4.2 Letter

Dating the Kawakawa/Oruanui eruption: Comment on Optical luminescence dating of a loess section containing a critical tephra marker horizon, SW North Island of New Zealand by R. Grapes et al.

Journal

QUATERNARY GEOCHRONOLOGY
Volume 5, Issue 4, Pages 493-496

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCI LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.quageo.2009.10.006

Keywords

Luminescence dating; C-14 dating; Isochron; Kawakawa tephra; Oruanui eruption; LGM; Loess; New Zealand

Ask authors/readers for more resources

An IRSL age of 17.0 +/- 2.2 ka (and a mean age of ca. 19 ka) reported by Grapes et al. [Grapes, R., Rieser, U., Wang, N. Optical luminescence dating of a loess section containing a critical tephra marker horizon, SW North Island of New Zealand. Quaternary Geochronology 5(2-3), 164-169.] for the Kawakawa/Oruanui tephra, and other ages associated with a loess section in New Zealand are untenable: age data presented are inconsistent, no formal statistical treatments or error determinations were undertaken in age analysis, and the ages proposed are seriously at odds with multiple radiocarbon age determinations on tephra sequences bracketing the Kawakawa/Oruanui tephra and with palaeoenvironmental evidence elsewhere for the time period concerned. We suggest that the bulk polymineral IRSL ages on the tephra and encapsulating loess deposits were underestimated in part because of contamination of the loess by the integration of younger materials during slow deposition and continuous modification by upbuilding pedogenesis. Single-grain luminescence assays may reveal such contamination. A C-14-based age of ca. 27 +/- 1 ka cal BP (2 sigma), reported in 2008, currently remains the best estimate for the age of eruption of the Kawakawa/Oruanui tephra. (C) 2009 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.2
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Large silicic magma bodies and very large magnitude explosive eruptions

R. S. J. Sparks, J. D. Blundy, K. Cashman, M. Jackson, A. Rust, C. J. N. Wilson

Summary: In the past 20 years, there have been new insights into the processes leading to large silicic explosive eruptions through the integration of geophysical, geochemical, petrological, geochronological, and dynamical modeling approaches. In the next 10 years, significant advancements are expected in dynamical modeling, analytical techniques, and geophysical methods, which will be supported by field research.

BULLETIN OF VOLCANOLOGY (2022)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Significance of tridymite distribution during cooling and vapor-phase alteration of ignimbrites

Yuli Heled, Michael C. Rowe, Isabelle Chambefort, Colin J. N. Wilson

Summary: This study examines the relationship between tridymite and vapor-phase crystallization and devitrification in silicic ignimbrites, providing insights into the emplacement and cooling history of these ignimbrites. The results show that tridymite can be used as a potential mineralogical fingerprint to interpret post-emplacement devitrification and vapor-phase alteration, and to study the lateral transport of fluids in geothermal reservoirs.

AMERICAN MINERALOGIST (2022)

Article Geology

Taupoinflate: illustrating detection limits of magmatic inflation below Lake Taupo

Susan Ellis, Simon J. Barker, Colin J. N. Wilson, I. Hamling, Sigrun Hreinsdottir, Finnigan Illsley-Kemp, Eleanor R. H. Mestel, James D. Muirhead, Bubs Smith, Graham Leonard, Martha K. Savage, Pilar Villamor, Peter Otway

Summary: Lake Taupo is a volcanic caldera in the central Taupo Volcanic Zone, and ground deformation is an important indicator of volcanic unrest. The authors present a spreadsheet tool, TaupoInflate, for calculating and plotting ground deformation caused by magmatic inflation beneath the caldera. Some locations around the lake have limited detection capabilities for inflating magma bodies due to station placement restrictions.

NEW ZEALAND JOURNAL OF GEOLOGY AND GEOPHYSICS (2022)

Correction Geochemistry & Geophysics

Textural and micro-analytical insights into mafic-felsic interactions during the Oruanui eruption, Taupo (vol 173, 35, 2018)

Shane M. Rooyakkers, Colin J. N. Wilson, C. Ian Schipper, Simon J. Barker, Aidan S. R. Allan

CONTRIBUTIONS TO MINERALOGY AND PETROLOGY (2023)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

The compositional diversity and temporal evolution of an active andesitic arc stratovolcano: Tongariro, Taupo Volcanic Zone, New Zealand

Leo R. Pure, Colin J. N. Wilson, Bruce L. A. Charlier, John A. Gamble, Dougal B. Townsend, Graham S. Leonard

Summary: New geochemical data for Tongariro volcano in New Zealand reveal systematic cycles in its eruptive history, with mafic replenishment events occurring at specific intervals. The isotopic ratios also indicate periods of prolonged crustal residence of magmas. It is suggested that the magma assembly processes at Tongariro and neighboring volcanoes were contemporaneous and influenced by tectonic activities.

CONTRIBUTIONS TO MINERALOGY AND PETROLOGY (2023)

Article Geography, Physical

Millimetre-scale pollen analysis of non-varved lacustrine sediments from Onepoto maar palaeolake, Auckland, reveals distal vegetation responses and landscape recovery following the ∼25.5-ka Oruanui supereruption, New Zealand

Stephen B. Piva, Simon J. Barker, Rewi M. Newnham, Andrew B. H. Rees, Colin J. N. Wilson, Lionel Carter, Nels A. Iverson, Benjamin Läuchli, Paul C. Augustinus

Summary: This study analyzed sediment cores from Onepoto maar palaeolake in Auckland to investigate the impacts of the Oruanui supereruption on vegetation and landscape. The results showed that the eruption caused partial defoliation of canopy trees, allowing more light penetration and promoting sub-canopy vegetation growth. This study also demonstrated the value of millimeter-scale stratigraphic pollen analysis for assessing eruptive impacts on sub-decadal timescales.

JOURNAL OF QUATERNARY SCIENCE (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Processes and timescales of magmatic rejuvenation and residence prior to post-caldera rhyolitic eruptions: O?kataina Volcanic Centre, Aotearoa New Zealand

Hannah C. Elms, Simon J. Barker, Daniel J. Morgan, Colin J. N. Wilson, Bruce L. A. Charlier

Summary: Understanding the formation and development of magma bodies in the crust prior to eruption is crucial for volcanic monitoring. This study focuses on the timescales of pre-eruptive processes during young intra-caldera eruptions in O over bar kataina Volcanic Centre, New Zealand. By analyzing mineral chemistry and zoning patterns, the researchers found that melt segregation, magma body assembly, and residence in the upper crust occur over timescales ranging from decades to centuries or even as short as months. The findings highlight the importance of multiple processes in the assembly and eruption of melt bodies and their relevance to geophysical imaging and monitoring initiatives.

JOURNAL OF VOLCANOLOGY AND GEOTHERMAL RESEARCH (2023)

Article Geography, Physical

An integrated proximal-distal radiocarbon dating approach provides improved age constraints for a key Holocene tephra isochron

Charlotte O. Pizer, Jamie D. Howarth, Kate J. Clark, Colin J. N. Wilson, Stephanie E. Tickle, Jenni L. Hopkins, Jenny A. Dahl

Summary: Volcanic ash (tephra) horizons are important for correlating natural archives, but age uncertainties can hinder their effectiveness. We use the Waimihia tephra as a case study to improve age constraints for Holocene tephra isochrons by employing detailed assessments, precise AMS dating, and Bayesian age models. Our findings have implications for refining paleoearthquake correlations and chronologies relying on the Waimihia isochron.

QUATERNARY SCIENCE REVIEWS (2023)

Article Geology

Seismically-induced down-sagging structures in tephra layers (tephra-seismites) preserved in lakes since 17.5 cal ka, Hamilton lowlands, New Zealand

Max O. Kluger, David J. Lowe, Vicki G. Moon, Jordanka Chaneva, Richard Johnston, Pilar Villamor, Tehnuka Ilanko, Richard A. Melchert, Rolando P. Orense, Remedy C. Loame, Nic Ross

Summary: We analysed various soft-sediment deformation structures (SSDSs) in siliceous tephra layers deposited in riverine-phytogenic lakes in the Hamilton lowlands, New Zealand. These SSDSs include down-sagging structures of different sizes and dykes. Through sediment/tephra descriptions and scanning, we classified these structures and identified the deformation mechanism. The liquefaction of older tephra layers may have been triggered by seismic activity to the northeast, while the liquefaction of younger tephra layers may have been caused by local faulting or distant faulting.

SEDIMENTARY GEOLOGY (2023)

Article Engineering, Geological

Monotonic and cyclic undrained behaviour and liquefaction resistance of pumiceous, non-plastic sandy silt

Jordanka Chaneva, Max O. Kluger, Vicki G. Moon, David J. Lowe, Rolando P. Orense

Summary: Limited experimental data on the mechanical behavior of crushable pumiceous soils, especially pumiceous silts, led this study to investigate the undrained behavior and liquefaction resistance of a natural volcanic-ash derived, non-plastic pumiceous silt from northern New Zealand through monotonic and cyclic triaxial tests. The results revealed that the pumiceous silt exhibited a contractive response and high flow liquefaction susceptibility, similar to hard-grained soils. Furthermore, the material showed lower liquefaction resistance compared to hard-grained soils and pumiceous sands.

SOIL DYNAMICS AND EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Absence of low-& delta; 18O magmas despite widespread assimilation of altered crust in a large magmatic and hydrothermal province

Shane M. Rooyakkers, Isabelle Chambefort, Kevin Faure, Colin J. N. Wilson, Simon J. Barker, Nick Mortimer, Hannah C. Elms, Juliana Troch, Bruce L. A. Charlier, Graham S. Leonard, David Farsky

Summary: Despite the common association of large-scale magmatism with intense hydro-thermal activity, magmas with low 818O values are globally rare. This study investigates this paradox in the central Taupo Volcanic Zone (TVZ) in New Zealand and provides possible explanations. The study finds that although silicic magmas with low 818O values are absent, interactions between large silicic magmatic systems and shallow altered crustal rocks are common and widespread in the TVZ.

GEOCHIMICA ET COSMOCHIMICA ACTA (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Crustal basement terranes under the Taupo over bar Volcanic Zone, New Zealand: Context for hydrothermal and magmatic processes

Nick Mortimer, Bruce L. A. Charlier, Shane M. Rooyakkers, Rose E. Turnbull, Colin J. N. Wilson, Marianne Negrini, Stephen Bannister, Sarah D. Milicich, Isabelle Chambefort, Craig A. Miller, Geoff Kilgour

Summary: The Quaternary volcanic rocks in New Zealand's Taupo Volcanic Zone (TVZ) are hosted by the metasedimentary crustal basement terranes rather than the volcanic and volcaniclastic fill. Research shows that the boundary of these terranes is not vertical, but gently dips west. This new interpretation provides important constraints for geodynamic understanding, petrological modeling, and future deep geothermal drilling.

JOURNAL OF VOLCANOLOGY AND GEOTHERMAL RESEARCH (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Volcanic glass from the 1.8 ka Taupo eruption (New Zealand) detected in Antarctic ice at ∼ 230 CE

Stephen B. Piva, Simon J. Barker, Nels A. Iverson, V. Holly L. Winton, Nancy A. N. Bertler, Michael Sigl, Colin J. N. Wilson, Nelia W. Dunbar, Andrei V. Kurbatov, Lionel Carter, Bruce L. A. Charlier, Rewi M. Newnham

Summary: By analyzing glass shards in the Antarctic ice core, this study successfully identified the Taupo volcanic eruption 1.8 ka and linked it to other eruption events. These findings are important for accurately estimating eruption timing, source volcanoes, and the impact of volcanic activities on climate.

SCIENTIFIC REPORTS (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Pre-eruptive rhyolite magma ascent rate is rapid and independent of eruption size: a case study from Okataina Volcanic Centre, Aotearoa New Zealand

Hannah C. Elms, Madison L. Myers, Alexander R. L. Nichols, Paul J. Wallace, Colin J. N. Wilson, Simon J. Barker, Bruce L. A. Charlier

Summary: By studying eight volcanic eruptions at the Okataina Volcanic Centre in New Zealand, it was found that there are differences in the volatile content and ascent rate of volcanic rock, melt inclusions, and embayments. The final movement of volcanic eruption towards the surface may only take a few hours.

BULLETIN OF VOLCANOLOGY (2023)

Article Anthropology

Building on the past: Refining our current understanding of Lapita stilt structures

Nicholas W. S. Hogg, Yi-lin E. Chen, Glenn R. Summerhayes, Gretel Boswijk, Sturt W. Manning, Alan G. Hogg, Chris Gosden

Summary: This paper reviews the current knowledge of Lapita stilt structures in the Bismarck Archipelago, Papua New Guinea, and presents new data from the study of a wooden post from a Lapita-era stilt structure in the Arawe Islands. The analysis identifies the wooden post as Intsia bijuga, a saltwater-resistant species, suggesting that the Lapita populations had a good understanding of available timber resources. The paper also describes the first attempt to radiocarbon wiggle-match date a Lapita-age wooden artifact.

AUSTRALIAN ARCHAEOLOGY (2022)

Article Geography, Physical

Post-violet infrared stimulated luminescence (pVIRSL) dating protocol for potassium feldspar

Monika Devi, Naveen Chauhan, Ashok K. Singhvi

Summary: Devi et al. (2022) suggested that post-violet infrared stimulated luminescence (pVIRSL) of K-feldspars has a near zero athermal fading rate. This study investigates the mechanism and suitability of the pVIRSL signal for dating applications. The results show that pVIRSL is a recuperated signal resulting from the eviction and recapture of charges in deep traps by violet stimulation and subsequent infrared stimulation. The pVIR-SAR protocol worked well for dating seven K-feldspar samples from various depositional environments.

QUATERNARY GEOCHRONOLOGY (2024)

Article Geography, Physical

Investigating the potential of African land snail shells (Gastropoda: Achatininae) for amino acid geochronology

Chloe Baldreki, Andrew Burnham, Martina Conti, Lucy Wheeler, Michael J. Simms, Lawrence Barham, Tom S. White, Kirsty Penkman

Summary: Aragonitic calcium carbonate mollusc shells with complex shell microstructures can be used for amino acid geochronologies in Africa. Different microstructural shell layers may have different protein compositions, requiring sampling strategies. The 3AL shell portion showed closer adherence to closed-system behavior and demonstrated the potential of fossil achatinids for building relative amino acid geochronologies across Africa.

QUATERNARY GEOCHRONOLOGY (2024)

Article Geography, Physical

Snow avalanche synchronicity derived from a multi-path tree-ring reconstruction in the Fagaras Mountains (Southern Carpathians, Romania)

Patrick Chiroiu, Alexandru L. Onaca, Adrien Favillier, Mircea Voiculescu, Christophe Corona, Petru Urdea, Markus Stoffel

Summary: Snow avalanches present a constant threat to mountainous regions worldwide, and understanding past avalanche events is crucial for managing and mitigating avalanche hazards and risks. In this study, dendrogeomorphic techniques were used to analyze 17 avalanche paths in a small region of the Fagaras Mountains. The analysis reconstructed 174 snow avalanche years across all paths and revealed widespread avalanche occurrence in the study area. The study emphasizes the importance of investigating multiple avalanche paths in a small, homogeneous area to gain a better understanding of snow avalanche activity at both path-scale and mountain range-scale.

QUATERNARY GEOCHRONOLOGY (2024)