2015)

Article Management

Strategic and ethical foundations for responsible innovation

Krsto Pandza, Paul Ellwood

RESEARCH POLICY (2013)

Proceedings Paper Computer Science, Information Systems

Reconceptualising Dynamic Capabilities: A Design Science Study on the Role of Agency

Abdelghani Es-Sajjade, Krsto Pandza

PRACTICAL ASPECTS OF DESIGN SCIENCE (2012)

Article Business

Shifting back and forth: How does the temporal cycling between exploratory and exploitative R&D influence firm performance?

Eva Mavroudi, Effie Kesidou, Krsto Pandza

JOURNAL OF BUSINESS RESEARCH (2020)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Process and variance research: Integrating research on university spinoff evolution

Athira Bahuleyan, Meena Chavan, Anna Krzeminska, Francesco Chirico

Summary: This paper conducts a systematic literature review to explore the trajectory of university spinoffs (USOs). By examining 120 peer-reviewed journal articles, the paper develops a comprehensive model of USO development and identifies specific factors that affect each phase of development. The study contributes to the academic entrepreneurship literature and highlights the complementary nature of process and variance models in advancing research on USOs.

TECHNOVATION (2024)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Integration of product-service innovation into green supply chain management: Emerging opportunities and paradoxes

Oscar F. Bustinza, Ferran Vendrell-Herrero, Charbel Jose Chiappetta Jabbour

Summary: This article discusses the relationship between product-service innovation and Green Supply Chain Management (GSCM), and presents several key themes, highlighting the vital role of sustainability in mediating technological change and competitiveness.

TECHNOVATION (2024)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Institutional context and agile team innovation: A sensemaking approach to collective knowledge creation

Maria Carmela Annosi, Francesco Paolo Appio, Antonella Martini

Summary: This study provides insights into the role of institutional context in Agile teams' knowledge work. It explores how team members navigate daily situations through sensemaking activities, and uncovers the underlying mechanisms of knowledge management and sensemaking processes within Agile teams. The study highlights the value-driven nature of knowledge creation and identifies distinctive modes of knowledge creation and utilization within teams. It also sheds light on the role of managers in leveraging high-level learning beyond project boundaries, revealing the tension between teams' priorities and managers' suggested actions.

TECHNOVATION (2024)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Filling successive technologically-induced governance gaps: Meta-organizations as regulatory innovation intermediaries

Heloise Berkowitz, Antoine Souchaud

Summary: Successive digital innovations create governance gaps that can be filled by sectoral governance. Through a case study of the FinTech sector in France, this research explores the role of meta-organizations as regulatory innovation intermediaries.

TECHNOVATION (2024)

Review Engineering, Industrial

How can technology assessment tools support sustainable innovation? A systematic literature review and synthesis

Giacomo Parolin, Tim C. Mcaloone, Daniela C. A. Pigosso

Summary: Sustainability considerations are increasingly important for manufacturing companies, especially in the early stages of product design, to promote the development of products and processes with better environmental and social benefits. However, existing sustainability assessment tools are challenging to apply in the uncertain and data-scarce frontend of innovation. A systematic literature review provides best practices and design propositions to improve early-stage sustainability assessment, along with recommendations for designing and implementing sustainability assessment tools in technology development. Opportunities for future research, including refining the design propositions and operationalizing early-stage sustainability assessment, are also proposed.

TECHNOVATION (2024)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Academic intrapreneurs navigating multiple institutional logics: An integrative framework for understanding and supporting intrapreneurship in universities

Jeanette Engzell, Solmaz Filiz Karabag, Anna Ystrom

Summary: This study explores the experiences of intrapreneurs in the academic context and how universities navigate the conflict between intrapreneurial logic and academic logic. The findings highlight the need for intrapreneurs to enhance their skills and integrate elements from intrapreneurship, teaching, and research. Additionally, universities should incorporate intrapreneurial logic into their operational processes to foster intrapreneurial activities.

TECHNOVATION (2024)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Adaptive organizational responses to varied types of failures: Empirical insights from technology providers in Ghana

Matthew Ayamga, Maria Carmela Annosi, Ayalew Kassahun, Wilfred Dolfsma, Bedir Tekinerdogan

Summary: This study investigates how firms respond to and learn from misfits generated from failure. The research reveals that firms exhibit distinct response and learning patterns depending on the type of misfit encountered, and identifies specific strategies and resources utilized by firms.

TECHNOVATION (2024)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Exploring Intrapreneurial Activities in the Context of the Entrepreneurial University: An analysis of five EU HEIs

Colette Henry, Katja Lahikainen

Summary: Higher education institutions are encouraged to become entrepreneurial universities to deliver their third mission and cultivate entrepreneurial graduates. This paper argues that many of the activities engaged in by these institutions can be categorized as intrapreneurship rather than entrepreneurship. The focus on intrapreneurial activities is seen as crucial for sustaining the entrepreneurial university status. By examining the entrepreneurial activities of five universities in Europe, this research highlights the intrapreneurial dimensions and provides insights for future research in the context of intrapreneurship and the entrepreneurial university.

TECHNOVATION (2024)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Unveiling new opportunities: A mixed gamble approach to external search breadth within family firms

Ruben Martinez-Alonso, Maria J. Martinez-Romero, Alfonso A. Rojo-Ramirez

Summary: This study introduces the concept of the 'mixed gamble' of external search breadth for family firms, highlighting the unique trade-off between financial and socioemotional wealth gains and losses. The study examines the influence of family management and family generational stage on this mixed gamble, as well as the impact of export propensity. The findings suggest that family firms with greater family management and in first-generation prioritize current SEW losses over potential gains, resulting in lower external search breadth. However, export propensity can alter this trade-off and lead to higher external search breadth.

TECHNOVATION (2024)

Article Engineering, Industrial

A validated measurement scale for sustainable product innovation performance

Eyup Calik

Summary: The purpose of this study is to develop a validated scale for measuring sustainable product innovation performance in manufacturing companies. Through the use of factor analysis and other methods, the researchers have developed the first validated scale for measuring sustainable product innovation performance. This scale can be used by researchers and manufacturing executives.

TECHNOVATION (2024)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Exogenous crises and SMEs resilience: The Dynamic Open Innovation Funnel

Melissa Vasi, Giuliano Sansone, Vincent English

Summary: This paper investigates the experiences of SMEs in Bavaria and proposes an innovative framework called the Dynamic Open Innovation Funnel, which integrates the managerial constructs of Open Innovation and dynamic capabilities to support SMEs' resilience during exogenous crises.

TECHNOVATION (2024)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Innovation intermediaries at the convergence of digital technologies, sustainability, and governance: A case study of AI-enabled engineering biology

Claire Holland, Adam McCarthy, Priscila Ferri, Philip Shapira

Summary: This research explores the missions and practices of innovation intermediaries involved in the convergence of digital technologies, focusing specifically on AI-enabled engineering biology. Despite the availability of responsible innovation frameworks that encourage attention to societal and sustainability implications, innovation intermediaries in the engineering biology domain still prioritize conventional scale-up and commercialization approaches.

TECHNOVATION (2024)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Is it substantive or just symbolic? Understanding innovation theater in organisations: The case of technology-based innovation

Cristian Granados, Yarid Ayala, Monica Ramos-Mejia

Summary: Innovation is seen as crucial for organizations, but existing research shows that many firms engage in superficial activities when developing technology-based innovations. This phenomenon, known as 'innovation theatre', involves organizations using symbolic actions to legitimize themselves. Our study finds that this is driven by hard, soft, and legitimacy factors.

TECHNOVATION (2024)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Natural language processing for innovation search - Reviewing an emerging non-human innovation intermediary

Julian Just

Summary: Applying artificial intelligence, especially natural language processing, to innovation intermediation activities can help organizations find promising solutions. This study reviews 167 academic articles and identifies 18 distinctive innovation practices where NLP approaches enrich intermediation, such as trend forecasting, illustrating technology and idea landscapes, filtering contributions, recombining knowledge, and matching problems with solutions. The choice of the most appropriate approach depends on the characteristics of the innovation practice.

TECHNOVATION (2024)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Intrapreneurship activity and access to finance in natural science: Evidence from the UK academic spinoffs

David B. Audretsch, Maksim Belitski, Deepa Scarra

Summary: Recent research investigates the impact of digital technologies and growth stages on finance access and profitability of intrapreneurial academic spinoffs. The study emphasizes the significance of the intrapreneur's own development of digital technology, stage of growth, and the field of science in determining finance access and profitability.

TECHNOVATION (2024)