4.6 Review

Single-incision laparoscopic surgery (SILS) vs. conventional multiport cholecystectomy: systematic review and meta-analysis

Journal

Publisher

SPRINGER
DOI: 10.1007/s00464-011-2051-0

Keywords

Pancreatobilio; Cancer; Cholecystectomy; SILS

Categories

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Single-incision laparoscopic surgery (SILS) has gained increasing attention due to the potential to maximize the benefits of laparoscopic surgery. The aim of this systematic review and pooled analysis was to compare clinical outcome following SILS and standard multiport laparoscopic cholecystectomy for the treatment of gallstone-related disease. An electronic search of Embase and Medline databases for articles from 1966 to 2011 was performed. Publications were included if they were randomised controlled studies in which patients underwent either single-incision or multiport cholecystectomy. The primary outcome measures for the meta-analysis were postoperative complications and postoperative pain score [visual analogue scale (VAS) on the day of surgery]. Secondary outcome measures were operating time and length of hospital stay. Weighted mean difference was calculated for the effect size of SILS on continuous variables, and pooled odds ratios were calculated for discrete variables. In total, 375 cholecystectomy operations from 7 randomised controlled trials were included, 195 by single-incision (SILS) and 180 by conventional multiport. Operating time was significantly longer in the SILS group compared to the standard multiport laparoscopic cholecystectomy group (weighted mean difference = 2.13; P = 0.0001). There was no significant difference in the incidence of postoperative complications, postoperative pain score (VAS), or the length of hospital stay between the two groups. The results of this meta-analysis demonstrate that single-incision laparoscopic cholecystectomy is a safe procedure for the treatment of uncomplicated gallstone disease, with postoperative outcome similar to that of standard multiport laparoscopic cholecystectomy. Future high-powered randomized studies should be focused on elucidating subtle differences in postoperative complications, reported postoperative pain, and cosmesis following SILS cholecystectomy in more severe biliary disease.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.6
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Surgery

Lipidomic Profiling of Colorectal Lesions for Real-Time Tissue Recognition and Risk-Stratification Using Rapid Evaporative Ionization Mass Spectrometry

Sam E. Mason, Eftychios Manoli, James L. Alexander, Liam Poynter, Lauren Ford, Petra Paizs, Afeez Adebesin, James S. McKenzie, Francesca Rosini, Rob Goldin, Ara Darzi, Zoltan Takats, James M. Kinross

Summary: This study used REIMS to analyze the lipid composition of colorectal tissues and evaluate its accuracy for real-time tissue recognition and risk stratification. The results showed that REIMS can differentiate samples of carcinoma, adenoma, and normal mucosa with 93.1% accuracy and 96.1% negative predictive value for carcinoma. It can also predict the presence of neoplasia (carcinoma or adenoma) with 96.0% accuracy and 91.8% negative predictive value. In addition, the study identified unique lipidomic features associated with colorectal carcinogenesis, such as the progressive increase in relative abundance of phosphatidylglycerols, sphingomyelins, and monounsaturated fatty acid-containing phospholipids.

ANNALS OF SURGERY (2023)

Review Health Care Sciences & Services

Machine learning for technical skill assessment in surgery: a systematic review

Kyle Lam, Junhong Chen, Zeyu Wang, Fahad M. Iqbal, Ara Darzi, Benny Lo, Sanjay Purkayastha, James M. Kinross

Summary: This study systematically reviewed the literature on the use of machine learning (ML) for surgical skill assessment and found that Hidden Markov Models (HMM), Support Vector Machines (SVM), and Artificial Neural Networks (ANN) were the most commonly used ML methods. Some studies used kinematic data, video or image data for assessment, and evaluated benchtop tasks, simulator tasks, and real-life surgery. Although there were variations between studies, accuracy rates of over 80% were achieved. Barriers to progress in the field included a focus on basic tasks, lack of standardization between studies, and lack of datasets. Future research should go beyond the assessment of basic tasks, focus on real-life surgery, and provide interpretable feedback with clinical value for surgeons.

NPJ DIGITAL MEDICINE (2022)

Review Gastroenterology & Hepatology

Gut Microbiota Modulation of Efficacy and Toxicity of Cancer Chemotherapy and Immunotherapy

Despoina Chrysostomou, Lauren A. Roberts, Julian R. Marchesi, James M. Kinross

Summary: Accumulating evidence supports the important role of the gut microbiome in cancer development and progression, as well as its influence on the efficacy and toxicity of cancer treatments. The microbiome is now being utilized to develop personalized therapeutic approaches in cancer treatment. However, the development of a new model that incorporates gut microbial cometabolism of drugs is necessary for the successful translation of the microbiome into next-generation oncologic treatments. The objective of this review is to outline the current knowledge of oncologic pharmacomicrobiomics and propose innovative approaches to modulate the gut microbiome for improved therapy efficacy and reduced toxic effects.

GASTROENTEROLOGY (2023)

Article Gastroenterology & Hepatology

Preparing the Bowel (Microbiome) for Surgery: Surgical Bioresilience

Heidi Paine, Faye Jones, James Kinross

Summary: The bowel preparation before radical surgery is crucial for colorectal practice. However, the evidence for this intervention is inconsistent and of varied quality. Nevertheless, there is a global trend towards using oral antibiotics to reduce perioperative infective complications. The gut microbiome plays a vital role in the systemic inflammatory response, wound healing, and perioperative gut function, but the mechanisms through which bowel preparation and surgery affect the microbiome are still unclear.

CLINICS IN COLON AND RECTAL SURGERY (2023)

Review Oncology

A systematic review of microbiome-derived biomarkers for early colorectal cancer detection

Florine H. Zwezerijnen-Jiwa, Hugo Sivov, Petra Paizs, Konstantina Zafeiropoulou, James Kinross

Summary: Increasing evidence suggests that the gut microbiome may play a role in colorectal cancer development and can be used as a biomarker for early detection. This review provides an overview of published studies on the use of the microbiome as a screening tool for early colorectal cancer. A total of 28 studies were included, showing varying diagnostic performance of fecal bacteria-derived and co-metabolome-derived biomarkers. The findings suggest the potential of the gut microbiome as a complement to existing screening tools, but further research is needed before clinical implementation.

NEOPLASIA (2023)

Editorial Material Gastroenterology & Hepatology

Microbiome is the key to preventing anastomotic leak in colorectal surgery

James M. Kinross

Article Education & Educational Research

Can mixed reality technologies teach surgical skills better than traditional methods? A prospective randomised feasibility study

Payal Guha, Jason Lawson, Iona Minty, James Kinross, Guy Martin

Summary: This study aimed to assess the feasibility of using Microsoft HoloLens 2 (HL2) as a tool for enhancing technical surgical skills training. A prospective feasibility study was conducted, with 36 novice medical students being trained using either a mixed reality HL2 tutorial or a standard video-based tutorial. The results showed that the HL2 group had significantly greater improvement in overall technical proficiency and a narrower range of scores, indicating better skill progression and consistency compared to the video group. Participant feedback also indicated higher satisfaction with the interactive and engaging nature of the HL2 technology.

BMC MEDICAL EDUCATION (2023)

Article Microbiology

Pathobionts in the tumour microbiota predict survival following resection for colorectal cancer

James L. Alexander, Joram M. Posma, Alasdair Scott, Liam Poynter, Sam E. Mason, M. Luisa Doria, Lili Herendi, Lauren Roberts, Julie A. K. McDonald, Simon Cameron, David J. Hughes, Vaclav Liska, Simona Susova, Pavel Soucek, Verena Horneffer-van Der Sluis, Maria Gomez-Romero, Matthew R. Lewis, Lesley Hoyles, Andrew Woolston, David Cunningham, Ara Darzi, Marco Gerlinger, Robert Goldin, Zoltan Takats, Julian R. Marchesi, Julian Teare, James Kinross

Summary: This study investigates the association between gut microbiota, metabolome, and colorectal cancer (CRC). The authors identify specific microbiota clusters, such as cluster 7 containing Fusobacterium nucleatum and Granulicatella adiacens, that are strongly associated with CRC and can predict favorable disease-free survival. They also find that cluster 1 containing Faecalibacterium prausnitzii and Ruminococcus gnavus is negatively associated with cancer and predicts worse disease-free survival. In addition, certain metabolic clusters show associations with CRC, such as Met 1 composed of fatty acids, ceramides, and lysophospholipids, which is negatively associated with CRC, and Met 2 composed of phosphatidylcholine species, nucleosides, and amino acids, which is strongly associated with CRC.

MICROBIOME (2023)

Article Education, Scientific Disciplines

Knowledge Attainment and Engagement Among Medical Students: A Comparison of Three Forms of Online Learning

Ashlyn A. Stackhouse, Damir Rafi, Risheka Walls, Rebecca Dodd, Kerry Badger, Daniel J. Davies, Celia A. Brown, Adrian Cowell, Karim Meeran, Omid Halse, James Kinross, Martin Lupton, Elizabeth A. Hughes, Amir H. Sam

Summary: This study compared knowledge attainment and student enjoyment and engagement between clinical case vignette, patient-testimony videos and mixed reality (MR) teaching via the Microsoft HoloLens 2. The results showed that MR teaching is an effective and feasible method for large-scale clinical medicine education, but students preferred case-based tutorials.

ADVANCES IN MEDICAL EDUCATION AND PRACTICE (2023)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

Effect of Mixed Reality on Delivery of Emergency Medical Care in a Simulated EnvironmentA Pilot Randomized Crossover Trial

Jason Lawson, Guy Martin, Payal Guha, Matthew Gold, Amr Nimer, Sadie Syed, James Kinross

Summary: This study aimed to assess the efficacy and feasibility of MR technology in enhancing emergency care delivery in a simulated environment. The results showed that MR technology significantly reduced errors, improved teamwork, and enhanced practitioner confidence.

JAMA NETWORK OPEN (2023)

Article Endocrinology & Metabolism

Metabolic profiling stratifies colorectal cancer and reveals adenosylhomocysteinase as a therapeutic target

Johan Vande Voorde, Rory T. Steven, Arafath K. Najumudeen, Catriona A. Ford, Alex Dexter, Ariadna Gonzalez-Fernandez, Chelsea J. Nikula, Yuchen Xiang, Lauren Ford, Stefania Maneta Stavrakaki, Kathryn Gilroy, Lucas B. Zeiger, Kathryn Pennel, Phimmada Hatthakarnkul, Efstathios A. Elia, Ammar Nasif, Teresa Murta, Eftychios Manoli, Sam Mason, Michael Gillespie, Tamsin R. M. Lannagan, Nikola Vlahov, Rachel A. Ridgway, Colin Nixon, Alexander Raven, Megan Mills, Dimitris Athineos, Georgios Kanellos, Craig Nourse, David M. Gay, Mark Hughes, Amy Burton, Bin Yan, Katherine Sellers, Vincen Wu, Kobe De Ridder, Engy Shokry, Alejandro Huerta Uribe, William Clark, Graeme Clark, Kristina Kirschner, Bernard Thienpont, Vivian S. W. Li, Oliver D. K. Maddocks, Simon T. Barry, Richard J. A. Goodwin, James Kinross, Joanne Edwards, Mariia O. Yuneva, David Sumpton, Zoltan Takats, Andrew D. Campbell, Josephine Bunch, Owen J. Sansom

Summary: In this study, the potential of untargeted metabolomics as a stratification tool for colorectal cancer (CRC) was investigated. The researchers presented a comprehensive pipeline to uncover metabolic vulnerabilities in CRC based on its genetic origin. Perturbations in methionine metabolism linked to APC deficiency were observed, and adenosylhomocysteinase was identified as an actionable therapeutic target.

NATURE METABOLISM (2023)

Review Pharmacology & Pharmacy

Flow rate accuracy of infusion devices within healthcare settings: a systematic review

Opeyemi Atanda, Jonathan West, Tom Stables, Chris Johnson, Robert Merrifield, James Kinross

Summary: This systematic review examines the accuracy of infusion sets and devices and identifies factors that affect flow rate accuracy. The study finds significant variability in the accuracy of infusion devices and highlights the impact of physiological and mechanical factors. However, there is a lack of research on the clinical outcomes and patient safety implications of these findings.

THERAPEUTIC ADVANCES IN DRUG SAFETY (2023)

Article Primary Health Care

A novel digital rectoscope for the triage of lower gastrointestinal symptoms in primary care: a prospective multicentre feasibility study

James Lewis, Alan Askari, Arihant Mehta, Yasmin Razak, Prash Patel, Ravi Misra, Henry Tilney, Tanveer Ahmed, Mooyad Ahmed, Adnan Syeed, John Camilleri-Brennan, Ralph John Nicholls, James Macalister Kinross

Summary: This study evaluated the feasibility, acceptability, and safety of digital rectoscopy in primary care. The results showed that it is a feasible and acceptable method, with no serious adverse events reported. It also demonstrated the potential to reduce referrals and save costs.

BJGP OPEN (2023)

Article Oncology

Genetic and immune landscape evolution in MMR-deficient colorectal cancer

Benjamin R. Challoner, Andrew Woolston, David Lau, Marta Buzzetti, Caroline Fong, Louise J. Barber, Gayathri Anandappa, Richard Crux, Ioannis Assiotis, Kerry Fenwick, Ruwaida Begum, Dipa Begum, Tom Lund, Nanna Sivamanoharan, Harold B. Sansano, Melissa Domingo-Arada, Amina Tran, Hardev Pandha, David Church, Bryony Eccles, Richard Ellis, Stephen Falk, Mark Hill, Daniel Krell, Nirupa Murugaesu, Luke Nolan, Vanessa Potter, Mark Saunders, Kai-Keen Shiu, Sebastian Guettler, James L. Alexander, Hector Lazare-Iglesias, James Kinross, Jamie Murphy, Katharina von Loga, David Cunningham, Ian Chau, Naureen Starling, Juan Ruiz-Banobre, Tony Dhillon, Marco Gerlinger

Summary: MMRd CRCs have high mutation burdens and pervasive ITH, but driver mutations show a clear hierarchy. Immune evasion (IE) drivers are mainly subclonal and show parallel evolution. IE drivers and T cell infiltrates coevolve. PD-L1 expression correlates with T cell density but is associated with loss of CDX2 expression, leading to a higher recurrence risk in MMRd CRCs.

JOURNAL OF PATHOLOGY (2023)

No Data Available