4.7 Review

Bones as biofuel: a review of whale bone composition with implications for deep-sea biology and palaeoanthropology

Journal

Publisher

ROYAL SOC
DOI: 10.1098/rspb.2010.1267

Keywords

bioerosion; Osedax; whale-fall; marine mammals

Funding

  1. Natural Environment Research Council, UK

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Whales are unique among vertebrates because of the enormous oil reserves held in their soft tissue and bone. These 'biofuel' stores have been used by humans from prehistoric times to more recent industrial-scale whaling. Deep-sea biologists have now discovered that the oily bones of dead whales on the seabed are also used by specialist and generalist scavenging communities, including many unique organisms recently described as new to science. In the context of both cetacean and deep-sea invertebrate biology, we review scientific knowledge on the oil content of bone from several of the great whale species: Balaenoptera musculus, Balaenoptera physalus, Balaenoptera borealis, Megaptera novaeangliae, Eschrichtius robustus, Physeter macrocephalus and the striped dolphin, Stenella coeruleoalba. We show that data collected by scientists over 50 years ago during the heyday of industrial whaling explain several interesting phenomena with regard to the decay of whale remains. Variations in the lipid content of bones from different parts of a whale correspond closely with recently observed differences in the taphonomy of deep-sea whale carcasses and observed biases in the frequency of whale bones at archaeological sites.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Editorial Material Ecology

A decade to study deep-sea life

Kerry L. Howell, Ana Hilario, A. Louise Allcock, David Bailey, Maria Baker, Malcolm R. Clark, Ana Colaco, Jon Copley, Erik E. Cordes, Roberto Danovaro, Awantha Dissanayake, Elva Escobar, Patricia Esquete, Austin J. Gallagher, Andrew R. Gates, Sylvie M. Gaudron, Christopher R. German, Kristina M. Gjerde, Nicholas D. Higgs, Nadine Le Bris, Lisa A. Levin, Elisabetta Manea, Craig McClain, Lenaick Menot, Nelia C. Mestre, Anna Metaxas, Rosanna Milligan, Agnes W. N. Muthumbi, Bhavani E. Narayanaswamy, Sofia P. Ramalho, Eva Ramirez-Llodra, Laura M. Robson, Alex D. Rogers, Javier Sellanes, Julia D. Sigwart, Kerry Sink, Paul V. R. Snelgrove, Paris V. Stefanoudis, Paulo Y. Sumida, Michelle L. Taylor, Andrew R. Thurber, Rui Vieira, Hiromi K. Watanabe, Lucy C. Woodall, Joana R. Xavier

Summary: The United Nations Decade of Ocean Science for Sustainable Development offers a great opportunity for the deep-sea research community to achieve positive change in ocean use.

NATURE ECOLOGY & EVOLUTION (2021)

Article Biology

A late Paleoproterozoic (1.74 Ga) deep-sea, low-temperature, iron-oxidizing microbial hydrothermal vent community from Arizona, USA

Crispin T. S. Little, Karen C. Johannessen, Stefan Bengtson, Clara S. Chan, Magnus Ivarsson, John F. Slack, Curt Broman, Ingunn H. Thorseth, Tor Grenne, Olivier J. Rouxel, Andrey Bekker

Summary: Modern marine hydrothermal vents emit fluids rich in dissolved chemicals and mineralize rapidly. Iron-oxidizing bacteria play a significant role in the formation of deposits, with filamentous microstructures resembling those formed by ancient FeOB found in a late Paleoproterozoic deposit in Arizona. The presence of these structures may have implications for understanding the redox models of Paleoproterozoic oceans.

GEOBIOLOGY (2021)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Shallow-marine serpentinization-derived fluid seepage in the Upper Cretaceous Qahlah Formation, United Arab Emirates

Benjamin Eickmann, Crispin T. S. Little, Jorn Peckmann, Paul D. Taylor, Adrian J. Boyce, Daniel J. Morgan, Wolfgang Bach

Summary: This study presents evidence of serpentinization-induced fluid seepage in shallow-marine sedimentary rocks from the Upper Cretaceous in Jebel Huwayyah, United Arab Emirates, indicating that the serpentinization of Semail Ophiolite by seawater occurred soon after obduction and marine transgression, and continued through to the Miocene with interaction with meteoric water.

GEOLOGICAL MAGAZINE (2021)

Review Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

The history of life at hydrothermal vents

Magdalena N. Georgieva, Crispin T. S. Little, Valeriy V. Maslennikov, Adrian G. Glover, Nuriya R. Ayupova, Richard J. Herrington

Summary: Hydrothermal vents, supporting highly productive communities of specially-adapted fauna, have been a feature of Earth since its early history, intricately woven into the history of life on the planet. Fossils and molecular data provide valuable insights into the evolution and adaptation of life at vents, showing a transition in community composition over Earth's history. Targeting ancient vent deposits with low diagenetic changes can provide further insights and fill gaps in knowledge about vent fossils.

EARTH-SCIENCE REVIEWS (2021)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Impact of the the COVID-19 pandemic on a queen conch (Aliger gigas) fishery in The Bahamas

Nicholas D. Higgs

Summary: The COVID-19 pandemic in early 2020 led to increased unemployment and concerns about food security in the Caribbean region, resulting in a surge in fishing activities. However, this study revealed the risks of overexploitation of natural resources on food security and long-term sustainability of fishery stocks.

PEERJ (2021)

Article Paleontology

Late Cretaceous hydrothermal vent communities from the Troodos ophiolite, Cyprus: systematics and evolutionary significance

Andrzej Kaim, Crispin T. S. Little, William J. Kennedy, Ellen M. Mears, Louise M. Anderson

Summary: Modern hydrothermal vent communities are supported by microbial primary producers, with many dominant taxa emerging during the Cenozoic and Cretaceous periods. Fossil records of vent communities from these time periods are scarce. A discovery of Cretaceous vent communities in Cyprus reveals a diversity of new species in gastropods, with shared tube worms among vent sites in the western Neotethyan Ocean.

PAPERS IN PALAEONTOLOGY (2021)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Global COVID-19 lockdown highlights humans as both threats and custodians of the environment

Amanda E. Bates, Richard B. Primack, Brandy S. Biggar, Tomas J. Bird, Mary E. Clinton, Rylan J. Command, Cerren Richards, Marc Shellard, Nathan R. Geraldi, Valeria Vergara, Orlando Acevedo-Charry, Zuania Colon-Pineiro, David Ocampo, Natalia Ocampo-Penuela, Lina M. Sanchez-Clavijo, Cristian M. Adamescu, Sorin Cheval, Tudor Racoviceanu, Matthew D. Adams, Egide Kalisa, Vincent Z. Kuuire, Vikram Aditya, Pia Anderwald, Samuel Wiesmann, Sonja Wipf, Gal Badihi, Matthew G. Henderson, Hanspeter Loetscher, Katja Baerenfaller, Lisandro Benedetti-Cecchi, Fabio Bulleri, Iacopo Bertocci, Elena Maggi, Luca Rindi, Chiara Ravaglioli, Kristina Boerder, Julien Bonnel, Delphine Mathias, Philippe Archambault, Laurent Chauvaud, Camrin D. Braun, Simon R. Thorrold, Jacob W. Brownscombe, Jonathan D. Midwood, Christine M. Boston, Jill L. Brooks, Steven J. Cooke, Victor China, Uri Roll, Jonathan Belmaker, Assaf Zvuloni, Marta Coll, Miquel Ortega, Brendan Connors, Lisa Lacko, Dinusha R. M. Jayathilake, Mark J. Costello, Theresa M. Crimmins, LoriAnne Barnett, Ellen G. Denny, Katharine L. Gerst, R. L. Marsh, Erin E. Posthumus, Reilly Rodriguez, Alyssa Rosemartin, Sara N. Schaffer, Jeff R. Switzer, Kevin Wong, Susan J. Cunningham, Petra Sumasgutner, Arjun Amar, Robert L. Thomson, Miqkayla Stofberg, Sally Hofmeyr, Jessleena Suri, Rick D. Stuart-Smith, Paul B. Day, Graham J. Edgar, Antonia T. Cooper, Fabio Cabrera De Leo, Grant Garner, Paulson G. Des Brisay, Michael B. Schrimpf, Nicola Koper, Michael S. Diamond, Ross G. Dwyer, Cameron J. Baker, Craig E. Franklin, Ron Efrat, Oded Berger-Tal, Ohad Hatzofe, Victor M. Eguiluz, Jorge P. Rodriguez, Juan Fernandez-Gracia, David Elustondo, Vicent Calatayud, Philina A. English, Stephanie K. Archer, Sarah E. Dudas, Dana R. Haggarty, Austin J. Gallagher, Brendan D. Shea, Oliver N. Shipley, Ben L. Gilby, Jasmine Ballantyne, Andrew D. Olds, Christopher J. Henderson, Thomas A. Schlacher, William D. Halliday, Nicholas A. W. Brown, Mackenzie B. Woods, Sigal Balshine, Francis Juanes, Mitchell J. Rider, Patricia S. Albano, Neil Hammerschlag, Graeme C. Hays, Nicole Esteban, Yuhang Pan, Guojun He, Takanao Tanaka, Marc J. S. Hensel, Robert J. Orth, Christopher J. Patrick, Jonas Hentati-Sundberg, Olof Olsson, Margot L. Hessing-Lewis, Nicholas D. Higgs, Mark A. Hindell, Clive R. McMahon, Rob Harcourt, Christophe Guinet, Sarah E. Hirsch, Justin R. Perrault, Shelby R. Hoover, Jennifer D. Reilly, Catherine Hobaiter, Thibaud Gruber, Charlie Huveneers, Vinay Udyawer, Thomas M. Clarke, Laura P. Kroesen, David S. Hik, Seth G. Cherry, Justin A. Del Bel Belluz, Jennifer M. Jackson, Shengjie Lai, Clayton T. Lamb, Gregory D. LeClair, Jeffrey R. Parmelee, Matthew W. H. Chatfield, Cheryl A. Frederick, Sangdon Lee, Hyomin Park, Jaein Choi, Frederic LeTourneux, Thierry Grandmont, Frederic Dulude De Broin, Joel Bety, Gilles Gauthier, Pierre Legagneux, Jesse S. Lewis, Jeffrey Haight, Zhu Liu, Jarod P. Lyon, Robin Hale, Dallas D'Silva, Ian MacGregor-Fors, Enrique Arbelaez-Cortes, Felipe A. Estela, Camilo E. Sanchez-Sarria, Michelle Garcia-Arroyo, Giann K. Aguirre-Samboni, Juan C. Franco Morales, Shahar Malamud, Tal Gavriel, Yehezkel Buba, Shira Salingre, Mai Lazarus, Ruthy Yahel, Yigael Ben Ari, Eyal Miller, Rotem Sade, Guy Lavian, Ziv Birman, Manor Gury, Harel Baz, Ilia Baskin, Alon Penn, Amit Dolev, Ogen Licht, Tabi Karkom, Sharon Davidzon, Avi Berkovitch, Ofer Yaakov, Raoul Manenti, Emiliano Mori, Gentile Francesco Ficetola, Enrico Lunghi, David March, Brendan J. Godley, Cecilia Martin, Steven F. Mihaly, David R. Barclay, Dugald J. M. Thomson, Richard Dewey, Jeannette Bedard, Aroha Miller, Amber Dearden, Jennifer Chapman, Lauren Dares, Laura Borden, Donna Gibbs, Jessica Schultz, Nikita Sergeenko, Fiona Francis, Amanda Weltman, Nicolas Moity, Jorge Ramirez-Gonzalez, Gonzalo Mucientes, Alexandre Alonso-Fernandez, Itai Namir, Avi Bar-Massada, Ron Chen, Shmulik Yedvab, Thomas A. Okey, Steffen Oppel, Volen Arkumarev, Samuel Bakari, Vladimir Dobrev, Victoria Saravia-Mullin, Anastasios Bounas, Dobromir Dobrev, Elzbieta Kret, Solomon Mengistu, Cloe Pourchier, Alazar Ruffo, Million Tesfaye, Mengistu Wondafrash, Stoyan C. Nikolov, Charles Palmer, Lorenzo Sileci, Patrick T. Rex, Christopher G. Lowe, Francesc Peters, Matthew K. Pine, Craig A. Radford, Louise Wilson, Lauren McWhinnie, Alessia Scuderi, Andrew G. Jeffs, Kathleen L. Prudic, Maxim Larrivee, Kent P. McFarland, Rodrigo Solis, Rebecca A. Hutchinson, Nuno Queiroz, Miguel A. Furtado, David W. Sims, Emily Southall, Claudio A. Quesada-Rodriguez, Jessica P. Diaz-Orozco, Ku'ulei S. Rodgers, Sarah J. L. Severino, Andrew T. Graham, Matthew P. Stefanak, Elizabeth M. P. Madin, Peter G. Ryan, Kyle Maclean, Eleanor A. Weideman, Kyle D. Kittelberger, Josip Kusak, Jeffrey A. Seminoff, Megan E. Hanna, Takahiro Shimada, Mark G. Meekan, Martin K. S. Smith, Mohlamatsane M. Mokhatla, Malcolm C. K. Soh, Roanna Y. T. Pang, Breyl X. K. Ng, P. Y-H Lee Benjamin, Adrian H. B. Loo, Kenneth B. H. Er, Gabriel B. G. Souza, Christopher D. Stallings, Joseph S. Curtis, Meaghan E. Faletti, Jonathan A. Peake, Michael J. Schram, Kara R. Wall, Carina Terry, Matt Rothendler, Lucy Zipf, Juan Sebastian Ulloa, Angelica Hernandez-Palma, Bibiana Gomez-Valencia, Cristian Cruz-Rodriguez, Yenifer Herrera-Varon, Margarita Roa, Susana Rodriguez-Buritica, Jose Manuel Ochoa-Quintero, Reut Vardi, Victor Vazquez, Christian Requena-Mesa, Miyako H. Warrington, Michelle E. Taylor, Lucy C. Woodall, Paris Stefanoudis, Xiangliang Zhang, Qiang Yang, Yuval Zukerman, Zehava Sigal, Amir Ayali, Eric E. G. Clua, Pamela Carzon, Clementine Seguine, Andrea Corradini, Luca Pedrotti, Catherine M. Foley, Catherine Alexandra Gagnon, Elijah Panipakoochoo, Celene B. Milanes, Camilo M. Botero, Yunior R. Velazquez, Nataliya A. Milchakova, Simon A. Morley, Stephanie M. Martin, Veronica Nanni, Tanya Otero, Julia Wakeling, Sarah Abarro, Cyril Piou, Ana F. L. Sobral, Eulogio H. Soto, Emily G. Weigel, Alejandro Bernal-Ibanez, Ignacio Gestoso, Eva Cacabelos, Francesca Cagnacci, Reny P. Devassy, Matthias-Claudio Loretto, Paula Moraga, Christian Rutz, Carlos M. Duarte

Summary: The global lockdown due to COVID-19 pandemic has impacted human interactions with nature, resulting in immediate effects on wildlife and environmental threats. Reports from around the world indicate a mix of positive and negative impacts on conservation and illegal activities.

BIOLOGICAL CONSERVATION (2021)

Article Ecology

Depth and substrate type influence community structure and diversity of wood and whale-bone habitats on the deep NE Pacific margin

Emily L. Young, Kenneth M. Halanych, Diva J. Amon, Iris Altamira, Janet R. Voight, Nicholas D. Higgs, Craig R. Smith

Summary: Whale bones and wood on the deep-sea floor support characteristic faunal assemblages and promote biodiversity in an otherwise food-poor environment.

MARINE ECOLOGY PROGRESS SERIES (2022)

Article Environmental Studies

Application of scientific criteria for identifying hydrothermal ecosystems in need of protection

S. Gollner, A. Colaco, A. Gebruk, P. N. Halpin, N. Higgs, E. Menini, N. C. Mestre, P-Y Qian, J. Sarrazin, K. Szafranski, C. L. Van Dover

Summary: Deep-sea hydrothermal vent fields are globally rare ecosystems, abundant in extraordinary life based on chemosynthesis and polymetallic sulfide resources. The International Seabed Authority manages mineral resources beyond national jurisdictions and ensures environmental protection. Through various criteria assessments, most vent fields meet standards for ecosystems in need of protection.

MARINE POLICY (2021)

Article Oceanography

Megabenthos habitats influenced by nearby hydrothermal activity on the Sandwich Plate, Southern Ocean

Katrin Linse, Miriam Roemer, Crispin T. S. Little, Yann Marcon, Gerhard Bohrmann

Summary: The Sandwich Plate is a highly active region in terms of tectonic activity in the Southern Ocean and Antarctica, with volcanic islands, submarine volcanic features, seismic activity, and hydrothermal vents. A recent investigation explored potential hydrothermally active sites in different depths, revealing thermal anomalies and chimney structures. However, the benthic habitats and communities of the Sandwich Plate are still poorly understood.

DEEP-SEA RESEARCH PART II-TOPICAL STUDIES IN OCEANOGRAPHY (2022)

Article Biology

Sulfur isotopes of hydrothermal vent fossils and insights into microbial sulfur cycling within a lower Paleozoic (Ordovician-early Silurian) vent community

Magdalena N. Georgieva, Crispin T. S. Little, Richard J. Herrington, Adrian J. Boyce, Aubrey L. Zerkle, Valeriy V. Maslennikov, Adrian G. Glover

Summary: Symbiotic relationships between animals and microbes involved in sulfur cycling are crucial for animals to thrive in deep-sea hydrothermal vent environments. The study reveals that ancient and recently mineralized vent fossils preserve potential signatures of their metabolisms in sulfur isotopes, indicating the potential for using sulfur isotopes to study fossil vent communities.

GEOBIOLOGY (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Metabolically diverse primordial microbial communities in Earth's oldest seafloor-hydrothermal jasper

Dominic Papineau, Zhenbing She, Matthew S. Dodd, Francesco Iacoviello, John F. Slack, Erik Hauri, Paul Shearing, Crispin T. S. Little

Summary: This study reports the discovery of putative fossils in jasper-carbonate banded iron formations from the Nuvvuagittuq Supracrustal Belt in Quebec. These fossils, which are hematite filaments and tubes, have characteristics that suggest both biological and abiotic origins. The presence of mineral associations, resemblance to younger microfossils, and similarities to modern Fe-bacteria indicate a possible biological origin. On the other hand, the presence of abiotic structures and the enrichment of certain minerals suggest complex prebiotic forms. These findings provide insight into the diversity of microbial ecosystems on early Earth and the potential for similar ecosystems on other planetary bodies.

SCIENCE ADVANCES (2022)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Long duration of benthic ecological recovery from the early Toarcian (Early Jurassic) mass extinction event in the Cleveland Basin, UK

Jed W. Atkinson, Crispin T. S. Little, Alexander M. Dunhill

Summary: This study documents the recovery of benthic macrofauna following the early Toarcian mass extinction event in the Cleveland Basin. The recovery was initially dominated by specialist communities tolerant to low oxygen levels and later accelerated with improving seafloor ventilation and sand deposition. Full recovery occurred approximately 7 million years after the extinction event.

JOURNAL OF THE GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY (2023)

Letter Zoology

Phylogenetic context of a deep-sea clam (Bivalvia: Vesicomyidae) revealed by DNA from 1 500-year-old shells

Yi-Xuan Li, Yanjie Zhang, Jack Chi-Ho Ip, Jing Liu, Chong Chen, Crispin T. S. Little, Yusuke Yokoyama, Moriaki Yasuhara, Jian-Wen Qiu

ZOOLOGICAL RESEARCH (2023)

Article Paleontology

UPPER TOARCIAN (LOWER JURASSIC) MARINE GASTROPODS FROM THE CLEVELAND BASIN, ENGLAND: SYSTEMATICS, PALAEOBIOGEOGRAPHY AND CONTRIBUTION TO BIOTIC RECOVERY FROM THE EARLY TOARCIAN EXTINCTION EVENT

Mariel Ferrari, Crispin T. S. Little, Jed W. Atkinson

Summary: A new marine gastropod fauna from the upper Toarcian of England is described, consisting of 16 species with three new ones. Most species represent the earliest records of their genera, showing paleobiogeographical connections with other regions. The taxonomic composition differs significantly from faunas of other periods in the basin.

PAPERS IN PALAEONTOLOGY (2021)

No Data Available