4.6 Article

Clinical and educational proficiency gain of supervised laparoscopic colorectal surgical trainees

Journal

Publisher

SPRINGER
DOI: 10.1007/s00464-013-2806-x

Keywords

Colorectal cancer; Education; Fellowship; Laparoscopic; Learning curve; Training

Categories

Funding

  1. National Cancer Action Team as part of the National Training Program for Laparoscopic Colorectal Surgery
  2. Ethicon Endosurgery

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The self-taught learning curve in laparoscopic colorectal surgery (LCS) is between 100 and 150 cases. Supervised training has been shown to shorten the proficiency gain curve of senior specialist surgeons. Little is known about the learning curve of LCS trainees undergoing mentored training. The aim of this study was to analyze the proficiency gain curve and clinical outcomes of English surgical trainees during laparoscopic colorectal surgery fellowships. In 2010 the educational, Web-based platform from the National Training Program in Laparoscopic Colorectal Surgery in England was newly available to surgical trainees undertaking a laparoscopic colorectal fellowship. These fellows were asked to submit clinical outcomes, including patient demographics and case specifications. In addition, self-perceived performance was evaluated using a validated task-specific self-assessment form [global assessment scale (GAS) range 1-6]. Proficiency gain curves and learning rates were evaluated using risk-adjusted (RA) cumulative sum (CUSUM) curves. Of 654 cases 608 were included for analysis. The clinical outcomes included 9.2 % conversions, 16.9 % complications, 4 % reoperations, 2.6 % readmissions and a 0.8 % in-hospital mortality rate. RA CUSUM curves for complications and reoperation do not show a learning effect. However, the RA CUSUM curve for conversion has an inflection point at 24 cases. The GAS CUSUM curves for 'setup' and 'exposure' have inflection points at case 15 and case 29 respectively. The curves for 'mobilization of colon,' 'vascular pedicle' and 'anastomosis' plateau towards the end of the training period. 'Flexure' and 'mesorectum' do not of reach a plateau by case 40. Supervised fellowships provide training in LCS without compromising patient safety. Forty cases are required for the fellows to feel confident to perform the majority of tasks except dissection of the mesorectum and flexure, which will require further training.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.6
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Surgery

Development of a Reliable Surgical Quality Assurance System for 2-stage Esophagectomy in Randomized Controlled Trials

Alexander Harris, James Butterworth, Piers R. Boshier, Hugh MacKenzie, Masanori Tokunaga, Hideki Sunagawa, Stella Mavroveli, Melody Ni, Sameh Mikhail, Chi-Chuan Yeh, Natalie S. Blencowe, Kerry N. L. Avery, Richard Hardwick, Arnulf Hoelscher, Manuel Pera, Giovanni Zaninotto, Simon Law, Donald E. Low, Jan J. B. van Lanschot, Richard Berrisford, Christopher Paul Barham, Jane M. Blazeby, George B. Hanna

Summary: A reliable surgical quality assurance system for 2-stage esophagectomy has been developed, which includes an operation manual, video, and photographic assessment tools. It aims to ensure surgical quality in surgical oncology randomized controlled trials.

ANNALS OF SURGERY (2022)

Article Surgery

Laparoscopic Colorectal Surgery Outcomes Improved After National Training Program (LAPCO) for Specialists in England

George B. Hanna, Hugh Mackenzie, Danilo Miskovic, Melody Ni, Susannah Wyles, Paul Aylin, Amjad Parvaiz, Tom Cecil, Andrew Gudgeon, John Griffith, Jonathan M. Robinson, Chelliah Selvasekar, Tim Rockall, Austin Acheson, Charles Maxwell-Armstrong, John T. Jenkins, Alan Horgan, Chris Cunningham, Ian Lindsey, Tan Arulampalam, Roger W. Motson, Nader K. Francis, Robin H. Kennedy, Mark G. Coleman

Summary: This study examines the impact of The National Training Program for Lapco on the rate of laparoscopic surgery and clinical outcomes. The results show that Lapco increased the rate of laparoscopic surgery and reduced mortality and morbidity.

ANNALS OF SURGERY (2022)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

Qualitative analysis of stakeholder interviews to identify the barriers and facilitators to the adoption of point-of-care diagnostic tests in the UK

Jeremy R. Huddy, Melody Zhifang Ni, James Barlow, George B. Hanna

Summary: This study identified 32 barriers and 28 facilitators to the adoption of POCTs. Most themes were common to both barriers and facilitators suggest that good device design, stakeholder engagement and appropriate evidence provision can increase the likelihood of a POCT device adoption.

BMJ OPEN (2021)

Letter Pediatrics

Tributyrin ester-impregnated pH strips for confirming neonatal feeding tube placement: a diagnostic test accuracy study

Jayanta Banerjee, Anna McLister, Batia Gourin, Zoe McClure, Kirupalini Mariampillai, Robert J. Boyle, George B. Hanna, Melody Z. Ni

ARCHIVES OF DISEASE IN CHILDHOOD-FETAL AND NEONATAL EDITION (2023)

Meeting Abstract Infectious Diseases

Evaluation of remote triazole capillary blood testing to facilitate remote therapeutic drug monitoring (TDM): A validation study

Lisa Nwankwo, Jackie Donovan, Melody Ni, Michael Loebinger, Darius Armstrong-James, Anand Shah

MEDICAL MYCOLOGY (2022)

Article Ophthalmology

Comparing the Effectiveness of Phacoemulsification

Tom Sherman, Ian A. S. Rodrigues, Saurabh Goyal, Pouya Alaghband, Philip Bloom, Keith Barton, Hari Jayaram, Mohammed Abu-Bakra, Melody Ni, Kin Sheng Lim

Summary: This study describes the methodology of the CONCEPT study, a randomized controlled trial comparing the effectiveness of phacoemulsification alone and phacoemulsification combined with endoscopic cyclophotocoagulation (ECP) in treating primary open angle glaucoma. 160 eyes with primary open-angle glaucoma and visually significant cataract will be included in the study. The results of this study can provide important information for clinical decision-making.

OPHTHALMOLOGY GLAUCOMA (2023)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

The Biomarker Toolkit - an evidence-based guideline to predict cancer biomarker success and guide development

Katerina-Vanessa Savva, Michal Kawka, Bhamini Vadhwana, Rahul Penumaka, Imogen Patton, Komal Khan, Claire Perrott, Saranya Das, Maxime Giot, Stella Mavroveli, George B. Hanna, Melody Zhifang Ni, Christopher J. Peters

Summary: This study aims to create a Biomarker Toolkit to bridge the gap between biomarker discovery and clinical use by identifying clinically promising biomarkers. A validated checklist of attributes linked with successful biomarker implementation was generated through mixed-methodology, including systematic literature search, interviews, and a Delphi survey. The toolkit can be used to detect biomarkers with the highest clinical potential and shape the design and execution of biomarker studies.

BMC MEDICINE (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Development and validation of Medical Device Key Evidence Tool ('MeDKET'): An evidence-based framework to explain success in selected European and US companies

Stefania Manetti, Emanuele Lettieri, Melody Zhifang Ni

Summary: This study aims to develop and validate an evidence-based framework that helps innovators assess their readiness for successful medical device development and deployment. Through a key-informant process and Delphi method, a checklist for small and large enterprises was constructed and validated. The study found that early Health Technology Assessment plays a pivotal role in the success of the medical device industry.

PLOS ONE (2023)

Review Biotechnology & Applied Microbiology

Scoping Meta-Review of Methods Used to Assess Artificial Intelligence-Based Medical Devices for Heart Failure

Rossella Di Bidino, Davide Piaggio, Martina Andellini, Beatriz Merino-Barbancho, Laura Lopez-Perez, Tianhui Zhu, Zeeshan Raza, Melody Ni, Andra Morrison, Simone Borsci, Giuseppe Fico, Leandro Pecchia, Ernesto Iadanza

Summary: Artificial intelligence and machine learning are increasingly important in the field of medical devices, but the Health Technology Assessment process still lacks a common methodology for assessing AI/ML-based devices. A meta-review conducted by the International Federation of Medical and Biological Engineering collected existing evidence on methods used to assess AI-based devices, with a focus on heart failure management. The findings showed that deep learning is commonly used, and electronic health records and registries are prevalent data sources for AI/ML algorithms.

BIOENGINEERING-BASEL (2023)

Meeting Abstract Economics

IS THE NATIONAL TRAINING PROGRAMME FOR LAPAROSCOPIC COLORECTAL SURGERY (LAPCO) VALUE FOR MONEY?

M. Ni, H. Mackenzie, Zamora M. B. Talaya, D. Miskovic, S. Wyles, M. Coleman, G. Hanna

VALUE IN HEALTH (2022)

Meeting Abstract Surgery

A Review of Minimally Invasive Oesophagogastric Cancer Surgery in a High-Volume UK Unit

Prem Chana, Melody Zhifang Ni, Jonathan Moore, Cara Baker, Mark Kelly, Andrew Davies, James Gossage

BRITISH JOURNAL OF SURGERY (2022)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Current status of medical device malfunction reporting: using end user experience to identify current problems

Arkeliana Tase, Melody Z. Ni, Peter W. Buckle, George B. Hanna

Summary: This study emphasized the under-reporting of medical device performance and patient risks, as well as the reliance on personal experience rather than evidence in medical device use. Multiple barriers to reporting and patient safety issues were identified.

BMJ OPEN QUALITY (2022)

Article Infectious Diseases

A retrospective 'real-world' cohort study of azole therapeutic drug monitoring and evolution of antifungal resistance in cystic fibrosis

M. Di Paolo, L. Hewitt, E. Nwankwo, M. Ni, A. Vidal-Diaz, M. C. Fisher, D. Armstrong-James, A. Shah

Summary: This study found a high prevalence of subtherapeutic azole levels in adults with cystic fibrosis (CF), with increased risk associated with using itraconazole capsules and voriconazole therapy. The rapid emergence of azole resistance was also observed, highlighting the need for effective antifungal stewardship and further longitudinal studies on the impact of antifungal resistance on CF outcome.

JAC-ANTIMICROBIAL RESISTANCE (2021)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Utilisation of remote capillary blood testing in an outpatient clinic setting to improve shared decision making and patient and clinician experience: a validation and pilot study

Lisa Nwankwo, Kate McLaren, Jackie Donovan, Zhifang Ni, Alberto Vidal-Diaz, Michael Loebinger, Alice Morrisey, Adam Igra, Anand Shah

Summary: Remote capillary blood sampling can accurately monitor specific tests for chronic diseases and improve shared decision making and patient experience when incorporated into outpatient clinical pathways. Further research is needed to determine the health economic impact and applicability within telemedicine-based outpatient care.

BMJ OPEN QUALITY (2021)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Medical device error and failure reporting: Learning from the car industry

Arkeliana Tase, Peter Buckle, Melody Z. Ni, George B. Hanna

Summary: The healthcare industry has low levels of reporting performance failures in medical equipment, while derivation of incident data from different sources leads to uncertainties in understanding the full extent of patient harm. Learning from the reporting systems in the car industry, such as emphasizing the importance of reporting source in ensuring data quality, could help the healthcare sector improve its own reporting and performance.

JOURNAL OF PATIENT SAFETY AND RISK MANAGEMENT (2021)

No Data Available