4.2 Article

Action observation and execution: What is shared?

Journal

SOCIAL NEUROSCIENCE
Volume 3, Issue 3-4, Pages 421-433

Publisher

ROUTLEDGE JOURNALS, TAYLOR & FRANCIS LTD
DOI: 10.1080/17470910802045109

Keywords

-

Funding

  1. ESRC [RES-000-23-1571] Funding Source: UKRI
  2. Economic and Social Research Council [RES-000-23-1571] Funding Source: researchfish

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Performing an action and observing it activate the same internal representations of action. The representations are therefore shared between self and other (shared representations of action, SRA). But what exactly is shared? At what level within the hierarchical structure of the motor system do SRA occur? Understanding the content of SRA is important in order to decide what theoretical work SRA can perform. In this paper, we provide some conceptual clarification by raising three main questions: (i) are SRA semantic or pragmatic representations of action?: (ii) are SRA sensory or motor representations?: (iii) are SRA representations of the action as a global unit or as a set of elementary motor components'? After outlining a model of the motor hierarchy. we conclude that the best candidate for SRA is intentions in action, defined as the motor plans of the dynamic sequence of movements. We shed new light on SRA by highlighting the causal efficacy of intentions in action. This in turn explains phenomena such as inhibition of imitation.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.2
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Neurosciences

Do readiness potentials happen all the time?

Eoin Travers, Nima Khalighinejad, Aaron Schurger, Patrick Haggard

NEUROIMAGE (2020)

Article Psychology, Biological

Feeling free: External influences on endogenous behaviour

Lucie Charles, Patrick Haggard

QUARTERLY JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY (2020)

Article Clinical Neurology

No increased suggestibility to placebo in functional neurological disorder

Anne-Catherine M. L. Huys, Brianna Beck, Patrick Haggard, Kailash P. Bhatia, Mark J. Edwards

Summary: The study showed that patients with FND do not exhibit a stronger placebo response compared to healthy controls, suggesting that increased suggestibility to placebo in FND patients may be a misconception. Instead, occasional dramatic placebo responses may occur due to the inherent variability of functional symptoms compared to organic diseases.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF NEUROLOGY (2021)

Article Biology

Touch inhibits touch: sanshool-induced paradoxical tingling reveals perceptual interaction between somatosensory submodalities

Antonio Cataldo, Nobuhiro Hagura, Yousef Hyder, Patrick Haggard

Summary: Human perception of touch is influenced by inputs from multiple channels. Contrary to classical theories, it was found that inputs from two sub-modalities of mechanical input channels interact to determine tactile perception. Sustained mechanical pressure was shown to inhibit tingling sensations induced by a bioactive compound, without mediation from nociceptive or affective channels.

PROCEEDINGS OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY B-BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES (2021)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

A Hierarchical Attractor Network Model of perceptual versus intentional decision updates

Anne Loffler, Anastasia Sylaidi, Zafeirios Fountas, Patrick Haggard

Summary: The study explores decision reversals that involve integrating multiple classes of information, such as sensory evidence, higher-order intentions, and motor costs. Movement trajectories reveal when participants change their mind about dot-motion direction and colour choices. Results show that decision reversals about colour intentions are less frequent in participants with stronger intentions and lower motor costs for intention pursuit.

NATURE COMMUNICATIONS (2021)

Article Clinical Neurology

Misdirected attentional focus in functional tremor

Anne-Catherine M. L. Huys, Patrick Haggard, Kailash P. Bhatia, Mark J. Edwards

Summary: The study found that in functional tremor, the attentional focus on ongoing visual feedback from the movement is not beneficial and has a detrimental impact on motor performance. This altered attentional focus may partly responsible for functional tremor, and it also worsens motor performance in healthy control participants and patients with an organic action tremor when directed towards visual feedback.

BRAIN (2021)

Letter Clinical Neurology

A Note of Caution on Distorted Visual Feedback as a Treatment for Functional Movement Disorders

Anne-Catherine M. L. Huys, Patrick Haggard, Kailash P. Bhatia, Mark J. Edwards

MOVEMENT DISORDERS CLINICAL PRACTICE (2022)

Article Ethics

The dynamics of responsibility judgment: Joint role of causal explanations based on dependence and transference

Sofia Bonicalzi, Eugenia Kulakova, Chiara Brozzo, Sam J. Gilbert, Patrick Haggard

Summary: Reasoning about underlying causal relations influences responsibility judgments, with a preference for pluralistic causal reasoning. Dependence theories and transference theories are two main approaches in causal reasoning, and hybrid models combining both have emerged. Our experiment findings indicate that diminished responsibility judgments occur when dependence, transference, or both fail.

PHILOSOPHICAL PSYCHOLOGY (2022)

Article Clinical Neurology

No exaggerated tremor severity perception in functional tremor

Anne-Catherine M. L. Huys, Patrick Haggard, Kailash P. Bhatia, Mark J. Edwards

Summary: This study aimed to test whether patients with functional tremor exaggerate their symptom perception and reporting. The results showed that compared to patients with organic tremor and healthy controls, patients with functional tremor did not perceive or report their tremor to be exaggerated.

JOURNAL OF NEUROLOGY (2022)

Article Biochemical Research Methods

A novel method to selectively elicit cold sensations without touch

Ivan Ezquerra-Romano, Maansib Chowdhury, Caterina Maria Leone, Gian Domenico Iannetti, Patrick Haggard

Summary: This paper introduces a non-contact, temperature-controlled, multi-purpose cooling stimulator, which can precisely control the cold sensation stimulation and be used to study different aspects of cold sensation. It avoids the interference of mechanical contact. Through experiments, it is verified that this method can measure the cold detection threshold without mechanical contact, providing a more accurate method for studying cold sensory pathways and cold-touch interactions.

JOURNAL OF NEUROSCIENCE METHODS (2023)

Article Biology

Interhemispheric communication during haptic self-perception

Gaiqing Kong, Antonio Cataldo, Miruna Nitu, Lucile Dupin, Hiroaki Gomi, Patrick Haggard

Summary: During self-touch, the combination of kinaesthetic and tactile signals affects haptic perceptions. The size of perceived bumps is influenced by changes in tactile pressure.

PROCEEDINGS OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY B-BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES (2022)

Article Biology

Mistaking opposition for autonomy: psychophysical studies on detecting choice bias

Ashild Kummen, Patrick Haggard, Gwydion Williams, Lucie Charles

Summary: Research shows that people's perception of freedom is influenced by their behavioral tendencies, even when their choices are biased by habits. This illusion of freedom artificially increases the sense of freedom and has important implications for understanding mechanisms of persuasion.

PROCEEDINGS OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY B-BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES (2023)

Editorial Material Psychology, Biological

Neuroscience evidence counters a rape myth

Ebani Dhawan, Patrick Haggard

Summary: In cases of rape and sexual assault, victims often experience a state of immobility referred to as 'freezing'. Neuroscientific research suggests that this freeze response is a result of fear and threat, which can inhibit the brain circuits responsible for voluntary movement. Thus, defense arguments that blame victims for freezing are inappropriate and unfair.

NATURE HUMAN BEHAVIOUR (2023)

Letter Clinical Neurology

Perceived Intention-Motor intention perceived as movement despite paralysis and retained insight

Anne-Catherine M. L. Huys, Patrick Haggard

JOURNAL OF NEUROLOGY (2023)

Letter Clinical Neurology

Symptom-Triggered Attention to Self as a Possible Trigger of Functional Comorbidity

Anne-Catherine M. L. Huys, Kailash P. Bhatia, Patrick Haggard, Mark J. Edwards

MOVEMENT DISORDERS CLINICAL PRACTICE (2021)

No Data Available