3.8 Article

How will it work? A qualitative study of strategic stakeholders' accounts of a patient safety initiative

Journal

QUALITY & SAFETY IN HEALTH CARE
Volume 19, Issue 1, Pages 74-78

Publisher

BMJ PUBLISHING GROUP
DOI: 10.1136/qshc.2008.029504

Keywords

-

Funding

  1. Health Foundation

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Objectives Implementation of quality improvement programmes may suffer if the stakeholders involved do not share a common understanding of the theory of change or do not accept it as legitimate. We aimed to identify how strategic stakeholders understood and responded to the first phase of the Health Foundation's Safer Patients Initiative, a programme aimed at making hospitals safer for patients in the UK. Methods Semistructured telephone interviews were conducted with 60 strategic-level hospital stakeholders and with five stakeholders involved in commissioning, designing and introducing the initiative. Analysis was based on the constant comparative method. Results The aims of the initiative were seen as legitimate and sound by most hospital stakeholders, and the theory of change was generally understood and accepted, but seven hospital stakeholders were unable to describe it. Although participants had specific doubts, particularly relating to feasibility of implementation and scientific legitimacy of some elements of the initiative, overall there was a broadly shared vision and commitment to the principles and practices associated with the theory of change, and considerable enthusiasm and optimism. Contestations about the legitimacy and relevance of the initiative among front-line staff, local resistance to changes that went against established norms, and resource and structural issues were, however, seen as potentially threatening to implementation. Conclusions It is possible to get strategic-level individuals, even when widely dispersed, to understand and agree upon a theory of change that can be used in their organisations. These individuals are also able to recognise the contexts of negotiation in which programmes of change are enacted.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

3.8
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Review Obstetrics & Gynecology

Training in the use of intrapartum electronic fetal monitoring with cardiotocography: systematic review and meta-analysis

S. Kelly, P. Redmond, S. King, C. Oliver-Williams, G. Lame, E. Liberati, I Kuhn, C. Winter, T. Draycott, M. Dixon-Woods, J. Burt

Summary: This systematic review on training healthcare professionals in intrapartum electronic fetal monitoring found little evidence of impact on neonatal outcomes. More research is needed to improve the evidence base for training in this area.

BJOG-AN INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF OBSTETRICS AND GYNAECOLOGY (2021)

Article Infectious Diseases

Investigating infection management and antimicrobial stewardship in surgery: a qualitative study from India and South Africa

Sanjeev Singh, Marc Mendelson, Surya Surendran, Candice Bonaconsa, Oluchi Mbamalu, Vrinda Nampoothiri, Adam Boutall, Mark Hampton, Puneet Dhar, Tim Pennel, Carolyn Tarrant, Andy Leather, Alison Holmes, Esmita Charani

Summary: This study investigates the barriers to effective infection management and antimicrobial stewardship across high-infection-risk surgical pathways in South Africa and India. It identifies the neglect of existing roles of healthcare professionals, particularly the ownership of decisions by operating surgeons, as a critical obstacle to integrated care. The study concludes that recognizing implicit HCP roles and implementing a framework approach involving nurse leadership and pharmacist empowerment are essential for optimized care.

CLINICAL MICROBIOLOGY AND INFECTION (2021)

Article Infectious Diseases

Drivers of Broad-Spectrum Antibiotic Overuse across Diverse Hospital Contexts-A Qualitative Study of Prescribers in the UK, Sri Lanka and South Africa

Carolyn Tarrant, Andrew M. Colman, David R. Jenkins, Edmund Chattoe-Brown, Nelun Perera, Shaheen Mehtar, W. M. I. Dilini Nakkawita, Michele Bolscher, Eva M. Krockow

Summary: This study identified multi-level influences on broad-spectrum antibiotic overuse, with drivers found at individual, social, and structural levels. Structural drivers varied significantly across environments, highlighting the need for antimicrobial stewardship efforts to address context-specific conditions.

ANTIBIOTICS-BASEL (2021)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

A qualitative study of organisational response to national quality standards for 7-day services in English hospitals

Elizabeth Sutton, Julian Bion, Russell Mannion, Janet Willars, Elizabeth Shaw, Carolyn Tarrant

Summary: Most NHS hospital trusts in England responded to the introduction of national standards for 7-day services by focusing on hitting targets and achieving compliance with the standards. Compliance-based responses were associated with a hierarchical organisational culture and focus on external performance. Trusts that took a commitment-based approach tended to have a developmental organisational culture and a history of higher performance across the board.

BMC HEALTH SERVICES RESEARCH (2021)

Editorial Material Health Care Sciences & Services

Antibiotic overuse: managing uncertainty and mitigating against overtreatment

Carolyn Tarrant, Eva M. Krockow

BMJ QUALITY & SAFETY (2022)

Review Psychology, Multidisciplinary

Prosociality in the social dilemma of antibiotic prescribing

Eva M. Krockow, Carolyn Tarrant, Andrew M. Colman

Summary: The prescribing of antibiotics can be seen as a social dilemma where the overuse of antibiotics for immediate risks to individual patients can result in a suboptimal outcome for society in the long run. Doctors face the challenge of balancing individual patient interests with the collective good when prescribing antibiotics.

CURRENT OPINION IN PSYCHOLOGY (2022)

Article Primary Health Care

Identifying how GPs spend their time and the obstacles they face: a mixed-methods study

Carol Sinnott, Jordan M. Moxey, Sonja Marjanovic, Brandi Leach, Lucy Hocking, Sarah Ball, Alexandros Georgiadis, Guillaume Lame, Janet Willars, Mary Dixon-Woods

Summary: Although problems that impair task completion, known as operational failures, have been little studied, this research quantified the time GPs spend on different activities during clinical sessions and identified the nature and impact of operational failures. The study showed that operational failures disrupt patient care, impair experiences of work, and impose burden in an already pressurised system, highlighting the need for coordinated action to support GPs.

BRITISH JOURNAL OF GENERAL PRACTICE (2022)

Article Health Policy & Services

What counts as a voiceable concern in decisions about speaking out in hospitals: A qualitative study

Mary Dixon-Woods, Emma L. Aveling, Anne Campbell, Akbar Ansari, Carolyn Tarrant, Janet Willars, Peter Pronovost, Imogen Mitchell, David W. Bates, Christian Dankers, James McGowan, Graham Martin

Summary: Healthcare workers are an important source of information about safety concerns, but failures of voice persist. This study found that determining what can be voiced is not simply a matter of applying objective criteria, but involves discretionary judgement in specific organizational and cultural contexts. The determination of voiceable concerns is not solely based on the features of the concern, but also on whether the person who noticed the concern felt it was voiceable.

JOURNAL OF HEALTH SERVICES RESEARCH & POLICY (2022)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Qualitative study of candidacy and access to secondary mental health services during the COVID-19 pandemic

Elisa Liberati, Natalie Richards, Jennie Parker, Janet Willars, David Scott, Nicola Boydell, Vanessa Pinfold, Graham Martin, Peter B. Jones, Mary Dixon-Woods

Summary: This study examines the experiences of accessing mental health services during the first wave of the COVID-19 pandemic in England, using the concept of candidacy. The findings indicate that the pandemic-induced service changes had significant effects on people's eligibility for care, reshaping their perceptions of what issues deserved attention and their entitlement to care. Healthcare professionals faced complex decisions and ethical dilemmas regarding care provision, which could impact equity.

SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE (2022)

Article Health Policy & Services

Encouraging openness in health care: Policy and practice implications of a mixed-methods study in the English National Health Service

Graham Martin, Sarah Chew, Imelda McCarthy, Jeremy Dawson, Mary Dixon-Woods

Summary: The NHS in England has implemented policies aimed at increasing openness and transparency regarding quality and safety. The evaluation of these policies reveals a mixed picture, influenced by organizational history and heterogeneity. Key conditions for sustained progress in improving openness include authentic integration into organizational mission, effective administrative systems, flexibility in implementation, and a spirit of continuous inquiry and improvement.

JOURNAL OF HEALTH SERVICES RESEARCH & POLICY (2023)

Article Infectious Diseases

Indispensable yet invisible: A qualitative study of the roles of carers in infection prevention in a South Indian hospital

Surya Surendran, Enrique Castro-Sanchez, Vrinda Nampoothiri, Shiny Joseph, Sanjeev Singh, Carolyn Tarrant, Alison Holmes, Esmita Charani

Summary: This study investigates the roles of patient carers in infection-related care on surgical wards in a South Indian hospital. The findings reveal that carers play important but unrecognized roles in patient care, actively participating in personal and clinical care activities. However, there is a misalignment between their actual roles and how they are positioned by the organization and healthcare workers.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF INFECTIOUS DISEASES (2022)

Editorial Material Health Care Sciences & Services

Polypharmacy and continuity of care: medicines optimisation in the era of multidisciplinary teams

Carolyn Tarrant, Rachel Lewis, Natalie Armstrong

BMJ QUALITY & SAFETY (2023)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Visual identifiers for people with dementia in hospitals: a qualitative study to unravel mechanisms of action for improving quality of care

Elizabeth Sutton, Natalie Armstrong, Louise Locock, Simon Conroy, Carolyn Tarrant

Summary: This study aims to investigate the use, potential negative consequences, and effective conditions of visual identifiers for patients with dementia. Through case studies and interviews with experts and patients, it was found that visual identifiers can facilitate personalized care, resource prioritization, and coordination of care. However, inconsistent standards, lack of individual patient information, and stigma associated with dementia diagnosis can undermine their effectiveness. Optimizing the use of identifiers requires consensus, support, training, and meaningful engagement with caregivers and patients.

BMJ QUALITY & SAFETY (2023)

Article Obstetrics & Gynecology

Definition, management, and training in impacted fetal head at cesarean birth: a national survey of maternity professionals

Katie W. Cornthwaite, Pauline Hewitt, Jan van Der Scheer, Imogen A. F. Brown, Jenni Burt, Eliane Dufresne, Mary Dixon-Woods, Tim Draycott, ABC Contributor Gr, Thiscovery Authorship Grp, Rachna Bahl

Summary: This study aimed to assess the views, understanding, and current practices of maternity professionals regarding impacted fetal head at cesarean birth, in order to provide guidance on standardized definition, clinical management approaches, and training. The findings showed a high level of agreement on the definition of impacted fetal head and the need for a multi-professional team approach to management. There was also a significant demand for training in the management of impacted fetal head.

ACTA OBSTETRICIA ET GYNECOLOGICA SCANDINAVICA (2023)

No Data Available